Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Christian Yelich will ruin his swing if he participates in the Home Run Derby

Real talk. It's going to mess up his swing if he competes in the home run derby... [Big Cat]: You're going to fuck up your swing. Real talk, if he says that he's going to be in the home run derby, I will put steroids in his drink.

Yelich did participate in the 2019 Derby. While he was still very good in the second half, his OPS dropped from 1.140 in the first half to 1.011 in the second half, though he still won the batting title before getting injured in September.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Max Kellerman farted on 'First Take' because he's terrified of Stephen A. Smith

I think he did fart, and I think it's because Stephen A. Smith has just been owning him with debates... Kellerman is scared of Stephen A. Smith. He is absolutely frightened by the very sight of him.

The 'fart' remained a viral mystery; Kellerman later denied it, but the social dynamics of the show were a frequent joke on PMT.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Raptors should trade Drake to break the Drake Curse

The Raptors should trade Drake. He's a big mad. I think he's upset.

Hot TakeBasketballMediumSarcastic
The Raptors did not trade Drake and actually won the NBA Championship two months later, effectively ending the Drake Curse.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I was wrong about Tiger Woods never winning another major

Hand up, I never thought I'd see Tiger back in this spot. I was definitely in the camp of he'll be in it maybe a couple times, maybe flirt with one... but he'll never win another major. I was very wrong.

Tiger won the 2019 Masters, proving the prediction that he'd never win another major incorrect.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2019 Masters was a bad weekend for the Augusta National course

I don't think I root for the course anymore. The course got embarrassed. This was a bad weekend for the course. Yeah, low scores.

The winning score was -13, which is low but not the tournament record (-18).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Orlando Magic will beat the Toronto Raptors in their playoff series

As the number one Orlando Magic podcast on the internet, we've decided that just from our four seconds of talking about the Magic on Friday, I would say that we got the Magic their win... It's not a good look for Toronto at all. They'll win this series, but it's good to have the Magic get that one.

The Raptors actually came back to win the series 4-1 after losing the first game.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jimmy Butler screwed up the 76ers' chemistry

I think Jimmy Butler came in and screwed up the whole chemistry. That's what I think. Simmons can't shoot. It's so much easier to defend in the playoffs.

While they lost to the Raptors in a heartbreaker, Butler was arguably their best playoff performer. However, he left after the season, confirming some level of friction.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Giannis Antetokounmpo is currently the best player in the NBA

Giannis is an absolute monster. He's a problem. He's a huge problem. He's the best player in the NBA at this point.

Giannis won the 2018-19 NBA MVP, validating this take for that specific point in time.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Capitals killed the Eastern Conference

Did the Washington Capitals kill the Eastern Conference? Not just the Penguins, who, by the way, they haven't won a game in the playoffs since the Caps beat them... Nor have the Tampa Bay Lightning.

The Lightning were famously swept by Columbus in 2019 despite a record-breaking regular season. The Penguins were also swept by the Islanders.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2019 Tampa Bay Lightning were scared of being embarrassed by the Capitals again

I do give credit to the Penguins and to the Lightning. It's a smart move to not want to get embarrassed by the Capitals again. So just getting the fuck out of the playoffs as early as possible.

Hot TakeHockeyHotSarcastic
The Lightning were swept by the Blue Jackets in one of the biggest upsets in NHL history; they obviously didn't lose on purpose.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Olympics should be held every year in Las Vegas since no other city wants them

They should do the Olympics every year. What the fuck? Just do it in Vegas. Because no city wants it. Just do it in Vegas every year.

The Olympics remain on a 4-year cycle and are held in various rotating cities.
Win
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Tiger Woods beating the athlete golfers he inspired (Koepka, DJ) is his most impressive feat

There's a whole wave of guys that he created, right? The guys that look like Dustin Johnson and Brooks Koepka that could be athletes in any sport... And they all kind of wanted to be him. And he beat all of them... when it's over, he wins.

Tiger did defeat Koepka and Johnson, who finished T2.
Win
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Francesco Molinari's Sunday collapse will be forgotten because Tiger Woods won

[Molinari] is the one guy that's going to walk away from this the most gutted because if he doesn't make a couple mistakes, then maybe it's him. [Big Cat: I think he's the luckiest guy... no one will remember it because it's Tiger]. SVP: I hadn't even considered that... that actually makes a ton of sense.

Molinari's collapse at 12 and 15 is indeed secondary to the legend of Tiger's 15th major in most retellings.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 'Hot in the Streets' trend is saying you want an attractive person to kill you

My hot in the streets is saying that you want an attractive person to kill you. That's like real hot on Twitter these days... just if you think somebody's exceptionally attractive, say, oh man, I want this girl to shoot me in the head. It's a nice way of saying that she's so attractive that she could do whatever she wants to.

This was indeed a common hyperbolic way of expressing attraction on 'Stan Twitter' around this era.
Win
HankHank

The Hound will defeat The Mountain in Game of Thrones

Do you think he's going to fight the mountain? Yes... Who do you think is going to win? Hound.

In S8E5, both died in a fall into fire, but the Hound achieved his goal of killing the Mountain, making this effectively correct.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Cersei Lannister is the best character on Game of Thrones

I love Cersei. I love her. One of the best lines when they're like... I choose violence. And then she blows up everyone in the city... As soon as you get to a certain point where it's like, oh, this bitch doesn't care. I fucking love her.

Purely subjective opinion on character quality.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Samwell Tarly will win the Iron Throne

I think Samwell Tarly is going to win the throne. They're going to do a 10-year show where it's like, hey, at the end of the day, nerds win.

Bran Stark won the throne; Samwell Tarly became Grand Maester.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bran Stark will win the Iron Throne

I think Bran's going to win the throne. He's not a human anymore, though. He's a three-eyed raven. He'll fucking tell everyone about it.

Bran Stark was indeed chosen as King in the series finale.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Masters Sunday is the biggest napping day of the year

Everybody watches the Masters by themselves, maybe with their dad, maybe with a roommate or something like that, but it is the one day a year where you can take part in the biggest sporting event of that sport of the year and just sit there and chill, fall asleep, take a nap. It's the biggest Seebs Day of the year.

The concept of 'golf naps' is a subjective cultural phenomenon among sports fans.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals will beat the Hurricanes in five games

I'm assuming they're [Capitals] going to win. It's Caps-Canes. Sounds like a Burlington Coat Factory, not a playoff series. I'm very confident. I'm thinking, like, Caps in five.

The Hurricanes actually upset the Capitals in seven games.
Win
HankHank

The Celtics won't make it past the second round of the NBA playoffs

The panic button is pressed. If they make it past, like, the second round, I'll be surprised. I mean, it's like you would say [Marcus Smart] is the heart and soul of the team. They are already kind on a rocky road going into it.

The Celtics lost to the Milwaukee Bucks 4-1 in the Eastern Conference Semifinals (the second round).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Warriors will win the 2019 NBA Championship

Out West, I think the Warriors are going to win the NBA title. Okay, that is a fucking take. Watch out, guys. Take warning. I fucking... Oh, man. I wish someone would beat them because that's what really kind of dampens the... well, you think someone... I mean, Houston could.

The Warriors lost to the Toronto Raptors in the Finals.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Clippers will not win a single game against the Warriors

The Clippers are going to annoy them in the first round. They're not going to win. They might not even win a game, but the Clippers are like the all-hustle team.

The Clippers surprisingly won two games against the Warriors in that series.
Win
HankHank

I'm taking the field over the Warriors to win the 2019 NBA Championship

Can I pick the field? ... whatever you guys are ready to risk, like, I'll risk it for the biscuit.

The Raptors (part of 'the field') beat the Warriors in the Finals.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin should hire Rick Pitino as their next head coach

We need to do a better job of getting Rick Pitino a job... Where else is there a head coaching vacancy? [Hank: Wisconsin]. I'd fucking take him in a second. I think that would make my life so much better if Rick Pitino was the coach. I mean, we would win the national title.

Wisconsin did not hire Rick Pitino; Greg Gard remained the coach for years after.
Void
DJ Pauly DDJ Pauly D

I am a B-plus level celebrity

What level of celebrity do you guys think you are now? [Vinny]: D minus... [DJ Pauly D]: Yeah, he's like a B. B plus. [Big Cat]: I live with that.

Fame level is inherently subjective.
Win
DJ Pauly DDJ Pauly D

Rob Gronkowski will return to the NFL if Tom Brady calls him

I'm really sad about the whole [Gronk retirement]. [Big Cat: You think he's going to keep playing?] I do. I don't know how many games, but I think if Brady calls him, I mean, how could you say no to Brady, in my opinion?

Gronk stayed retired for 2019 but returned in 2020 to join Brady on the Buccaneers.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Grizzlies' ceiling is giving a team a tough series in the second round

The Grizzlies are always going to be rebuilding. That's kind of what they're up to. I feel like the ceiling on the Grizz is giving a team a tough series in the second round.

The Grizzlies have historically struggled to advance past the second round, only reaching the WCF once in 2013.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bulls should send Bill Murray or Jim Belushi to represent them at the draft lottery

Zion. Maybe Zion... That's going to be the biggest night of the Bulls probably since Derrick Rose left. You need to figure out who the ultimate good luck charm is. Jim Belushi. Final answer. [PFT]: Or Bill Murray. [Big Cat]: Get Bill Murray to do it. Yes.

The Bulls did not send Murray or Belushi; Horace Grant represented them in 2019.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Chris Davis's hitless streak is actually fun to watch

Do you feel bad for Chris Davis, who is now 0 for 53? [PFT]: No, because it's so much fun to watch. And if the Orioles were going to be a threat to do anything this year, then maybe I would be. But he's helping them.

This is a subjective opinion on the entertainment value of a statistical outlier.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Virginia's national title run is one of the coolest stories in sports history

UVA now becomes one of the coolest stories in all of sports going from the loss to UMBC last year as a one seed to a 16 seed never happened before to then get all the way back and go to the national title and win the national championship. It's all like one story. And it all kind of erases. I feel like if they don't have that low, they don't get to this high.

Virginia did win the 2019 National Championship after losing to a 16-seed in 2018.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The best sports teams are usually the luckiest ones

To me, it seems like the best teams are always the ones that get the luckiest. You can make the case like, oh, Tom Brady shouldn't have as many Super Bowls because the interception bailed him out at the end of the Seattle game... But it turns out that if you have luck that adds up a lot, you're probably just good.

This is a philosophical observation about sports success that is inherently subjective.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Unders in the first half are a strong betting trend for games played on raised floors in football stadiums.

I've noticed that teams, when they're on that raised floor... in the first half, it seems to me like all the first half unders were hitting on any game that's ever been played on an elevated floor, like in a football [stadium].

The shooting struggles in domes are a well-documented phenomenon in college basketball, though the 'trend' of unders is hard to verify without specific historical data.
Void
HankHank

Basketball broadcasts should use the baseline rolling camera angle more frequently.

More basketball games should have the camera that they have on the baseline that rolls with the action. I only see that during the Final Four National Championship.

Inherently subjective preference on sports broadcasting aesthetics.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Texas Tech is officially a basketball school as long as Chris Beard is the coach.

I now officially consider you [Texas Tech] a basketball school as long as Chris Beard stays there.

Chris Beard eventually left for Texas, and Texas Tech has remained a competitive basketball program, though Beard was the catalyst for their peak.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Instant replay should have a shot clock to keep the game moving

We should just have a shot clock on the replays because that would be thrilling. If the ref only has a certain amount of time... if they can't find the replay fast enough, guess what? Tough shit.

This is a policy recommendation for sports broadcasting and officiating.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sports replays should be broadcast in standard definition to better reflect what the human eye sees.

The replay should be done in standard definition... Going back to standard definition makes you feel like you're intoxicated already. It's blurry as shit. That would be actually a great way to tell.

This is a satirical policy suggestion for sports officiating.
Void
HankHank

Jimmy Kimmel is no longer a 'guy's guy' because he thinks 'One Shining Moment' is bad

That's when Jimmy stopped being a guy's guy. [When he said] that one shining moment lived out its one shining moment 15 years ago... that it's not cool anymore.

The quality of a song and a person's status as a 'guy's guy' are subjective.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Magic Johnson resigned as Lakers president so he could spend more time tampering.

We all thought when he did it, we're like, oh, he is upset because he can't tamper as president. And so he wants to retire to spend more time with his tampering. He was like, I want to be a free bird. Right now I'm a caged bird and I'm not allowed to hit up Russell Westbrook and say, hey, congrats on the 2020.

Hot TakeBasketballHotSarcastic
Magic himself stated during his press conference that he wanted to be able to congratulate players and 'be Magic again,' which many interpreted as wanting to tamper without penalty.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James will eventually fire everyone in the Lakers organization, including Jeannie Buss

I think LeBron is going to fire everyone if they don't get another star. He'll go all the way up the ladder. He'll probably tell Jeannie Buss she's fired.

LeBron didn't actually fire Jeannie Buss (which he can't), but Luke Walton and Magic Johnson both left shortly after. The team eventually traded for Anthony Davis.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Steph Curry's ankle injury timing is perfect for providing an excuse if he plays poorly in the playoffs.

Steph Curry getting his yearly sprained ankle so that now when the playoffs start, we can say is Steph really 100% if he starts sucking? That was actually the perfect timing for him to roll his ankle.

Curry and the Warriors won the title in 2022 without such excuses, but the take reflects the 2019 narrative of his 'glass ankles.'
Win
HankHank

LeBron is struggling to find co-stars for Space Jam 2 because players don't want to deal with him

He's having a very hard time recruiting co-stars to join the movie... Giannis denied him said he doesn't he doesn't like being Hollywood... they're worried about if they go to the movie then they're gonna have to potentially play with him on his team.

There were numerous reports in 2019 that stars like Giannis, James Harden, and Steph Curry declined roles in Space Jam 2.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Masters deserves all the hype it gets and cannot be overhyped

You can't overhype the Masters. Take your microphone off. That's a bad take. The Masters deserve all the hype.

The level of 'hype' an event deserves is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Reed's Masters menu looks like what a 14-year-old thinks an adult dinner is.

This menu really is like what a 14 year old would think an adult's menu looks like. He basically was forced to be like well I like steak and and I don't really like anything else. I like macaroni and cheese. I'm surprised chicken fingers weren't on here.

This is a subjective opinion on Patrick Reed's culinary taste.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tiramisu is an overrated dessert

The dessert is weird. It's tiramisu. Tiramisu is overrated, by the way.

Taste in dessert is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The player who signs second between Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving will be viewed as the follower, not the leader.

Durant and Irving are debating on who will sign first. Why is that important? The player that is signed second is viewed as the follower, not the leader. Oh, my God. This league.

Durant and Irving ended up signing with the Nets together; the leader/follower narrative persisted regardless of timing.
Win
Chris LongChris Long

The double dribble by Virginia against Auburn was a clear foul that should be called 90% of the time.

I'm telling you, they missed the double dribble. I mean, that's clear. But... that play that went to the review, everybody that just two days ago was saying, we need to get every call inside two minutes right is all of a sudden anti-replay.

Broad consensus among officials and rules experts was that it was a missed double-dribble.
Void
Chris LongChris Long

Instant replay has been positive for the NFL and fans generally don't mind the pace of play issues.

I think replay has been good for football... Honestly, I don't know how we'd get through games nowadays without it. I think people mostly don't even notice that it's slowing the game down at all. I think we're mostly glad we have it.

Public opinion on NFL replay remains highly divided, making this an inherently subjective take.
Win
Chris LongChris Long

Tony Bennett has revolutionized Virginia's style of play using Wisconsin's influence

I mean, Dick Bennett, you know. Indirectly a little bit. I mean, you guys, you know, kind of revolutionized our style of play, right?

Tony Bennett explicitly credits his father's 'Pack Line' defense and coaching philosophy, which was developed at Wisconsin, for his success at Virginia.
Void
Chris LongChris Long

Being a sports fan is way harder than being a professional player

It's totally different as a fan. It's almost more nerve-wracking. You just feel so hopeless... As a fan, I am just, man, I, uh, I'm, I'm a basket case... being a fan is way harder than being a player.

The psychological difficulty of being a fan vs. a player is subjective.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers