Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

I want my mind to get duller as I get older, rather than sharper

I never want to do anything that sharpens my mind. I want it to get duller and duller as days go by... Gary V being like learn something new every day. No, come on. I'm just trying to just get up, wake up and then go to sleep.

Inherently a satirical life choice.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Saban was secretly relieved to lose the National Championship because it provides bulletin board material

I think that there's like a small part of Nick Saban that was kind of relieved that he lost. That was like more rat poison. He's happy that he lost because now he's got all sorts of bulletin board material for next year.

OpinionCFBMediumSarcastic
Nick Saban has never expressed relief at losing a national title game; he is known as one of the most competitive coaches in history.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Nick Saban is the greatest coach of all time

He's won it all. He's the greatest coach of all time. Losing one, it's obviously disappointing for Alabama, but man, Georgia, what an unbelievable game.

Nick Saban retired in 2024 with a record seven national championships (six at Alabama, one at LSU), widely cementing him as the greatest in the eyes of the sport's history.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kirby Smart is sneaky athletic and could probably dunk a basketball

He probably has like a 30 inch vertical leap... I think Kirby sneaky athletic. I think he can get rim.

There is no video evidence of Kirby Smart dunking, but his 5'11" frame and former playing career make a 30-inch vertical plausible but unverified.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

It will be a long time before another walk-on quarterback starts for a National Champion

It will be, I'll say this confidently, there'll be a long time before we see a walk-on be the starting quarterback for a national champion again.

The same walk-on, Stetson Bennett, won the National Championship again the following season (January 2023).
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2021 Indianapolis Colts would beat the 2021 Georgia Bulldogs by 20 points

I think the Colts would beat Georgia by 20 points. But I do think that this game, the Alabama Georgia national championship, had as many fast players on the field as most NFL teams would.

While the game was never played, historical precedent and roster construction heavily favor any NFL team over a college squad, regardless of talent level.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The top tier of college football (top 2-5 teams) effectively plays a different sport than the rest of the country

If you're a fan of pretty much any team except for like the top five, you realize it's a different sport. Those guys are playing a different sport than everyone else in college.

This is an observation about the structural disparity in college football talent and resources.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Defensive-minded head coaches like Brian Flores and Vic Fangio are rightfully judged for failing to fix their offenses

It's similar to Vic Fangio. If you don't get the offense figured out, it still counts against [the coach]. Even though he's a defensive coach, it's—if you don't get the offense figured out, it still counts against [you].

This is a coaching philosophy take. Both coaches were fired in part due to offensive stagnation.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL owners are generally idiots with the same IQ level as a dumb coworker

The person that owns your favorite team is a pretty big idiot. Just like the sooner you come to terms with that, the better they're just they're morons. Like everybody else, like think of the dumbest people that you work with that is typically about the same IQ level as an NFL owner.

This is an inherently subjective opinion about intelligence and competence.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The only way the Bears can be fixed is firing Ted Phillips, who uses the Arlington Heights land purchase to avoid being fired

The only way the bears can be fixed is Ted Phillips has to go... he's obviously in charge of the Arlington Heights land purchase. And I think that will never happen because Ted Phillips knows, as long as they're still negotiating it, he will still have a job.

Ted Phillips retired from the Bears in early 2023. The organization has since seen significant changes, though success remains intermittent.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Polian's Hall of Fame success is largely predicated on simply choosing Peyton Manning over Ryan Leaf

He's the architect of the Colts. He drafted Peyton Manning. His biggest career accomplishment is like, 'I didn't take the other guy.' I took Peyton Manning. Good choice, Bill. I'm just going to ride that for the rest of my life. I had one good week of work in the last 30 years and now I just get to coast off that.

While Polian built several Super Bowl contenders, the Manning pick is undeniably the cornerstone of his legacy.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Judge staying with the Giants makes him a 'human shield' for the new GM

For a GM, [the Giants job] is absolutely [attractive] because you do have some draft picks this year... and then you have the perfect scapegoat and Joe judge, nobody expects anything out of Joe judge next year, right? Human shield. Yes. You need a human shield.

The Giants actually fired Joe Judge on Jan 11, 2022, right as this episode was dropping (the show acknowledges they recorded before he was fired).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks would be smart to bring back both Pete Carroll and Russell Wilson for the next season

The Seahawks will be so smart to just bring Pete Carroll and Russell Wilson back... You're better with these two guys than like 80% of the [NFL].

The Seahawks traded Russell Wilson to the Denver Broncos in March 2022, opting to rebuild rather than bring the duo back.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Travis Barker is the best songwriting drummer and makes any act he plays with significantly better

Whatever [Travis Barker] does, he's somehow like the best songwriting drummer, where he makes any band or any act that he plays with that much better.

Subjective musical assessment.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Andrew Luck looks extremely happy and appears to have zero interest in returning to football

Andrew luck shows up out of nowhere... and he looked like he's lost about 70 pounds. My God, I actually don't think that Andrew luck has picked up a football in the last three years. And he looks really happy.

Andrew Luck has remained retired and has expressed contentment with life outside of football.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Deliberately scheduling a 'congratulations' tweet for the losing team is a genius move for social media engagement

That is a genius plan to get people talking about [us]... every account should do that... schedule a tweet for 12 hours later and be like 'Congratulations to the [losing team]'... and everyone be like 'Oh, when scheduling tweets goes wrong.' And then sweet interactions.

This is a verified tactic used by social media managers to boost reach.
Win
John CenaJohn Cena

James Gunn maintains a 'no asshole' rule on his film sets

[James Gunn] also has a no asshole [rule]. And he puts together teams of people who there's not a bad apple in the bunch... I knew I was going to be surrounded by good people.

This is a frequently cited policy by James Gunn and his regular cast members in multiple interviews.
Void
John CenaJohn Cena

Competition in the wrestling industry is good because it forces every performer to be at their best

Do I think competition is good? I think competition is great... Whenever there is more buzz around an industry, it's good for the industry and it forces all of us to be at our best... repeatable bad segments from the group means the company can't be good, which means that the competition will succeed.

This is a business and entertainment theory take.
Win
John CenaJohn Cena

Getting in shape requires a consistent lifestyle change rather than a temporary diet

The tips are easy. The application is hard. Make good choices and be consistent. And that's absolutely it. Don't make it a January diet, make it a lifestyle change, make good choices and be consistent.

This is widely accepted medical and fitness advice.
Loss
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

The Steelers will beat the Chiefs in the playoffs because Kansas City is due for a bad game

I really think the Steelers could beat the chiefs... the chiefs are due for a bad game, man. They really are just due for one... I wouldn't be surprised.

The Chiefs beat the Steelers 42-21 in the Wild Card round on January 16, 2022.
Win
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

TJ Watt is definitively the best defensive player in football

For anybody who's been watching the NFL this year or the past three years... the best defensive player in football has been TJ watt. It's a fact.

TJ Watt won the 2021 NFL Defensive Player of the Year award, tying the single-season sack record.
Loss
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

The NFL is rigged for ratings and views

How somehow some way, and the fourth quarter... the scores magically are going to line up. If this team gets a touchdown in a two point conversion, it's like, wow, it's, it's rigged. This is rigged for ratings, for views.

There is no verifiable evidence that the NFL rigs game outcomes for ratings.
Win
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

The elevator technicians union is one of the best and most lucrative trades to join

In the union's, there is elevator union. Biggest money can make one of the best unions there is. Wow. They like this guy's first year he'll he'll easily make probably 120-125... I mean you're talking about guys that make over 200, 250 a year.

Elevator installers and repairers are consistently among the highest-paid construction trades in the U.S.
Loss
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

I would trade my own financial security for Ben Roethlisberger to win one more Super Bowl before retiring

If I could have one dream and one thing come true, it wouldn't be for me to be a millionaire. It wouldn't be for my family to be set for the rest of their life. It would be for Big Ben to go out like the Bus [Jerome Bettis], with a ring. I'd do anything for that.

The Steelers lost to the Chiefs in the Wild Card round (42-21), and Roethlisberger retired shortly after without a final ring.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Raiders were smart to win rather than tie because they have a better chance against the Bengals than the Chiefs

On just a level for the Raiders, it was smart to go for the win. Once they're in that spot at the end of the game... if you let the Chargers in, you have to go play the Chiefs, right? Where now you get to go play the Bengals. I mean, the Bengals are better than the Raiders, but they have a lot better of a chance against the Bengals than they have against the Chiefs who has had their number and kick their ass this year.

The Raiders did play the Bengals and lost 26-19 in a close game, while the Chiefs blew out the Steelers 42-21 in the same round, supporting the idea that the Bengals were a more manageable opponent.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

This was the best Week 18 in the history of the NFL

I'm just going to say that was the best Week 18 in the history of the NFL. It came right down to the last game of the last week. Congratulations, Roger Goodell. You've done it again.

This was only the first year of the 17-game schedule (Week 18), so technically it was the best by default, though it was genuinely highly dramatic.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Brandon Staley's decision to go for it on 4th and 1 from his own 18-yard line was absolutely insane

Brandon Staley living and dying by going forward on fourth down... the Raiders were up three and Brandon Staley went forward on fourth and one on his own 20... It was 17-14. They went for it on fourth and one at their own 18 with 8:57 left in the third quarter. That's how crazy he is guys. Fucking crazy.

The decision was widely criticized as the Raiders scored shortly after, and the Chargers ultimately lost the game and missed the playoffs.
Loss
HankHank

The Patriots are ready to face the Bills and should face them head-on

I've never been more ready for anything in my life... why wait? You know, the bills are the better team they're favored all that shit. They're at home, but this is what you want. Why run? Why not just face it head on.

The Patriots were absolutely demolished by the Bills 47-17 in the Wild Card round, making this confidence look misplaced.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

George Kittle is the lock for the Nickelodeon MVP (NVP)

It's gotta be Kittle. We gotta keep it in the family. Kittle would be nice. You have to keep it in the, I think that's the only answer. It's Kittle. I'm just saying if there is a fan vote, he has won MVP. All right, Greg, although anymore losing.

Dak Prescott won the NVP for the Cowboys vs. 49ers Wild Card game, likely due to a troll vote from fans.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jaguars fans should keep wearing clown outfits because they are undefeated as clowns

You also got to keep wearing clown outfits. I think if you're Jags fans, right? You're undefeated as the clowns. Yes. You are the clowns. Change the team name to the clowns.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The Jaguars did not change their name to the Clowns, though they did find more success in the following season after firing Urban Meyer.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Carson Wentz is the king of making bad plays worse

Carson Wentz is still the king of making bad plays worse. And he'll always be that guy. [He'll] always be that guy that, you know what, I'm going to add the Colts to the list of teams that I think if Kirk Cousins was on, they could win a Super Bowl.

Wentz was traded by the Colts shortly after the season following his collapse against the Jaguars, effectively confirming the team's lack of faith in him.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers are the team you want to face in the playoffs because their quarterback is immobile

No one wants to see the Steelers in the playoffs. I think the Steelers are the team that you want, if you were to circle a team that you would really want to see without a doubt. I really want to see the Steelers in the playoffs. They can't run the ball, they have a quarterback that doesn't have legs. His face got so fat that he can't physically remove his helmet.

The Steelers were blown out 42-21 by the Chiefs in the Wild Card round, proving they were indeed the 'preferred' opponent for top seeds.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Vrabel will win NFL Coach of the Year

I actually do think that [Mike Vrabel] is probably going to end up winning Coach of the Year, unless he's a bad guy and Hub [Arkish] has something to hold against him. But I think he checks out. He's a good guy. Great coach. Even better human being.

Mike Vrabel was officially named the 2021 NFL Coach of the Year.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2021 Lions are the best three-win team in NFL history

I think it's safe to say that these Lions are the best 3-13-1 team of all time. I actually think that these Lions are probably the best awful team that I've ever seen.

While subjective, the 2021 Lions were famously 11-6 against the spread, supporting the idea they were much more competitive than their record suggested.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Judge has done everything in his power to get himself fired since being told he was staying

Joe Judge was told that he was going to keep his job on December 26... after that moment, he lost a combined 85 to 20 in the three games... he did a QB sneak from the three yard line and the four yard line on second and 10 and third and nine because he was too scared about giving up a safety. I have never seen someone be told that they're going to get to keep their job and done everything in their power to try to have them reverse that decision.

Joe Judge was indeed fired by the Giants on January 11, 2022, just one day after this podcast aired, proving the decision-making was fatal to his tenure.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kirk Cousins needs to play worse to help his team win

Kirk Cousins is without a doubt like top 10, maybe top 5 guy in some of those [stat] categories. I think I figured out his problem though, because they lost a lot of games where he played well, statistically. Well, I think he's just too good. And I think that he scores too fast sometimes, and then puts his defense in a position to lose. Kirk needs to get a little bit worse at playing if he wants to be truly good.

The take is satirical and inherently illogical, meant to mock stat-based arguments in football.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Stafford will throw a critical interception that ends the Rams' season

But he's just, you know what I mean? Like that feeling of, well, this is like, there'll be a moment and he will make sure that he throws an interception in that moment. That critical moment. And then your season's over.

This turned out to be famously incorrect as Stafford led the Rams to a Super Bowl victory that same postseason, making several clutch plays without a season-ending mistake.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Pete Carroll and Russell Wilson will both return to the Seahawks next year

I now think that both Pete Carroll and Russell Wilson will come back next year. Why not? I think they're going to, I think they're going to run it back.

Russell Wilson was traded to the Broncos on March 16, 2022, ending his tenure in Seattle before the next season began.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bills can beat the Chiefs in Kansas City

I think the Bills have quietly put together—like they put themselves back together to being one of those teams that's contending in the AFC. I'm telling you, I think the Bills could beat the Chiefs in Kansas City.

The Bills famously lost to the Chiefs in Kansas City 42-36 in the Divisional Round after the '13 seconds' debacle.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brian Flores is the only coach who can consistently beat Bill Belichick

What's up with Brian Flores being the only coach that can beat Bill Belichick consistently? He's 4-2 [against him]. He definitely has your number right now.

At the time, Flores was 4-2 against Belichick, which was one of the best records of any coach against him in that era.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Saints would have been the one seed if Jameis Winston hadn't gotten injured

The real question is do the saints get the one seed overall if Jameis Winston doesn't get injured. [PFT: Yes.] I think definitely. I think definitely.

The Saints were 5-2 when Jameis got hurt and finished 9-8. While plausible, it's impossible to verify.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alabama will beat Georgia 30-21 in the National Championship

The final score was 30 to 21, Alabama. So I'm going to bet that exact same. I'm going to bet that kind of the spread at an alternate line... I feel good about it. I don't know if I can trust my own brain sometimes, but I feel like when I turned my brain off, that's when I do my best thinking.

Georgia won the National Championship 33-18.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Georgia -2.5 is my Game of the Year for the National Championship

2022 is going to be the year of game of the years. I'm just saying it right now. Georgia minus two and a half. I've decided this breaking news game of the year.

Georgia won 33-18, easily covering the -2.5 spread.
Win
Billy FootballBilly Football

The Manning Cast curse is officially undefeated on the year

The Manning Cast curse, it is officially undefeated on the year. Aaron Rodgers went on week 17 and the Packers lost to the Lions. Week one Travis Kelce, Russell Wilson, they all lost the week after they appeared.

During the 2021 season, active players were indeed 0-7 in games immediately following their Manning Cast appearance.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Antonio Brown and Bruce Arians are likely both at fault for the Buccaneers drama

I think the truth is probably Antonio Brown and Bruce Arians are both assholes. Like that might be the truth because it seems like a lot of people are taking the side of Antonio Brown because you have to take the side of player safety... Bruce Arians never wanted Antonio Brown on the Bucs. That was Tom Brady's idea. So it's not totally unbelievable that Bruce Arians would be like, 'You're outta here because you won't go back in the game.'

The truth remains somewhat obscured, but both parties moved on contentiously, confirming a breakdown in the relationship as Big Cat suggested.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Antonio Brown will not be back on an NFL team

I don't think Antonio Brown will be back on an NFL team. I guess you can never say never... but I don't think he's going anywhere.

Antonio Brown never played in the NFL again after his release from the Buccaneers following the January 2, 2022 game against the Jets.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Intentional losing is a valid strategy for the PMT road trip competition

I want to miss all these picks. So feel free to fade me. I'm taking the over though. Colts Jags 44 points... I don't know why you're upset that I want to go on a road trip.

Subjective strategy for a show-specific competition.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Tom Brady will aggressively target the NFL passing record against the Panthers

[Tom Brady] can get the passing record with 488 yards. I want to think. I want to say so he's definitely going to try to get that. So box minus eight, I feels like he'll just keep trying to throw late.

Brady threw for 326 yards in this game, falling well short of the 488 needed for the single-season yardage record held by Peyton Manning.
Void
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

Anthony Davis has bulked up too much and it has negatively affected his mobility and shooting

I feel like everybody called [Anthony Davis] a pussy last year... and I just feel like, all right, well now I'm definitely lifting more. And I think he came back and I think the bulk has actually slowed him down and it just didn't work. Anthony Davis, when he played, was arguably the worst jump shooter in the league based on how many shots he was taking.

AD's shooting percentages from distance and mid-range have indeed remained significantly lower than his championship-year peak, supporting Russillo's analysis.
Win
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

Russell Westbrook's style of play does not lead to winning and he will never change

How many fucking years do you have to watch [Russell Westbrook] do the exact same thing that never leads to winning and think that it's just magic and it's going to work out at some point? Like most of us don't change and a basketball player that's as stubborn as he is isn't going to change... in the playoffs, it doesn't make any sense. He doesn't offer up any spacing for AD and LeBron, he's never set a screen in his fucking life.

The Westbrook-Lakers experiment was a failure, resulting in the Lakers missing the playoffs in 2022 and Westbrook being traded in early 2023.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers