Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Trey Lance should try to play for Andy Reid in Kansas City to save his career

Trey Lance should step away and then try to find a way to wind up in Kansas City and play for Andy Reid and then become great.

Lance was traded to the Cowboys shortly after this episode, not the Chiefs, and remained a backup.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trey Lance should step away from football for a little bit

[Trey Lance] should step away. Trey Lance for a little bit.

This was a reactionary suggestion following the news of Sam Darnold being named backup over Lance.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If the Eagles trade for Jonathan Taylor, they will easily win the Super Bowl

If the Eagles get Jonathan Taylor on top of everything that they have already. Easy Super Bowl. Yeah. Easy. Not a doubt in my mind.

The trade never happened; Jonathan Taylor remained with the Colts, and the Eagles did not win the Super Bowl.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I bet $10,000 on the Jets to win the Super Bowl because a ghost told me to

I placed $10,000 on the Jets to win the Super Bowl because the ghost told me to.

The Jets did not win the Super Bowl and finished with a losing record of 7-10.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Garrett Wilson will have 2,000 receiving yards in 2023

Garrett Wilson. 2,000 yards this year. Easy. 2,000. Easy.

Garrett Wilson finished the season with 1,042 receiving yards, well short of the 2,000 mark.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Shannon Sharpe joining ESPN is a move to get back at Skip Bayless

Shannon Sharpe is going with Stephen A. Smith to ESPN. This just proves what we all knew that he hated Skip Bayless. This is a move that's not just for Shannon Sharpe, it's to get back at Skip. It's like getting with your buddy's ex-girlfriend.

While Shannon has confirmed friction with Skip, the 'primary motivation' remains an interpretation of the move.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Penn State is a legitimate national title contender in 2023

Penn State is loaded with freaky talent this year. Like they could really be a Big 10 title contender. And if you're a Big 10 title contender, it means you could actually be a national title contender.

Penn State lost to Michigan and Ohio State, failing to qualify for the Big Ten Championship or the CFP.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Alabama will have a throwback season relying on defense and the running game

Doesn't it feel like Nick Saban has the defense is gonna be very good. The offense line's gonna be very good. They're gonna run the ball down your throat. It might be a throwback Alabama type of year. Is this gonna be like a throwback Nick Saban... they're gonna zag now when everyone zigs with the spread it out.

Alabama leaned heavily on their defense and Jalen Milroe's rushing ability to win the SEC and reach the CFP.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Texas will fail to win 10 games and miss out on a Big 12 title

Texas is gonna be favored to win the Big 12... But I've seen too many times. I need to see them win these games before I can believe. And so like, the total is nine and a half. I picked the under and everybody went nuts.

Texas finished the regular season 11-1 and won the Big 12 title, finishing with 12 total wins before the CFP.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Kentucky is a dark horse to surprise the SEC in 2023

Kentucky seems to have fixed a lot of the things that caused problems last year... They've got Devin Leary now... They could be quite a bit better. That's one that if you're Tennessee, if you're Florida, if you're South Carolina, you're worried about them right being considerably better than they were last year.

Kentucky finished 7-6, which was actually the same record they had the previous year. They did not significantly 'surprise' the conference.
Win
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Michigan is the best-positioned team to win the national championship in 2023

Michigan, this is the best chance Michigan has to win a national championship. It feels like this is the culmination of everything Harbaugh's built.

Michigan went undefeated and won the National Championship.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Michigan could have 20 players drafted off their 2023 roster

Jim Harbaugh told my friend Bruce Feldman, he thinks 20 guys are gonna get drafted off this roster... Jim Naggie from the Senior Bowl said he thinks there's seven offensive linemen who are draft eligible... who he thinks will be in NFL camps next year. Dudes that aren't even gonna start. And that is a lot of talent.

Michigan set a program record with 13 players drafted in 2024, but fell well short of the claimed 20.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Jim Harbaugh will coach every game this season despite the NCAA investigation

He'll coach all the games this year because basically... they wouldn't even have the hearing probably till after the season. You wouldn't find out the results of that till months after that. So Jim Harbaugh, you know, he may be the NFL by that point.

Harbaugh was suspended for the first three games (self-imposed) and the final three regular-season games (by the Big Ten).
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dabo Swinney is on the hot seat because of the NIL era

I would say yes. Hot seat for Dabo, by the way. Because in his own words, he said he would quit coaching college football if the players got paid. He put himself on the hot seat.

'Hot seat' is a subjective term regarding job security or pressure.
Push
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

College Football Playoff prediction: Georgia, Michigan, Oregon, and Alabama

I'm gonna go Georgia, Michigan. I'm gonna go Oregon. I'm gonna say Oregon wins the Pac-12. First Pac-12 playoff participant since 2016. And then Alabama.

Staples correctly predicted Michigan and Alabama, but Georgia and Oregon failed to make the Playoff.
Win
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Notre Dame will cover -20.5 against Navy in Ireland

I kind of like Notre Dame to cover against Navy. And I realize it's 20 and a half. But I, I'm, I'm excited to see Sam Hartman in that Notre Dame offense.

Notre Dame defeated Navy 42-3, easily covering the 20.5-point spread.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Donald Trump's 2016 Republican debate performance is a first-ballot Hall of Fame ass-kicking

The one that we, no one's gonna pick, but I do actually think it is a 1-1. It is Trump and the Republican debates. Trump versus all the other Republicans. He just fucking smoked him. He ended all their careers. Ted Cruz, your wife's ugly. Marco Rubio's got a small penis. He just great school bullied them all. It was a total ass kicking.

The take is subjective, but Trump did win the nomination after those debates.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Washington Commanders' win over the Ravens was the biggest win in preseason history

The Washington Commanders have had the biggest win in Preseason history. We did it... some people were being haters saying like, oh, that you guys are acting like you won the Super Bowl... This was not just a Preseason game for the Commanders. This was a release.

The Commanders did end the Ravens' 24-game preseason winning streak on August 21, 2023.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You don't become a billionaire without being at least a little bit weird

It was a cringey weird moment by a billionaire who I believe that all billionaires are weird. That you don't get to a billionaire without being a little weird.

This is a subjective psychological assessment of a financial class.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers is actually trolling Zach Wilson by being overly polite to him

I think Aaron [Rodgers] was being sarcastic when he said that [he'd turn it over to Zach for 20 years]. I think he was laying the praise on a little bit thick and having a big joke on everybody... Zach will not know that I'm making fun of him because I'm being so obviously over the top.

This is an interpretation of Rodgers' internal motivations and cannot be verified.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Jalen Hurts, Trevor Lawrence, and Justin Herbert are the actual top 5 QBs in the NFL

We should start taking PA—top five quarterbacks in the league right now. Sam Howell, Josh Allen—Sam Howell, no. Josh Allen. Josh Allen, Joe Burrow. Joe Burrow, Jalen Hurts, Trevor Lawrence, Justin Herbert, Justin Herbert. That's our five.

QB rankings are inherently subjective.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Drinking is a bigger cause of fan misbehavior at sports than gambling

What do you think is a bigger culprit for people screaming out at inappropriate times or yelling inappropriate things? Would you say it is gambling or would you say it is drinking? Because it's probably drinking.

While difficult to prove definitively, crime and public disturbance statistics generally correlate more heavily with alcohol than gambling.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Taylor Swift is either a cult leader or a terrorist

Is Taylor Swift kind of a terrorist? She might be kind of a terrorist. It feels like she's got, I'll tell you what, She is either a cult leader or a terrorist and she's very good at doing both. Whichever one it is. So anything that she does, I'm on her side.

This is a satirical characterization of a pop star's influence.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Baker Mayfield will win NFL Comeback Player of the Year

I put a little future on Baker [Mayfield] Win Comeback Player of the year. And I, for whatever reason, I just think that I, maybe it's that game that he had on, was it Christmas? Yeah. The Christmas game sold me.

Joe Flacco won the 2023 NFL Comeback Player of the Year. Mayfield was a finalist and had a great season, but did not win the award.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jim Harbaugh's self-imposed three-game suspension is a genius move to avoid missing the Texas game in 2024

Jim Harbaugh, Michigan self-imposed a three game suspension on him. Genius. Genius Moves. So he misses all the out of conference games... Michigan was like, okay, tell you what, you pressed our hand. We'll go as far as three games. Well, I mean it would, I would guess... they're playing like no one. It's at all the, at a conference stuff.

Harbaugh missed games against East Carolina, UNLV, and Bowling Green, allowing him to return for Big Ten play.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Miley Cyrus will perform the sexiest Super Bowl halftime show ever in Las Vegas

Miley's back, she's gonna play at the Super Bowl probably in Allegiant Stadium, which is the sexiest stadium in the world. It's gonna be the most boner inducing halftime show of all time. We can only hope and pray that Justin Timberlake gets out there and there's another Janet Jackson scenario.

Usher performed the Super Bowl LVIII halftime show in Las Vegas. Miley Cyrus did not perform.
Win
Tony SchefflerTony Scheffler

Breeding Maine Coon cats is a $4,000-per-kitten business

We got this new cat. They call it a Maine coon. ... We're looking to breed. ... [The market is] 3,500, 4 grand a piece. ... 10 years outta the league, it's time to move on and make some money.

Maine Coon kittens from reputable breeders in the US typically cost between $1,500 and $4,000, making his estimate accurate for high-end breeding.
Win
Tony SchefflerTony Scheffler

Josh McDaniels is a terrible head coach who won't be successful

Not a fan. ... He implemented the Patriot Way though... Overnight you've got 'do your job' written on every wall... It was just kind of awkward from the start.

McDaniels was fired from the Raiders in October 2023, just months after this take, finishing with a career 20-33 record as a head coach.
Void
Tony SchefflerTony Scheffler

All NFL kickers are dorks, with the exception of Matt Prater

[Kickers are] dorks. Huge dorks. [Matt Prater] is not a dork. Matt Prater is a dude.

Positional dorkiness is purely subjective.
Win
Brandon BeaneBrandon Beane

Christian McCaffrey's versatility makes him worth a high running back salary

I think the backs that bring that true three down versatility that you're gonna use him as much throwing in the ball as you are hand, those are the guys that are gonna get paid... you look at what Christian [McCaffrey] can do, he's a dual weapon. You can line him up in the backfield, you can split him out. He's a return. He just brings so many different elements.

McCaffrey went on to win 2023 Offensive Player of the Year, justifying his elite status and contract.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kanye West's 'College Trilogy' is the best pound-for-pound album trilogy in history

To separate the art from the artist Right. And understand that these are maybe the three like pound for pound best albums out there... It is Kanye West College Dropout Late Registration. Graduation. They call it the College trilogy.

Subjective opinion on music rankings.
Void
HankHank

The Godfather Part III is so bad that it ruins the whole movie trilogy

Godfather three... one and two are so good... The Tri literally just say the Godfather of three doesn't exist. It like they try to make it so it's not a trilogy... The trilogy then sinks the whole trilogy within itself. That's not, that is incorrect.

Subjective opinion on film series quality.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 2017 Barstool Van Talk cancellation was caused by a bad omen involving a dead squirrel

He said that when we were there, a hawk came and picked up a squirrel and after we left the hawk dropped the dead squirrel on the bench we were sitting on. And his wife said, whatever those guys were talking about, it's not gonna work out. ... That's a bad omen. Really bad.

Supernatural omens cannot be verified.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers are my surprise team for the 2023 season

Kenny Pickett. Yes. Two touchdown drives. Diced them up. Diced him up. ... Steelers Look ready to go. Steelers are my surprise team. Yeah. No one's talking about the Steelers. We are.

The Steelers finished 10-7 and made the playoffs as a Wild Card, but they weren't a major 'surprise' contender in the AFC.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Trey Lance sucks and doesn't know how to play football

Trey Lance sucks. Yeah. Well that's, doesn't even know how to play football. ... The one clip of him throwing, just standing there with no pressure while guys were open, feeling pressure that wasn't there, and then mis-throwing it. That was a bad look.

Lance was traded to the Cowboys and remained a backup; his career trajectory currently supports the 'not an NFL-caliber starter' view.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Bijan Robinson is already the best running back of all time

My other one is Bijan Robinson is the best running back of all time. That was a great, great performance by him. That's, he's a clip monster. Everyone's like, look at this. It's just Bijan finding [room].

Bijan had a very good rookie season, but is obviously not the literal greatest running back of all time.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

If Aaron Rodgers makes Zach Wilson a 15-year starter, he is the greatest quarterback of all time

I'll say this right now. If Aaron Rodgers makes Zach Wilson a 15-year starter in the NFL, he is the greatest quarterback of all time. Like, that would be, that is way more impressive than winning a Super Bowl, any MVP, to make Zach Wilson a 15-year starter, that would be the greatest quarterback of all time.

This is a conditional hypothetical about the future career of Zach Wilson and the legacy of Aaron Rodgers.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lionel Messi is the best soccer player ever and the MLS might be rigged for him

Messy, he's a goat. We all know he's a goat and he just keeps proving that he's... Some people are saying MLS is rigged that they brought Messi over and they're letting him score all these goals because there's no way that the professional league can be that bad where [Messi] just steps in and dominates.

Messi is widely considered the GOAT (subjective), but the claim that the league is 'rigged' is a satirical conspiracy theory that cannot be proven.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Yankees should extend both Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman

I think they should extend Aaron Boone. Yeah. I think he's the steady hand and Cashman. I think Aaron Boone is a steady hand that the Yankees need to control their franchise. ... We official vote of confidence as they should extend both of them. Yes.

Hot TakeBaseballFireSarcastic
Cashman remains employed and Boone's contract was eventually extended through 2024 (with a 2025 option), so technically PFT's mock-wish came true.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Signing Aaron Judge to a mega-deal was a mistake

Build around Aaron Judge. ... I don't know if you wanna build around Aaron Judge. He's like 32 isn't he? They just signed him to a mega deal. I know that was a mistake. ... He's gonna be 32 before next season. Okay. Whew. And he's got like 14 years left on his contract.

Judge won the 2024 AL MVP and had an all-time great season, making the 'mistake' label look very early.
Win
Daryl "Moose" JohnstonDaryl "Moose" Johnston

Charles Haley was the final piece that shifted the NFC power from San Francisco to Dallas

That was the final missing piece to those teams. And it shifted the power in the N F C from San Francisco to Dallas for a number of years once we got Charles.

The Cowboys won 3 Super Bowls shortly after acquiring Haley from their chief rival, the 49ers.
Loss
Daryl "Moose" JohnstonDaryl "Moose" Johnston

The New York Jets are legitimately a quarterback away from being a contender

Obviously everybody's looking at the Jets. ... It's hard to say that a team is one player away, but I tell you what, you watch the Jets last year, they had a great defense. ... They legitimately are like a quarterback away. I mean, that was the thing that held them back last year. And, how much does Aaron Rodgers elevate that team?

Rodgers got injured 4 plays in, and the 2023 Jets finished 7-10, suggesting they were more than 'one player' away given their O-line issues and coaching.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Lions and Dan Campbell have successfully built a culture of grit and trenches-first football

I definitely think that there's a culture that you create that starts to represent how you play on the field. And that's what Dan [Campbell] has done. And the reason I like Dan Campbell is... Dan sees it the same way I do from the inside out. You know, you gotta be able to run the football. Well, you gotta focus on the offensive line, you gotta control everything there.

The Lions did indeed build this culture, leading to a successful 2023 season where they won the division and reached the NFC Championship.
Win
Daryl "Moose" JohnstonDaryl "Moose" Johnston

The Patriots will struggle to keep up in the increasingly difficult AFC East

I just think that that's a tough division, you know, with the Jets potentially being who they are, what Mike McDaniel did with the Dolphins and how good he made them. And then you still got Buffalo. So, you know, for a number of years the Patriots were able to feast on a very, very weak division. And now they've got a very, very challenging division.

The Patriots finished last in the AFC East with a 4-13 record.
Void
Greg MadduxGreg Maddux

The MLB pitch clock is more of a hitter's clock than a pitcher's clock

I kind of think it's more of a hitter's clock personally. It speeds them up. You know, it seemed like we were always waiting on the hitter. You know, they had their walkup song and they were stepping out and calling timeout all the time. So I think as a pitcher, for me personally, it'd be great because I think it speeds the hitter up and kind of keeps the game moving.

Subjective analysis from a legend, though statistical data from the 2023 season showed pitchers generally adjusted faster than hitters.
Win
Greg MadduxGreg Maddux

My sleeper pick to win the World Series is the Texas Rangers

My sleeper this year is Texas. You know, I'm staying with, I'm, I think I'd love the odds on Texas this year, you know, if I had money to bet, I'd go down and at least make sure I put something on them.

The Texas Rangers won the 2023 World Series.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I bet Hank $20,000 that the Patriots won't make a Super Bowl in the next five years

Hank and I have a five year Super Bowl bet. If the Patriots don't get back to the Super Bowl in the next five years... If they do get there in the next five years, I owe Hank $50,000. If they don't, he owes me 20 grand.

Pending. The Patriots have not made the Super Bowl since the bet was made in 2023.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA should adopt tackle rules and change point scoring to mimic the NFL

The NBA needs to learn a lot about sports from the NFL namely like allow tackling and that sort of thing... make your goals worth three points. Make penalty kicks worth two. Boom. It's very easy to do. And you get the illusion of higher scoring.

The NBA did not adopt tackling or three-point goals in place of field goals.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

College football message boards are where you find the actual truth about sports and life in America

Going to college football message boards is where you get the actual truth about sports and really life in America. I love SEC message boards. They're the best. Tiger Droppings, Hagville. Just feed it, inject it directly into my veins.

Push
Big CatBig Cat

Jameson Williams might be cursed

Jameson Williams might be cursed because if you remember, he's already out for six games for gambling and now he's out [for the preseason]... he missed most of last year. They were using the preseason to try to get him reps... Now he's out again. He might be cursed.

Williams had a rough start but eventually became a key contributor to a successful Lions team in late 2023 and 2024.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers