Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jay Cutler will return to the NFL to play for the 49ers

I know some people who know some people who know some people... heard Jay Cutler is going to be back for the San Francisco 49ers... I think Jay Cutler is going to be great in the San Francisco 49ers.

Cutler never played for the 49ers or in the NFL again after 2017.
Loss
Chris JohnsonChris Johnson

Jeff Fisher will return to coaching in the NFL next year

I know he will. Actually, I talked to him... a year ago. And he said... he was going to take a year off and then he'll probably get back into coaching. So probably next year.

Jeff Fisher never held another coaching job in the NFL.
Void
Chris JohnsonChris Johnson

The NFL is definitely getting soft with the new rules

[Big Cat]: So do you land on the NFL getting soft, or do you think it's good that they're trying to protect players? [Chris Johnson]: It's definitely getting soft.

Subjective opinion on the state of the league.
Void
LW
Lendale White

USC would have beaten Texas in the Rose Bowl if they had run the ball more

I definitely feel if we would have ran the ball more, the game would have been over. [Big Cat]: What about when Reggie did the fumble?... [Lendale White]: I'm sure Chris can attest to this... I know if I was in the game, I would have caught it and scored.

This is a subjective counterfactual that can never be proven, though White averaged 6.2 yards per carry in that game.
Loss
Bartolo ColonBartolo Colon

I would like to pitch one more year in Major League Baseball

If we make it to next year, I'd like to get one more year in.

Bartolo Colon's last season in MLB was 2018.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cavaliers are going to lose a shitload of games this year

Tyronn Lue said, it's not about wins and losses. It's about wins and lessons. [Big Cat]: Translation, we're going to lose a shitload of games this year.

The Cavaliers finished the 2018-19 season with a 19-63 record.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jimmy Butler has officially been traded to the Phoenix Suns

Breaking case of emergency, Jimmy Butler trade. He just got traded to the Suns... Devin Booker, DeAndre Ayton, Jimmy Butler.

Butler was never traded to the Suns; he was traded to the Philadelphia 76ers in November 2018.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jared Goff's success is actually due to the complicated 'lessons' he learned from Jeff Fisher

If Jared Goff is this good and sucked with Jeff Fisher, does that mean that Steve McNair is actually the greatest quarterback of all time? [PFT Commenter]: No. It took a year for Coach Fisher's lessons to sink in because they were so complicated... Jeff Fisher taught Jared Goff a lot of lessons. Not losses. Lessons.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
This is a satirical take designed to troll proponents of modern coaching, as Goff's improvement was clearly linked to Sean McVay.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Animal crackers are cookies, not crackers

I think they're cookies. They're sweet. They're not savory, they're sweet... they're the worst cookie but the best cracker.

Subjective classification of a snack food.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Fitzpatrick is the most classic NFL player because you can see his magic disappearing in real-time

I love Ryan Fitzpatrick. If you don't love Ryan Fitzpatrick, you got a big old dump in your pants because he is so classic and you can tell the minute Ryan Fitzpatrick is losing his magic. It is so fun to watch the downfall. It's great to watch the rise. He will get to the highest of highs, and then he will get to the lowest of lows.

Ryan Fitzpatrick's career was famously defined by stretches of elite play followed by high-turnover slumps (e.g., 2018 with the Bucs).
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ryan Fitzpatrick is the best sliding quarterback in the NFL

I'll say this about him. I think [Ryan Fitzpatrick] is the league's best sliding quarterback. He knows exactly when to time his slides to make it just a little appetizing for the defender to throw a shoulder into his head. So sabermetrically, I'm sure he picks up more of those [penalties].

This is a subjective assessment of a quarterback's 'sliding' skill for the purpose of drawing flags.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

NFL offenses should stop blocking and let defenders hit the QB to draw 15-yard penalties

I'm actually at the point now where I think if I were a coach in the NFL, I would say to my offensive line, just treat every play like a screen and half of you don't block. And let them get to the quarterback because we'll most likely get 15 yards.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
While no team ever literally stopped blocking, the 2018 season saw a massive spike in roughing the passer calls that influenced defensive behavior.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You have to keep starting Ryan Fitzpatrick until it gets 'real ugly'

You ride Ryan Fitzpatrick until it gets real ugly. Here's why you don't [bench him]... I want him out there until he pulls like a Dan Orlovsky and does something as dumb as like sprinting out of the back of the end zone into the tunnel with a ball.

Subjective coaching philosophy, but the Bucs did start him one more game (against the Bears) where it did indeed get 'real ugly' and he was benched.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears vs. Buccaneers game is the perfect litmus test for Ryan Fitzpatrick

I honestly think that against the Bears defense is Bucs Bears on Sunday. It's the perfect Ryan Fitzpatrick litmus test. Can he still do this against a good defense? Okay, no, he can't. He's either going to fail spectacularly or the Bucs will win the game.

The Bears defense dominated. Fitzpatrick was benched at halftime after throwing zero touchdowns and one interception, while the Bears won 48-10. Big Cat was correct that he would fail spectacularly against a good defense.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A Colin Kaepernick primetime game for the 49ers would be the highest-rated game of the season

I actually think that if Colin Kaepernick started a game in prime time for the 49ers, it would be the highest-rated game of the entire season. Absolutely. And Twitter would melt down.

Kaepernick never returned to the NFL, so the ratings impact can't be verified, though the surrounding media circus suggests it would have been massive.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jay Cutler to the 49ers makes too much sense given his links to John Lynch and the Shanahans

I'm actually working on Jay Cutler to the 49ers... I've talked to someone in the 49ers building. I've talked to Jay Cutler. I'm bringing both parties to the table... He's got a link to John Lynch. He's got a link to the Shanahan family. It makes too much sense.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
The 49ers never signed Jay Cutler; they stuck with C.J. Beathard and Nick Mullens for the remainder of the 2018 season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Cubs will remain in first place 'by hook or by crook' for the rest of the season

No matter what, by the time you're listening to this, no matter what, the Cubs will still be in first place by hook or by crook.

The Cubs actually lost the division in a Game 163 tiebreaker to the Milwaukee Brewers on October 1, 2018, and then lost the Wild Card game. They did not stay in first 'no matter what.'
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Maddon gave an Urban Meyer-esque answer regarding Addison Russell's abuse allegations

That's an Urban Meyer-esque answer, basically saying my internet doesn't work and my brain doesn't work and I forgot that I should probably read about my accusations that my players committed domestic abuse. Whether it's true or not, bad answer, Joe Maddon.

The response was widely panned by media and fans for lack of transparency and leadership.
Void
Gordon HaywardGordon Hayward

Injured players secretly hope their team loses so their importance is validated

I don't think you'd be human if there wasn't a part of you that was like, I hope that we lose... it's the competitive nature in you. I know you're obviously rooting for your teammates. You want them to win, but there's a part of you that always wants to be part of the winning team.

This is a subjective psychological insight, but widely recognized as a 'real' sentiment in competitive sports.
Void
Gordon HaywardGordon Hayward

Brad Stevens is the best X's and O's coach I have ever seen

From an X's and O's standpoint, he's one of the best, if not the best I've ever seen. It's like when you watch... the Celtics games, or if you have watched old Butler games, like after timeout plays, we're getting the bucket every time.

Stevens was widely regarded as a top tactical coach during this era, though he eventually transitioned to the front office.
Void
Gordon HaywardGordon Hayward

The 2010 Duke team was the best coached team in the tournament, not the most talented

Duke was not the most talented team that we played or had the best players that we played throughout the tournament... But they were the best coached and, like, the most disciplined. They were kind of like us.

Duke had three future NBA players (Singler, Smith, Plumlee), while Butler had Hayward and Mack. Talent levels were arguably closer than tradition suggests.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Michael Rapoport suing Barstool over herpes allegations will trigger the Streisand effect

Rappaport claims Barstool engaged in a campaign to discredit and embarrass him, including accusing him of having herpes. The actor wants to make it clear in legal documents that he does not have herpes... I would tell everyone to please Google the Streisand effect and then laugh at the whole thing.

The lawsuit did indeed cement the 'herpes' joke as a permanent part of the Rapoport/Barstool lore and led to years of ridicule.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Alabama's maroon home uniforms look slow and boring

I've always thought that the Alabama maroon uniforms look kind of slow... Whenever they put on the maroons at home... They just look a little slow. They're a little dull. Just everything about Alabama is a little bit boring. It's a factory. It's industrial.

Uniform aesthetics are inherently subjective.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Arkansas was the better team despite losing 34-3 to Auburn

The 34-3 score was not indicative of how well the Razorbacks played. Special teams played dictated that score. So the better team didn't win... 34-3. Arkansas outplayed them. Except for the score.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
Losing by 31 points almost always indicates the other team was significantly better that day.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

A Jimmy Butler trade to the Heat would make them a top-four seed in the East

Jimmy Butler with the Heat, do they compete in the East? Yeah. I'd say that they're probably... Three or four seed? I'm going to go with probably the [Celtics], I'm going to go with the Raptors, the Celtics, the Heat [as the top seeds].

Jimmy Butler was traded to the Philadelphia 76ers in November 2018, not the Heat. The Heat finished as the 10th seed in 2018-19. Butler did eventually join the Heat in 2019.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Josh Allen is a better running quarterback than Cam Newton

Josh Allen, better running quarterback than Cam Newton.

While Josh Allen became one of the greatest running QBs ever, at the time of the take, Cam Newton was still the gold standard for power running at the position.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Done Chain is officially on the Houston Texans

I am going to hang the Done Chain on the Houston Texans. Done. Done. I'm done with them.

The 2018 Texans actually went on a 9-game winning streak after this and finished 11-5, winning the AFC South. This is a legendary 'cold take'.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Deshaun Watson will not have a great season due to his ACL recovery timeline

I didn't think that Deshaun Watson was going to have a great year this year because Adrian Peterson screwed it up for everybody by coming back from that ACL so quickly... It's going to be like a year and a half before he gets back to normal.

Watson actually had a very strong 2018, throwing for over 4,000 yards and 26 TDs while making the Pro Bowl.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Andrew Luck's shoulder is not fully healthy

When the Colts wanted to go Hail Mary, they brought in Jacoby Brissett. Andrew Luck's shoulder... maybe not as healthy as we think it is.

Andrew Luck admitted later he didn't have the arm strength for a 60-yard throw at that point, though he finished the season strongly before retiring the following year due to injuries.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes will win MVP and be inducted into the Hall of Fame in his rookie year

I think he's going to be the first player ever in his rookie year to win MVP and automatic induction to the Hall of Fame.

Mahomes did win MVP in 2018 (his second season, but first as a starter), but obviously didn't go to the HOF that year. He is however a lock for the future.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Andy Reid's teams always take a sharp performance dip after Halloween

We all know that Andy [Reid], he takes a sharp dip after Halloween. He goes into stage two diabetes and never comes back.

OpinionFootballMediumSarcastic
The 2018 Chiefs actually finished 12-4 and secured the #1 seed, though they lost in the AFC Championship. They went 5-3 after Halloween.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Patriots will still win the AFC East despite their slow start

The Patriots are still going to probably win the AFC East, right? ... You could probably even say they'll go to the AFC Championship.

The Patriots won the AFC East at 11-5 and went on to win the Super Bowl.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Vikings will beat the Rams on Thursday Night Football

The Vikings are going to beat the Rams up Thursday night... Because the Rams are the best team in football, we can all agree... don't take anything the week before and put it on this week.

The Rams beat the Vikings 38-31 in a high-scoring game on Thursday night.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Tiger Woods is all the way back

Tiger Woods is all the way back. He won the Tour Championship... Tiger Woods still was able to break through to anyone who's even watching football who doesn't even care about golf.

Tiger went on to win the Masters in 2019, confirming he was indeed 'back' to winning at the highest level.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Batman will definitely appear in the upcoming Joker movie

Batman will be in [the Joker movie] at some point. That's my solemn promise to you is Batman will be in there at some point.

While a young Bruce Wayne appears, Batman does not appear in the 2019 Joker movie.
Win
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

The Rams have already won the NFC West

I'm about ready to give the Rams the NFC West title right now.

The Rams finished 13-3 and won the division easily.
Win
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

Josh Gordon will not have long-range success with the Patriots

I don't think [Josh Gordon] has long-range success written over it... because he's not passionate about football... If you're not willing to do the time and the effort into it, you're just going to get cast aside.

Gordon played 11 games for the Patriots in 2018 before stepping away for mental health reasons/suspension risk, and was eventually waived in 2019. It was not a long-term solution.
Push
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

Dont'a Hightower can no longer play linebacker effectively

Hightower can't run like he used to run. And so he's really a defensive end. He can't play linebacker anymore.

While Hightower did age and slow down, he remained a starting linebacker for the Patriots' Super Bowl LIII winning team later that season.
Void
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

Derek Carr is not worth a $20 million salary

I'm not sure that [Derek] Carr's worth the $20 million when you watch him play.

This remained a debate for Carr's entire Raiders career; he never reached elite tier despite high pay.
Push
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

The 49ers are so bad defensively they could end up with the #1 overall pick in the draft

If they don't do something in San Francisco, they could easily be picking the first pick in the draft because with that defense, they haven't stopped anybody in three weeks.

The 49ers finished 4-12 and earned the #2 overall pick (Nick Bosa). The Cardinals got the #1 pick.
Void
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

Dak Prescott is not the problem in Dallas, the scheme is

I don't think [Dak Prescott sucks]... I think their scheme is so bad. I think they do nothing to help them. I think if Sean McVay went and spent two weeks in Dallas, they'd probably score 30 points a week.

The Cowboys' offense improved significantly once they changed play-callers and eventually coaches (Kellen Moore/Mike McCarthy), suggesting Lombardi was onto something regarding the scheme.
Loss
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

The 2018 Super Bowl will be Rams vs. Chiefs

I think it would be the Rams and the Chiefs, and probably the over would be at 70.

The Super Bowl was Patriots vs Rams. The Chiefs lost to the Patriots in the AFC Championship Game.
Win
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

The Miami Dolphins are pretenders despite their 3-0 start

I'm not buying Miami, even though they're 3-0.

Miami finished the 2018 season 7-9 and missed the playoffs.
Win
Mike LombardiMike Lombardi

Mitch Trubisky is not an instinctive quarterback and lacks the 'feel' for the position

When the game goes fast, I think it's hard for [Mitch Trubisky]. I think the reason he didn't play... at North Carolina is because it wasn't an instinctive position for him.

Trubisky eventually lost his starting job and is widely regarded as a draft bust, validating Lombardi's critique of his processing.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Shaq and Dwight Howard are more alike than people realize in their sensitivity

Shaq and Dwight Howard are more alike than people realize... Shaq is kind of a fucking loser like that too, where he can joke... but if you come at him, he's kind of a baby about it.

This is a subjective character assessment that can't be definitively proven but matches public observations of both players.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets are exactly what we thought they were, a 7-9 team

The Jets are exactly what we thought they were like a seven and nine team. You want to crown their asses? They're 7-9. I think that's actually a pretty realistic expectation for them.

The Jets finished the 2018 season with a 4-12 record, failing to reach the 7-9 mark.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cleveland Browns will make the playoffs

Welcome to being a winner Cleveland. I say the Cleveland Browns are going to make the playoffs.

The Browns finished 7-8-1 in 2018 and missed the playoffs.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You cannot win a championship with Jimmy Butler as your number one guy

I would not want to pay [Jimmy Butler] a max deal right now. I don't think that you can win a championship with Jimmy Butler as your one or one a guy.

Butler reached the 2020 and 2023 NBA Finals as the primary star but has not won a championship as of 2024.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Texans' season is over if they lose to the Giants

This is officially if the thing is, I'm pretty sure the Giants are terrible. And if the Texans lose to a terrible team, their season's over.

The Texans did lose to the Giants to start 0-3, but they famously won their next 9 games and finished 11-5, winning the AFC South. Thus, the take was incorrect.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Panthers are not a good football team even if they win

I actually think this is kind of a, are we sure they're a good game for the Panthers too? Because if the Panthers lose, I'm going to start asking, are we sure they're good? I don't think the Panthers are good, even if they win.

The Panthers started 6-2 but then lost seven games in a row to finish 7-9, proving Big Cat's skepticism somewhat correct.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers