Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Chiefs might be done

Are the Chiefs done? The Chiefs might be done. Is Travis Kelce, has he lost all of his skills? A lot of football to get to.

The Chiefs recovered from their late-season slump to win Super Bowl LVIII.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

George Pickens is worth the headache

This was the George Pickens game. He had the Randy Moss stat line... it doesn't excuse everything George Pickens done this year, it just confirms that George Pickens is worth the headache because he has this in him.

Pickens' elite talent is undeniable, but whether it outweighs the 'headache' is a subjective organizational choice.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Tomlin will find his way to nine wins

Whatever you wanna say about [Tomlin], he will find his way to nine wins. He's gonna find his way to nine wins. They had to win this game to find his way to nine wins... the Mike Tomlin path is set.

Mike Tomlin finished the 2023 season with 10 wins, extending his streak.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills are worth betting at 35-1 to win the Super Bowl

If you like the Bills to beat the Chiefs, take 'em 35 to one to win the Super Bowl because the AFC is wide open. And it's not saying that the Bills aren't, it's not saying the Bills are some world beating team. It's that the rest of the pack has come back to the Bills.

The Bills lost in the Divisional Round to the Chiefs.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jared Goff's stats are better than Matthew Stafford's this year

Jared Goff has 3,984 yards, 27 touchdowns, 10 interceptions. Matthew Stafford has 3,648 yards, 23 touchdowns, nine interceptions... Jared Goff more yards, more touchdowns, and only one more interception than Matthew Stafford this year.

The stats provided were accurate for that point in the 2023 season.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You have to wait 50 years before you can start feeling bad for a rival fan base's misery

I think 50 years is the right amount [to not feel bad for a rival]. I think probably for [the Cowboys] not making the playoffs, I would start to feel bad for Cowboys fans after 50 years. That's the right amount.

This is a subjective rule for sports fandom.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will match Big Cat's offer of Super Bowl tickets for Lions fans

Max, thank you. Huge for you, Max. You wanna match? I'll match. I'm matching for this year. Not saying like extending it to Infinity. This season. This season we're gonna... I'm not saying extending it to infinity... I'm matching for this year.

The Lions lost in the NFC Championship, so the condition for this ticket match was never met.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm starting to think that the Browns might go to the Super Bowl

Joe Flacco and Amari Cooper... that was incredible. I'm starting to think that the Browns might go to the Super Bowl. Browns-Lions. If he's throwing the ball like that, you can win a Super Bowl if your defense continues to be like the best in the league by far.

The Browns lost in the Wild Card round to the Texans 45-14.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Flacco is a better option for the Browns than Deshaun Watson

If he's healthy as he is right now, [Flacco] is without a doubt, a better option for your team than Deshaun Watson.

Flacco led the Browns to the playoffs and won Comeback Player of the Year, statistically far outperforming Watson's 2023 stint.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons would be winning the NFC South if Taylor Heineke had been starting all year

The Falcons would be winning that division if Taylor Heineke had been starting the entire season because he takes risks... He's a game wrecker. No telling which team he'll wreck it for, but he's gonna give you a better chance to win overall than Desmond Ritter who just sucks.

The Falcons finished 7-10 and out of the playoffs, including losses with Heineke starting later in the year. The division was won by the Bucs at 9-8.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks will get the number seven seed in the NFC

Seahawks stay alive... the Seahawks are officially alive. It feels like they actually might be the team that gets in that seven spot, which we've been talking about forever. That seven spot in the NFC because the Vikings and the Packers have both died.

The Seahawks finished 9-8 and missed the playoffs. The Green Bay Packers (9-8) took the #7 seed based on tiebreakers.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Evans is a first-ballot Hall of Famer

Mike Evans is a first ballot hall of famer... If he plays for five more years... he would be in the list with Jerry Rice, Larry Fitzgerald, Randy Moss, and T.O. ... He will go down as one of the best receivers of all time.

Evans is not yet eligible, but his stats (10 consecutive 1,000-yard seasons) make this a highly plausible opinion.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Herbert to the Bears for the #1 pick is the best possible trade

Justin Herbert for the number one pick would be the greatest thing in my life... You know that owner cares about getting fans in that stadium. If they can draft Caleb Williams... and then give the Bears Justin Herbert... I would do that in a second.

This trade never happened; the Bears kept the pick and drafted Caleb Williams, and the Chargers kept Herbert.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL should require the player who scores the touchdown to kick the extra point

I've always said that the player that scores the touchdown should have to kick the extra point. How awesome would that be?

This is a subjective opinion on how the rules should be changed.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dolphins and Cowboys are both frauds

The Cowboys are frauds. Frauds, but the Dolphins are also frauds because all they prove that they is that they can beat a fraud... we didn't learn anything from this game whatsoever.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Both teams were eliminated in the first round of the playoffs, supporting the 'fraud' Narrative in spirit.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys win that game if they have Ezekiel Elliott

The Cowboys, it's funny how the narratives work... if they have Zeke Elliott, I think they win that game. They have struggled in the red zone all year, and Tony Pollard around the goal line has been a disaster.

The Cowboys' red zone struggles were a documented issue, but adding Zeke is a hypothetical fix.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick will beat the Jets one last time then leave for the Commanders

If Belichick is going to the Commanders, Belichick will figure out a way to beat the New York Jets one last time... and then give the Patriots a worst pick, give his potential new team a better pick. That's my fanfiction world.

Belichick did beat the Jets in his final game, but he did not join the Commanders; Dan Quinn was hired.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Taylor Swift ruined Santa Claus for thousands of children

Taylor Swift probably ruined Santa Claus for thousands and thousands of children across America today... my four-year old son Chris walked in and he saw Santa... Santa was in her box, and he said, dad, we just opened presents... how come he's on TV right now?

This is a comedic exaggeration and not a factual claim about mass childhood trauma.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Antonio Pierce must be the permanent head coach of the Raiders

Antonio Pierce needs to be the head coach. His message before this game... was 'hatred, violence and pain.' ... There will be no better head coach for the Raiders... perfect culture fit.

The Raiders officially hired Antonio Pierce as their head coach on January 19, 2024.
Loss
MaxMax

The third-and-20 conversion to A.J. Brown saved the Eagles' season

There was one play that saved the season. It was after the pick six. They go to third and 20. That was the third and 20 to A.J. Brown was the play that saved the season. Because if they don't pick that up, they're fucked.

The Eagles won the game but collapsed shortly after, losing in the Wild Card round.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I predict the Giants will bring Tommy DeVito back next year

I don't think we've seen the last of Tommy DeVito. I think he was too much fun to the point where I feel like the Giants will bring him back next year as far as the backup goes. He had a few good games.

Tommy DeVito remained with the Giants for the 2024 season, initially on the practice squad before being elevated back to the active roster.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens and the Browns are the only two teams in the NFL that play defense on a different level

I did have the Ravens today and it's really just, I think the Ravens and the Browns are the two teams that play defense on a different level. When you have to play a defense that good, things don't come as easy.

The Browns finished #1 and Ravens #6 in total defense for 2023. The Ravens reached the AFC Title game primarily on the strength of their defense.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

NFL MVP is stupid because it's decided in the last three weeks

This is why the MVP in the NFL is so stupid... it feels like it is decided in the last three weeks of the season every year. It's whoever has a big primetime game at the end of the year.

This is a subjective critique of award voting patterns.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

My 'Pretty Much Dry January' rules allow drinking on Fridays, Saturdays, Monday Night Football, Sunday brunches, and any night I want a beer

I am going to be doing pretty much dry January again this year. The rules are as follows: no drinking unless it's Friday. If there's football on a Monday, you can also drink on a Saturday and you can have brunch on a Sunday and then you can have a beer during the week any night. But besides that, no heavy drinking whatsoever.

This is a satirical set of rules for a personal resolution.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I will eat 50 Dairy Queen blizzards as my New Year's resolution

My New Year's resolution is I'm gonna eat more blizzards, Dairy Queen blizzards... New Year's resolutions are, to me, less about changing yourself for the better and more about just doing the things you like more... I'm thinking like 50.

Whether he actually ate 50 is unknown, but the philosophy is a subjective life take.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Shohei Ohtani to the Dodgers is not more impactful than Jackie Robinson

Ben Verlander... said that Shohei Ohtani to the Dodgers is the most important signing in Dodgers history... Jackie Robinson? ... Pretty impactful. The word impactful was really interesting to us. Most important, most impactful.

Jackie Robinson breaking the color barrier is universally considered the most impactful event in Dodgers (and arguably MLB) history.
Push
MaxMax

The NBA is back to being irrelevant

Who's back? NBA being Irrelevant.

Hot TakeBasketballHotSarcastic
NFL ratings on Christmas significantly outperformed NBA ratings, though 'irrelevant' is subjective.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Rams are officially a legitimate, good football team

I think we can say that the Rams are legit. Like they're, they're a good, they're a good team.

The Rams finished 10-7 and made the playoffs, proving they were indeed a good team in 2023.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams are officially a dangerous playoff team

I'm gonna say this, the Rams, I think they're officially dangerous. That's what they are. They're dangerous. Matt Stafford playing great ball.

The Rams took the Lions to the brink in the Wild Card round, losing by only 1 point, validating the 'dangerous' label.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Stafford is a Hall of Famer

Matt Stafford is a hall of Famer and watching him play football is fun. Like his, the the throws he makes And, it, it's, it doesn't feel like it's gratuitous. It's like it's making some of these throws. 'cause he has to make these throws.

Stafford is still active, so his HOF status is pending, but the consensus on his candidacy improved significantly after his Rams Super Bowl win.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

A playoff matchup between Matt Stafford and the Detroit Lions would be the meanest thing to ever happen to that franchise

Matt Stafford going to Detroit Lions first home playoff game. Man, that would be brutal. ... That's not fun for anybody. ... That would be the meanest, meanest thing to happen to the Lions. Like of all the things that would be the meanest thing. I don't want that to happen.

This exact scenario happened in the Wild Card round; Stafford returned to Detroit for the Lions' first home playoff game in decades. The Lions won, so it wasn't 'brutal' in the way Big Cat feared for the outcome, but the matchup prediction was spot on.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Matthew Stafford for Jared Goff trade was a win for both the Rams and the Lions

No, [Stafford] is, I think he's always just had that same arm. That arm never goes away. It's just a matter of putting pieces around him and the, and the Rams have done, I'd say, you know what, I think both teams won that trade.

Both teams reached the playoffs multiple times after the trade, with the Rams winning a Super Bowl and the Lions reaching an NFC Championship Game with Goff.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Dennis Allen might be the worst coach of all time

We also need to talk about the fact that Dennis Allen might be the worst coach of all time. And that's not being facetious. That's not being like hyperbolic. That is, if you look at the stats, I think he is somewhere around the seventh to 10th worst coach record wise.

While Allen had a poor record, coaches like Hue Jackson (3-36-1) had statistically worse tenures, making 'all time worst' technically incorrect.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers will beat the Bengals in Week 16 because of their culture

This feels like to me and also no Jamar Chase for the Bengals and DJ reader, which will be very important in my opinion. This feels like the Mike Tomlin Steelers era is on the line. This is for the culture because it's, it's an underdog game at home. No one thinks the Steelers are good. They're very banged up and I think they're gonna win this game.

The Steelers beat the Bengals 34-11 in Week 16.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mason Rudolph starting on Christmas weekend is an easy scripted win for the Steelers

If we're looking at this from the eyes of the NFL script writers Mason Rudolph starting Christmas weekend, that seems like an easy win for the Steelers. ... I feel like this is a Mike Tomlin, do you have any culture game? Yes. And if they lose Big Ben was right. If they win, the culture exists for at least one more week.

The Steelers beat the Bengals 34-11, with Rudolph playing surprisingly well.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Chargers interim coach Giff Smith might be a rat for surviving three different head coaching regimes

He could be a rat. 'cause he survived three head coaches getting fired in Chargers now. Giff Smith was there under Mike McCoy. He was under there, there under Anthony Lynn. And now he was there for Brandon Staley getting fired. So I feel like three coaches, you gotta be like, wait, what's going on here?

This is a humorous characterization and cannot be factually proven.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bryce Young will win Offensive Player of the Week in Week 16

I think Bryce Young is gonna get offensive player of the week. Oh. Because the last two quarterbacks that the Packers have played against have done Offensive Player of the Week, baker Mayfield. And then the week before that Tommy Devito. Yeah. So, Bryce Young, next up Player of the week.

Bryce Young did not win NFC Offensive Player of the Week for Week 16 (Amari Cooper won AFC, and Puka Nacua/Baker Mayfield had strong weeks, but Baker was Week 15). Young had a good game (312 yards, 2 TDs), but didn't get the award.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The loser of the Cowboys-Dolphins game is officially a fraud, while the winner is a true Super Bowl contender

Whoever wins this game, the loser I'm going to think is just forget about it. ... winner's a super Bowl contender in my mind. This, this is the most important game of the, of the season in the entire NFL. ... They might as well just eliminate the loser from the playoffs and put the winner into their conference championship.

The Dolphins won the game but both teams were eliminated in the Wild Card round, largely validating the 'fraud' concerns for both, despite the winner status.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I feel so strongly about the 49ers that I'm going to bet the NFC to win the Super Bowl

I feel so strongly about the Niners that I almost wanna bet them. ... I think I might do that. Okay. Just go NFC. [Big Cat: Should just take the Niners to win the super Bowl even though it's a terrible lineup.]

The 49ers (NFC) lost the Super Bowl to the Chiefs (AFC).
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Philadelphia fans will end up rooting for 'Passing Paisan' Tommy DeVito on Christmas

Tommy is gonna go into Philly and that crowd's gonna be rooting so hard for my guy. And they're gonna say, Hey, this guy, he's a good guy. Standup guy. He's one of us. We can't root against our guy. The passing paisan. I love that. And that's what I love about the city. Philadelphia.

DeVito was actually benched during the game and Philly fans certainly did not root for him.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Ron Rivera will be fired by the Commanders

Do you think Ron Rivera will get fired? Yeah, I do.

Ron Rivera was fired by the Commanders on January 8, 2024.
Push
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill Belichick coaching for a team other than the Patriots is a looming reality

Could you see Bill Belichick coaching for any team, but the New England Patriots next year? I mean, I think it's a reality that's gonna, that's gonna come, you know, I won't believe it until it's done. But it it, when the media starts getting on this and starts talking about it where there's smoke, there's fire. And I just hope it's handled correctly.

Belichick and the Patriots mutually parted ways in January 2024, although he did not end up coaching for another team in the 2024 season.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Jerod Mayo is one of the smartest football players I ever played with

Jerod, he, he's one of the smartest football players I played with. You know, he was the guy that was helping me get lined up when I was playing DB. I'd look at him, he's [saying] cover fucking five, get over there. You know, so Jerod knows football.

Mayo was hired as the Patriots head coach shortly after, confirming the organization shared Edelman's high opinion of his intelligence.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Drops are contagious among wide receivers

Are drops contagious? They are. I, I, I, I honestly think it's not just one thing that you fix it, it, it comes down to, you know, guys working together to execute a play. ... It ultimately comes down to just practice and preparation.

This is a psychological observation from a professional athlete that is widely accepted in football culture.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers are beatable if you run the ball effectively and keep their offense off the field

You gotta run the ball against them. ... You do not want to get on a hole against that defensive line that only has to rush four. And then you can get all that crazy scheme of the defense behind and they fly. ... You gotta keep that offense off the field. You know, and that's what the running game does as well.

This is a fundamental football strategy; the Chiefs used a balanced attack to beat them in the Super Bowl.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Ravens are the biggest threat to the 49ers in a Super Bowl matchup

Lamar Jackson is just a game plan killer. Right. You know, he can go take a game over, you know, and especially if he's, you know, Odell, when when the lights are bright, you know, odells gonna come out and he's gonna start bawling. ... I think they're a scary football team ... Lamar Jackson and the Ravens are 19 and 5 against the spread as an underdog.

The Ravens and 49ers were the #1 seeds in their respective conferences, and the Ravens beat the 49ers on Christmas Day shortly after this take.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Brock Purdy is the NFL MVP

How do we talk about Brock Purdy? Is he the MVP? I mean, right now he, he probably is. That's a, I mean that the MVP's always a quarterback, right. ... You have to give credit to what Brock Purdy's doing. You have to, you have to, you know, the, this whole game manager thing, people don't realize it's more like a game operator.

Lamar Jackson won the 2023 NFL MVP. Purdy finished 4th in voting.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Drew Lock will make four career Pro Bowls

Drew Lock. My, my take that he would make four Pro Bowls, which I said like four years ago, three years ago in this program. Now it's at an all time high. I think it's even higher than it was when I set it. Yeah. At the time to be more likely. He's probably not gonna do that, but it's closer than it was yesterday.

Drew Lock has 0 career Pro Bowls as of the 2024 season and is a backup for the Giants.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks' season is officially saved after the win over the Eagles

Drew Lock, the Seahawks season is saved where now they are still like neck and neck where they're tied at seven and seven with the Vikings and the Rams and the Saints. Drew Lock having that moment, having everyone talking about him.

The Seahawks finished the season 9-8 and missed the playoffs. While the win kept them in the hunt, their season was ultimately not 'saved' in terms of postseason success.
Win
MaxMax

The Eagles will not be winning the Super Bowl this year

The Eagles will not be winning the Super Bowl this year.

The Eagles lost in the Wild Card round to the Buccaneers.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers