Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The city of Edmonton does not actually exist

I don't think the town of Edmonton actually exists. I don't know anyone that's ever been there. I'm a big-time Edmonton truther. The whole city is filled with crisis actors.

The city of Edmonton definitively exists.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Clippers must blow up their current core

Can we just be done with the Clippers as they currently are constructed? I don't know how they're going to blame it on Blake Griffin, but I'm sure they will. Doc Rivers, just stop. Just get out of here. Don't coach anymore. Chris Paul, go find another team.

The Clippers did blow it up shortly after this; Chris Paul was traded to the Rockets in June 2017, and Blake Griffin was traded in January 2018.
Void
HankHank

The Celtics are one LeBron James injury away from making the NBA Finals

[The Celtics] are like one big Cavaliers injury away from maybe making it to the show... By one big Cavaliers, [I] mean LeBron James. If LeBron James [gets hurt], then yeah, I think the Celtics have a pretty good shot.

LeBron James remained healthy and led the Cavaliers to the Finals, so the condition of the take was never tested, but the spirit of the Celtics being the second-best team was accurate.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I'm not convinced Doc Rivers is actually a good NBA coach

Doc Rivers also is one of those coaches that... are we sure he's a good coach? I'm not sure. He won with some really good talent, but he also has lost with some really good talent a lot. So are we sure he's good? Very, very wonky career for Doc Rivers as a coach.

This remains a highly debated topic in NBA circles with no objective resolution, though Doc's lack of deep playoff runs with elite talent since then supports the skepticism.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Either Joe Mixon or John Ross will definitely get injured or suspended for the Bengals

[The Bengals] got Joe Mixon and John Ross. One will get injured. The other will probably get suspended. But for a minute there, people are going to say, wow, is Andy Dalton going to put it together?

John Ross was famously injury-prone, missing significant time throughout his Bengals career. Joe Mixon remained mostly productive but the prediction for Ross was very accurate.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

John Fox will be fired as Bears head coach by the end of the year

I think John Fox, I'm going to call it right now, he's going to get fired at the end of the year because Ryan Pace basically has built the team around someone else.

John Fox was indeed fired by the Bears on January 1, 2018, immediately following the conclusion of the 2017 season.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The first few years after college are more fun than college itself

I think the first three or four years after you graduate can be more fun than college. Because you actually have money in your pocket. You have money in your pocket. You make real life friends. It's not just like, whoever was living on my hallway.

This is a purely subjective life opinion.
Void
George BrettGeorge Brett

Kansas City has the best barbecue in the country

Kansas City, best barbecue in the country? I think so.

Barbecue preference is subjective.
Void
George BrettGeorge Brett

Clubhouse character and camaraderie are essential for winning in MLB

All of a sudden, [Dayton Moore] brought this culture in, and he wanted guys that came up through the minor leagues together... all of a sudden, character became very, very important. And I really believe that's one of the reasons that a team... all of a sudden, we go to the playoffs... next year, win the World Series. And so that's when I became a firm believer that character does play a role, the camaraderie in the locker room.

The impact of 'clubhouse chemistry' is a perennial debate in sports and can't be objectively proven or disproven.
Void
George BrettGeorge Brett

I would not have survived playing in the Major Leagues during the cell phone era

Do you think you would have been able to survive with the cell phone era? No... Well, back in the day, you had to take a picture... and then develop it and then mail it to somebody... I got married at 39. So you were single for your entire career, basically. Right.

This is a personal reflection on his own habits and the changing media landscape.
Win
George BrettGeorge Brett

Cleveland had the absolute worst stadium amenities in Major League Baseball

Which stadium had the worst amenities in that restaurant? Cleveland, by far. Really? Cleveland. Yeah? It was just a shithole? Yeah. Really bad.

Old Cleveland Municipal Stadium was famously known as the 'Mistake by the Lake' and had notoriously poor conditions for players and fans.
Void
George BrettGeorge Brett

I would have hit 40 home runs in today's era with modern training

Do you think if you played right now and you had they had all the technology and how these guys train relentlessly... do you think you would have hit more home runs? Yeah. [Big Cat: 30 was your highest year... you'd say like mid-30s to 40 guy?] Oh, you know, I think it depends on what park you play in, too... Home run might have gone up.

Hypothetical historical comparison that cannot be tested.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Roger Goodell is embracing the heel role and is an ultimate villain

I really do think Roger Goodell has passed a certain point where he is starting to embrace the heel. [Big Cat: He wiped a booger on a handicapped child] that's super villain stuff that is the ultimate villain not because he embraced not because he was like oh i'm the super villain... he's just evil.

Purely an interpretation of public perception and character.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Noah Syndergaard needs to leave the Mets because their medical staff is terrible

Noah [Syndergaard]... maybe go to a different team because it seems like the Mets doctors probably aren't the best... Any name with silent letters in it. Weak. I don't trust it.

The Mets medical staff has been a punchline for years, and Syndergaard's repeated injury setbacks eventually led to him leaving the team in 2021, though he never quite regained his elite form elsewhere.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

T.Y. Hilton's son will date Riley Curry in 15 years

Also, I just want to make a prediction. Within, I'm going to say 10 to 15 years, T.Y. Hilton's kid is going to be dating Riley Curry. I just want to put that out there. I think that's the next sports power couple.

The children are still very young; as of 2024, there is no indication of this happening.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Dwight Howard is incapable of self-reflection and will never realize he's the problem

Dwight Howard unhappy with the situation. [PFT: It sounds like he's just depressed.] Dwight Howard causing a problem on his team... At what point do you think he looks in the mirror and is like, hey, maybe it's me? No, he doesn't do that. No, it's never going to happen.

Dwight Howard bounced around several more teams (Hornets, Wizards, 76ers) before reinventing himself as a role player with the Lakers in 2020, which many saw as a moment of self-reflection.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Mitchell Trubisky will be good for the Bears

I'm going to spin zone it real quick. I think [Mitchell Trubisky] is going to be good, okay? And he gets to learn behind Mike Glennon and Mark Sanchez... He actually had, I read this stat because I was digging deep trying to sell myself on this. I have 66% completion rate under pressure. Highest of any quarterback drafted in the first round.

Mitchell Trubisky is widely considered a bust for the Bears, especially given they passed on Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Gareon Conley is better off in Las Vegas than Cleveland

Do you think that [Gareon] Conley's going to be better off getting away from Cleveland where there's all these nightlife and temptations and all that and going to a low-key place like Las Vegas? I think that'll keep him in line... The desert heat might dry you out. Stay out of trouble.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
The joke is that Las Vegas is far more of a 'nightlife' city than Cleveland.
Void
Donovan McNabbDonovan McNabb

I would come out of retirement to play for the Browns for $15-18 million

If Cleveland offered you, let's just say $15 million a year, are you coming back? Absolutely... 15 to 18 a year. I'll be back.

The Browns never offered this, and McNabb remained retired.
Void
Donovan McNabbDonovan McNabb

I am a better two-sport athlete than Greg Paulus

[Who's a better two-sport Syracuse athlete, you or Greg Paulus?] That would definitely be me. But I will say this about Greg Paulus. Greg Paulus was an All-American in football, All-American in basketball. Chose to play basketball at Duke... I won't say he's better than me, but he played.

Subjective comparison of athletic careers.
Void
Donovan McNabbDonovan McNabb

Terrell Owens' locker room issues were his own fault

If it happens once, then it's kind of overblown. If it happens twice, let's kind of see what's going on. If it happens more than three times, then sometimes it's maybe not anyone else. It may be you... [His antics] wasn't such a problem until it hit the media. Then now he has to defend himself in the media.

This is a subjective assessment of a locker room dynamic.
Loss
Donovan McNabbDonovan McNabb

Myles Garrett is a 'safe' but questionable number one overall pick due to low sack totals

There are a lot of questions about Myles Garrett, because you look at his sack total and it's very low... As a number one pick, that's rare. If you're coming in as a number one pick and you only have eight sacks... Is he a safe pick? He's a safe pick. But for the Cleveland Browns, if I'm the Cleveland Browns, I'm going to get Jay Cutler.

Garrett became a perennial All-Pro and one of the best pass rushers in the league, making the 'questionable' label incorrect in hindsight.
Push
Donovan McNabbDonovan McNabb

Deshaun Watson is the best quarterback in the 2017 draft class

I like Deshaun Watson. I think Deshaun Watson has proven he can play in big games... I think Deshaun Watson is probably number one.

Mahomes turned out to be the best in the class, though Watson was very successful early on.
Win
Donovan McNabbDonovan McNabb

Dalvin Cook is the running back in the 2017 draft class to keep an eye on

I like Dalvin Cook. Now, I know a lot of people have been down on Dalvin Cook because of his injury. I think he's kind of one of those guys that... Jamal Charles is a guy he idolized. I think that's probably the running back that I think people need to keep an eye on.

Dalvin Cook became a multiple-time Pro Bowler and one of the top backs in the league for several seasons, proving McNabb right.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Chiefs trading up for Patrick Mahomes was the worst pick in the draft

The worst pick, I think, in the draft was Mahomes at 10 and the Chiefs trading up 17 picks to get him? Do you think they did that because they're like, yo, Ryan Pace is going to get a lot of heat? Now's our time to just go under the radar and just, who cares? No one's going to talk about us.

Patrick Mahomes became arguably the greatest quarterback of his generation, making this an all-time 'Freezing Cold Take'.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Patrick Mahomes' arm is too strong for the Andy Reid offense

I also think it was a questionable move by Andy Reid. It doesn't really fit his system, which is throw the ball like four yards. His arm is too strong for the Andy Reid offense. He's just going to be overthrowing his receivers all day.

Mahomes and Reid formed the most dangerous deep-passing and creative offense in the league.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Coach Orgeron will have a five to ten year reign of dominance at LSU

I think that this performance by LSU's draft picks, that's going to push Coach O's recruiting over the top. I'm going to predict a five to ten year reign of dominance for Coach O by [Leonard] Fournette and Jamal Adams.

Orgeron won a title but was out of a job within 5 years of this prediction.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If Rajon Rondo is the linchpin of the Bulls season, that is a big problem

I even hate even more is people saying, oh, well, if Rondo was still in this series, the Bulls win. Yeah, probably right. But if Rajon Rondo is like the linchpin for your whole fucking season, that's a big fucking problem.

The Bulls lost 4 straight to the Celtics after Rondo's injury.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals are fine and will beat the Penguins

I'm not pressing the panic button on the Caps. The Caps dominated that game. The only stat that didn't go in their favor is the score... I'm throwing the panic button out the window. I'm not going to press it... I'm not worried at all. No, if you watch the game, it was dominance by the Caps.

The Penguins defeated the Capitals in 7 games in the 2017 playoffs.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Backing the NFL Draft up an extra month was the smartest thing Roger Goodell ever did

The smartest thing Roger Goodell ever did was backing the draft up another month. That way you get so many more mock drafts and you get so many more takes in. And yes, you're right. The anticipation. I've been walking around with an erection for the last two weeks.

The move to late April was highly successful commercially and for engagement, supporting PFT's sarcastic but valid point about increased take volume.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Russell Westbrook distrusts his teammates more than any player I've ever seen

I don't think I've ever seen—and don't tell him I said this because he'll get very upset at me—I don't think I've ever seen one player distrust his teammates more than Russell Westbrook. Unbelievable season, but he really was like, these guys fucking suck, and I need to make sure they never get the ball.

This is a subjective assessment of playstyle, though Westbrook's high usage and triple-double pursuit remain heavily debated topics from that season.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am officially off the James Harden train because of his playing style and Kinesio tape

I just want to say I am officially off the James Harden train. I can't stand that guy. It's the kinesio tape. It's also how he wears his shorts. And it's the thing that he does where he's coming off a screen and he acts like he was shooting the ball at half court the whole time.

This is a subjective opinion about a player's likability.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Brown is a better coach for the Warriors than Steve Kerr

Mike Brown is better than Steve Kerr. It's obvious if you watched the first quarter of that game last night. Steve Kerr, as we say on the show, he's a system coach. He only coaches well when he's coaching in his system. So I think that we're going to see him be exposed more and more.

While Brown led them during Kerr's absence in the 2017 playoffs to a perfect record, Kerr's overall resume and four championships prove he is one of the all-time greats, making the 'system coach' label incorrect.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Jaguars will win the 2017 NFL Draft with an A+ grade

The Jaguars won the draft. So I just want to call that right now. My post-draft grades, I don't know how 31 teams do. I know the Jags got an A+. This is the year that they're going to put it all together. They had a great draft.

The Jaguars had a strong 2017 draft (Fournette, Cam Robinson, Dede Westbrook) and actually reached the AFC Championship game that season, making this ironically correct.
Win
Ian RapoportIan Rapoport

The Browns will draft Myles Garrett with the number one overall pick

They're going to screw it up. I don't know. They can't. I mean, it's going to be Myles Garrett.

The Cleveland Browns did indeed select Myles Garrett with the first overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft.
Win
Ian RapoportIan Rapoport

Mitchell Trubisky will be the first quarterback taken in the 2017 NFL Draft

I would be very surprised if it's not Trubisky [going first among QBs]. That's what it seems like.

Mitchell Trubisky was selected 2nd overall by the Chicago Bears, making him the first quarterback taken.
Loss
Ian RapoportIan Rapoport

Mitchell Trubisky has a chance to start Week 1 for the team that drafts him

I mean, if you think about the rookies who will get picked this year, only, like, let's say the Browns take Trubisky. I think there's a chance he's their starter to open the season.

Trubisky did not start Week 1 for the Bears; Mike Glennon started the first four games before Trubisky took over in Week 5.
Loss
Ian RapoportIan Rapoport

Davis Webb could potentially be a first-round pick

Davis Webb. Potentially going in the first round. Some teams really, really like him. Character-wise, he's great. It's interesting. When they study the tape, they say Cal's offense looked better for him than it did for Jared Goff last year.

Davis Webb was not selected in the first round; he was taken in the third round (87th overall) by the New York Giants.
Win
Ian RapoportIan Rapoport

NFL free agents view Mike Glennon as a special talent

The weirdest thing for me is that I had free agents... contact me and ask me about [Mike] Glennon and say that they wanted to play with him because they think he is special. ... people reaching out to me and saying Mike Glennon can be special.

The fact claim is about what free agents told him, which is likely true, even if their evaluation of Glennon's talent was very wrong.
Win
Ian RapoportIan Rapoport

Tony Romo is finished playing football and will not return

Tony Romo really retired? All your sources... No chance. I would be stunned. But I was hearing he was going to retire in, like, November. He doesn't look like someone who's ready to jump back on the field.

Tony Romo never returned to professional football after his retirement following the 2016 season.
Loss
Logan CoutureLogan Couture

The Capitals have a great chance to win the Eastern Conference this year

Logan, is it the Caps year? You know what? They've got a great team. We don't really get to see the East as often, obviously. But if there's any team that can do it, I'd say I think so.

The Capitals lost in the second round of the 2017 playoffs to the Pittsburgh Penguins. (They would win the Cup the following year, but this take was about 2017).
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bulls' failure to adjust against the Celtics is embarrassing and lazy coaching

Wade said Bulls didn't make adjustments between game three and four because they just played low energy and didn't need a new game plan. They then lost game four. So Fred Hoiberg just like, yeah, you know what, guys? Low energy, I'm not going to coach. ... Fuck that.

Subjective opinion on coaching performance.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Pat Riley is an immortal time traveler because he has shut out all human feelings

Here's how I know he's not dead is because you have to have feelings to be alive in the first place. And since he has just shut out all of his feelings, then he can't possibly ever be alive or dead. Therefore, he'll never die. Therefore, he is a time traveler.

Pat Riley is a human being and not literally a time traveler.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The 2017 Capitals are a different team and will get past the Penguins

This is our year. The Capitals, it's a different team. Everyone knows it.

The Capitals lost to the Penguins in the second round in 7 games.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am more confident than ever that the Capitals will beat the Penguins

I'm more confident than i've ever been going into this [series]. We just beat a bunch of yahoos that dump gravy and cheese all over their fries. We can beat a city that puts it in their sandwiches.

The Capitals lost to the Penguins in 7 games in the 2017 second round.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA first round this year has been far superior to the NHL first round

The NBA first round this year has been far superior to the NHL first round. I know there's been a lot of overtime games, but like you said, there's no Game 7s. And the NBA feels like... last year was really bad. This year, there have been some really compelling stories, and we have a lot of fights going on.

This is a subjective opinion comparing two different sports seasons.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jeff Teague has been swept out of the playoffs by LeBron James for three consecutive years

I'm pretty sure Jeff Teague has been swept by LeBron three years in a row. That's amazing.

LeBron's teams swept Teague's Hawks in 2015 and 2016, and then Teague's Pacers in 2017.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Russell Westbrook is ruining the Oklahoma City Thunder

The answer to both questions is yes [is Westbrook ruining the Thunder]. Russ needs to respect the biz.

While Westbrook won MVP, the Thunder were eliminated in the first round; his impact remains a highly debated topic among basketball fans.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Steve Kerr's back issues were caused by inhaling LeBron James' pre-game chalk dust

I'm pointing the finger again at LeBron James for Steve Kerr's issues. LeBron James gets up before every game and throws some unknown substance into the air. Guess who's closer than anybody else to that situation? That dust that he's thrown. Steve Kerr.

Steve Kerr's back issues were medical complications from surgery, not LeBron James' pre-game routine.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tim Duncan is the least charismatic superstar in the history of sports

The Spurs built this entire dynasty on the least charismatic superstar of all time in Tim Duncan. And then Tim Duncan had a baby and basically told the baby, don't ever speak or show any emotion.

Charisma is subjective, though Duncan is famously known for his stoic and understated personality.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers