Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

MrBeast is effectively providing single-payer healthcare to individuals

I think the objection should be the fact that there are so many people out there that need a simple surgery that costs like a thousand dollars that can't afford it... Be mad at how we do healthcare. Be mad at healthcare, not MrBeast. Correctly providing single-payer healthcare to these people as an individual.

This is a social/political opinion on a specific event.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Watching deep-fake porn of your friends is a lifestyle choice, not a moment of weakness.

I've never clicked on a link being like, I want to jack off to my friends. That's not really, that sounds like a lifestyle choice. Not a moment of weakness.

This is an ethical and behavioral judgment that cannot be objectively proven true or false.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

People who work office jobs and don't shower in the morning are weird

My hot seat is I guess how I shower because I shower in the morning... People working like a nine to five in an office, not showering in the morning. That's fucking weird. It wakes you up. It makes you feel clean. It makes you feel fresh.

Inherently subjective matter of personal routine.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

Breakfast is unnecessary and takes up too much time

Intermittent fasting. Breakfast takes up too much time in the morning. Just like eating when you just wake up, do you do that? I think it would fall right with showers.

Subjective opinion on lifestyle and nutrition.
Void
Pete WeberPete Weber

The 10th strike is the most difficult part of bowling a 300 game

Everybody says the first one is the hardest one to throw. I totally disagree. I think the 10th one is. Because if you don't get the 10th one, then you have no chance... if you got the front nine, that 10th one is the most important.

This is a professional opinion from a subject matter expert.
Void
Pete WeberPete Weber

Dick Weber is the greatest bowler of all time.

To me my dad [Dick Weber] is the best of all time ever. Yeah, I agree. But you know, like Walter Ray has 47 titles... [but] I will never say that I'm better than him.

The 'GOAT' in any sport is inherently subjective, but coming from Pete Weber, it carries significant weight.
Win
Pete WeberPete Weber

The US Bowling Congress not inviting me to the US Open is an insult

A five-time Open champion... PBA/USBC Hall of Famer... and I don't get an invite? I think that's just an insult. That to me is a double insult. That I have to ask for an exemption into a tournament that I've won five times.

Pete Weber indeed did not receive an automatic invite to the 2023 US Open.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

A future Super Bowl punishment should be that someone has to hit a hole-in-one.

Next year I think we're gonna do, you gotta hit a hole in one. That would be so funny. If we just had a course in like a, a nice little [area]... it would take forever.

This was perfectly prescient; Max Dolente was eventually forced to attempt this exact feat in a viral 2024 marathon stream.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The late hit penalty on Joseph Ossai was 100% the correct call

The late hit call was good. That was the correct call. It was 100% the correct call. ... That's not a ref complaint because they got that right. And people who were upset about that call, they call that a hundred times out of a hundred times.

Officiating experts and the league office confirmed it was a clear late hit as Mahomes was well out of bounds.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL is rigged and scripted to get Patrick Mahomes in the Super Bowl

The NFL is rigged, rigged. It's rigged for ratings or for money. ... This shit is fucking rigged. The NFL is rigged. I don't, it's scripted everything... They want Patrick Mahomes in the Super Bowl.

The NFL is not literally scripted by Hollywood writers.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kirk Cousins has had a better NFL career than Tony Romo

I had a take last week that Kirk Cousins has had a better NFL career than Tony Romo did. ... I would rather have Kirk Cousins as the quarterback of my team for his whole career than Tony Romo. That's a fact.

Subjective comparison of two quarterbacks with similar profiles (high stats, limited playoff success). Romo has better peak accolades (All-Pro), Cousins has more longevity and volume.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles will win Super Bowl 57

Early thoughts. I'm not gonna hedge. I think the Eagles are gonna win this Super Bowl. I really do.

The Chiefs defeated the Eagles 38-35 in Super Bowl LVII.
Void
MaxMax

The Eagles roster is better than the Chiefs at every position group except quarterback and tight end

The Eagles are probably better than the Chiefs at every position group other than quarterback. Tight end—quarterback and tight end. Yeah. But offensive line, defensive line—I'm taking the birds. Receiver room, birds. Running game, birds. Secondary, birds. Like the Eagles have the better roster.

While the Eagles had a deeper roster, the Chiefs won the Super Bowl, arguably proving that having the edge at QB and TE (and head coach) was more important.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Andy Reid is a better head coach than Nick Sirianni

Andy Reid versus Sirianni. I would give the, I would put the check mark on Andy Reid's side on that one. So they [the Chiefs] get head coach and quarterbacks.

While subjective, Reid's victory in the head-to-head Super Bowl matchup and his historical resume support this.
Push
HankHank

I want the Chiefs to win the Super Bowl because of a bad referee call that screws over the Eagles

I'm rooting for the Chiefs to win in a similar game where the refs absolutely screw over the Eagles because then I can just be like, no, that was crazy. ... And it would just get Eagles fans so triggered because it'll be like, oh, they should have won. Like they basically won, but the refs.

The Chiefs did win, but the holding call on James Bradberry at the end, while debated, was generally considered a correct call and not a 'screw job' on the level Hank was hoping for.
Loss
Eli ManningEli Manning

The Bengals and 49ers will meet in Super Bowl 57

I think it'll definitely be the 49ers and the Bengals. I think they're playing the best, the best football and that would be a great, that'd be a great matchup. And two teams that have had a great run.

Both the Bengals and 49ers lost their respective conference championship games.
Void
Eli ManningEli Manning

I could still be a successful college quarterback today because of my knowledge of the game

I think I could, yeah, in college I could go in there and still be pretty successful. I wouldn't have to run the, the, the rush of the defense line is not, is not as bad. You could really, you know, get to a lot of good plays and with your checks and this knowledge. So I think I could go out there and, and have a pretty, a pretty successful year in college.

Cannot be verified as he is retired, but a 2-time Super Bowl winner would likely dominate college defenses mentally.
Void
Eli ManningEli Manning

My mother is the source of the championship genes in the Manning family

No doubt. She was a hoop a hoops player. You know, she, that's where we get the height from. She's, you know, six foot had a little hook shot. She was unstoppable in basketball. So that's where we get, that's where we get our vision. Just seeing the court, you know, and, and you know, but my mom, my mom's the best she was, was our, our ultimate fan and supporter.

Inherently subjective familial praise.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA referee apology for the LeBron no-call was written by Rich Paul

They should've had like just posted a picture of them at the time while they were tweeting it cuz it's definitely Rich Paul with a gun to their head. Yeah. As they're sitting there, LeBron James definitely hit up NBA officiating was like, I need a public apology. I need people to know that, that you guys screwed that up.

Hot TakeBasketballHotSarcastic
The apology was likely a PR move by the league, not literally dictated by an agent at gunpoint.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA play-in tournament gives bad teams a false sense of hope that they actually have a chance to win

I'm starting to sour on the play-in game. ... The NBA rigged it so that everyone has a chance so that everyone can stay invested. But it's like, do you really have a chance? ... Nobody really has a chance. ... They are right now two games out of the 10th seed and they're 23 and 27.

Since this is an opinion on league structure, it is subjective.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike McCarthy taking over play-calling is the beginning of the end for his time in Dallas

Mike McCarthy is saying that he's going to now take on play calling rules. So this is awesome. ... It's also just, it's the beginning of the end. And if it's because when you get this job, they're basically saying, now you have to fucking do this. Yes. And you're gonna, so it's, it is shuffling the, the deck chairs on the Titanic.

McCarthy's contract was not renewed after the 2024 season, confirming it was indeed the 'beginning of the end'.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Stetson Bennett's arrest for public intoxication makes him a better NFL draft prospect

Honestly that made Stetson Bennett go up in my draft board. ... If you're Stetson Bennett, what's stopping you from just getting absolutely hammered? He's in the middle of maybe the biggest case of senioritis of all time. And it's well deserved.

Bennett was drafted in the 4th round by the Rams. It's unlikely an arrest actually helped his draft stock with real NFL GMs.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Novak Djokovic is officially the greatest tennis player of all time

He won his 10th Australian Open. He is now tied with Rafa at all 22 men's singles Grand Slam. ... That's the goat. That's the goat.

Djokovic eventually surpassed Nadal and Federer in total Grand Slams and weeks at #1, strengthening the case.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Brock Purdy would erase Tom Brady's legacy if he wins seven Super Bowls

I'm rooting for Brock in the Niners because Brock has a chance to totally erase Tom Brady's narrative and legacy if he wins a Super Bowl... if he wins seven. If he wins seven, he would have a better... he would be like totally erased Tom Brady's underdog story cause it's even bigger underdog story.

Purdy is a great story but winning seven Super Bowls is an nearly impossible bar to clear.
Win
HankHank

The Eagles will beat the 49ers by three touchdowns

I'm betting on the Eagles. The Eagles are gonna win this game by three touchdowns. Rock Purdy is gonna have a Joe Flacco rookie quarterback stat line. Stop the run, score early, make 'em throw, win.

The Eagles won 31-7, exactly a 24-point (three touchdown + field goal) margin. Hank was shockingly accurate.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyle Shanahan is the first overall pick if NFL head coaches were redrafted

If every coach went into a big pool and you got to redraft coaches first overall pick. I think you take Kyle Shanahan... I'm not talking about in terms of the body of work... [but] right now.

This is subjective, but Shanahan remains widely considered a top-3 head coach in the NFL.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The first team to stop an early fourth down conversion will win the 49ers-Eagles game

There's gonna be a fourth down in the first half, a fourth and one... If they don't get it, they're gonna lose the game. Because fourth downs in the second quarter count exactly the same as fourth downs in the fourth quarter. Just file that one away.

The Eagles famously converted a 4th-and-3 on their opening drive (the DeVonta Smith 'catch'). The 49ers didn't really have a 'failed' early 4th down that flipped the game so much as the Purdy injury did.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Kadarius Toney will score a touchdown against the Bengals

I think Kadarius Toney's gonna score in this game. Reid's gonna break out some weird trick play that we haven't seen before... it's gonna be like, 'Kadarius Toney, the reason why we brought you here is you're a difference maker. Go do it.'

Toney did not score a touchdown in the AFC Championship game against the Bengals; he had one reception for 9 yards.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Steph Curry has an attitude problem because he keeps throwing his mouth guard

Steph Curry has been ejected three times in his entire career. All three for throwing his mouth guard. Does he have an attitude problem? He's always got it out half out of his mouth... why does he throw it?

Curry's ejections are indeed often related to mouthguard throwing, but labeling it an 'attitude problem' is subjective and comedic.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Pete Carroll did a bad job coaching the Seahawks this year

I think that Pete Carroll, you can now look back and make the argument Pete Carroll did a bad job coaching this year because they got more talented at the quarterback position this year [with Geno Smith]. And they failed to achieve the ultimate goals of winning playoff games.

Subjective opinion on coaching quality, though contrarian to the consensus that Carroll was a Coach of the Year candidate.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

NFL teams cannot just 'flip the switch' in the playoffs

Guys are just gonna flip the switch and it never happens like that. You are what you are. And that's the honest truth with football... Belichick used to say it, 'You can't just take a fucking Gatorade before practice and turn it on.'... Teams cannot turn it on.

Subjective football philosophy.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Buffalo Bills are a finesse team that can't run the ball or stop the run

What's a finesse team? A team that can't run the ball and can't stop the run. They had the best running game like statistically... but if you were watching the games, you're like, they can't run the football.

The Bills were bullied by the Bengals in the divisional round, supporting the claim that they lacked physical toughness in key moments.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill O'Brien is a great hire for the Patriots because he understands the standard

I think it's a great move for the Patriots because [Bill O'Brien] understands the standard. He's been in the situation of being a coach in the organization... and he's also been a head coach... he single-handedly developed Deshaun Watson, made him a $250 million quarterback.

O'Brien's 2023 return as OC for the Patriots resulted in a stagnant offense, and the team finished 4-13, leading to the departure of both Belichick and O'Brien.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Patrick Mahomes will not be able to practice physically before the AFC Championship

I don't think he's gonna physically be able to practice. I mean, they're gonna try to get that swelling out the whole week... I sprained my ankle and it wasn't even a real bad high ankle and I was out for like four weeks.

Mahomes was a full participant in practice all week leading up to the game and played effectively, despite Edelman's skepticism.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Chris Jones will be a massive problem for the Bengals' backup offensive line

Chris Jones is gonna be a problem. I marked Chris Jones [as a] problem. That was it, that was my entire scouting report. Problem... especially when you're in the middle of that thing with a guy like Burrow who likes sitting in that spot.

Chris Jones had a dominant performance with 2 sacks and 5 QB hits, terrorizing Burrow all game.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers will beat the Eagles in the NFC Championship

I like the Niners against Philadelphia. Niners defense... the linebackers for the Niners are insane. It's gonna be a bloodbath... I'm taking the Niners. I'm taking Kyle Shanahan over Sirianni. That's why I'm taking the Niners.

The Eagles defeated the 49ers 31-7 after Brock Purdy was injured early in the game.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Bengals will beat the Chiefs in the AFC Championship

I'm going with Bengals and it has to do with the ankle of Patrick Mahomes. I mean, that's gonna be a tough task... that Bengals team, they got a swagger, they got a confidence. They don't have excuses.

The Chiefs defeated the Bengals 23-20 to advance to the Super Bowl.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will cut my hair short by the summer if it doesn't improve

I'm dealing with my hair issue... noticeably thinning out back there. I've made the executive decision if it doesn't improve by the summer, we're taking it off. We're going short... I got my own blood injected into my head earlier today... if I haven't turned it around by then, gotta come home.

PFT did eventually cut his hair for the 'PMT Mount Rushmore' bet/move to Chicago, though he has fluctuated on length since then.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially refusing to wear flip flops in gym showers or steam rooms

I've been going in the gym's shower and the steam room with no flip flops and I'm disgusted by myself... [but] I'm never getting flip flops. Fuck it. I'm never getting flip flops.

This is a personal lifestyle choice.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Burrow is the best quarterback at 'quarterbacking' while Patrick Mahomes is just a great football player who plays quarterback

I think Joe Burrow is the best quarterback at quarterbacking in the NFL right now. [Patrick Mahomes] is a very good quarterback who happens to be a football player. Joe Burrow is a great quarterback who just happens to play football, right? Patrick Mahomes is a great football player who just happens to play quarterback.

This is a stylistic and subjective comparison of two elite players.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Brock Purdy will not be able to survive the environment at Lincoln Financial Field

Brock Purdy's top G in the NFL right now... but the man won't, won't be able to survive the Link [Lincoln Financial Field]. I just can't wrap my head around any world where a rookie quarterback goes in the Link and beats the number one seed Eagles.

Purdy was injured early in the game, and the 49ers lost 31-7, so he did not 'survive' or win the game.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears and Commanders would have eventually ruined Patrick Mahomes and Joe Burrow if they had drafted them

Our franchises are... they will never have nice things. Like if Patrick Mahomes was drafted by the Bears, the Bears would've ruined him. If the Commanders drafted Joe Burrow, they would've ruined him. We [Commanders] actually did our best to try to ruin Joe Burrow as an NFL quarterback [by hitting him].

This is a hypothetical claim about organizational culture that can never be proven true or false.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Chris Jones is going to be a massive problem for the Bengals in the AFC Championship

I actually think that the conversation last week about the Bengals offensive line... this week, Chris Jones is gonna wreck some shit. Because we all watched that Bills-Bengals game and we're like, 'Wow, the Bengals offensive line played incredible.' But the Bills don't have Chris Jones. Chris Jones is gonna be a problem.

Chris Jones was the dominant force in the game, recording two sacks and five QB hits in the Chiefs' 23-20 victory.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bengals have the best defensive line of the four remaining teams in the playoffs

I think the Bengals defensive line is the best defensive line that's remaining. Better than the Eagles and the Niners? I think so. Between DJ Reader, [Trey] Hendrickson, and then you got Sam Hubbard. That's a good room.

While the Bengals D-line was great, the Eagles unit was statistically historic with 70 sacks on the season, making this a tough subjective argument to win.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I will root for Aaron Rodgers to win a Super Bowl the moment he leaves the Packers

If Aaron Rodgers goes anywhere else, I will root for him to win a Super Bowl. Because it will be hilarious if he wins the same amount of Super Bowls on another team in like a year or two that he did with the Packers in 16 years. The minute he's gone, it would be very funny if he won a Super Bowl with another team.

Rodgers joined the Jets in 2023 but suffered a season-ending injury in Week 1, and the team struggled, so the Super Bowl scenario has not yet materialized.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will go on an Ayahuasca trip if Aaron Rodgers becomes the quarterback of the Commanders

Let me be very clear. I will go on an Ayahuasca trip if Aaron Rodgers becomes the quarterback of the Commanders. [Big Cat]: I'll match. We'll match, boys trip to Ecuador. I'll do anything to get him off the Packers... I will change my entire mindset. I would do it.

Aaron Rodgers was traded to the New York Jets, not the Commanders.
Win
HankHank

No rookie quarterback is going to win in the Linc against the number one seed Eagles

I just can't wrap my head around any world where a rookie quarterback goes in the Link and beats the number one seed Eagles. It's a philosophy. It's a life philosophy. It doesn't change year over year. Rookie quarterbacks in the playoffs, young quarterbacks are gonna struggle.

The Eagles defeated the 49ers 31-7 in the NFC Championship. Brock Purdy was injured early in the game, but the take held true regarding the outcome.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

John Scheyer is officially on the hot seat at Duke

My hot seat is John Scheyer. I'm surprised that it's taken us this long as a podcast to put John Scheyer on the hot seat. But he's in ninth place in the ACC as Duke's head coach. And I for one, miss Coach K.

Duke eventually turned their season around, winning the ACC Tournament and finishing 27-9. Scheyer was never in actual danger of being fired.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Baseball Hall of Fame is a joke because Barry Bonds is not in it

And Barry [Bonds] is not on there? This whole thing is a joke. The best player of all time is not in the fucking Hall of Fame. It's just funny that baseball writers take themselves so seriously. We just need all these guys to die and then maybe we can get the real players in the Hall of Fame.

This is a subjective opinion on the validity of the Hall of Fame based on Bonds' exclusion.
Void
Stephen A. SmithStephen A. Smith

The Dallas Cowboys are the most delusional, disgusting fan base in American history

I'm not bullshitting when I talk about Cowboy fans. I mean what I say about them. They are the most delusional, disgusting fan base in American history. It doesn't matter what happens to them. Give it 15 minutes. 'All right, we'll do it next year. We're going to win Super Bowl next year.' It's just nauseating. They don't take any time to smell their stench, which is why it's so enjoyable when they lose over and over and over again.

This is a subjective opinion about a fan base, though the Cowboys' lack of postseason success since 1995 provides plenty of fuel for the argument.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers