PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Take Slip·Aug 4, 2025
#PMT-2025-0804-5867
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Schwarber should win the NL MVP

I was gonna say Kyle Schwarber should be MVP. ... Shohei is not pitching. ... I also have a 90 to one ticket on Kyle Schwarber. But that has nothing to do with us saying Kyle Schwarber should win MVP.

Kyle Schwarber did not win the NL MVP; Shohei Ohtani won the award despite not pitching.
Loss
Take Slip·Aug 4, 2025
#PMT-2025-0804-5868
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cal Raleigh should be the AL MVP

I'm not concerned with the NL race. I'm more concerned Cal Raleigh should be AL MVP. I just feel very strongly.

Cal Raleigh did not win the AL MVP, which was taken by Aaron Judge.
Void
Take Slip·Aug 4, 2025
#PMT-2025-0804-5869
Big CatBig Cat

MLB should stop doing experimental stadium games and just do Field of Dreams every year

Why not just do it at Field of Dreams every single year. ... This is such a situation where like baseball had a really cool thing that White Sox Yankees game was insane. And why not just go back there and do it?

Subjective opinion on league scheduling and marketing strategy.
Void
Take Slip·Aug 4, 2025
#PMT-2025-0804-5872
Big CatBig Cat

The Pollad family are jerks who don't care about the Minnesota Twins winning

The Twins just trading their entire team and just being shitty ownership that needs to change. ... The Pollad family. Fuck you guys. Jim Pollad, Jerk. Carl Pollad, Jerk. Jim's son Joe, Jerk. ... Putting out a team where all you're trying to do is get to the playoffs a little bit and never actually go for it, that's bullshit.

Subjective evaluation of ownership intent and quality.
Open
Take Slip·Aug 1, 2025
#PMT-2025-0801-5119
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Cubs' 2025 trade deadline was a disaster with no clear plan.

Cubs Trade deadline recap... They got no plan. They got a bunch of rental arms. A super utility man. Which I like that. That's cool... But it feels like Kyle Tucker will not be resigned. The Cubs had, they, they traded a prospect, a really good pro prospect in Cam Smith for Kyle Tucker... And then they did nothing at the trade deadline. And they're holding onto prospects and then they're probably not gonna sign Kyle Tucker... it's a disaster.

The 2025 MLB season has not happened yet relative to the real-world date.
Void
Take Slip·Aug 1, 2025
#PMT-2025-0801-5120
Big CatBig Cat

The only way the Cubs can make their deadline right is by re-signing Kyle Schwarber in free agency.

The only way they can make it right is if they bring back Kyle Schwarber. I decided on that. I'm gonna start putting the pressure on that. 'cause he's a free agent.

This is a subjective claim about fan satisfaction/team management strategy.
Void
#PMT-2025-0730-14586
Big CatBig Cat

Bryce Harper is right that players are willing to lose a whole season over a salary cap.

He's right-ish... [Manfred] is pitching the salary cap right to the players circumventing the MLBPA. And it's their job to hear from the owners and then take that to the rank and file players. And then Harper's like, 'If you're gonna say that, get the fuck out.' Bryce Harper is right. Bryce is right about this... He can afford to lose 162 games. The guys at the top can afford to lose 162 games.

The willingness of the union to strike over a cap is a theoretical labor position that only gets tested during actual negotiations.
Void
#PMT-2025-0723-8390
HankHank

The walk-off catcher's interference rule is a stupid rule

I mean there's no, there's not much Hot Seat. It's just a stupid rule... Lost on walk off catcher's interference. Second time it's ever happened in MLB history. First time since 1971. The problem was the catcher just stuck it... It was technically letter of the law catcher's interference.

Rule validity is inherently subjective, though it is a codified MLB rule.
Void
#PMT-2025-0723-8389
MaxMax

I have no confidence in the Phillies right now

I, I, I'm, I'm tuned in. I watch every game. It's just, I, it's, I don't know. They're frustrating squad... Dude, I just don't have a lot of confidence in this, in this team right now.

This is a subjective emotional state for a fan, though the Phillies were highly successful in the 2024 season.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 23, 2025
#PMT-2025-0723-8394
Chase UtleyChase Utley

Getting hit by a pitch only hurts for about thirty seconds to a minute

My son looks at me, he goes, do you think that hurt? I was like, yeah, probably hurt. But it goes away after, you know, 30 seconds or a minute.

Pain threshold is subjective, though most medical experts would disagree that a high-velocity impact only 'hurts for a minute.'
Void
Take Slip·Jul 23, 2025
#PMT-2025-0723-8395
Chase UtleyChase Utley

I had no intention of hurting Ruben Tejada during the 2015 NLDS slide

There was zero intention to fuck anybody up on that play... Obviously the outcome was different than other slides that I've had. I didn't anticipate actually hitting him nearly as hard as I did... I had no intention of hurting him whatsoever.

Intent is inherently impossible to verify externally, but Utley maintains this stance years later.
Win
Take Slip·Jul 21, 2025
#PMT-2025-0721-4396
Rob ManfredRob Manfred

The Home Run Derby's current timing format is too exhausting for players

I don't think people appreciate how exhausting it is for the players to take that many swings that fast. So it's something we will talk about with ESPN regarding changing the format.

The league did indeed adjust the Derby rules for the following year to include pitch limits.
Push
Take Slip·Jul 21, 2025
#PMT-2025-0721-4397
Rob ManfredRob Manfred

Fixing blackouts is at the top of Major League Baseball's priority list

Blackouts number one are at the top of my list in terms of things we need to deal with. Ideally where you would like to be is if you have a digital home for baseball, you can go there and buy what you want to buy.

MLB has been centralizing broadcast rights but blackouts persist into 2025.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 21, 2025
#PMT-2025-0721-4398
Rob ManfredRob Manfred

The worst team in the league should always get the #1 overall pick

The team that was the worst last year should get the best player in the draft and there should be nothing that interferes with that correlation. The lottery thing, I'm not sure that it really affects behavior of teams in any meaningful way.

This is a policy stance, not a verifiable fact.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 16, 2025
#PMT-2025-0716-19174
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Schwarber is the greatest home run hitter in the game

Kyle Schwarber is the man. What a monster. Three swings, three dongs, three no-doubters. He hit three home runs in three swings, absolute monsters. He's the best. I fucking love him forever.

This take is subjective as 'the best' is an opinion, though Schwarber did win the hypothetical swing-off in the transcript context.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 16, 2025
#PMT-2025-0716-19175
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Judge showed bad leadership by leaving the All-Star Game early

Bad leadership by Aaron Judge at the All Star Game. [Ohtani and Judge] were probably on a plane... it did feel like the National League manager was trying to win harder than the American League manager.

The concept of 'leadership' in an exhibition game is inherently subjective.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 16, 2025
#PMT-2025-0716-19176
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Every baseball game should be decided by a swing-off

I like the swing off. The end of game is great. I want everything decided by swing offs now. Regular season baseball games swing off... child custody hearings swing off.

Clearly a satirical suggestion for MLB and legal reform.
Open
Take Slip·Jul 16, 2025
#PMT-2025-0716-19177
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Wood will be the future face of the MLB

James Wood... many are saying [he is the] future face of this league.

James Wood's status as the 'face of the league' is a long-term projection that will take years to evaluate.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 16, 2025
#PMT-2025-0716-19185
Shane VictorinoShane Victorino

Winning a World Series in Philadelphia is more special than in Boston

What separates the two for me was... there's not many championships in the city of Philadelphia. In the city of Boston, it's pretty different. That's what makes Philadelphia to me a little bit more special. You have a love and a passion for their sports, but I feel like [Philly fans] act differently about it because they don't have many.

Emotional significance is inherently subjective.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 16, 2025
#PMT-2025-0716-19186
Shane VictorinoShane Victorino

Stephen Strasburg at his peak was the filthiest pitcher I ever faced

Steven Strasburg, when he first came to the big leagues... he made his debut against us. He threw a hundred and you just threw me two off speed pitches in a three-two count... I was like, bro, like this dude is not real. His first five years... it was a joke. It wasn't fun.

A professional hitter's personal experience is subjective but authoritative.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 14, 2025
#PMT-2025-0714-19816
MaxMax

I want the Brewers' pitcher Brody Brecht to be the biggest bust in MLB history after he was selected over Ranger Suárez

I now hate this guy. I now want this guy to be the biggest bust in MLB history. Ranger Suárez has a 1.94 in 13 games... How do you possibly look at that and be like, this guy is more deserving than Ranger Suárez?

This is a subjective desire for a player's failure. Whether Suarez was more 'deserving' is also subjective.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 7, 2025
#PMT-2025-0707-11735
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Firing Nationals GM Mike Rizzo because of the team's record is nonsensical due to budget constraints

Firing a GM because you didn't give him enough money to spend on good food... That's like divorcing your wife because you got fat.

Subjective opinion on management quality vs. ownership spending.
Win
Take Slip·Jul 7, 2025
#PMT-2025-0707-11737
MaxMax

Trey Turner not receiving an MLB All-Star reserve spot is a snub

Trey Turner leads league in hits and he didn't even get a reserve spot... say what? Christopher Sanchez should have been in over MacKenzie Gore. That makes no sense.

The rosters were set as stated; whether it's a 'snub' is an opinion.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 2, 2025
#PMT-2025-0702-15263
Zac GallenZac Gallen

The dropped third strike is the stupidest rule in all of baseball

The dropped third strike rule is the stupidest rule in baseball of all time. You swing in a pitch that's that bad... and then just because the ball like bounced away, you get to go to first base. It's a participation trophy. I literally made you swing at a pitch that didn't even make it to the plate. It was that bad. And you get to run to first base.

The quality of a rule is inherently subjective.
Open
Take Slip·Jul 2, 2025
#PMT-2025-0702-15264
Merrill KellyMerrill Kelly

The Cincinnati Reds have an illegally flat pitching mound to gain an advantage

Cincinnati's tough. That mound is so flat. I know they're supposed to have regulations on how high the mound is, but whatever they're doing, they're cheating for sure. Because it's way lower. Our mound at home feels like a mountain compared to Cincinnati.

MLB mounds are strictly regulated at 10 inches, though perceptions of slopes can vary.
Void
Take Slip·Jul 2, 2025·Picks
#PMT-2025-0702-15267
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

CJ Abrams is the best Saber Metric pick in the Dingers Only draft because he leads off

Ideally you want your players to get as many opportunities to hit home runs as possible. Why not take a guy that hits lead off shortstop. CJ Abrams. He's gonna get like four more at bats than some of your guys' clowns.

While mathematically true that leadoff hitters get more ABs, it doesn't always translate to more HRs than middle-of-the-order sluggers.
Open
Take Slip·Jun 27, 2025
#PMT-2025-0627-17154
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dick Monfort promoting his son to COO is a classic case of nepotism that won't fix the Rockies

The Colorado, we, we've given a lot of shit to their owner. Dick Monfort piece of shit... And he promoted his oldest son. Oh. To be Chief Operating Officer... They're not content to, to mi away in the slums of mediocrity. They're gonna fix it out by just having his son do all the things he was gonna do.

OpinionBaseballMediumSarcastic
The success of the Rockies under the new COO will be measurable over the next several seasons.
Void
Take Slip·Jun 23, 2025
#PMT-2025-0623-7941
Big CatBig Cat

The 2025 Dodgers are the #1 champions of the calendar year across all sports

I'm gonna go Dodgers number one. Dodgers, Panthers, Florida basketball, Ohio State Football, Thunder, LSU Baseball, Eagles, Rory McIlroy. That feels good.

A subjective ranking of fictionalized 2025 outcomes.
Open
Take Slip·Jun 23, 2025
#PMT-2025-0623-7945
Big CatBig Cat

Cal Raleigh will hit 67 home runs this season

Cal Raleigh hit four home runs this weekend... he's now on pace for 67 home runs, which is pretty fucking insane. ... He's gonna hit 67 home runs.

Unlikely for a catcher to hit 67, but based on the fictional 2025 timeline's pace.
Void
Take Slip·Jun 23, 2025
#PMT-2025-0623-7946
Cal RaleighCal Raleigh

Robot Umpires should stay out of baseball to preserve the human element of arguing and ejections

Out on Robot Umps. I mean, don't you wanna keep a little bit of the baseball in it? You wanna see managers and guys getting ejected, like that's part of the game. ... If you take that away, it's like there's not, you know, you need a little bit of excitement in the game.

Subjective opinion on game quality.
Open
Take Slip·Jun 20, 2025
#PMT-2025-0620-9714
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Wood will be the face of baseball within two years

Buy all the James Wood stock that you can get right now. ... 22 years old. I think he's got 20 dingers right now. 50 some RBIs. ... I think we're gonna have a James Wood face of baseball conversation in the next two years.

The outcome depends on Wood's performance and marketing over the 2026 and 2027 seasons.
Open
#PMT-2025-0618-19701
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Christian Yelich is going to win the MLB Home Run Derby

When I was in Milwaukee, all the brewers, like almost every single brewer when I walked by said, Christian Yelich is gonna win the home run derby this year. It's disgusting.

The 2025 Home Run Derby hasn't happened yet.
Void
Take Slip·Jun 16, 2025
#PMT-2025-0616-5029
HankHank

Red Sox ownership does not care about the fans or winning after the Devers trade

I've been out of the Red Sox ownership since they got rid of Mookie Betts... they don't care about the fans. They don't care about winning. Like they know the Red Sox ownership is selfish and they don't care about winning because they know that fans are gonna show up either way.

The trade is fictional, but the opinion on ownership is a recurring sentiment.
Loss
Take Slip·Jun 11, 2025
#PMT-2025-0611-19672
Tarik SkubalTarik Skubal

I am officially the best bunter in Major League Baseball history

I do say this though. I do say I'm the best bunter in major league history... I had one bunt attempt got it down. So. Anytime big situations, I always say I'm the best bunner in major league history. You ready to, can't take that away from me. I'm one for one.

Skubal has a 100% bunt success rate but only on a single attempt, making the 'greatest in history' claim clearly satirical.
Void
#PMT-2025-0602-1569
Big CatBig Cat

Cal Raleigh is a legitimate MVP candidate and deserves more national attention

Cal Raleigh is the catcher for Seattle Mariners. He has 23 home runs and that's insane. It's nuts that he's doing this as a catcher... He won't win MVP, but he's got my vote. First catcher with 20 home runs before June.

Raleigh is statistically one of the best power-hitting catchers, though winning MVP is unlikely for a catcher on a non-dominant team.
Void
Take Slip·Jun 2, 2025
#PMT-2025-0602-1573
Ray RomanoRay Romano

Barry Bonds and Pete Rose should be in the Hall of Fame

I might be inclined to vote for Rose to get in, you know? And I think Barry Bonds should be in the Hall of Fame because everybody... most of the power hitters were, and he's by far the best hitter to ever play the sport. It's a museum at the end of the day.

This is a perennial debate in sports media with no objective resolution.
Void
Take Slip·May 27, 2025
#PMT-2025-0527-6869
Big CatBig Cat

MLB is failing by not having wall-to-wall nationally broadcast games on Memorial Day

I don't understand how the MLB still can't figure it out. That like, Memorial Day happens to start summer every year and you haven't figured out a way to have wall to wall baseball games. It's crazy to me. And it should be like, there should be games starting very early and it'd go all day and it should be all nationally broadcast. Like why, why wouldn't you do that?

This is a subjective opinion on league marketing and scheduling strategy.
Void
Take Slip·May 19, 2025
#PMT-2025-0519-17544
Tyler PhillipsTyler Phillips

An average person could likely get three outs in a Major League game eventually

I think you get three outs. Yeah. Like, honestly... The ball is bound to go to somebody. Yeah. Like there's no, like, it just goes against odds for the ball to just keep landing in the grass somewhere. Right.

Open
Take Slip·May 14, 2025
#PMT-2025-0514-16098
Big CatBig Cat

The Detroit Tigers will win the American League

I'll say this right now. I think the Detroit Tigers are gonna win The AL. I don't know if they can win the World Series. There's some good teams in the NL... in the last month, it's like [Javi Baez] recaptured something and, and, and come back to the world as, as what the electrifying Javi Baez was.

The Tigers had a late-season surge in 2024 but did not win the AL. Since this is dated May 2025, it's a prediction for the 2025 season.
Win
Take Slip·May 2, 2025
#PMT-2025-0502-12391
Big CatBig Cat

The Monfort brothers are terrible owners and the Colorado Rockies might be the worst team ever

We gotta get on the radar of the Colorado Rockies maybe being the worst team of all time... officially the Monfort Brothers, Dick and Charlie Monfort, we're looking at you, we're watching you, we're on your shit. We're just gonna say you fucking suck ass once every couple of months.

The Rockies finished 2024 with a 61-101 record, one of the worst in the league.
Void
Take Slip·Apr 30, 2025
#PMT-2025-0430-19810
Big CatBig Cat

Errors in the outfield are significantly worse than errors in the infield

Errors in the outfield are way worse than errors on the infield for whatever reason. 'cause anytime you're like backed to the field, you are chasing the ball after.

General baseball observation about the consequences of different errors.
Void
Take Slip·Apr 30, 2025
#PMT-2025-0430-19811
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Home Run Derby has lost its luster and isn't cool anymore

Home run derby's not even cool anymore. I don't even You messed up the format... the camera work's gone. I don't think Chris Berman's even doing it. It's lost a lot of its luster.

Subjective opinion on the quality and entertainment value of the MLB Home Run Derby.
Void
Take Slip·Apr 16, 2025·Picks
#PMT-2025-0416-19321
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Judge is not a true Yankee because he hasn't won a World Series

I would go even further and say he's [Aaron Judge] not a true Yankee. Which is funny because he's had some of the best seasons of all time by any offensive player. Still not a true Yankee... You can't be a true Yankee in the regular season. The Yankees season starts in October.

Subjective definition of what makes a 'true Yankee'.
Win
Take Slip·Apr 11, 2025·MLB
#PMT-2025-0411-2078
Big CatBig Cat

Zach Hampel is the best of all time at ball-hawking and deserves respect for his greatness

Listen, I, I know Zach Hampel's a very controversial, actually, he's not controversial. Everyone just hates him. He's, he's the best to ever do it... When did we stop respecting greatness?... He's literally the best to ever do it. What he does, he is the best of all time at.

Hampel's stats for collecting baseballs are empirically higher than anyone else's, though the 'greatness' label is the subjective part.
Win
Take Slip·Apr 4, 2025
#PMT-2025-0404-4474
Big CatBig Cat

Shohei Ohtani has reached maximum aura and is the definitive face of baseball

Does Shohei Ohtani have Aura? Because I think he has maximum Aura. First pitch home run. Just, he doesn't change anything about his expression, swing anything. It's just business as usual. I think Shohei Ohtani has reached the next level of Superstardom where he just has the most aura in the game. It's settled. Shohei is the face.

Most metrics and public sentiment support Ohtani being the face of the sport.
Void
Take Slip·Mar 31, 2025
#PMT-2025-0331-1620
MaxMax

Increased runs and homers are objectively good for baseball

Why you watch baseball? To watch homers? Yeah. Why do people want less homers? Yeah. Like everything in baseball right now is going towards the pitcher. The one time, the one time something goes towards the hitter and now everyone wants to freak out. That's what baseball's fun. You wanna watch people hit, you wanna, this is good for baseball. More runs is good for baseball

Whether high-scoring games are 'better' is an opinion, though generally correlated with viewership.
Open
Take Slip·Mar 28, 2025
#PMT-2025-0328-3415
Big CatBig Cat

Cam Smith will win the AL Rookie of the Year

I think I'm rooting for Cam Smith to win AL Rookie of the year. And I might even bet it... if he wins AL Rookie of the Year, then Tom Ricketts has to resign Kyle Tucker.

Determined by the AL Rookie of the Year voting results in 2025.
Open
Take Slip·Mar 28, 2025
#PMT-2025-0328-3417
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am fading the White Sox, Marlins, and Rockies for the entire 2025 season

I'm diversifying. I'm gonna be fading what I project to be the three worst teams in baseball, which would be the White Sox, the Marlins, and the Rockies.

Outcome depends on the combined win-loss performance of these three teams.
Open
Take Slip·Mar 28, 2025
#PMT-2025-0328-3404
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

The Cincinnati Reds are a sleeper team that could win the NL Central

I think people are sleeping on Cincinnati a little bit. Elly De La Cruz has a chance to be a super duper star... I like a team that has some youth on its side... the Reds feel like they could be that team this year.

Outcome determined by the Reds' final standings in the 2025 MLB season.
Open
Take Slip·Mar 28, 2025
#PMT-2025-0328-3407
Jeff PassanJeff Passan

Bubba Chandler will win NL Rookie of the Year and eventually be better than Paul Skenes

Bubba Chandler with the Pirates... Fastball up to a hundred now. Great breaking stuff, good control and commit. I picked him to win Rookie of the year this year. [He texted Paul Skenes] enjoy it while it lasts because next year I'm going to be starting opening day.

Rookie of the Year is verifiable; the long-term comparison is subjective but trackable.
13...21