Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Jake ArrietaJake Arrieta

The Padres made a huge mistake not bringing in Josh Hader to face Bryce Harper in the NLCS

And I mean, Harper the biggest at bat of his entire career... They don't bring in Josh Hader to face Harper, which I think was a huge mistake even though Suarez had pitched extremely well. It's like you have the best left-handed guy ready in the bullpen and he's on fire.

Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Sam Ehlinger is a better quarterback than Trevor Lawrence

The original take was Sam Ehlinger was a better quarterback than Trevor Lawrence. Right. If Sam Ehlinger even looks he won the bracket. If they finish above 500, I think you get a dub.

Trevor Lawrence established himself as a franchise QB while Ehlinger failed to keep the starting job long-term.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jim Nantz retiring from calling the Final Four but keeping the trophy presentation is 'horse shit'

I love Jim Nantz but I think this is kind of horse shit what he's doing. I think you have to either get out the Final four or all the way. Yeah. Or you're in it all the way. Yeah. You can't just say, I'm not gonna announce the game, but then kick it to me for the trophy presentation.

This is a subjective opinion on broadcasting etiquette.
Void
John KrukJohn Kruk

The Phillies 'daycare' players brought a winning energy that the veterans fed off of

I really think, you know, what they call the daycare the young kids, I think is infuse of energy in these guys... the stats, the ves, the may times, you know, they, they brought in a whole different energy for this team. And I think the older guys are feeding off these young players.

This is a subjective assessment of team chemistry during a successful run.
Win
Jake ArrietaJake Arrieta

Jeremy Pena is going to be a superstar in MLB

Jeremy Pena who's from Rhode Island, a third rounder that nobody even really knew about. Now he's one of the, the superstars of the post-season turning himself into, I don't know if we can technically call him a star yet, but it just, it looks like it's going in that direction. If you can perform at this level, this consistently, when games mean this much, I mean there's a 99.9% chance this dude is gonna be absolutely legit.

Jeremy Pena went on to win World Series MVP and became a fixture for the Astros.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Daniel Jones has officially become 'the guy' for the Giants

He's definitely become the guy... He's got that dog in him officially now.

While Jones led them to the playoffs in 2022 and got a massive extension, his play regressed significantly in 2023 and 2024, leading to him being benched.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The New York Giants will make the playoffs

The New York Giants are gonna make the playoffs. They just are, they're going. It's hard. I want you to all prepare yourself for that moment because I don't want to sneak up on anybody. The New York Giants are gonna be playoff team.

The Giants finished the 2022 season 9-7-1 and made the playoffs as a Wild Card team.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers are failing because they refuse to run an offense that fits their personnel

They have a roster set up to run the football and play defense and win games the ugly way. Yet they just refuse to run the football and use probably their best offensive player, not Aaron Rodgers, is Aaron Jones. They just don't use him... they're essentially running an offense that is not fit for their personnel and it just keeps failing.

The Packers finished 8-9 and missed the playoffs, with internal friction over the offensive scheme remaining a storyline throughout Rodgers' final season there.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Buccaneers are officially a bad football team

The Bucs are a bad football team. They lose 21 to three to the Carolina Panthers, who everyone thought was the worst football team in the nfl... they not only beat 'em, they beat the shit out of 'em. The bucks are so broken.

The Bucs finished 8-9, and while they technically won the division, they had a losing record and were easily eliminated in the Wild Card round.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Panthers should not trade DJ Moore or Brian Burns

DJ Moore played well, caught a crazy touchdown pass and Brian Burns played well and he's like, The Panthers should not trade those two guys. I know there's been a lot of talk about it... You don't want to trade like your actually young, good talent because then you draft someone and there's like a 50% chance they suck.

Moore was eventually traded to the Bears in the Caleb Williams/No. 1 pick deal, while Burns was traded to the Giants in 2024. Whether these were 'correct' moves is subjective, but Moore's departure directly enabled them to get Bryce Young.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Yankees are a bad franchise for their 13-year World Series drought

Congratulations the Red Sox, the Phillies, the Cubs and the Nationals have all gone to the World Series and the Yankees have not... That's a bad franchise. Imagine saying that... the Yankees have not [made it]. It's a bad franchise, poorly run franchise. Pinstripes don't mean anything anymore.

The Yankees had not reached a World Series since 2009 at this point, which is a fact. Calling them a 'bad franchise' is a subjective hot take.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Ryan is no longer a good quarterback

He's a very nice guy. We've had him on the show... He's had a great career. He's not good anymore.

Matt Ryan was benched twice during the 2022 season and retired shortly after.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Zach Taylor is officially a very good head coach

I think it's safe to say the Bengals are officially a well-coached team... the body of evidence is big enough now on Zach Taylor where you can say he's a very good coach. He might fuck up occasionally game to game, but you're in good hands with Zach Taylor in the long term.

Taylor led the Bengals back to the AFC Championship game later that season, further cementing his status as a top-tier coach.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Atlanta Falcons will make the playoffs

I think the Falcons are gonna make the playoffs. Ooh, that's my take. How I think they might make the playoffs... the most likely possibility for the Falcons to make the playoffs would be if the Buccaneers imploded entirely.

The Falcons finished 7-10 and missed the playoffs.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Arthur Smith is a good coach and the Falcons are in good hands

If the Falcons make the playoffs at all this year, you are fucking pumped going into next year because you realize that Arthur Smith is a good coach. If they're able to do that, [it's because he's a good coach].

Smith finished with three consecutive 7-10 seasons and was fired in early 2024, suggesting he was ultimately not the long-term answer.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys are a good football team, but they aren't 'Super Bowl good'

The Cowboys are good, but I don't think they're Super Bowl good, but they're good. They're a good team and they play great defense.

The Cowboys finished 12-5 but lost in the Divisional Round to the 49ers, proving they were a tier below the Super Bowl contenders.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Broncos' offensive struggles are not just about Russell Wilson

Russell Wilson's offense too sucks no matter what. Brett Ripen looked exactly the same as Russell Wilson in that office. It just stinks and it's completely wasted by a garbage, garbage offense.

Hackett was fired before his first season ended after leading one of the worst offenses in modern NFL history, confirming the problem was systemic.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Seattle Seahawks are a legitimately good football team

The Seattle Seahawks... might be a good football team. I don't think that there's anything weird or fluky about this team. I think that they're just playing good football and Pete Carroll is having a great time.

The Seahawks finished 9-8 and made the playoffs, exceeding all preseason expectations.
Void
HankHank

If the 49ers fail to win a Super Bowl, it will be because of Jimmy Garoppolo

There's no reason why they shouldn't make the championship or the Super Bowl. And if they don't it's probably gonna be because of Jimmy g.

Jimmy Garoppolo got injured later in the season, and Brock Purdy led them to the NFC Championship game, where he also got hurt. It's difficult to judge since Jimmy G didn't finish the season.
Loss
HankHank

The Sixers and Lakers are tanking for Victor Wembanyama

Tanking in the nba... there is a clear, clear, clear number. One Victor Wembanyama from France... so teams are tanking. The Sixers oh three trying to get 'em. Lakers oh three trying to get 'em.

The Sixers finished 3rd in the East and the Lakers made the Western Conference Finals. Neither team was tanking.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Bryce Harper has officially silenced all his critics

Bryce Harper... what he has done this playoffs and erased any negative Bryce Harper talk... he's been absolutely insane. I like that everything [Aaron] Judge isn't, Harper is. He was saying into the camera, 'I am that dude.' And it's like, yeah, you are.

Harper won NLCS MVP and led the Phillies to the World Series, proving he was a true franchise cornerstone and playoff performer.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Saints will beat the Cardinals 23-17

I'm gonna say Saints 23, Cardinals 17.

The Cardinals won 42-34, which is significantly different from the predicted low-scoring Saints win.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cliff Kingsbury is performing exactly as his resume suggested he would and is not a disappointment

I think people don't realize that Cliff Kingsbury is exactly who they thought he was when they hired him. Like, he has not been a disappointment based on his resume. He's been exactly what you should have thought that you were gonna get. He showed you what he is and he's been that.

This is a subjective assessment of Kingsbury's coaching pedigree versus his NFL output.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Being LeBron James' teammate is the most difficult job in the world

Being LeBron's teammate has to be like the most difficult job in the world. Not on the court because LeBron is obviously one of the best all time on the court... But it's, every time you lose, it's someone else's fault. Every time you win, it's, LeBron did it.

This is a subjective assessment of team dynamics and media perception.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lakers are only plus-160 to miss the playoffs, which is a juicy bet

They're only plus one 60 to miss the playoffs. [Big Cat: That's it? That's it?] That's juicy. [Hank: It's kind of low. I was hoping it was gonna be a little bit higher.]

The Lakers did make the playoffs in 2023, eventually reaching the Western Conference Finals, making this 'juicy' bet a loser.
Loss
HankHank

The Jaguars being 3-point favorites over the Giants is a trap line

Take the Jaguars minus three, the line makes no sense. Yep. Yep. Zero sense whatsoever. That's Vegas being like, take the Giants, they want you to take the giants, which means the jaguar's gonna win win handily. Don't fall for the trap. Take the jaguars.

The Giants won the game 23-17, meaning the 'trap' line was actually just a bad line or an incorrect assessment of the Giants' quality.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will buy Colts season tickets if Jim Irsay forces Dan Snyder to sell the Commanders

I've decided, you know, we talked about like, I would become a Colts fan if Jim Irsay was the straw that broke the camel's back. Yep. I'm gonna buy season tickets to the Colts next year. Wow. If, if, if Jim Irsay can get down out the fuck out, I'm gonna be a Colts season ticket holder.

Dan Snyder did sell the team in 2023, but PFT did not visibly become a Colts season ticket holder or change his primary fandom.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

The Packers will have a statement win and run up the score against the Commanders

I do think the Packers are gonna use statement when they're gonna run up the score. It's gonna be one of those things. If it's like close, they're not gonna let up. They're just gonna keep running it up.

The Commanders beat the Packers 23-21.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals have turned a corner because they are using more shotgun and throwing on first down

I feel like the Bengals might have turned a little bit of a corner... it feels like they're starting to throw on first down more, which they should be doing a lot more. The Bengals also their second half defense, they haven't given up a touchdown in the second half this year.

The Bengals did turn their season around, winning 10 straight games at one point and reaching the AFC Championship game.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lions will play to the level of their opponent and lose every game by three points

I think the Lions will lose to every team by three points. That's been my theory on the Lions all season long... the Lions can be competitive with any team in the NFL no matter how good or how shitty their opponent is. They will play exactly to that level.

While the Lions had several close losses early, they finished the season 9-8 and blew out several opponents (Jaguars, Bears) while losing by more than 3 to others.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bailey Zappy should be the starting quarterback for the New England Patriots over Mac Jones

Billy Zappy should be the quarterback of the New England Patriots. It's obvious to everybody that's watched the game... [He] does have more zip. Bailey Zappy should be the quarterback, more zip, I'll be the first to say it.

Zappy's performance eventually cratered (including an 0-2 start as the primary guy in 2023), proving Mac Jones (despite his own struggles) was the intended starter and Zappy was not the long-term answer.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The winner of Titans vs. Colts will win the AFC South

I think if the Titans win this game, I'm ready to declare the Titans the winner that division... I'm ready. Whoever wins this game will win this division.

The Titans won the game, but the Jacksonville Jaguars eventually won the AFC South title that season.
Void
Dan HarenDan Haren

The MLB Division Series is too short and should be seven games

I think the division series is too short though. Ooh, I don't understand. I don't understand why you play 162 and then it's gotta be five games. I think the, the better team would win out more often in a seven game series.

This is a subjective opinion on playoff structure.
Void
Dan HarenDan Haren

Yordan Alvarez is the best hitter I have ever had to scout

We've faced Yordan [Alvarez] this year. He was, he's the best hitter I've ever had to advance scout. Whoa. I'm talking about covering all the pitches, hitting lefties, everything. He's the best hitter I've ever had to had to scout.

This is Haren's expert opinion based on his scouting experience.
Win
Sergio PerezSergio Perez

The Titans will beat the Colts and the game will go under the total

Titans. It's easier to pronounce... I think it's gonna be quite a low score [because of the defense].

The Titans beat the Colts 19-10 on Oct 23, 2022. The total was 29, which stayed well under the 41.5-42.5 betting line. Sergio was correct on both counts.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

Modern truck auto-stop engine technology is dangerous and poorly designed

Every time you stop, it'll go to a full stop, the engine turns off... The thing is the car has to turn off and start back up again. And if people know, like the more miles you get on a truck, the more times you start a truck, the engine's gotta turn over... It happened to me in a busy ass intersection and I couldn't get the truck back started... putting people like myself in danger.

This is a subjective complaint based on a personal mechanical failure, though the technology is a common point of frustration for many drivers.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I enjoy watching the Broncos on primetime because the brand of bad football is a fascinating story every time

I actually, I'm gonna say this and I know this, people will be like, 'Oh, you're just saying this to be opposite,' I enjoy having the Broncos on primetime football because every time it's a story. It's bad football but you see something new every time and it's a weird story. It became so hilariously bad that it's interesting. There's something about a Broncos primetime game that it's fascinating to watch because it's just a car crash for 60 minutes plus.

Subjective opinion on entertainment value. The 2022 Broncos did remain a fascinatngly bad story for most of the season.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Russell Wilson is a mentally broken man

I think yes, there is [something wrong with Russell Wilson]. I think mentally he's a broken man.

While subjective, Wilson's tenure in Denver was statistically the worst of his career and he was eventually benched and released, supporting the idea of a major breakdown in his play.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nathaniel Hackett may be a good offensive coordinator, but he is clearly not prepared to be an NFL head coach

Nathaniel Hackett might be an offensive guru... but you also have to be like, 'Wait, this is something that you're just not prepared for at all.' Just because you're a good offensive coordinator doesn't mean you know how to do all this stuff [like picking up blitzes and making adjustments].

Hackett was fired before completing his first season (the first such firing in Broncos history), which strongly validates the 'not prepared' take.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Russell Wilson will eventually claim a season-ending injury to get a fresh start if this continues

It does feel like this is a situation where Russell Wilson could, if it keeps going bad, be like, I'm out for the year and just do a fresh start. And I actually wouldn't blame him because a fresh start is almost what this team needs.

Wilson played 15 games in 2022. He did not opt out for the year due to injury, though he was eventually benched late in the 2023 season for financial/contract reasons.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

There are only three or four truly good teams in the NFL right now

I just don't think there's more than three or four really good teams. Like when you think about the really good teams, the Bills and the Eagles have played really good football, the Chiefs, the Giants and Jets you could throw in there, but like everyone else has... had some real stinker of games.

The Giants and Jets both regressed, but the Bills, Eagles, and Chiefs remained the elite tier through the Super Bowl.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL teams that are starting slow this year are the ones that didn't play their starters in the preseason

I think all those teams that you mentioned, the ones that were starting slow, those are the guys that didn't play in the preseason either. Maybe we've been doing that for Russ Wilson and Nathaniel Hackett to have played in a couple games in the preseason. Maybe that would help them in mid-October.

This is a recurring theory that is difficult to prove but widely cited in sports media.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders will beat the Packers in Taylor Heinicke's first game back

I'm pretty pumped up about Heineke going into [home against] Green Bay and just beating the fuck out of Aaron Rodgers. [Heineke] will just make shit happen. He's gonna throw deep to your receivers that are very, very good and fun shit's gonna go down.

The Commanders beat the Packers 23-21 on October 23, 2022. Heinicke threw two touchdowns.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Astros should start cheating again to beat the Yankees in the ALCS

If I'm the Astros, I start cheating again. Like I want, I want them to just beat the fuck outta the Yankees and then to have the Yankees just looking around like what the, what the hell just happened to us? I want spin rates to be off the chart this series.

The Astros did sweep the Yankees in the ALCS 4-0 without any evidence of cheating, showing they didn't need it.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Alternate jerseys are for franchises with no history

Alternate jerseys are for franchises with no history. That's, I'm gonna say that that's a take.

This is an aesthetic opinion that can't be objectively proven, but is a common sentiment among traditionalist fans.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Denver Nuggets will win the NBA Championship if they stay healthy

You've been saying for like, it feels like five years now that once the nuggets get healthy, [watch out]. Jamal Murray's back and I know he's looking really good right now. Michael Porter's Jr. back... It's gonna be the Nuggets year.

The Nuggets won the 2023 NBA Championship, making this a perfectly prescient take.
Void
HankHank

Draymond Green glorified assaulting his teammate in his TNT mini-doc

He managed to turn him almost killing one of his teammates in a disgusting move... and then has a show on TNT where he like made it, he like glorified it. Basically he glorified himself assaulting his teammate and looking so like immature, childish and just bad.

The 'documentary' was widely panned for precisely the reasons Hank stated.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The rats run New York City, not the humans

I think the rats run the city. If you have to say that [the rats don't run the city], I think the rats run the city.

It's a satirical observation on the futility of NYC's rat war.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

Humans are currently dominating the rivalry with bears following several viral fight videos

My cool throne is humans. Humans have been taking tons of Ws against bears and just dishing out bears Ls. There was a video of a dude fighting a bear and throwing him off a cliff. And then there was another story of two Wyoming wrestlers beating the shit out of a bear and surviving a grizzly attack. We're up on bears.

Subjective/satirical bit about human vs animal conflict.
Win
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Tennessee is the best they have been since their 1998 national title team

This is the best Tennessee team since the [1998 team] led to a national title. Yep, for sure.

Tennessee finished the 2022 season 11-2 and won the Orange Bowl, their highest win total and best finish since 2001 (and arguably 1998 in terms of hype).

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers