Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Bill Belichick will be the next head coach of the Atlanta Falcons

Belichick's gonna go to Atlanta. ... because all you wanna do, if you're, if you're Arthur Blank, all you wanna do is win.

The Falcons hired Raheem Morris on January 25, 2024.
Loss
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Bears will be a playoff team next year no matter who is at quarterback

The Bears will be a playoff team next year, no matter who plays quarterback. ... They got good tackles. ... You have the, the weapons, the runners.

The Bears finished the 2024 regular season with a 7-10 record, missing the playoffs.
Win
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Jim Harbaugh will be the next head coach of the Chargers

I think Harbaugh to the Chargers makes all the sense. Yeah, in large part because it's the best job. You get the quarterback, you don't have to worry about the quarterback. And, and so I think that's the best scenario for him. I think he does end up going there.

The Chargers officially hired Jim Harbaugh on January 24, 2024.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I have completely converted to being a wipes person for bathroom hygiene

I buy them at stores 'cause I'm just like, I I've completely converted to a wipes person. ... You have to finish [with them].

Personal preference and habit, stated as a lifestyle change.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You got the full Joe Flacco experience — elite stretches where he can throw it a mile, then he just quits after the first quarter; that's Baldinger's cat

You got the full Joe Flacco experience because the old debate on whether or not he's elite goes back to Joe having games and stretches where he's just like, oh, this guy can throw the football a mile. And then he'll have a game like this where he just pretty much quits after the first quarter. And it's like, okay, it's not here today. I'm not elite today, but my eliteness will come back. It's Baldinger's cat — being elite and not elite at the same time.

PFT delivers the definitive Baldinger's cat take after the Browns' 45-14 wild card loss to the Texans, exemplifying the 'not elite today' side.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Texans are officially 'next up' and will be a powerhouse that the rest of the AFC has to deal with for the next decade

The Texans are next up. I think that's officially happened. We'll see how the rest of the Playoffs go for them. But the conversation is now when you talk about the AFC and it's [Joe] Burrow and it's [Josh] Allen and it's [Patrick] Mahomes, it's [Lamar Jackson], C.J. Stroud and the Texans and how good they are. This quickly is insane. ... you're gonna have to deal with the Texans.

The Texans followed up their 2023 success by winning the AFC South again in 2024 and remaining a top contender, though they haven't yet surpassed the Chiefs or Ravens.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

C.J. Stroud needs to win at least three Super Bowls or his career will be a disappointment

I think now it's our responsibility as media figures to set some unrealistic expectations. ... How many Super Bowls can he win in order for his career to not be a disappointment? ... You gotta get three or else you suck or else this or else you should have been bad from the get go. But you were so good at the start. Now you have to get three Super Bowls.

He's jokingly setting a bar that is nearly impossible for any QB to meet.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

C.J. Stroud has the best rookie season ever for a quarterback

I think the conversation might end with [Stroud] is the best rookie season in its totality in the NFL. ... led him to the Playoffs. This is, and who knows, I mean, they, they're probably, although I'm thinking back to it, like they played the Ravens, I think week one. ... and now winning a Playoff game as a rookie quarterback. I think [Stroud] might be it.

Subjective historical debate, though Stroud's 2023 season is widely considered one of the top 3-5 QB rookie seasons ever by EPA and efficiency metrics.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Dolphins lack toughness and are officially 'soft'

I know that sounds very, we're like minimizing everything. But the Dolphins do lack toughness. Yeah. ... they're soft. ... The Dolphins are are pretty much predicated on like, you gotta hit those big shots. And on Saturday night there were, there were none.

The Dolphins have struggled in cold weather and against physical teams with winning records consistently.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes is going to pass every great quarterback in history; he's already pacing to lap Montana and Favre

Patrick Mahomes has more playoff wins than any franchise. ... He has 12 playoff wins in six seasons. He's 12 and 3. It's insane. ... Brady's the only one who's come close. ... He will pass everyone. He's four away from [Joe] Montana. Like, it's crazy. He's out of this world good.

Mahomes added 3 more playoff wins and a Super Bowl title in 2024, bringing his total to 15, trailing only Brady (35) and Montana (16).
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Patrick Mahomes is the undisputed best quarterback in the NFL

The running disclaimer for Patrick Mahomes on this show is that like everything that we say... it could be prefaced by Patrick Mahomes is the best quarterback in the NFL. But, and then I say whatever I'm gonna say anyway. ... it's understood. He's the best quarterback in the NFL.

This is a widely held consensus that was reinforced by Mahomes winning his third Super Bowl MVP a month after this episode.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Jordan Love is officially a future Hall of Famer

The Packers Jordan Love is really fucking good. I've just accepted the fact that he's probably a future Hall of Famer. I'm hoping that, I'm hoping it's just one Super Bowl like the last two guys. ... Jordan Love is so calm, cool, collected everything we said for CJ's job goes for Jordan Love.

It's far too early to tell, but Love's end to 2023 was elite. We'll know in about 15-20 years.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McCarthy is done as the head coach of the Cowboys

Mike McCarthy's out. ... Busiest cat in Texas. ... I think there's gonna be a little cooling off period with Mike McCarthy. 'cause this was a, like, you just can't look. They looked so bad.

Despite the loss, the Cowboys announced two days later that McCarthy would return for the 2024 season.
Void
HankHank

Dak Prescott has the 'yips' and cannot throw the football

I have never seen in person witness someone have the yips like Dak had the yips. ... The first interception was a terrible throw. ... You could see he was telegraphing the pass. ... Dak Prescott, he had the yips. I, there was no other way to describe it. ... Dak Prescott's horrible, like literally is a quarterback that can't throw.

Dak struggled significantly in the first half of this specific game, but 'yips' as a career diagnosis is subjective and controversial given his regular season success.
Loss
HankHank

The Cowboys must get rid of Dak Prescott and hire Bill Belichick and Josh McDaniels

I think you gotta get rid of Dak. Okay. You gotta, you can't pay Dak, CD and Parsons. ... You gotta get rid of Dak. You gotta get Bill Belichick in there, clean house. Let 'em, let 'em run the show. ... Belichick and McDaniels together again.

The Cowboys retained Mike McCarthy and Dak Prescott, and Belichick did not take a coaching job in 2024.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Sean McVay is an incredible coach but simply cannot figure out clock management or late-game decision making

I also think Sean McVay, just like Sean McVay is an incredible coach. One of the best coaches in the league. He can't figure out clock management. I don't know why they punted there with one timeout. I don't know how they got one timeout going to the last four minutes of the game. But punting there made no sense to me.

Analytical models generally agreed that punting was a sub-optimal decision in that specific playoff situation.
Void
MaxMax

The Cowboys losing takes a lot of pressure off the Eagles locker room

The Cowboys losing has changed everything. It has changed everything. The entire vibe of Philadelphia. ... Nothing the Eagles can do tomorrow is worse than what the Cowboys did today. ... A lot of pressure has been taken, taken off out of that locker room. ... they're not going to say it out loud, but inside of their, inside of their head. Yes.

Subjective locker room psychology, but the Eagles proceeded to lose 32-9 the next day, suggesting the pressure wasn't relieved effectively.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Lions just won their Super Bowl by beating the Rams

The Lions just won their Super Bowl. ... Max will be all the way back in. If the Eagles had had to play the 49ers next week, Max would've been like, whatever... Now he is so close to being all the way back in.

The Lions went on to win a second playoff game and reach the NFC Championship, proving they had more left in the tank than just one 'Super Bowl' moment.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are going to smoke the Buccaneers

I think I'm gonna bet the Eagles. I don't, I'm on the Eagles. ... I just think the Bucs have beaten a lot of NFC south teams that don't know. ... I think you're gonna smoke 'em.

The Buccaneers beat the Eagles 32-9 the night after this episode aired.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jerry Reinsdorf is a 'half-ass' owner who set the Bulls Ring of Honor up to fail

Jerry Reinsdorf being the absolute worst. ... He's a fucking half-ass owner. He's bullshit. ... he knew that [Jerry Krause] was gonna get booed. ... He set it up. ... I'm not like absolving the fans, but I think that the real blame should be Jerry Reinsdorf for putting together a half-ass thing.

Subjective criticism of sports ownership, which is a common sentiment among Chicago fans.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Pete Carroll has an argument for being a top 10 football coach of all time

Pete Carroll has an argument for being a top 10 football coach of all time. He's 14th all time in NFL wins. He's got two national titles in college football. If you put it all together, Pete Carroll has an argument for being a top 10 football coach of all time.

Subjective all-time ranking.
Loss
HankHank

I would rather the Patriots hire Mike Vrabel than Jerod Mayo to replace Bill Belichick

I would rather Vrabel... He's a recurring guest, friend of the program. He's proven it. Super Bowl champion. Obviously Mayo is too, but I would rather Vrabel just [because of his] proximity to the show.

The Patriots hired Jerod Mayo on January 12, 2024, the day this episode aired, making Hank's preference obsolete.
Void
MaxMax

Bill Belichick might have wanted to leave the Patriots to find a team with a roster ready to win now.

I think that there's a chance he did wanna leave. I think that he might be at a point where he doesn't want to do a rebuilding coaching team and he wants to go to a, a place that has guys. I think that like, if the Cowboys are on the table... he may be willing to go to a give that up for a team. A team that could win now.

The true motives of Belichick and Kraft remain private, making this an unconfirmable opinion.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am no longer interested in the Commanders hiring Bill Belichick because he is now unemployed

I don't think I'm interested any longer at Bill Belichick because now that he doesn't have a team, it's like, do I really want to... he was way more attractive as a candidate when he had a job. Now it's like, oh, this unemployed guy wants to work for me... I don't want a retread like Belichick.

The Commanders did not hire Belichick; they hired Dan Quinn.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick's mystery landing spot could be the Dallas Cowboys

I have three candidates for the mystery team. The Dallas Cowboys. If Mike McCarthy loses in the first, or maybe even in the second game, if they get their ass kicked in the divisional round, I could see Jerry Jones being like, we gotta make a change, Belichick's out here.

Belichick did not join the Cowboys in the 2024 cycle; McCarthy was retained.
Void
HankHank

I still give Bill Belichick slightly more credit than Tom Brady for the Patriots' dynasty, roughly a 51 to 49 percent split.

I think it's 51-49 [Belichick over Brady]... it's not a one or the other. 2001 that was, that was Belichick. I know [Brady won a Super Bowl without him], I'm just saying it's not like... I think it's, if it's 51-49, whoever you want to call it. It's not a one or the other.

This is a purely subjective debate that can never be definitively resolved.
Void
HankHank

I will be the biggest Dallas Cowboys fan if they hire Bill Belichick

If he goes to Dallas, I'm gonna be the biggest Cowboys fan. Even bigger than I am now.

The condition (Belichick going to Dallas) never met.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Cleveland Browns will beat the Houston Texans in the Wild Card round

I think there's maybe a little, like, you might get into a point where it's like, as great as CJ Stroud's been this year, this is a different animal. And this is a different beast. And this is a team that's, that's completely different than the teams that they've been beating down the stretch.

The Texans beat the Browns 45-14.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Deshaun Watson has the highest ratio of football talent to being a bad person of any player currently in the NFL.

In today's game, I would say that Deshaun Watson has the biggest football to good guy ratio. [He is a] way better football player than human being. Insanely a large gap.

The definition of a 'good guy' is subjective, though Watson's legal history provides context for the take.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I like the over in the Browns vs. Texans game.

I kinda like the over in the game too. Good weather... I like the Browns offense. I like the Texans offense. Browns defense obviously is out of this world. But I still think CJ Stroud is gonna get his.

The final score was 45-14 (59 total points), comfortably clearing the over of 44.5.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Kansas City Chiefs will beat the Miami Dolphins because Tua Tagovailoa cannot play in the cold

I don't see Tua winning this game... the stats that you had for Tua, you can just watch Tua when he plays in the cold. He looks very uncomfortable going on the road. Arrowhead is like one of the top two or three hardest places to play... I think I'm gonna take the Chiefs.

The Chiefs beat the Dolphins 26-7 in one of the coldest games in NFL history.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Travis Kelce to score a touchdown is the Super Wild Card prop of the year

Travis Kelce scored touchdowns plus money now. And the dolphins are not great guarding the tight end. And I do think that like when you get to the playoffs, Patrick Mahomes will be like, who can I trust? Travis Kelce's the guy I can trust.

Kelce did not score a touchdown in the Wild Card game vs. Miami.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Josh Allen will have a big day running against the Pittsburgh Steelers.

I see a lot of plays where [Herbig] gets upfield because he likes to do that... they leave that little gap there on the end. And Josh [Allen] is just gonna eat that up. I think that Josh is gonna have a big day running.

Josh Allen had 8 carries for 74 yards and a touchdown, including a spectacular 52-yard scoring run.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Pittsburgh Steelers will beat the Buffalo Bills outright

I like the Steelers moneyline... You hate all our friends. You hate our futures. It's gotta be a dog that wins.

The Bills beat the Steelers 31-17.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills are very dangerous to go to the Super Bowl because they finally have a legitimate running game.

I do think the Bills are very dangerous to go to the Super Bowl... I'm bullish about the Bills because if you look back at last year and that Bengals game and that playoff game and they got bullied, absolutely bullied. The Bills now do have a legitimate running game... They have James Cook who's been awesome. Josh Allen is a part of the running game and Leonard Fournette can be a bully in cold weather.

The Bills were eliminated in the Divisional Round by the Chiefs, failing to reach the Super Bowl.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Nuclear missile whale play on the Packers vs. Cowboys over

I think I might make this a nuclear missile whale play on the over... I don't know how the Packers are gonna stop the Cowboys. And I also don't really know how the Cowboys are gonna stop the Packers 'cause Jordan Love's been that good... I like this over a lot. 50 and a half.

The final score was 48-32 (80 points), easily clearing the 50.5 line.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am switching my pick to the Detroit Lions over the Los Angeles Rams

I said Rams all week... and I've switched... I'm betting the Lions. I'm gonna take the Lions just because I don't want to make blood money off the Rams winning... I think the Lions are better.

The Lions beat the Rams 24-23.
Void
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

NIL is the primary reason Nick Saban decided to retire.

I think that the NIL stuff would be number one outta that bunch. [The NIL part] was something that bothered him... Texas is coming into the SEC Oklahoma's coming into the SEC, they gotta deal with LSU. Tennessee's very well funded. Like you can't make more rich people in Alabama... You're not gonna have as many people as they care deeply about Texas and Texas A&M football 'cause they just have more people.

While Saban hinted at these frustrations in later interviews, the exact primary reason for his retirement remains a mix of factors including age and family.
Void
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

The Alabama job is still a top three job but harder than Georgia and Ohio State

I still think [Georgia's] the best job. I think it's easier to recruit to Georgia... Ohio State's probably a better job because the way you dominate that state... Alabama is a little bit harder than those jobs. And Nick Saban made it look easy.

Subjective ranking of jobs.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Mike Norvell is my guess for the next Alabama head coach

I'm going to say Mike Norvell. That is going to be my guess. He's been recruiting in this area... Florida State has to recruit against Alabama, Auburn...

The Alabama job was ultimately taken by Washington's Kalen DeBoer.
Open
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

The next Alabama head coach will be expected to win a National Title within three years.

Your job at Alabama is to win the national title every year... The Alabama fan base will not be patient. But I think the administration given like if, if the the person is making reasonable progress toward national titles... the administration's probably gonna be fine with that. But the fan base will be raising holy hell if they're not winning national titles in three years.

Kalen DeBoer was hired; we will see if he wins a title by the end of the 2026-27 season.
Win
Aaron SchatzAaron Schatz

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are slightly favored over the Philadelphia Eagles in Wild Card Weekend

The biggest one for me is Philadelphia and Tampa Bay. I actually, in my projections, I have Tampa Bay very, very slightly favored... If you look at the weighted numbers that give more weight to recent games, Tampa Bay is 15th, Philadelphia is 21st.

The Buccaneers beat the Eagles 32-9.
Win
Aaron SchatzAaron Schatz

The Rams' historically bad special teams will likely cost them a game at some point in the playoffs.

The worst [special teams unit] by far by far was the Rams. Yeah. The Rams were the sixth worst special teams unit in DVOA history... Their special teams like it almost cost them against the Giants. It absolutely cost them the game against the Ravens. Punt return and touchdown in overtime. Their special teams are terrible... I would say it's likely that that will happen at some point along the way.

The Rams lost to the Lions by 1 point in the Wild Card round; while not a single special teams play decided it, they did miss a field goal in a one-point game.
Win
Aaron SchatzAaron Schatz

Josh Allen is elite despite the interceptions because he has the lowest sack rate in the league and often throws 'punted' interceptions.

The interceptions that Allen throws are for the most part not as bad because they tend to be downfield or on fourth down. And we don't talk about the fact that he had the lowest sack rate of any quarterback this year. Right. Those are negative plays too. And he doesn't take a lot of sacks. So like he was in quarterback value, I think we had him third this year... Allen does so much more of it on his own.

Schatz's DVOA metrics confirm Allen's efficiency, and Allen famously took zero sacks in his two 2024 playoff games.
Loss
Aaron SchatzAaron Schatz

Buffalo and Dallas are the two best teams in the NFL outside of San Francisco and Baltimore

The number two teams in each conference are pretty clearly Buffalo and Dallas. Not just the number two seeds, but the number two teams by both DVOA and weighted towards the end of the season. If somebody's gonna win this thing other than San Francisco or Baltimore, it's probably going to be Buffalo or Dallas.

Dallas lost in the Wild Card round; Buffalo lost in the Divisional round. Neither made the Super Bowl.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan was the best team in college football this year by a large margin

Washington fans, as much as it sucks right now, I just wanna say this, Michigan was always gonna win that game. That is what Michigan does... I really truly believe Michigan was the best team by a large margin in college football this year.

Michigan finished 15-0 and won the championship, validating their claim as the best team.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

JJ McCarthy should stay at Michigan for another season instead of entering the NFL Draft

JJ McCarthy, there's some JJ McCarthy haters out there... he's not like gonna electrify you with his throws, but he is one of those guys that just makes the big plays when they have to be made... I think he probably should stay another year.

McCarthy declared for the draft and was selected 10th overall by the Vikings, suggesting he was ready for the next level.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm out on Boeing airplanes until the safety issues are addressed

Boeing airplanes... had an explosive decompressor at 16,000 feet... So if it's, I don't know what kind of flights we have planned soon. But if it's Boeing, I ain't going. I'm out. I'm out on Boeing anytime soon.

Safety concerns regarding Boeing 737 Max 9 aircraft led to temporary groundings, justifying the concern.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

College football is ultimately about who is the best at cheating

I also think this proves that cheaters win, like in the, in the long term, everybody cheats. All right. This is not just Michigan. Every school, every major school in the country, they cheat in certain ways... college football is about who is the best at cheating. And Michigan was really fucking good at cheating.

The take is subjective and satirical in nature regarding the culture of college athletics.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Vacating a national title is the dumbest thing in sports

The vacated national title is the dumbest thing in sports. You have to take down the banner. Yeah. It's like, who cares? Every fan lived it. Every [Rick] Pitino's got a tattoo. Who cares?

This is a subjective opinion on sports governance.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers