Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl are the best duo since Michael Jordan and Scottie Pippen

I say he's Pippen and Jordan, I say the best duo since Pippen and Jordan. Wow. They're gonna, I think they're gonna win win a championship.

While elite, the duo had not won a Cup at this point and were eliminated shortly after this take. They did reach the Finals in 2024.
Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Seattle Kraken are for real and could win the Stanley Cup

No, they're for real. They just, so I, I didn't trust them against the Champs either. But Seattle is just such a disciplined team. They have all these castaway type players. I think Seattle could win it all.

The Kraken lost in Game 7 of the second round to the Dallas Stars, so they did not win it all.
Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Devils are a dark horse to win the Stanley Cup if they can outrun the Hurricanes

I would have my dark horse right now being down two one to Carolina... I think New Jersey, I still see something in New Jersey. I might be dead wrong, but that's probably the dark horse and best odds right now.

The Devils lost to the Hurricanes in 5 games.
Win
Billy FootballBilly Football

I am not moving to Chicago with the rest of the show

I will not be moving to Chicago. Kind of been in denial about it. It sucks to say there are various parts of my life that I keep private that impacted this decision. I hope you guys respect the decision. Please just remember that I am the only one who can weigh all the factors that impact my life.

This was a definitive personal announcement that came to pass.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If James Harden scores more than 30 points in a playoff game, you should sit him the next game

I'm a big believer and if James Harden scores more than 30 points in a playoff game, you should sit him the next game. Give him a nice little sit and then it's back to Philly. I'm sure that James Harden will be great in game seven like he always is.

Harden followed a 42-point Game 4 with 17 points in a Game 5 win, then struggled in Games 6 and 7. The take is satirically proven right by his inconsistency.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jayson Tatum is better than Joel Embiid in the playoffs

[Jayson Tatum] is the best player on the court. He's better than Joel Embiid. I'm sorry, like in playoffs, Joel Embiid, he had a very good game, but the fourth quarter he looked like the most gassed person in the world.

Tatum outplayed Embiid in Game 7 of this series to advance, supporting the claim for this specific postseason.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Players should not be allowed to take a charge if they are covering their genitals

You should not be allowed to take a charge if you're covering your nuts... How can you play defense if you're covering up your balls? You can't make a play on the ball if your hands are on your own balls.

This is a philosophical stance on basketball officiating rules.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Celtics will beat the Sixers in seven games

I do think this is gonna go seven and I think the Celtics are gonna win in seven because the Sixers didn't win game three. The Celtics are gonna have a reinvigorated effort on Tuesday night... Sixers win [Thursday]... back to Boston for game seven. Seltz win game seven.

The Celtics beat the 76ers 4-3, winning Game 7 in Boston.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James will play three or four more years and will not decline in quality

I think LeBron's gonna play what, maybe like four more years. Three more years maybe? And I don't think he's even gonna get worse. I think he kind of is what he is at this point and old less, slightly less athletic LeBron is still a fucking monster and so he's just gonna play until he decides to walk away and he's still gonna be super healthy at that point.

LeBron is still playing at an All-NBA level as of the 2024-2025 season (2+ years after the take) without a major drop-off.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James will be a bad father by making Bronny leave college early to play with him on the Lakers

LeBron's about to be a bad father because he's going to deny his son a degree just so that he can draft him to get him to play on the Lakers.

Hot TakeBasketballHotSarcastic
Bronny did leave USC after one year and was drafted by the Lakers in 2024, but characterizing this as LeBron 'denying him a degree' is a satirical stretch.
Loss
HankHank

The winner of the Celtics vs. Sixers series will go to the NBA Finals

Obviously now I would say whoever wins the Sixers-Celtics series is going to go to the finals. But the whole time I was like with the Celtics, they're gonna smoke whoever wins [Heat-Knicks] series.

The Miami Heat defeated the Boston Celtics in the Eastern Conference Finals to advance to the NBA Finals.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Erik Spoelstra is the best coach in the NBA

Spoelstra is the best coach left in the Eastern Conference. Probably in the NBA. I think in the NBA. It does feel like they have the edge there and a lot of these series do come down like to adjustments in game to game because you start to know your opponent so well.

While subjective, Spoelstra's performance leading an 8-seed to the Finals reinforced his status as an elite coach.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Harden will hit up every strip club while in Miami for the playoffs

If [James Harden] is in Miami during the playoffs, that man will be hitting up every strip club.

This is a stereotypical claim about Harden's lifestyle that cannot be definitively verified by game results.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 2021 Rams weren't actually that good despite winning the Super Bowl

I still don't think the Rams were that good [when they won the Super Bowl]. They just had Aaron Donald and Matt Stafford played really well for an extended stretch. But like yeah, I those teams exist in your mind. Like I still think the 49ers were better than the Rams.

This is a retrospective opinion on a previous season's champion.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Phoenix Suns are better without Chris Paul

I think in a sick way they definitely are better without Chris Paul. 100%. Because if you got Devin Booker and Kevin Durant, those guys, they can both create their own shots... they're not reliant on Chris Paul to run their offense.

The Suns went 2-2 without Paul in this series but ultimately lost in 6 games to Denver. Whether they are 'better' long-term is a matter of debate.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If Nikola Jokic gets suspended for shoving Mat Ishbia, it's absolute bullshit

That was a crazy scene because if Nikola Jokic gets suspended, that will be absolutely bullshit because Mat Ishbia... he grabbed the ball, wouldn't give it up, and then he kind of like chested into Jokic and then Jokic gave him a little shove. If Adam Silver suspends Jokic for this game, it's bullshit.

Jokic was fined but not suspended for the incident, making the 'bullshit' scenario moot.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Suns are better without Chris Paul because he brings bad vibes

Get Chris Paul on your team and then have him get injured. And that way everybody is psyched that they don't have to play with Chris Paul anymore. Better vibes on the team.

The Suns were 2-2 in the games Paul missed in this series before losing to the Nuggets. Whether the 'vibes' were better is subjective.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Maple Leafs' round one series win doesn't count if they get swept in the second round

Do we count the Leafs getting into the second round if they don't win a game? I don't think it counts. If they don't win a single game in the second round, I don't think they got to the second round.

Hot TakeHockeyMediumSarcastic
The Leafs lost the series 4-1 to the Panthers. They avoided the sweep, so by Big Cat's logic, it 'counts.'
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Meghan Markle attended King Charles' Coronation in a disguise

They're saying that that was Meghan Markle wearing a prosthetic, pretending to be a dude to sneak into the coronation. I have no idea if it's true or not, but I now I believe it because these people care so very deeply about it.

Meghan Markle was in California during the coronation; the person in the photo was Sir Karl Jenkins, a composer.
Void
Michael DaviesMichael Davies

Ken Jennings is the undisputed GOAT of Jeopardy

The host is Ken Jennings, who is the GOAT. He's the greatest Jeopardy player of all time. Won the most consecutive episodes... When they played a primetime event named GOAT to determine the greatest of all time, Ken Jennings won that against James [Holzhauer].

This is a widely held opinion backed by the results of the official 'Greatest of All Time' tournament.
Void
Michael DaviesMichael Davies

Barstool Van Talk was going to be a hit TV show

Barstool Van Talk was gonna be a hit TV show. And as I poured over the 18 to 34 demo results of that first episode, that was a hit TV show. So that was the one that got away.

The single episode aired on ESPN2 did well in the target demographic, though its 'hit' status is a projection.
Void
Michael DaviesMichael Davies

Sports and Jeopardy are the only things left worth watching on broadcast TV

The only show on television out-rates Jeopardy is the NFL. There's the NFL then Jeopardy, then every drama, every new show, every comedy, everything else. And Jeopardy still has those moments... all that's left is sports and Jeopardy really for me and TV. There's nothing else.

In terms of live ratings and cultural relevance, Davies' observation about the dominance of sports and Jeopardy is generally backed by viewership data.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Warriors are nearly unbeatable when Klay Thompson scores 30 or more points

Klay Thompson, when he scores 30 or more points... 64 and 10. Pretty good. When he has, when he's the perfect amount of high for a game, when he takes his edible and times it out perfectly before the game and he goes off, the Warriors win those games.

As of the episode date, the Warriors were statistically dominant when Klay hit the 30-point mark.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Lakers-Warriors series is going to seven games

It feels like this is gonna be a seven game series. I'm very, very excited... I like, I can't decide who's going to win this series because I do still...

The Lakers won the series in six games.
Loss
MaxMax

Joel Embiid will score at least 35 points in Game 3 against the Celtics

He's gonna look so much better tonight... He's gonna drop at least 35 [points].

Embiid scored 30 points in Game 3, missing the 35-point threshold.
Loss
MaxMax

The Sixers will never play as poorly as they did in Game 2 again in these playoffs

That game [Game 2] will not happen again... we will not see the Sixers look like that again in this playoffs.

While they played better in some games, the Sixers were blown out again 112-88 in the decisive Game 7 of the same series.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Marcus Smart will never have another shooting performance as good as Game 2

Marcus Smart will never shoot like that again. That's fact.

Smart shot 50% or better again in the same series, notably going 8/15 (53%) in Game 6.
Loss
HankHank

The Celtics will gentlemen's sweep the Sixers

Must win. Five games, gentlemen's sweep starts tonight.

The series went the full seven games, with the Celtics winning 4-3.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sam Darnold is the most talented pure thrower in 49ers history

He said Sam Darnold might be the most talented thrower of football that the 49ers have ever had... I guess he's right. Most talented thrower of football.

Even as a 'pure thrower', ranking Darnold above Joe Montana or Steve Young is historically absurd.
Void
Christian HornerChristian Horner

The F1 Las Vegas Grand Prix will be the biggest sporting event in the world in 2023

I think it's gonna be the biggest sporting event globally this year. I really do. I think that the interest and the hype around that race, I mean, a Saturday night race down the strip in Vegas, who doesn't wanna be there?

The inaugural Las Vegas GP was a massive financial and viewership success, though 'biggest globally' is subjective compared to the Super Bowl or Champions League final.
Loss
Randy MossRandy Moss

Derma Sotogake will win the Kentucky Derby

There are two Japanese horses in the Derby this year. One of them is my pick to win the Derby... His name is Derma Sotogake.

Derma Sotogake finished 6th; Mage won the Derby.
Push
Randy MossRandy Moss

Add Disarm to your Kentucky Derby trifecta because he is a great finisher

If you're looking for a big long shot to throw into the try other than Hit Show, I would say a horse called Disarm who's gonna be a stretcher runner who's doing really well.

Disarm finished 4th in the Derby, just missing the trifecta but validating the 'great finisher' claim by moving up from 13th.
Loss
Randy MossRandy Moss

Wet Paint will be very hard to beat in the Kentucky Oaks

It's gonna be hard to beat the favorite, the favorite's name is Wet Paint... She's a horse that's won, I think, three races in a row... I like a Wet Paint South Lawn Exacta.

Wet Paint finished 4th and South Lawn finished 10th in the 2023 Kentucky Oaks; Pretty Mischievous won.
Void
Randy MossRandy Moss

Flightline was a better horse than American Pharoah

Secretariat was the best... The four best horses that I've seen... were Secretariat, Flightline, Spectacular Bid, and American Pharoah... I would put 'em in that order. And I know some people think it's heresy to say that Flightline was better than American Pharoah... but I just think that Flightline was better.

This is a subjective historical ranking within horse racing that cannot be definitively proven.
Loss
HankHank

I will become a scratch golfer by the end of the week

I'm gonna become a scratch golfer by the end of the week.

PredictionGolfFireSarcastic
Hank did not become a scratch golfer (0 handicap) by the end of that week, nor has he ever been one.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James might be better as a Robin than a Batman for the Lakers

I think what we're seeing is LeBron might be better as a Robin than he is as a Batman. They've got a true number one option finally on the Lakers in AD who looks healthier than we had predicted.

The Lakers did lean heavily on Davis during their 2023 WCF run, but the dynamic remains a shared leadership. LeBron's role as a playmaker makes the Batman/Robin dynamic subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

My fear of the Lakers making a championship run has reached a new level

My fear of LeBron and the Lakers making a championship run has elevated to another rung. So I do think this is gonna be a great series. I obviously, you know, like game one, especially the Warriors coming off of game seven, I don't know how they're gonna solve for the fact that the Lakers are just taller than them.

The Lakers did make a run to the Western Conference Finals, though they were ultimately swept by the Nuggets. Big Cat's fear was justified as they beat the defending champ Warriors.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

NBA playoff teams should only wear their classic home and road jerseys

When you're in the playoffs, you wear your jerseys, you wear your classic jerseys, you wear your home, you wear your road. Like don't fuck it up. ... I don't want your city connect. I don't want your 17th Nike jersey. ... I do sound like an old man right now, but I want your classic jersey playing in the playoffs.

This is a matter of personal aesthetic preference and tradition.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Whitney was completely wrong for saying the Kraken would only win one playoff game

The Kraken are fucking... put the Kraken every time they're on the screen. It also, Ryan Whitney's full of shit for saying the Kraken were gonna win one game in the playoffs.

The Kraken won their first-round series against the Avalanche (4 games) and won three games in the second round against the Stars. Whitney was definitively wrong.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Erik Spoelstra is the best coach in the NBA

Spoelstra is the best coach in the league I think. I think he might take over the title. I think he might be—Pop has not been in the playoffs for a few years. I think Spo is the best coach. Like the fact that he had that team almost winning at the garden, missing three guys and having the refs go against you.

While subjective, Spoelstra led the 8-seed Heat to the NBA Finals in 2023, largely vindicating this take.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Phil Jackson's greatest skill was managing the massive egos of his superstar players

Management of egos is also equally as important. Kerr does that a great job with that. Phil Jackson was managing Michael Jordan, Scotty Pippen, Shaq, Kobe, Dennis Rodman. And he was also banging the owner of the team too. I think he's pretty good at managing egos.

This is a widely accepted historical perspective on Jackson's 11 rings.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JCOs are a fashion look that needs to make a comeback in the 2020s

James Harden wore the Clutch jeans on his entrance to the stadium. He did. He's bringing JCOs back. It's been a long time. We've been squatting on that. Take: JCOs are a look that needs to come back in the 2020s.

Fashion is subjective, though JCOs have seen a niche ironic resurgence.
Loss
HankHank

Brad Stevens should come down from the front office to call plays for the Celtics

Brad Stevens for all you know, intents and purposes one of the best X's and O's guys ever when he was coaching... He's still in the organization. Why don't they just put him on the bench and just have him call the plays at the end of the game?

This never happened; Stevens remained in his GM role while Mazzulla continued as head coach.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jayson Tatum is clearly the best player on the court in the Celtics-Sixers series

Jayson Tatum... he is an exceptional, he's gonna be first team all-NBA. He's an exceptional except exceptional player. It feels like that last thing is that killer instinct of like, this is my game I'm taking over. I'm the best, he is the best player on that court.

Tatum was First Team All-NBA in 2023 and outlasted Embiid in the series, scoring 51 in Game 7.
Push
HankHank

Joel Embiid returning to the lineup will discombobulate the Sixers

I think that Embiid coming back at not a hundred percent will discombobulate them. I think it helps [the Celtics]. ... If Embiid comes back it's gonna discombobulate them enough for the Celtics to win.

The Celtics did win the series in seven games, though Embiid's return led to two Sixers wins (Games 4 and 5) before they collapsed in Game 7.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Celtics will blow out the Sixers in Game 2

I do think the Celtics are gonna kill them tonight. I think there's a just a natural like let down, you won one in Boston, you didn't need Embiid. It the Celtics now have to like give their best effort. It feels like a Celtics blowout.

The Celtics won Game 2 by 34 points (121-87). Absolute bullseye.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Denver Nuggets will beat the Phoenix Suns in six games

I still standby prediction Nugs in six. I think that KD and Booker are gonna have a couple of those games where they just go nuclear.

The Nuggets defeated the Suns in exactly 6 games.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Nuggets will beat the Suns in five games

Just watching the game... the Nuggets have so many more answers and the Suns just, they, they can't, they have to play perfect. I think it's Nugs in five.

The series went 6 games. Big Cat was close but technically incorrect.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick trading back in the draft just to spite the Jets was a brilliant move

The Patriots traded that draft pick to the Steelers because they knew that the Jets wanted to take Broderick Jones... They even got less than they should have gotten from the Steelers because they wanted to move that pick so badly... specifically so they could fuck the New York Jets. That's brilliant.

This was widely reported as the intended outcome of the trade, as Jones was the last top-tier tackle on the board and the Jets were forced to pivot.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Dillon Brooks has talked himself out of the NBA

I really do think [Dillon Brooks] might've played himself. Like he talked himself out of the NBA. Well and also the lack of play... he talked himself out of the [league].

Brooks did not leave the NBA; he signed an $80 million contract with the Houston Rockets shortly after this.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers