Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Cam Ward has the 'eye test' of a franchise quarterback despite his poor debut stats

Cam Ward, if you look at his stats, you think he sucked. If you watched the game, you'd be like, there's something there... his receivers were dropping balls, his coaching was confusing at times... I'd be pumped, that Cam Ward looks like through one game, the eye test, it's there.

The quality of a quarterback's 'eye test' performance is inherently a matter of opinion.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jake Moody should be cut by the 49ers next week

Jake Moody has been a problem for the Niners... 12 of 23 is insane. He's gotta be cut this week... I'd be shocked if he was on the team next week.

Jake Moody was not cut by the 49ers the following week. He remained on the roster and the 49ers went 12-5, making the playoffs as a Wild Card team.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Phillies fan who yelled at the man over a home run ball should be banned for life from Citizens Bank Park

I think she should be banned for rest of Citizens Bank Park... She should be banned from Citizens Bank Park... she almost fought somebody over a home run ball.

This is a subjective moral judgment and opinion on stadium policy.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Clark is a 'piece of shit' for berating Peter Schrager

My who's back of the week is our guy Peter Schrager... Ryan Clark's a piece of shit. I'll just say that... he just like berated Peter Schrager for having a take on a take show because he didn't play the game... Ryan Clark, come on, man.

Subjective moral judgment on a public feud.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are the best team in the NFL right now

But they are the best team in the NFL. They won the Super Bowl. They're also the only team that's 1-0.

This is subjective but grounded in the fact they are the reigning champions in this transcript's narrative.
Loss
Eli ManningEli Manning

The Giants defense will be ferocious and cause problems for the league

Their defense is, is set up to be very good, especially kind of in a pass happy league they can get to quarterback... they can get sack fumbles, they can get, you know, get to the quarterback and really, you know, cause some problems.

The Giants went 4-13 in 2025. Their defense was not 'ferocious' enough to cause significant problems for the league with such a poor overall record.
Push
Howie LongHowie Long

The Raiders and Broncos will surprise people and make the a FC West competitive

Pete Carroll coming to the Raiders and... I think they could surprise some people and make that division a lot more interesting. Denver I think is on its way up.

The a FC West remained dominated by the Chiefs, though Denver showed some improvement.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

My worst-case scenario for the Bears is Caleb Williams being 'absolute dog shit'

I think we all know my worst case scenario, it's that Caleb [Williams] is dog shit... It's essentially that everyone is good around Caleb and Caleb is just absolute dog shit. That would be worst case scenario by far.

The season hasn't started yet as of the episode date.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

My worst-case scenario for the Commanders is Jayden Daniels suffering a major knee injury

My worst case scenario because it does, I think about this every Sunday. Is Jayden Daniels' knee exploding? Oh, I think I think about it way too much every time he gets hit. I think about it.

Subjective fear/scenario; cannot be 'correct' unless it actually happens.
Void
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Travis Kelce is more name than game at this stage of his career

Kelsey, the football player isn't the same as he used to be. Let's be real... he's more name than game than he is been in the past.

Subjective assessment of a player's performance level.
Void
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

The 90s Cowboys would have won five straight Super Bowls if Jimmy Johnson stayed

We often talk about we would've could've won five straight, [with Jimmy Johnson] but it didn't happen that way.

Counterfactual history that cannot be proven.
Void
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

The Cowboys family dynamic, not just skill, is what's missing for a Super Bowl run

They've always had the skill. It's just I need the collective will. Those three years we went 12 and 5, we had a good enough team... They had the skill, it was just not the collective will when we got to the playoffs. Hopefully that comes together.

Subjective analysis of team chemistry.
Void
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

George Pickens will be a phenomenal talent for the Cowboys playing with Dak Prescott

Phenomenal talent [George Pickens]... imagine what he must feel like Right now with a Dak Prescott at quarterback. Yeah.

Subjective evaluation of fit/talent.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alabama is back to being a regular program like it was before Nick Saban

This is going back to Bama. This is what you were before Nick Saban was there. That's what you're gonna be after Nick Saban leaves, unless you find the next Nick Saban.

While Saban's departure is real, Alabama remains a top-tier program in the 2024 reality.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Every college football game should be played on campus because neutral site games lack 'juice'

This is why every single game should be played on campus because it was awesome. And I hate like the Syracuse, Tennessee game being played in Atlanta just had no juice. South Carolina, Virginia Tech, no juice. Play every game on campus. That's what makes the sport so much fun.

This is a purely subjective aesthetic and cultural preference for the sport.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Northwestern's athletic department are 'scumbag pieces of shit' for refusing Tulane's request to honor Hurricane Katrina victims

What the fuck, Northwestern, you fucking scumbag pieces of shit. Did you guys see this story? Tulane wanted to wear their all white jerseys in honoring the 20th anniversary of the hurricane Katrina... Northwestern said, no... You can't be a bigger dick than to be like, no, you can't wear these uniforms to honor Katrina.

The host is expressing a strong moral opinion on the school's decision-making.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Putting a 'C' on an NFL player's chest is overrated

Listen, putting a C on somebody's chest is overrated. And that's what Max has always told you.

This is a subjective opinion on the value of team captains.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Luis Suarez's passion for soccer is so high that he's still spitting on staff members in MLS games

I kind of admire Luis Suarez's passion in that he's still so fired up for soccer that he's spitting on an old guy in a Seattle Miami MLS game... that passion's never gone away. He just blacks out. I think that's why he's not retired from soccer.

Subjective interpretation of a player's behavior and motivations.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is only playing another season to avoid retiring in the same year as Chris Paul

I think the only reason he is not gonna play, or he is gonna play another year is 'cause Chris Paul's gonna retire. He doesn't wanna retire the same year as Chris Paul because Chris Paul would overshadow his retirement.

This is a purely speculative theory about LeBron's internal motivations.
Void
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Alabama's players looked out of shape and lacked the necessary effort in their loss to Florida State

The most surprising thing... they didn't play with a lot of effort, they almost reminded me of guys that weren't in shape. Like they were loafing. They didn't run to the ball. It was like they just didn't care... the thing that made Alabama really good, which was the attention to detail, the effort, they didn't have.

Subjective evaluation of effort and physical conditioning based on game film.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ben Johnson is a 'true culture changer' who the Bears desperately needed

Ben Johnson, from everything that I've watched, read Training Camp, he is a true culture changer. And the Bears needed that in the worst way possible.

Subjective assessment of team culture and coaching impact.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I bet Caleb Williams went back to painting his nails to get back to the basics

Caleb Williams is my one to watch. There was an article that came out in ESPN today about why he stopped painting his nails last season and the fact that he is back to painting his nails now. He needs to get back to basics. It's like the peacock—the basics here are painting your nails.

This is a subjective lifestyle observation about a player's routine and its impact on his game.
Void
HankHank

Keegan Bradley not picking himself for the Ryder Cup is better for the team

Keegan wanted to pick himself, but he's taking, it's, it's, it was the right move, I guess to not pick himself for the team. It's better for the team and everyone can kind of rally around... you gotta win one for the captain.

Subjective take on team chemistry and leadership.
Void
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Will Howard will look much better at Ohio State because of the elite wide receivers around him

I think of how Will Howard looked at Kansas State and then I think of how Will Howard looked at Ohio State. Right. Looked a lot different when you have all those guys to throw to... great receivers can elevate a mediocre quarterback.

Subjective evaluation of how a player's performance is tied to his supporting cast.
Push
Brandon WalkerBrandon Walker

Kalen DeBoer is not built for the SEC and will fail at Alabama

For whatever reason the coach doesn't fit Alabama... it takes a different kind of human to win in the SEC... I don't think Kalen DeBoer fits Alabama. Alabama fan base and the Alabama pressure is different and it fucks people up. And it fucked him up last year. I think it's gonna fuck him up again. He's not built for this shit.

Alabama went 11-4 in 2025 under Kalen DeBoer, making the CFP and beating Oklahoma in the first round. However, they were blown out 38-3 by Indiana in the quarterfinals and lost the SEC title game 28-7. DeBoer showed mixed results - competitive but not elite.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

An NFL trade request doesn't really mean anything anymore; it's just the new version of a holdout

What this should teach us more than anything about the NFL is that a trade request doesn't really mean shit anymore. In the NBA I feel like if you request a trade... it's over. In the NFL, that's just the new holdout, right? Is requesting a trade.

The 2024 off-season saw numerous trade requests (Aiyuk, McLaurin, Hendrickson) result in the players staying with their original teams on new deals.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Terry McLaurin's 'hold in' only worked because he didn't miss mental reps and stayed in shape

I like to think that Terry is a consummate pro... they were just giving him all the assignments, the playbook, all that stuff he was doing mental reps. He's gonna be in shape.

Subjective assessment of a player's preparation during a holdout.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Trey Hendrickson's contract raise is a win-win for both the player and the Bengals

I think there's a win-win. You get more money for this year. You still get to be a free agent next year and maybe cash in one more time. And the Bengals... don't have to worry about it in the coming years.

Outcome of the contract's value is subjective to team and player goals.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Winning the Ryder Cup as a playing captain would make Keegan Bradley an all-time legend, perhaps better than winning a major

If he wins as the playing captain, you're an all time legend. All time... Winning as a playing captain might be better than winning a major. I think I could see that being the truth.

This is a subjective value judgment on sports achievements.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Tour Championship is basically all the golf majors combined

[The Tour Championship] is basically the fifth major. The only one I would say it's all the majors combined. It's an aggregate of all the majors. So [Tommy Fleetwood] is the biggest golf winner of the year.

OpinionGolfMediumSarcastic
The Tour Championship is a prestigious event but is not literally an aggregate of the majors, nor is it considered a major by the golf world.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Starting Dorian Thompson-Robinson proves Kevin Stefanski isn't racist

I actually think that Kevin Stefanski starting DTR [Dorian Thompson-Robinson] in actual NFL football games is concrete evidence of him not being racist. Correct. And it's like case closed.

A logically sound counter-argument to a specific internet narrative, though 'proving' someone isn't racist is subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Minnesota Vikings franchise is the 'Hall of Very Good' of NFL teams

Minnesota Vikings franchise hall of very good 65 seasons. 32 playoff appearances in 65 seasons. They've literally been in the playoffs almost exactly half the time. ... They've never won a Super Bowl. They're the hall of very good franchises.

A statistical fact claim used to support a subjective categorization.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Above-ground pools are 'very good' and belong in the Hall of Very Good

Our second pick is going to be above ground pools. ... They're very good. They're very fun. I've had a fun time in an aboveground. ... So much better than no pool.

Inherently subjective opinion on leisure items.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Canada is a 'Hall of Very Good' country, but not a top-three country

Our next pick is gonna be Canada as a country, which is very good. Not Hall of Fame country... They're just very good. Seems pretty good... But have they ever been in history, a top three country? No. No. And that's okay. They're like the Scottie Pippen of countries.

Subjective ranking of countries cannot be factually proven.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Titty fucking is 'very good' but not 'Hall of Fame' level

We want to take titty fucking. Yeah. It's very good. ... It's not Hall of fame. Hall of Fame is sex. ... If you're titty fucking in an above ground pool in Canada, you're having a very good time. Yeah.

Subjective opinion on a sexual act.
Void
Mike FlorioMike Florio

Dak Prescott, Josh Allen, and Lamar Jackson have the most pressure in the NFL

I think there's a ton of pressure on Dak Prescott. He's making 60 million a year... how can you not say there's pressure on Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson to finally close the gap with the chiefs and finally deliver it.

Pressure is subjective but widely agreed upon for these specific veterans.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Harrison Phillips trade is a great addition for the Jets' defensive depth

Harrison Phillips got traded to the Jets. It's actually a nice, nice trade for the Jets. More defensive line depth.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Shohei Ohtani should be eliminated from MVP consideration after giving up five runs to the Rockies

Shohei [Ohtani] got rocked and he got hit by a line drive... he hit into a triple play, five runs against the Rockies. Those two things should eliminate you from the MVP.

Void
MaxMax

Zelda: Ocarina of Time is the best video game ever made

We are gonna go Zelda: Ocarina of Time... widely known as the best game ever... It's like known as being the best game ever.

Void
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

I am not drafting Justin Fields in fantasy football this season

Anything with Justin Fields, it's just not happening. We can't with Justin Fields this season. I'm so sorry. [He] has the ability to rush but a quarterback also has to have the ability to pass the ball as well.

This is a statement of personal draft strategy rather than a verifiable outcome, though his performance can be reviewed.
Void
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

I am staying away from drafting Kyle Pitts in fantasy football this year

Staying away from the Falcons... Kyle Pitts lets us down every year. I'm not falling for it again. I know I'm supposed to be open to the universe except Kyle Pitts. I'm not open to the universe of Kyle Pitts.

This is a personal draft strategy take based on subjective frustration.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Daniel Jones starting for the Colts is a decision made under duress by Shane Steichen

I believe this is a decision made under duress by Shane Steichen. He [is] very much on the Hot Seat. And he basically is in the worst place you wanna be as an organization where it's like, I'm gonna get fired. I gotta find a way to eke out like six or seven wins. Daniel Jones gives you a higher floor.

Anthony Richardson eventually started the season, rendering the take about Jones winning the job under duress incorrect as Jones remained a backup.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The AFC North is officially the 'division of quarterbacks' now that Joe Flacco is back

AFC North quarterbacks: Flacco, [Aaron] Rodgers, Lamar [Jackson], [Joe] Burrow. It's the division of quarterbacks. Listen, two guys have, the two old guys have Super Bowls. The young guys haven't done it.

The AFC North is indeed stacked with high-profile QBs, though Rodgers is in the AFC East. This is a common mix-up in the moment.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Giving the Super Bowl to another country is disgusting

The Super Bowl is the most important thing we do as a country. We, we create the Super Bowl every year. We have a season, a football season that creates the Super Bowl. To give that to another country is disgusting. I'm disgusted with you.

Subjective opinion on the cultural significance of the game.
Void
HankHank

Number 47 is a terrible number for a BYU quarterback

Bear's a bad start. You can't. You put harder earned money on a team and you see a quarterback coming out wearing number 47. Terrible number for a quarterback.

Purely an aesthetic opinion.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Auburn adding four historical national titles is the beauty of college sports

Auburn football won four national championships today. They updated their official national titles. They added a championship in 1910, 1914, 1958, and then most notably they added 2004. They finished the season undefeated, but they didn't get invited. This is kind of the beauty of college sports. That you can just claim whatever you want.

Auburn did indeed update their media guide to include these 'selective' titles.
Void
Adam FriedlandAdam Friedland

Nick Mullen is the funniest guy of all time

Nick [Mullen] was a genius. He was the funniest guy of all time. No, I mean, it was incredible. It was so funny.

Completely subjective opinion about a comedian.
Void
Adam FriedlandAdam Friedland

The Democratic Party is desperate for a podcast 'answer' because they offer no real substance

They're fucking desperate. If it's me from Cumtown, they don't have shit, dude. They think they lost because they didn't have a good enough podcast? They're fucking idiots because they offered nothing. Maybe they lost because they're like 'yeah, you can't have healthcare, but we painted a rainbow crosswalk'.

Adam's critique of political strategy is subjective but widely debated.
Void
Adam FriedlandAdam Friedland

Being an American soccer fan is the 'worst kind of guy you could be'

Being an American soccer fan is like, it's the, it's just the worst kind of guy you could be. Really? It's just the most [lame]. I live in Brooklyn, and I like footy. Like, it's just like shut up, you know.

Purely a subjective social critique.
Void
Adam FriedlandAdam Friedland

LeBron winning in the bubble didn't feel the same as a real title

When we won, won in the bubble. I've said this before, but like, I like looked into my heart like 30 seconds later I was like, it doesn't feel the same with him [LeBron]. Yeah. It really doesn't feel the same with him.

Subjective feeling on the value of a championship.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers