Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
Big CatBig Cat

Mac Jones will be a bust because he is crying in his DUI mugshot

I like my quarterbacks when they get a mug shot to not have a little cry in their eyes. Oh, he's sad in it? Yeah, look it up. He's got a tiny bit of cry in his eyes. So I'm saying bust just on that. Just based on that.

Mac Jones was benched and eventually traded by the Patriots after three seasons, largely considered a bust for a first-round pick.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mac Jones is only the best backup quarterback prospect in the 2021 draft

Mac Jones is the best backup quarterback in this draft at the next level. He projects to be a top-tier, long-term backup.

While Mac Jones started for several seasons, he was eventually benched and traded to be a backup for the Jaguars, partially validating the 'long-term backup' ceiling.
Win
HankHank

Citizen Kane is no longer the best movie of all time according to Rotten Tomatoes

Someone that works at Rotten Tomatoes found an 80-year-old review... talking a negative review about Citizen Kane. So they put it in the Rotten Tomatoes whatever system, and now it's 99 on Rotten Tomatoes, not 100. Paddington 2 is 100. So Citizen Kane, by Rotten Tomatoes metrics, no longer the best movie of all time.

This actually happened in April 2021; a negative 1941 review from the Chicago Tribune was added, dropping the score to 99%.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

ESPN's new hockey coverage will feature a 'safe' and poor imitation of Ryan Whitney or Paul Bissonnette

My prediction is that they're going to need to find somebody to fill like the Paul Bissonette, Ryan Whitney. There's definitely a meeting going on right now at ESPN where they're like, 'we need to get our Biz Nasty or Ryan Whitney of our own on ESPN.' But, you know, like a little safer than them. And they're going to go out there and try to find somebody. And it's going to be the worst impression of Paul Bissonette and Ryan Whitney that they have on the set.

ESPN's NHL coverage has generally been more traditional, while Biz and Whit stayed with TNT and Barstool.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

It is safe to stop wearing masks outside now

My hot seat is anyone who's still wearing masks outside. We're good. CDC said we don't have to do it anymore. Which I don't want to say not to brag, but I called it. But last week, my sunglasses were getting fogged up. And I was like, I think I'm done wearing a mask outside.

The CDC did indeed update guidance around April 2021 regarding outdoor mask-wearing for vaccinated people.
Win
Steven CheahSteven Cheah

Jalen Mayfield is a 'dumpy' prospect who will have to move from tackle to guard in the NFL due to his arm size

Jalen Mayfield... is your classic, like bad body guy, but he's a better football player. As far as offensive tackles arm size, you're going to want to see 34 inches and above; I believe [Jalen] Mayfield's like 32 and change. So that kind of limits him. He's probably going to move inside to guard because his arms aren't really a required size to play on the outside.

Mayfield was drafted by the Falcons and moved to guard, where he struggled significantly before moving back to tackle later.
Loss
Steven CheahSteven Cheah

Justin Fields is the 'Red Star' guy of the 2021 draft who will not bust

My red star guy, honestly, Justin Fields. I think everyone's overthinking Justin Fields. The fact that he's not going to be a top three quarterback... This guy's not going to bust. I know that this guy is legit. He's the guy we should draft on our team. I'm fully vouching for this guy.

Fields struggled as a starter in Chicago and was eventually traded to Pittsburgh to be a backup, suggesting the 'not a bust' claim is incorrect or at least partially incorrect.
Push
Steven CheahSteven Cheah

Rashod Bateman will translate instantly to the NFL as a successful receiver

Rashod Bateman, wide receiver out of Minnesota... He's just a guy that separation as far as route running, catching over the middle stuff. He's going to translate instantly. He's probably going to be a second round guy, maybe a late first, but Rashod Bateman would be my red star guy.

Bateman was a first-round pick but his 'instant translation' was slowed significantly by multiple injuries early in his career.
Loss
Steven CheahSteven Cheah

Devonta Smith will not be a top 10 pick in the NFL Draft

I had the take during the national championship... I think Devonta Smith is going to be awesome, but I cannot see a team spending a top 10 pick on a 175 pound wide receiver... drafting traits over production... Devontae Smith just does not have the frame.

Devonta Smith was selected 10th overall by the Philadelphia Eagles in the 2021 NFL Draft.
Win
Steven CheahSteven Cheah

DeVonta Smith does not have the physical frame to add significant weight in the NFL

DeVonta Smith officially [weighed in] a couple weeks ago at 166 pounds. He had several months to gain weight and puff up. He got to 166. So he was several pounds below that. DeVonta Smith just does not have the frame to add more weight because he had several months to do so and still couldn't do it. I don't see how he gets into an NFL program and then all of a sudden gets to like 185 or 190. He just needs more sand.

Smith has remained slim throughout his career but has been highly productive regardless of his size.
Void
Steven CheahSteven Cheah

Mac Jones is the 'Coach Killer' of the 2021 draft for Kyle Shanahan

It is Mac Jones because – It is, from what we've heard, Kyle Shanahan versus the personnel department in San Francisco... If Mac Jones does not turn out and Trey Lance and or Justin Fields turns out to be a very good player, we could be witnessing the beginning of the end to Kyle Shanahan.

Kyle Shanahan drafted Trey Lance, not Mac Jones. Shanahan remains the 49ers coach and has since made a Super Bowl.
Win
Steven CheahSteven Cheah

Joe Tryon has the 'body beautiful' that scouts look for in an edge rusher

On defense, we're going to look at an edge rusher out of Washington... Joe Tryon. I mean, he's just 6'5", 260, muscled up. He's exactly what you'd want to look for as far as body beautiful. That dude's wrapped.

Tryon-Shoyinka was drafted 32nd overall by Cheah's Buccaneers, largely due to his physical profile.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bears will draft Kyle Trask and he will be a bust

I'm calling it right now. They're going to draft Kyle Trask, and then he's going to stink, and [Big Cat's] life will be made a living hell by a quarterback who sucks that looks exactly like Billy Football.

The Bears did not draft Kyle Trask; they traded up for Justin Fields. Trask was drafted by Tampa Bay in the second round.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jon Gruden would trade his entire draft for Derrick Henry

I feel like it might be [Jon] Gruden. He might do it for Derrick Henry just because of his size. I feel like Gruden is a guy that respects mass.

This is a hypothetical opinion about a coach's tendencies and cannot be definitively proven.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Arthur Smith's family wealth proves his genuine love for football

His dad is the CEO of FedEx and he could have just been rich. Instead, he's like, I want to grind tape and be an offensive coordinator for a bunch of years and then hopefully get the dignity of being able to stand on the sidelines as my team collapses... it's pretty fair to say that he loves football.

Whether someone 'loves' football is subjective, though his career path supports the logic.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jake Paul 'owns' Dana White by exposing UFC fighter pay disparity

The reason why I say Jake Paul kind of owns Dana White a little bit, he got Dana White to talk about him in the post-fight press conference... he points out that he has made more money than every other UFC fighter before him. Except for Khabib and McGregor... basically he is like, Dana, why don't you pay your guys so they don't have to come fight me and make their big payday?

The financial claims are largely verifiable and the 'ownership' is an opinion on the PR battle.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

MMA fighters should start wearing shin guards in professional fights

They should make the shin kicks illegal. Or make them wear shin guards like they do in other MMA sports... I think literally guys are just kicking so hard the shin can't evolve fast enough.

While an opinion, it's highly unlikely the UFC would ever adopt shin guards for pro fights.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Pitchers who get upset about batters celebrating home runs are 'soft'

[Trevor Bauer] said, I like it. Pitchers who have that done to them and react by throwing at people or getting upset and hitting people or whatever, I think it's pretty soft. If you give up a homer, a guy should celebrate it... I'm all for it, and I think it's important that the game moves in that direction.

This is a subjective opinion on sportsmanship and baseball culture.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Oregon basketball court is the worst court design of all time

The Oregon court is the worst court of all time. I hate that court. It looks like it's warped. Every time I see that court, I get fucking so mad.

Aesthetic judgments are inherently subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Counterfeiting $2 bills is a genius idea because people don't know what they look like

One of my dumbest slash maybe most genius ideas is to counterfeit $2 bills because no one actually knows what they look like. And no one would ever think you'd counterfeit a $2 bill. So if you just counterfeited all the $2 bills, I think you'd be able to...

This is a subjective opinion on a criminal strategy.
Win
HankHank

There are more complete-game one-hitters than no-hitters in MLB history

I'll bet that there's more [complete game one-hitters]. I'm not a math guy, but I'm rolling with math on this one.

Statistically, one-hitters are significantly more frequent than no-hitters in Major League history.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Novelty drinks are back and I will order them every time they're on a menu

My who's back of the week is novelty drinks. Novelty drinks are back big time. If there's a novelty drink that's on the menu, I'm going to order it every single time. I'm talking like a punch bowl style thing or a margarita that's got a beer upside down in it.

A personal commitment to a lifestyle choice is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Chad Ochocinco flexing about maintaining a 2.2 GPA is hilarious

Shadow Tricinco replied, I caught the bus to school, then went to football practice, caught the bus to McDonald's for a six-hour shift, all while maintaining a 2.2 GPA and being a star athlete. Chad, I don't know if he was joking or not, but that is such a hilarious flex to be like, look how hard I worked, and I fucking rocked nothing but, like, C's.

Humor is subjective.
Win
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Zach Wilson will be drafted number two overall by the Jets

I know for a fact Zach Wilson is going number two overall to the Jets.

Zach Wilson was indeed selected #2 overall by the New York Jets in the 2021 NFL Draft.
Loss
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Kyle Shanahan wants to draft Mac Jones while the Niners personnel staff prefers Trey Lance

What I'm told is, and from people that I really trust in the league, is that the personnel department would like to take Trey Lance from North Dakota State. But Kyle Shanahan, the head coach, wants to take Mac Jones.

The 49ers drafted Trey Lance, contradicting the prediction that Shanahan would get his way for Jones, though the internal conflict remains a matter of reporting rather than public fact.
Win
Todd McShayTodd McShay

The Falcons are likely to draft Kyle Pitts at number four

I've talked to another really reliable source that thinks that they're going to take Kyle Pitts, the tight end from Florida. So it could be quarterback, quarterback, quarterback for the first three picks. And then Pitts, the tight end, could come off the board at number four to Atlanta.

The Falcons selected Kyle Pitts with the 4th overall pick.
Loss
Todd McShayTodd McShay

The Patriots are more likely to trade back than trade up in the first round

I don't think [trading up] is going to be New England based on my sources. I think New England is more likely to trade back than they are to move up.

The Patriots stayed at pick 15 and drafted Mac Jones.
Loss
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Washington, Chicago, and New England all have interest in drafting Davis Mills in the second round

I'm told Washington, Chicago, and New England all have interest in [Davis Mills] in the second round. [David Shaw] said he's the closest thing that we've had since [Andrew Luck] in terms of physical tools.

None of these teams drafted Mills; he was selected by the Houston Texans in the 3rd round.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Long-haired quarterbacks do not win Super Bowls

Are you concerned that his [Trevor Lawrence's] hair is too long because long-haired quarterbacks don't win Super Bowls? ... It's basically, I think Kenny Stabler is the only one. And he was a little shaggy. I wouldn't call it long hair.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Historically largely true for extremely long hair, though Mahomes and others have had some length. Lawrence has not won a Super Bowl yet.
Void
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Jason Oweh is the most difficult evaluation in the draft due to zero sacks

Jason Oweh from Penn State to me is one of the hardest evaluations simply because if you can't get a sack as an edge rusher, then what are we doing here? ... All butt, no sack.

Evaluations are subjective, but Oweh's NFL career has mirrored this, showing great athleticism but inconsistent sack production.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Disney 'wokeness' critic is a compelling weirdo

I actually think this guy might rule. I think he might rule. I think I might be a fan of his... the fact that he spends this much time thinking about Disney is weird, but also kind of cool because it's just cool to be that excited about anything.

This is a subjective opinion on a person's personality.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL stashed the Justin Fields epilepsy story to drop it during a slow news week before the draft

If the draft wasn't pushed back this far, we might never have found out about it... They're like, hey, the week before, let's drop the epilepsy story. We're going to stash that one away because people are going to be starved for some news.

This is an unprovable theory about PR timing.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Two quarterbacks will be drafted immediately after Mac Jones goes off the board.

I think that there's going to be, after Mac goes, I think that it's just going to be two quarterbacks immediately after him.

Mac Jones was drafted 15th. The next quarterback taken was Kyle Trask at 64th and Davis Mills at 67th. There was no run immediately after Jones.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am skeptical of Nick Sirianni because he self-leaked the rock-paper-scissors draft story.

He put the news out there that he was evaluating draft prospects by asking them to play rock, paper, scissors against them... I would have liked this story if someone else had reported it... but the fact that he put it out there, he's like, look at this cool, smart, awesome football guy thing that I did... I'm officially skeptical of Nick Sirianni at this point.

Subjective opinion on coaching style and PR tactics.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Portland State basketball coach is a 'football guy' because he takes metaphors literally

Football guys, and I know he's a basketball coach, but he is a football guy... the biggest thing with them is they take metaphors literally. They're like Amelia Bedelia. He probably when they read Animal Farm they were probably like that's a crazy story about pigs talking.

Subjective definition of a personality archetype.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Professional sports owners should be required to run their own team Twitter accounts

I actually think that every NFL owner should be the only people that tweet from the main account. Every tweet should be... there should not be communication staff. It should be directly from the brain of that owner.

This is a policy recommendation for sports leagues based on entertainment value.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mark Davis will eventually have to sell the Raiders because he won't be able to afford the inheritance tax.

And then when Mark gets the team, he's not going to have the money to pay the inheritance tax on it. Correct. And so he'll have to sell that team.

This prediction depends on future events (Carol Davis passing and subsequent tax filings). As of now, Mark Davis still owns the team.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 6-foot mark is the new 'height shaming' frontier in the NFL

This is like a very important moment in height shaming where if six feet becomes the new height that you can shame, everyone under is very fucked. So you need to like defend the wall.

Observation of cultural trends in sports media.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joel Embiid's missed full-court heave against the Suns is the best shot in NBA history.

I don't care that it didn't go in. I think that is the best shot... that's the best shot in NBA history. ... The process of that shot, I'm not going to base whether or not it was a good shot off if it went in. ... The most incredible thing I've ever seen on a basketball court.

Subjective value judgment on a missed shot.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes' diving incompletion in Super Bowl LV is the best throw ever made on a football field.

Patrick Mahomes touchdown throw that didn't count. Yeah, the best throw I've ever seen on a football field.

Subjective opinion on quarterback talent and specific play history.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Nikola Jokic is the NBA MVP.

Jokic is our MVP. I was reminded we're nuggets podcast. ... 7% credit. All I was saying was I was just throwing it out there.

Nikola Jokic was named the 2020-21 NBA MVP in June 2021.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

We are in the golden age of fans eating shit in the stands at baseball games.

I think we are in a golden age that we have to appreciate right this second with spaced out seating to just see awesome videos of people eating shit because think about it usually there's fans so you're not going to go for a ball right... Now it's just selling out.

A subjective cultural observation about viral sports videos during the pandemic era.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The sports world has forgotten about Saquon Barkley.

I think we've forgotten about Saquon Barkley. I just haven't heard his name a lot... I'm not trying to make a grand point or anything out of this. I'm just saying that I feel like as a nation we've forgotten about Saquon.

Barkley would return to prominence later, but in April 2021 he was indeed out of the news cycle due to rehab.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I will buy and wear Chris Paul's signature shoes out of spite for Blake Griffin

Maybe I'm a Chris Paul fan... I'm going to start wearing [his shoes]. All right, let's get to our interview.

Spite-based fandom that Big Cat likely won't follow through on long-term.
Win
HornswoggleHornswoggle

I am going to make people know who Jeremy Smith is for once by fighting him.

I'm going to box. I'm going to fight. I'm going to make people know who the fuck Jeremy Smith is for once. ... and I'm going to make some money.

Jeremy Dynamite Smith won the fight, but Hornswoggle's prediction about eyes on the fight was correct given the high viewership for that R&R.
Void
HornswoggleHornswoggle

WWE's X-Pac would have anyone's back in a bar fight.

I feel like X-Pac would have anyone's back in a bucket. He just wants some action, yeah. He just wants the fight, yeah.

Subjective opinion on another person's character.
Win
HankHank

You have to pick Jeremy 'Dynamite' Smith over Hornswoggle in Rough and Rowdy 14

After hearing [Hornswoggle] talk about the fight, when looking at the play Barstool, you have to pick between him or Dynamite. You got to pick Dynamite. Especially after the Ben Askren thing.

Jeremy Smith defeated Hornswoggle via unanimous decision at R&R 14.
Void
HankHank

I went 27 years and no one ever told me how to pronounce pint

I went 27 years and no one ever told me how to pronounce what you put a thing of ice cream in or a liter of beer.

He's not wrong that no one told him. His friends and family have a lot to answer for.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Hank's greatest hits: Thailand, Ob-jen, Pint, Post Mostly, Super Relatives

What are Hank's greatest hits? There's Thailand. There's Ob-jen. Pint. Post Mostly. Super Relatives.

A comprehensive catalog of destruction. Island Gorilla was nominated from the floor but didn't make the official list.
Loss
HankHank

My worst one was island gorilla — I thought it was a lowland gorilla from the island

My personal opinion, the worst one was island gorilla... Lowland gorilla. Oh yeah. You thought it was the gorilla from Des Moines? How sick would Iowa be if there were just wild gorillas rolling through the country?

It's a lowland gorilla, named for the low-altitude tropical forests where it lives. Not an island gorilla, though Iowa would be significantly improved by wild gorillas.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers