Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers will play in the NFL in 2023 for $50 million despite his 'darkness retreat'

I can save you. You don't have to have your brain exert the chemical that's reserved for you when you die to pacify you... to know that Yes, you do want to play football for one more year for 50 million.

Aaron Rodgers did return to play in 2023, though he was traded to the New York Jets and suffered a season-ending injury in Week 1.
Void
JJ WattJJ Watt

The Hall of Fame should give me a speaking slot before Tom Brady so I don't have to follow him

I don't want the last speech. Oh, have no interest in the last speech. Okay. So see, I can, like, I can just fluff it up for Tom and let him hit it out of the park. I can give him all like the, the praise and everything and then just let him maybe say like a quick sentence about me before he gets into Yeah. Thanking everybody.

This is a subjective preference about event scheduling.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JJ Watt is a significantly better football player than he is a person

A lot of people will say like, JJ Watt great player, all-time player, even better person. That's bullshit. You're a way better football player than you are a person and you're a pretty good person.

This is a subjective comparison between athletic peak and personal character.
Void
JJ WattJJ Watt

I'm the greatest defender ever for a single season or game

For one single game? Or are you talking about for one single season that which player would you want? Because that's different. I mean, I'm, I'm never gonna argue for the longevity of my career... But for one season or one game, I, I'll, I'll put myself in that argument.

Watt won 3 DPOY awards in 4 years; statistically, his 2014 season is widely considered one of the best in NFL history.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders' home field at FedEx Field is responsible for player injuries and is cursed

I'd like to get off that field. Everybody's been hurt on that field. Yeah. Oh. I mean, and just like as a guy who's played in every, every stadium... That place could use upgrade.

FedEx Field has a long-standing reputation for poor field conditions and high injury rates.
Void
JJ WattJJ Watt

Trent Williams is the best at using a defender's momentum and 'vet savvy' against them

One of the guys that does that [using tricks] very well, as Trent Williams. Trent does, he has some tricks and, and things to his game that are just very, very smart, very vet savvy... [he'll] just knock your hands down and you'll fall flat on your face.

Subjective opinion from an elite contemporary player.
Open
JJ WattJJ Watt

T.J. Watt will be a better player than me if he stays healthy

If he stays healthy and, and I, I hope he stays healthy and I hope he does. He'll break every record I got and he'll absolutely be a better player than me. There's no doubt for a single season, for a single, like being able to do everything. I I I won't give up that title.

T.J. Watt has already won a DPOY and holds elite sack numbers, but JJ's 20.5 sack seasons and multiple DPOY awards set a very high bar.
Loss
JJ WattJJ Watt

Luke Fickell is building a monster at the University of Wisconsin

Luke Fickell building a monster. Looking forward to that. ... We have more quarterbacks in the room now than we've had our entire history ever. I don't understand. I have no clue what's going on.

Luke Fickell did not build a 'monster' at Wisconsin. The Badgers went 4-8 in 2025, their worst season under Fickell, with blowout losses to Iowa (37-0) and Ohio State (34-0).
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kirk Cousins' Pro Bowl victory proves he can win big games

Kirk Cousins leads NFC to a comeback. So there you go. All the haters that say Kirk Cousins can't win a big game. He just won the Pro Bowl Flag Football challenge.

Literally correct that he won the flag football game, but the take is entirely ironic.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyrie Irving to the Mavericks is a good move because there's only half a season for his 'team cancer' to spread

I think it's a good move for the Mavericks because he only has half a season for his team cancer to spread. So this is like a good window for Kyrie... it's hard to destroy a brand new team in like four months.

The Mavs actually missed the playoffs and even the play-in tournament entirely in 2023 after the trade, so it did not work out well in the short term.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Kyrie Irving trade raises the Mavericks' ceiling but makes their floor 'lava'

This trade to the Mavericks raises their ceiling but makes the floor lava. And that's perfect... In a world where this all works out, you now added like... a walking bucket.

The Mavericks finished 11th in the West, missing the postseason, which arguably hit the 'lava' floor in the immediate aftermath.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Mavericks will win their first-round series but then Kyrie Irving will eventually cause the team to flame out

I think the Mavs will probably, like, they'll torch some team in the first round and everyone will say, look at this, this is real. And then either Kyrie [Irving] will get hurt or decide not to show up or something will happen and they won't win a title... there's just no way that this is gonna end [well].

The Mavericks missed the playoffs entirely in 2023, so they didn't even get the first-round 'torch' job Big Cat predicted.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I might bet on the Mavericks to win the NBA championship this year following the Kyrie trade

I might put some money down on the Mavs winning the championship this year. Cause what if? Yeah, that'd be, can you imagine that... the Dallas Mavericks are world champions.

The Mavericks failed to qualify for the playoffs in 2023.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kevin Durant misses and appreciates Steph Curry more after playing with Kyrie Irving and Ben Simmons

I actually think the internet might have bullied [Kevin Durant] a little too hard with the legacy talk... playing with James Harden, Ben Simmons and Kyrie [Irving] I would say makes you appreciate Steph Curry a lot more... He probably writes out text messages to Steph at like two in the morning and then deletes them being like, 'I miss you. I'm sorry... I should have been okay with [it being your team]'.

This is a subjective assessment of a player's private feelings.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Adding Kevin Durant to the Phoenix Suns would make them a major threat to win the Western Conference

The Phoenix Suns are prepared to pursue Brooklyn Nets star Kevin Durant... that scares me a little bit because I do think that the Suns with Kevin Durant would probably become a significant threat... the West is crazy. The West has every team could win it right now.

The Suns did acquire Durant and became a top contender, though they lost in the second round of the playoffs to the Nuggets.
Loss
MaxMax

The Eagles will win Super Bowl LVII

I mean regardless... I mean you guys [Eagles] are gonna win.

The Eagles lost Super Bowl LVII to the Chiefs, 38-35.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Duke is officially back after snapping their losing streak against North Carolina

Who's back is Duke? They snap their losing streak. Their two game losing streaks [against] North Carolina over the weekend... they're one and oh in the post coach K era against North Carolina.

Duke finished the season 27-9, winning the ACC tournament, but lost in the second round of the NCAA tournament. Whether they are 'back' is subjective.
Void
Chris BermanChris Berman

Tom Brady and Joe Montana are tied as the greatest quarterbacks of all time

I do [think Brady is the greatest]. It's one on one A... but if the ultimate yardstick is winning... he played in 21 years... he played in half the Super Bowls. He won a third of them, seven out of 21... I'm not saying he won with, he still had great coaching... but [Brady and Montana] are the best.

Greatest of all time rankings are inherently subjective.
Void
Chris BermanChris Berman

The Buffalo Bills lost to the Bengals because they were emotionally and physically drained by the Damar Hamlin situation and multiple snowstorms

I wondered, and I'm close with them, but they're human beings with Damar Hamlin... you had that for three weeks. Maybe not sleeping at night worrying about him. You had two, six-foot snowfalls where you're going to Detroit... I wondered how much gas did they use up to get to this point? Is that the reason they lost to the Bengals? The Bengals were better, but they're human beings... It's a slow leak in the tire.

This is an interpretive claim about a team's psychological state.
Loss
Chris BermanChris Berman

The Buffalo Bills and San Francisco 49ers will eventually meet in a Super Bowl

I found the football [from 1992]... it didn't happen. But I saved that one... I un-saved seven of them, but saved that one. I was ready to bring it on set... and alas, alas, it'll wait another year. [Bills versus Niners].

Chris Berman hoped for a Bills vs. 49ers Super Bowl. This did not happen in Super Bowl LX. The Bills lost in the Divisional Round to the Broncos, and the 49ers lost in the Divisional Round to the Seahawks. The Super Bowl was Seahawks vs. Patriots.
Open
Chris BermanChris Berman

The Buffalo Bills will reach at least one Super Bowl during the Josh Allen window

I think they'll be in one, at least one. Cause [Josh Allen] is really good. And he was hurt... but they're the best three [Mahomes, Burrow, Allen]. I'm very confident that they'll [get in].

Josh Allen's window is still open. As of the end of the 2024 season, the Bills have not yet reached a Super Bowl with Allen.
Open
Chris BermanChris Berman

Andy Reid will coach the Chiefs for at least five more years

I would think... Will Mahomes play more than five more years? Yes. Let's hope so. I'd be surprised if, if [Andy Reid] is not driven by... where am I going? If I have [Mahomes] and I have this set up.

Andy Reid is still coaching the Chiefs as of early 2025. We need to see if he reaches the 5-year mark from the 2023 take.
Push
Chris BermanChris Berman

The Chiefs will beat the Eagles 29-26 in Super Bowl LVII

I'm gonna pick the Chiefs... Could it be 31 27? Yes it could. About 29, 26 having a schwam. Yeah, that's a schwam score... I'm gonna give you guys the nod with the score.

Berman correctly predicted the Chiefs would win, but the final score was 38-35, not 29-26.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Brady is the GOAT of retirements

It's back-to-back retirements, two consecutive retirements for Tom Brady. He's the GOAT at that too. Not a dynasty, but a nice little run.

Brady did eventually stay retired after this, making it exactly two consecutive retirements before his transition to broadcasting.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

There is a 25% chance Tom Brady comes back from retirement

I listen, Tom Brady. Thanks. It does feel like he's officially retired this time. Would we say, you said 25% chance he comes back. I still think he can come back.

Tom Brady did not return to play in the NFL after this retirement video.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

No one will ever win seven Super Bowls again

He is the greatest quarterback of all time. I know that there's now debates going around... Tom Brady was seven and three. I don't think anyone will ever win seven Super Bowls again.

The highest active player is Patrick Mahomes with 3. Matching 7 is nearly impossible in the modern era.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Greg Olsen might fend off Tom Brady for the top Fox broadcasting job

I also think that there's a decent chance that Greg Olsen fends Tom Brady off somehow because he's that good and he's a proven commodity now. And you can still, you can think, yeah, it's Tom Brady and he'll probably approach it with the same dedication he approached football with... but I think that there's a chance that they work something out behind the scenes because they like Greg Olsen.

Tom Brady did eventually take over the #1 booth at Fox for the 2024 season, displacing Olsen.
Void
Corey KispertCorey Kispert

Madison Square Garden, Philly, and Capital One Arena are the three best shooters' gyms in the NBA

Personally I think it's the Garden. I think it's Philly. And then as a Wizard, I think it's the Great Capital One Arena. Great spot to watch a game.

This is a subjective preference of an NBA player.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Tom Brady has more playoff wins than most NFL franchises; he has more than the Browns, Jets, and Saints combined.

Tom Brady has 35 [playoff wins], which is pretty fucking insane. He has more playoff games than 13 teams total. He has more playoff wins than the Browns, Jets and Saints combined as franchises.

The stats were accurate at the time of his retirement in 2023.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Brady’s career was the direct result of the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand

He's the walking embodiment of the butterfly effect... Gabriel Prince [Gavrilo Princip] got assassinated or assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand... It immediately led to Tom Brady's career in the NFL. Started all of it.

It's a satirical causal link that cannot be factually proven or disproven but is logically absurd.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Brady will have a weird retirement filled with plastic surgery

He's going to have a very weird retirement. He's going to be plastic surgery dating like random chicks all the time. The TV 12... he's going to do some weird shit. There's nobody that's ever had just a touch of plastic surgery.

Brady's post-retirement appearance has been a constant source of internet speculation regarding cosmetic procedures.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Everyone at the Cowboys is about to get fired because Jerry Jones is talking about 20-year timelines

I don't know what the Cowboys, it feels like everyone's about to get fired because why else would you talk like this? Jerry Jones... said he wants Mike McCarthy to coach the Cowboys as long as Tom Landry... Steven Jones today said he wants Dak to be their quarterback for the next 10 years.

Mike McCarthy's contract expired after a 7-10 2024 season and he and the Cowboys parted ways. Dak Prescott was injured and missed most of the season. The organization did undergo major changes, though it wasn't exactly 'everyone getting fired' — McCarthy's contract simply wasn't renewed, and they hired Brian Schottenheimer.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am betting $8,500 on the Eagles to be a good friend to Big Cat

I've decided, I'm going... I need to be a good friend. Would a good friend root against his buddy to lose $200,000? No... So I've decided... I'll put 8,500 on the Eagles.

The Eagles lost Super Bowl LVII to the Chiefs 38-35.
Open
Corey KispertCorey Kispert

Gonzaga will eventually win a national title

Is Gonzaga ever going to win a national title? Yes. Yes. But soon? That's a different question... I think we're gonna win one.

Gonzaga has still not won a national title as of 2024.
Void
Josh DuhamelJosh Duhamel

Kirk Cousins is just like Dak Prescott; he has a ceiling and is never going to lead a team to a Super Bowl win.

I gotta say the guy [Cousins] played pretty well... The problem is he's like Dak, he's got a cap and he's not, he's never going to take you all the way... He's gonna do something stupid in the end... He's gonna check down.

Opinion on a player's capability; Cousins hasn't reached a Super Bowl.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes will have the career numbers, but Joe Burrow might be the one winning more Super Bowl titles.

Maybe it's like one of those things where... Mahomes will put up the numbers and Burrow might win the titles.

As of late 2024, Mahomes has 3 titles and Burrow has 0, making this look unlikely, but it's still pending.
Win
Josh DuhamelJosh Duhamel

Aaron Rodgers had his worst year ever and the Packers didn't even deserve to make the playoffs.

I was hoping they [the Packers] weren't gonna make the playoffs just cause I didn't think they deserved to be there. They, he [Aaron Rodgers] had a, his worst year I've seen him play.

Rodgers did have statistically one of his worst years (91.1 passer rating) and the Packers missed the playoffs.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Punxsutawney Phil is a fraud and a 'wannabe Greta Thunberg'

My big fire fest is really for America... because you guys are letting a groundhog ruin your day today. Punxsutawney Phil saw his shadow... be a fucking man... I'm going to wear shorts and short-sleeve t-shirts just to show that little wannabe Greta Thunberg telling me the sky is falling.

Hot TakeLifeHotSarcastic
A groundhog's weather prediction is scientifically unreliable, making 'fraud' a reasonable (if comedic) label.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am having a third child and I purposefully conceived to ensure it wouldn't be born during football season

I'm having another child, so congrats. Father three loading... early June... Are you purposely conceiving for the off-season? I mean, yeah... it's nice not having children during football season. I am a football guy.

Big Cat's third child was indeed born in June 2023, during the NFL offseason.
Loss
Josh DuhamelJosh Duhamel

I still believe Carson Wentz has good football left in him and I would take him on the Vikings right now.

I still believe in Carson... You don't jump ship on somebody that quickly... I still believe that he's got some good football in him. I'll take him on the Vikings, man. I would trade [Kirk Cousins] for him.

Wentz has not regained his form as a top-tier starter since this take.
Void
Corey KispertCorey Kispert

Steph Curry is an underrated defender because he has great hands and gets a lot of steals.

I would say [Steph Curry's] defense is underrated... You see his stature and his height and you kind of think you can go at him, but he does a really good job. He's got great hands and gets a ton of steals.

Subjective opinion from an active NBA player.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am going to wear shorts and short-sleeve t-shirts all next week in the cold just to prove that Punxsutawney Phil isn't the boss of me.

Be a fucking man. I'm gonna put on shorts right in that little rat fuck's [Punxsutawney Phil] face. I'm gonna wear shorts next, all next week... just to show that little wannabe Greta Thunberg telling me, 'oh, the sky is falling,' that I'm a man and I can make my own decisions.

OpinionLifeHotSubjectiveSarcastic
It's a personal vow/opinion on Groundhog Day rituals.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

I'm going to beat Billy McFarland in a fight, and it's going to be a public execution.

I'm gonna beat his ass. Gonna skull fuck him. It's gonna be sick. This is gonna be a public execution. He's gonna be a Christian in the Colosseum and he's gonna get fed to the lion.

The fight never occurred.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I would beat the fuck out of Darren Rovell in a fight, make him cry, and force him to delete his Twitter.

I wanted to wipe [Darren Rovell] off the internet. He'd have to delete his Twitter if I beat him. I would beat the fuck out of Darren Rovell. I would smash his nose in. I would make him cry.

The fight never happened, so the outcome is speculative.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Sean Payton is the perfect coach to fix Russell Wilson

Sean Payton's worth more than the 29th pick when [Russell Wilson] has been so bad and you've invested in Russell Wilson. You gotta figure out a way to fix him. Who better to fix a short quarterback whose arm might be losing a little bit of the steam? He's the perfect guy.

Payton famously failed to fix Wilson, benching him at the end of the 2023 season before the team took a massive dead cap hit to release him.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sean Payton will be a decent coach in Denver but won't win a Super Bowl with Russell Wilson

The vibe that I'm getting is that he's gonna come back. He's gonna be a decent head coach... I think he knows how to run a team. So it's gonna be a completely different look for the Broncos... but I don't see him like winning Super Bowls in Denver. At least not with Russell Wilson.

Wilson was released by the Broncos in March 2024 without winning a playoff game under Payton.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Kelce brothers facing off in the Super Bowl is genuinely wild and not overstated

The Kelce Brothers, it's gonna be talked about nonstop... it's actually very crazy. It's really cool that they are the first two brothers to face off in a Super Bowl and they're both really fucking good. I actually think it's wild.

The Kelce brothers did indeed become the first brothers to play against each other in a Super Bowl on Feb 12, 2023.
Loss
HankHank

Patrick Mahomes will eventually catch Tom Brady in Super Bowl losses

People keep talking about Patrick Mahomes is gonna catch up to Brady. Right? That's the storyline. Well in my eyes he's going—the only thing that he's going to catch up to Brady on is Super Bowl losses. He would lose this one and would still need to lose another one. But if he did, then he would catch up to Tom Brady in losses.

Mahomes won Super Bowl LVII (and Super Bowl LVIII the following year), meaning he did not add to his Super Bowl loss total (still at 1). Tom Brady lost 3 Super Bowls.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 76ers 'Process' worked; they just drafted the wrong players

I don't know. It kind of worked. They got the guys, they just picked the wrong guys. Picked Markelle Fultz and Ben Simmons and Nerlens Noel. The actual [Process]—and Embiid. Of course. But I'm saying the process, I always am a fan of the process because I always thought the brutal honesty of a team being like, we are trying to suck so that one day we can get good. I actually am a big fan.

The 76ers have yet to reach a conference final since starting The Process, though Joel Embiid did win an MVP.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tanking in professional sports objectively works.

Tanking works. It objectively works. If the Redskins had lost that Dolphins team, yeah. I would have Joe Burrow right now. That's just a fact.

While subjective, his specific example is widely supported by NFL analysts who agree the Redskins missed out on Burrow by winning a meaningless game.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers