Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
HankHank

College baseball fans are currently the craziest and most intense fans in sports

I think the college baseball fans have been the craziest of all the fans I've seen so far. Or at least it just feels... it's probably a smaller crowd, more packed in. But the walk-off home run in Tennessee the other night was crazy. The Arkansas home run last night was crazy. Insane. It's a great, great atmosphere.

Subjective opinion on fan intensity.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jeff Bezos will disable his companies while in outer space to prank Earth

I think the Earth's actually in the hot seat for all that because it's bad news whenever the richest person on Earth decides to leave for a little bit. what better there will never be a better time for jeff bezos to disable all of his companies that we depend on for everything than when he's in outer space with his brother pissed off at his ex-wife.

PredictionLifeHotSarcastic
Bezos went to space and came back without sabotaging Amazon.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Australia is back on the map as the 'weirdest' people on Earth thanks to a kid eating a watermelon rind

He brings an entire watermelon with him, and he starts eating it. He bites through the rind, and he eats the entire watermelon by himself. When I say entire, I mean the green, the white part. Everything... it's a huge dub for Australia... This put australia back on the map as like the weirdest people on the planet.

Subjective cultural ranking.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially counting LeBron James out

So, well, let's just do a quick straw poll. Are you counting [LeBron] out? ... I want to count him out. Yeah, I'm going to do it. I'm going to count him out.

LeBron continued to be an All-NBA player and won an In-Season Tournament title in 2023, though he hasn't reached the Finals since this take.
Win
Wade PhillipsWade Phillips

Reggie White's 21-sack season in 12 games is a record that will never be beaten

Reggie White... had the greatest year that I've ever coached in that he had 21 sacks, which was the record for a long time. But that was in a 12-game season because we had a strike... So in 12 games, he had 21 sacks. I mean, I don't think anybody's going to ever come close to that.

While the single-season sack record is 22.5 (Strayhan/Watt), they played 16 games. No one has approached 21 sacks in 12 games.
Win
Wade PhillipsWade Phillips

J.J. Watt is the only defensive lineman I've ever coached who was allowed to call his own stunts based on offensive formations

One of the guys I coached in the last several years was J.J. Watt. And we let J.J., we let him determine where he was going to go by the formation... Normally, the linebacker plays off the defensive lineman, but we just did the opposite with him. He's one of the few guys I've ever had that... just decipher what the formation is and then go play.

Wade is describing his own coaching philosophy and specific tenure with the Texans.
Void
Wade PhillipsWade Phillips

The Titans' Music City Miracle was definitely a forward pass

I was standing there on the sideline, you know, right across from where they were making the play, where he was throwing the ball forward. So I still thought when they scored, I thought they, you know, they're going to call it back... threw it from behind the line and the guy caught it in front of a line. So I don't see how it couldn't have been forward.

The play was reviewed and upheld as a legal lateral; scientific analyses of 'parallax error' generally support the call, but it remains a legendary debate.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Gerrit Cole should have just lied about using Spider Tack

Garrett Cole, here's a little PR I want to run for you. It's called lying. You just have to lie. And if you just lie, what will happen is people will print your lie. And then people will read that and be like, oh, Garrett Cole doesn't use spider tack. And then the story's over.

Subjective PR advice based on the humor of the situation.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I would bail any PMT cast member out of jail for killing a man, but not a woman

I think if it was another man, I'd bail all of you guys out for killing another man. Well, no, I would not bail you out if you killed a woman. I think I'd bail you guys out if you guys were like, hey, I got into beef with another man, had to kill him. I'd be like, alright, fine, fuck it, let's roll.

A hyperbolic hypothetical about future behavior.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bryson DeChambeau's head is an orphanage where all the problem children of the PGA Tour and the fans live rent-free

Everyone is in [Bryson's] head at this point. It's an orphanage. All the problem children of the PGA Tour and the fans are allowed to live now rent-free in [his head].

This is a subjective assessment of a player's mental state.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Golf rivalries and fans hating players are good for the game

Golf should be fun. Rivalries are fun. Having guys hate each other is fun. Being able to hate another golfer as a fan is fun. All of these things make watching golf more enjoyable, and grows the game. You cannot tell me otherwise.

The Brooks vs. Bryson rivalry significantly increased golf engagement in 2021, leading up to 'The Match'.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kyrie Irving has the most desirable game of any NBA player

I think Kyrie Irving has the number one. If you could pick which game you could have, if you're any NBA player, you'd pick Kyrie Irving. Because his handles are incredible. His finishing at the rim... he's just so goddamn good.

This is a subjective opinion about playing style preference.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyrie Irving would win an NBA-wide one-on-one tournament

I think that if there was, like, a bracket one-on-one tournament in the NBA, I think that Kyrie would probably win.

Whether Kyrie Irving would win a hypothetical NBA one-on-one tournament is entirely speculative and subjective. No such tournament exists to verify this.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The best thing an athlete can do is start their career great but doughy so they always have 'getting in shape' as a backup plan

I think that's the greatest thing you can do as an athlete is start your career, be great, but be a little doughy so that you know you can always be like, 'well I could just get in shape.' Like Luka, he just looks at me like, 'dude, if I was in shape I'd probably win this game seven.'

This is a subjective theory on career management and athlete psychology.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

L.A. is currently a Clippers and Chargers town over the Lakers and Rams

L.A. is a Clippers town. Make no mistake about it. Right now, Big Cat, the town's going nuts for them. Them and the Chargers.

OpinionBasketballHotSarcastic
L.A. remains overwhelmingly a Lakers town by every metric (ratings, merchandise, polling), making this take incorrect.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

College baseball celebrations are the best in sports

I have to say, college baseball celebrations are the best thing, like, in sports. I don't know why it took me so long to, like, get into it.

Subjective opinion on entertainment value.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Vrabel builds teams based solely on player girth and size

I think I've figured out what Mike Vrabel's strategy is here... He's just trying to get the biggest dudes that he can possibly get his hands on. I think that he has the biggest starting 11, just mass-wise. He is Billy Football as a coach. He just wants pounds. And Julio Jones is a massive dude.

Subjective characterization of roster building, though the Titans did prioritize big, physical players during the Henry/Vrabel era.
Void
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The NBA is a 'sick league' where stars care more about movies than winning

The best player in the world [LeBron James] is walking off the court with 15 minutes left in the game like an asshole. And nobody says a word to him. And then he talks about his fucking cartoon movie after the game. Imagine being on that team. You just lost after being champions and talking about the Monstars.

This is a subjective cultural critique of the NBA vs NHL.
Push
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Montreal Canadiens aren't actually good, they just have a hot goalie

I think Montreal isn't good. They have an amazing goalie [Carey Price] who's hitting his stride at the right time... it's like they get goaltenders that get hot and then the magic of the Canadians jersey they end up winning games... the Canadiens will get into the probably final four and then just get shit pounded by Vegas or the Avalanche.

Partially correct. The Canadiens did reach the Final Four and then the Stanley Cup Finals, but they actually beat Vegas in the semi-finals before losing to Tampa Bay.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The 2021 Stanley Cup Final will be Tampa Bay vs. Colorado

I'm going Tampa, and I think the Avs end up getting it done against the Knights and then smoke the Canadians. And we're looking at Tampa, Colorado, and I think it'll be one of the best cup finals we've ever seen.

Incorrect. While Tampa won the Cup, Colorado lost in the second round to Vegas, and Montreal represented the other side of the bracket.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Logan Paul will catch Floyd Mayweather once, and that will wake Floyd up

I think that Logan is going to catch him once. I think he's going to catch him one time. And then that'll wake Floyd up. Because remember, we saw the Mayweather-McGregor fight a few years ago. Same type of thing happened.

Mayweather was never significantly caught or wobbled by Paul; he controlled the exhibition entirely, making this incorrect.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Floyd Mayweather vs. Logan Paul fight is the start of the 'participation trophy era'

The fight ended. No one won. For the first time, I'm going to say the participation trophy era is real. I think that's my takeaway from this. Like, what did we just watch?

The fight literally ended without a winner, making the 'no one won' part correct. The broader cultural claim is subjective.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James will pull an 'Aaron Rodgers' and publicly flirt with retirement this offseason to get people talking

My prediction for this offseason is that LeBron James, he's going to pull like an Aaron Rodgers. He's going to publicly flirt with retiring, but privately he's going to be like, I'm going to come back. But he wants people to talk about whether or not this is the end of the road for him.

LeBron did return for the next season and did not significantly flirt with retirement that specific summer; the Rodgers comparison holds more weight for LeBron's 2023 offseason.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James will never be 100% healthy again

He's old. He's 36. He's not as dominant as he used to be. He's never going to be 100% again. He said it himself.

This is largely a medical and subjective opinion, though LeBron has continued to have high-level seasons, he has consistently battled more significant injuries in his late 30s.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James' playoff losses are partly karma for how Space Jam: A New Legacy handled Lola Bunny

All I'll say is it might be karma for giving Lola Bunny a small ass. Yeah. The basketball gods caught up with [LeBron James].

The take is inherently absurd and satirical; the connection between a character's anatomy in a movie and a basketball series outcome is not a causal fact.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Lakers would have beaten the Suns if Anthony Davis stayed healthy

I do think – I'll say one nice thing about the Lakers. I do think that if Anthony Davis stays healthy in this series, it's totally different. They were up 2-1, tie ball game, game four, and he gets hurt.

This is a hypothetical outcome that cannot be proven, though the Lakers were leading the series before the injury.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James quit on his team in Game 5

So game five, he quit on his team. I mean, I don't know how you could see it otherwise. He left the game with five minutes and 40 feet, left the bench.

Subjective interpretation of player behavior.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I want to root for the Suns in the series against the Nuggets

First and foremost, I would like to root for the Suns... I want to root for the Suns is what I'm saying.

He did end up rooting for the Suns, who swept the Nuggets in that series.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Repeating as champion is the hardest thing to do in sports

LeBron has done it once. Hardest thing to do in sports is repeat, right?

Inherently subjective comparison of difficulty across sports.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lakers 2020 Bubble championship simply didn't happen

I think we can all agree that just didn't happen. It doesn't. Yeah. The bubbled never. That's not basketball. Yeah. No fans around.

The 2020 NBA championship is an official record.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James' roster for the 2020-21 Lakers was deeply flawed

They should fire LeBron James, the GM. Because this roster was flawed. And that's his team.

The 2020-21 Lakers roster struggled with injuries and shooting, supporting the claim that it was flawed compared to the previous championship season.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Coach K is retiring because of NIL and changes in the sport, despite claiming it's for 'family'

Coach K made it clear in his press conference that he's doing it because of family, not due to changes in the sport. So let's just all respect Coach K... [but] maybe because the likeness, you know, the players actually get paid. So paying them under the table isn't going to have the same effect.

While speculative, many analysts shared this view as many older coaches left shortly after NIL and the transfer portal became prominent.
Win
HankHank

Coach K is the greatest college basketball coach of all time

This is the greatest coach in the sport, and all you guys do is make jokes and mock him. Most wins of all time. 12 Final Fours. 15 ACC Tournament titles. 97 NCAA Tournament wins. 126 weeks ranked No. 1.

While 'greatest' is subjective, the stats cited are accurate as of the air date.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If the Duke Blue Devils are anywhere near the bubble next year, they will definitely be in the tournament for Coach K's final season

There's no chance whatsoever that [Duke is] getting left out of the tournament next year, no matter what. If they're anywhere close to a bubble... you are putting Duke Blue Devils in that fucking tournament.

Duke was excellent the next year, finishing 32-7 and reaching the Final Four, so they weren't even a bubble team.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

John Scheyer will be successful because he knows how the Duke system operates

But I think he will, with the right boosters and connections and bag men, I think he will be very successful at Duke. So, and I think just having a guy who won a national title for Coach K be the guy who's now coaching, I think it's a fairly easy transition.

Scheyer has had success in the regular season and recruiting, though he has yet to reach a Final Four in his first two seasons.
Win
HankHank

Brad Stevens is the right person to run the Celtics front office

If there's anyone that knows exactly what this Celtics roster needs to be and beat these teams that are on the next level, it is Brad Stevens. Obviously, Danny Ainge said that he was like, there's been moves that me and Brad didn't agree on, and now Brad has full control to do whatever he wants.

Brad Stevens has been highly successful as a GM, trading for Al Horford, Derrick White, Kristaps Porzingis, and Jrue Holiday, eventually winning a title in 2024.
Win
HankHank

The Hawks will beat the Sixers in the second round because of Joel Embiid's injury

They don't have Joel Embiid because he can't stay fucking healthy ever. And they're going to get boat raced by the Hawks in the second round and not make the Eastern Conference Finals again. That's my opinion.

The Hawks did indeed beat the Sixers in 7 games in the 2021 second round.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NHL should suspend players for dirty hits but allow them back for one 'grudge' game

I think they should do this more often... suspend him for enough games where he can come back and then everyone can tune in to watch him have fights all night. I think the rule should be if you get suspended for a dirty hit in the playoffs, you should be forced to start the next game, skate one shift, and then after that point, your suspension begins.

This is a satirical rule suggestion.
Void
Chris BoshChris Bosh

It is harder to stay at the top than to reach it in professional sports

It's always easy to have the hunger before you get it... But then when you are successful, in our case, when an NBA championship, you know, you understand what it takes to be able to stay at that level. And it's not easy... Now you're not the hunter anymore. You're the hunted.

Standard elite athlete philosophy.
Win
Chris BoshChris Bosh

The San Antonio Spurs stadium was excruciatingly and miserably hot during the 2014 'AC Game'

It was excruciatingly hot... We went back into the gym and was like, oh, oh, my God. We start playing and it was miserable. It was miserable.

Multiple players and reporters confirmed temperatures exceeded 90 degrees Fahrenheit due to the failed AC system.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Anyone over the age of 25 must hire a mover

Over the age of 25, you should hire a mover. I agree. I am that mover in this case. Yeah. Well, are you hired? No. Okay. You need to get hired.

Subjective life advice.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The pandemic has caused fans to lose their minds and forget how to behave in arenas

I do think the pandemic has fucked people up more than we realize. And people are just getting back into the real world and losing their fucking minds. Preseason. Yes, preseason. No one knows how to act right now. Give it a couple weeks. I do not think it's some huge epidemic where this is going to be the new norm that fans are just fucking with players constantly.

Fan incidents did eventually decrease in frequency from the initial post-reopening peak, though occasional incidents persist. His prediction that it wouldn't be the 'new norm' largely held true.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The media will soon claim that sports were better without fans in the building

I'm going to level it up. I'm going to say by the time you're hearing my voice, if it's in the afternoon tomorrow... somebody will have already written the take that sports were better when there were no fans in the building.

Many articles were indeed written in June 2021 debating the value of fans vs. the safety of players after incidents involving Kyrie Irving, Trae Young, and Russell Westbrook.
Win
HankHank

The Celtics will not win another game in their series against the Nets

[Jason Tatum] had 50, right? Yeah, that's fine... The starting lineup, it's one of those things where it doesn't matter. You could play those starting two lineups 100 times and the Celtics might win one. [Big Cat: 'Can we call it over?'] 100%. It's over.

The Nets won Game 5 on June 1st to close out the series 4-1. The Celtics did not win another game.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Joel Embiid didn't hurt his knee; he actually hurt his back or tailbone

I don't think [Joel Embiid] hurt his knee. I think he hurt his ass slash back. He grabbed his back. He fell on his back. His back has been bothering him all year. He grabbed his back, but he also grabbed the back of his leg. This is Drew Brees' ribs all over again. Joel Embiid's back is hurt.

The 76ers announced on June 2nd that Embiid had a small lateral meniscus tear in his right knee. It was a knee injury, not a back/tailbone injury.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Tom Thibodeau's coaching style prevents teams from having an extra gear in the playoffs

Tom Thibodeau is a fantastic coach, and he will always get your team to overachieve and play to their max ability during the regular season. And then when you get to the postseason, there's no extra gear... he also played Julius Randle the most minutes of anyone in the NBA this year. It's always going to go like this when you do that with your star player who can't figure out a double team.

The 2020-21 Knicks indeed sputtered out in the first round after a surprising regular season, and Randle's performance dropped significantly from his All-NBA regular season form.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm predicting a vintage, dominant LeBron James performance in Game 5 against the Suns

I think we're going to get like a vintage, vintage LeBron just every single way... 38 [points], 12 [rebounds], 8 [assists]. It's going to be one of those stat lines where Nick Wright will be like, 'no player since Michael Jordan has ever done this in the playoffs.'

In Game 5, LeBron had 24 points, 5 rebounds, and 7 assists in a 115-85 blowout loss to the Suns. It was far from a dominant vintage performance.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Luka Doncic is actually several years older than the Mavericks claim

I think Luka's older than we think he is... I think it's a Danny Almonte, Alfonso Soriano thing. I don't think Luka's 22 years old. I think Luka's probably 27, 28 years old. If you're a player that's not born in the United States and you come over, there's a lot of paperwork that can get either lost or changed very easily.

There is no evidence to support this; Doncic has been a highly visible pro since he was 13 at Real Madrid.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

A no-show in a Game 7 is a worse way to lose than a late-game collapse

There's actually nothing worse than a no-show in game seven. Like, losing in game seven... I know that that's bad in 2013 when they lost the way they lost. I would contend that a no-show the way they lost tonight [Game 7 vs Canadiens] where you get a fucking goal with 30 seconds left to just have something on the score sheet, that hurts so much worse.

Subjective opinion on the nature of sports pain.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If the Cowboys don't win a Super Bowl in the next 20 years, they will become the NFL's version of the Toronto Maple Leafs

The Cowboys, I think, have the element of... They're one of the teams that you think of when you think of football. The Leafs are one of the teams you think of when you think of hockey. They have historical relevance, but it's all in the past... If the Cowboys, if we're sitting here 2045 and the Cowboys haven't gone back to a Super Bowl, they would be the Maple Leafs.

This is a subjective comparison of future outcomes, but the historical parallels of 'America's Team' vs. Canada's most historic franchise in a long drought are strong.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers