Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Justin Fields will be the Jalen Hurts of the 2023 season

We're then gonna reach for in round three... for Justin Fields. I have a feeling he's gonna be the Jalen Hurts of this season. We have to ensure that we get him.

Justin Fields did not have a breakout season; the Bears struggled, and he was eventually traded to the Steelers after the season.
Loss
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Jonathan Taylor will not play at all this season

I would not [draft Jonathan Taylor]. I don't think he's gonna play this season at all. I don't think he's gonna play.

Taylor did play in 2023, appearing in 10 games for the Colts after returning from the PUP list.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am very high on Todd Monkin as the Ravens' offensive coordinator

I'm high on the OC for the Ravens, Todd Monkin. He's, I think they're gonna have a very good year.

The Ravens offense flourished under Monkin in 2023, with Lamar Jackson winning MVP and the team securing the #1 seed.
Win
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Michael Pittman is an under-the-radar wide receiver one

Michael Pittman. We think he's gonna have a good season. He's a, he's under the radar wide receiver one. And I think Anthony Richardson's a good quarterback.

Pittman finished as WR13 in PPR, effectively performing as a low-end WR1/high-end WR2.
Push
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Tony Pollard will have an incredible year and is worth a second-round pick

Tony Pollard is gonna have an incredible year. He, he might be round two for us if he's up there... I will take Tony Pollard over Joe Mixon.

Pollard had over 1,000 yards but was widely considered a fantasy disappointment relative to his high ADP, finishing as RB14.
Loss
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Darren Waller will be right up there with Travis Kelce for tight end production

We are going to take Darren Waller. We're reaching in the fourth round. We're taking him... I think he's gonna be right up there with Kelce.

Waller had a disappointing season with the Giants due to injuries and poor team performance, finishing with only 552 yards and 1 TD.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sam Howell will have the most average quarterback season of all time

I want the haters to know Sam Howell is gonna have like, the most average season of all time. Perfectly average. And that means that we're gonna make the playoffs.

Howell was benched late in the season, led the league in interceptions and sacks taken, and the team went 4-13.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Chase Claypool is a great late-round flyer in fantasy

Chase Claypool. I actually think that he could... he's playing for money. He slots in better now that DJ Moore's there. Just a flyer [in the 13th or 14th round].

Claypool was a disaster for the Bears, played poorly, was inactive for multiple games, and eventually traded to the Dolphins mid-season.
Loss
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

I'm not drafting any Packers players this year

Green Bay. No one. [Big Cat: Nice. Okay, good, good, good, good.]

Several Packers became high-value assets (Jordan Love, Jayden Reed) as they made a playoff run, making a total fade incorrect.
Loss
Jerry O'ConnellJerry O'Connell

Brock Purdy is going to have a bad season and we'll see why he was Mr. Irrelevant

Brock Purdy ain't gonna cut it... I think we're gonna find out why he's called Mr. Irrelevant. I think he's gonna have a bad season.

Brock Purdy was a Pro Bowler and MVP finalist in 2023, leading the 49ers to the Super Bowl.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I will bet on the Dolphins every week if they trade for Jonathan Taylor

I will say this right now, if Jonathan Taylor goes to the Dolphins, it will be very hard for me not to bet on the Dolphins every week. Because in a [Dolphins offense], they would probably be leading the league.

The trade never happened; Taylor remained with the Colts, so this scenario was never tested.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Thomas is a killer in international play and belongs on the Ryder Cup team

Justin Thomas is a killer in international play. That's a fact. ... Justin Thomas 16 and 5 [in international play]. ... How do you say no to that? Hank? That's a resume pick. ... He's a fucking killer when he plays an international play.

Thomas made the team but struggled at Marco Simone, going 1-2-1 as the US lost the Ryder Cup.
Win
HankHank

Selecting Justin Thomas for the Ryder Cup is a risky pick given his current form

He's not playing good golf right now. ... I just feel bad for, you know, Keegan and the guys. ... It's a risky pick in my opinion. ... Imagine if he performs badly. The final day is 12 singles matches. If he performs badly, everyone would be like, why would you pick a person who didn't even make the FedEx Cup playoffs?

Thomas's poor form continued into the Ryder Cup, where he had a losing record and the US lost.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 'World Champion' debate is dumb because all the world's best players are in the NBA

This is the dumbest debate ever, especially when you consider all the best players in the world playing the NBA. ... This is one of those cases where a guy's trying to say something deep and then he says it... and when it comes out of his mouth, he's like, yeah, take that guys.

Subjective debate regarding the prestige and terminology of professional sports championships.
Loss
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Georgia's schedule is so easy they are a lock for the CFP and a likely three-peat

Georgia's obviously won the last two national titles. They're probably gonna win a third. ... when I look at Georgia's schedule, there is absolutely no way in hell they are not making the playoffs.

Georgia lost to Alabama in the SEC Championship and was left out of the 4-team College Football Playoff.
Loss
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

LSU is better than Alabama and will win the SEC West

I really, I, I'm not gonna say that the Alabama dynasty is dead, but I feel like it's dying. ... I look at LSU... I just look at that division and I think LSU is better than Alabama this year and they're more likely to win the west.

Alabama defeated LSU 42-28 and won the SEC West title in 2023.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Arizona Cardinals are in full tank mode for Caleb Williams

That team is clearly trying to get the first pick. They want Caleb Williams more than anything... That team is in tank mode. I just watched the Bears do it last year. So I know the move.

The Cardinals finished 4-13, a poor record, but they did not secure the #1 pick (which went to the Bears via Carolina) and did not draft Caleb Williams.
Loss
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Penn State has its best chance to win the Big 10 in a long time thanks to Drew Allar

I do think this is [Penn State's] best chance to win the Big 10 in a long time. ... Drew Allar is... the first guy really [since McSorley] who has that kind of attitude, but he's also really fucking good. So I think that could give them a step up.

Penn State finished 10-3 but again lost to both Michigan and Ohio State, failing to make the Big 10 Championship or the Playoff.
Push
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Iowa will score 31 points per game and win the Big 10 West

I'm on record. They're gonna score 31 points per game and I think they're gonna win the west. I think they are the best team. They're the one I have the fewest questions about.

Iowa won the Big 10 West but averaged only 15.4 points per game, the second-worst in the FBS.
Open
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

The Sun Belt will be the best G5 conference within the next 10 years

I think the Sun Belt's gonna be the best G5 conference within the next 10 years because... there's just a buy-in from all the schools about wanting their football programs to be good. ... I think long-term Sun Belt's gonna be the best G5 leader.

This is a 10-year outlook. While the Sun Belt is currently strong, its status as the definitive 'best' G5 conference is still pending.
Win
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Texas is the most underrated team in the country and will beat Alabama in Week 2

I was asked for the most underrated team in the country and I chose Texas. ... I really do think this year's Longhorns team is going to be very good. ... I think Texas, if there is an elite team in that conference [Big 12] this year, it is Texas. ... Texas is gonna win that game [against Alabama].

Texas defeated Alabama 34-24 in Week 2 of the 2023 season and won the Big 12.
Loss
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Caleb Williams will win back-to-back Heisman trophies

Caleb Williams is the real fucking deal. ... It's why I think he's the best player in college. It's why I think he'll be the first pick in the draft and it's why I think he's gonna be the first guy to win the Heisman at consecutive years since Archie Griffin.

Jayden Daniels won the 2023 Heisman Trophy; Caleb Williams did not finish in the top three.
Loss
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Texas Tech -14 against Wyoming is a Game of the Year lock

Texas Tech minus 14 against Wyoming... I went full I mean go as many as you're comfortable going, but it's Game of the Year Territory for me. I have Texas Tech minus 14. I also have Texas Tech alternate lines at minus 20. So that's, I'm feeling pretty good about this one.

Texas Tech lost to Wyoming 35-33 in 2OT, failing to cover -14 and losing the game outright.
Win
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Mississippi State will be the worst team in the SEC this season

I'm gonna go Mississippi State because... their coach died. And it's not something you can really game plan for. ... Zach Arnett... is completely overhauling the offense. ... I think Mississippi State has a chance to have a pretty bad year. But I would say it's either them or Vandy.

Mississippi State finished 1-7 in the SEC, which was tied for last in the conference with Vanderbilt and Arkansas.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am willing a Tom Brady return to the Patriots into existence

If I'm gonna put it on my Florio hat real quick here... I will Tom Brady back to the Patriots. ... Tom Brady has been linked to conversations coming back to New England Patriots this year per us.

Tom Brady did not return to the Patriots in 2023.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Garrett is a total buzzkill on the broadcast

There's no better way to kill your football buzz than having Jason Garrett call the game... I know it was week zero. I know there's only like seven games. They all, they all mean something to me. And then Jason Garrett was on there and I immediately fell in a nap in the second quarter.

Subjective opinion on broadcast quality.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Pac-12 is dying because people can't watch stars like Caleb Williams play on their network

The returning Heisman Caleb Williams, who would probably be the number one pick in the draft and no one in America could watch it 'cause it was Pac-12 network... that could not have been the better way to tip off the last Pac-12 season opener to be like, hey, this is why we're dying. Because we can't watch fucking Caleb Williams play football.

The Pac-12 effectively collapsed shortly after this, largely due to media rights issues and lack of visibility.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2023 Commanders vs. Ravens matchup was the most important preseason game of all time

It is good to have games that mean something besides obviously the Commander's Ravens game, which was the most important preseason game of all time.

This is a subjective, satirical claim about a preseason game's importance.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

College football should move the season forward so every team plays during 'Week Zero'

I wish week zero. Like everyone should play Week zero. They should just move the season forward... everyone plays. And then week one... I just want all the games right now.

This is a subjective opinion on how the college football schedule should be structured.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Miami of Ohio will beat Miami (FL) in their season opener

First time you'll hear this, I think Miami's gonna win... I'm taking Miami [of Ohio].

Miami (FL) won the game 38-3 on September 1, 2023.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will cut off a testicle if the Miami Hurricanes lose to Miami of Ohio

My hundred percent lock. I I will, I will cut off a testicle if Miami doesn't win that game.

Miami (FL) won 38-3, so his testicles were safe.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bob Barker is the GOAT game show host

In my mind the GOAT game show host. Yeah. I mean I know Trebek... Trebek's great. It was, it was the GOAT game show. Right. And he was the host for so long... Just the perfect amount of kind of horny, you know, made sure that everyone got their pets spayed and neutered would get a little pissed off when people were dumb. He just was the best.

Subjective ranking of entertainment figures.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 49ers trade for Trey Lance is one of the worst busts in NFL history

Find another team that trades three first round picks and misses that badly on a quarterback and still is potentially a Super Bowl team... but that has to be one of the worst bust slash trades in, in NFL history.

Trey Lance was traded for a 4th round pick after starting only 4 games for the 49ers, having cost three 1st-rounders. It is statistically one of the worst ROI trades in NFL history.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Fans will clamor for Trey Lance the moment Dak Prescott throws his first interception

I am, I'm very much looking forward to though the first terrible interception. Yes. Dak Prescott throws. Yes. I will be clamoring, I'll be standing on the table for Trey Lance, which will [happen] exactly two weeks from right now.

Dak Prescott did throw an interception in his season opener (against the Giants), and the media/fanbase immediately started debating the Trey Lance backup dynamic.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The new college football running clock rule on first downs is ruining the game

The new rule about First Downs sucks. The fact that they keep the running clock sucks. Yeah, it sucks. It's stupid... they just added more commercials. They fucking, it sucks. They're ruining college football.

Subjective opinion, though data later showed games were slightly shorter with fewer offensive plays per game.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Stephen Strasberg's contract was the worst in baseball history

Post World series, he was paid $460,000 per pitch. He was paid 2.6 million per out. 7.8 million per inning pitch. And he was paid $30.6 million per start. Whoa. Probably, probably the worst contract in baseball history.

Strasberg signed a 7-year, $245M extension and pitched only 31.1 innings after signing it. In terms of value per dollar, it is almost universally cited as the worst in MLB history.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers is going to be incredible for the Jets

[Rodgers] is gonna be incredible. Yeah. I watched the first two drives and then it was college football. That's all I needed.

Rodgers tore his Achilles 4 plays into the first game, making it impossible for him to be 'incredible' for the 2023 season.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Vikings quarterback Kirk Cousins will be incredible during the 2023 season

Kirk Cousins looks great. Yeah, he does. Have you seen the mustache? He looks awesome... I'm in on 'em.

Cousins was playing at an elite level through 8 games before a season-ending Achilles injury; the Vikings finished 7-10 and missed the playoffs.
Void
HankHank

Messi's assist against the Red Bulls was the craziest pass I've ever seen

Beat the Red Bulls scored another or no? Yeah. Unbelievable goal. Probably the craziest pass I've ever seen in the, in the sport of football... I think it was [better than his World Cup pass].

Subjective opinion on aesthetics and skill.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Donald Trump is the best golfer in the United States

Rick Re says that it wasn't actually 67. I don't be a hater, Rick. He says it was more like an 86... [Trump] is the best golfer in the United States.

Donald Trump is not a professional-level golfer capable of being the 'best in the US' by any objective metric.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Herm Edwards is a total fraud for the mess he left at Arizona State

My who's back is Herm Edwards being a fraud because Arizona State has a bull ban... He's on ESPN giving speeches about, you know, upstanding character and doing the right thing. And he just left this mess in his past. So he is a total fraud.

Edwards was fired mid-season and the program later self-imposed a bowl ban for violations committed under his watch.
Void
Howie LongHowie Long

Howie Long Jr. is the best athlete in the Long family

People ask why I waited to name our third child Howie. And I said, well, you know, it's easy because he's our favorite. You know, he's the best athlete in the family. He's, he's really just our favorite.

Inherently subjective familial ranking.
Loss
Howie LongHowie Long

The Jaguars will take another step forward because Doug Pederson brings a calm influence to the quarterback

Jaguars I think are, are gonna be a team that, you know, I remember that that game down there in the playoffs... I like what they're doing down there. I like Doug. I think Doug brings a, a calm particularly to the, the quarterback room.

The Jaguars actually regressed in 2023, finishing 9-8 and missing the playoffs after a late-season collapse.
Push
Howie LongHowie Long

Sean Payton will fix Russell Wilson by stripping away the extras and getting back to basics

I think Russell is a guy that I think needed Sean Payton to come in... Sean is the guy that will come in and he is not afraid to tell you, you know, the office thing. That's not No, we're not doing that... We're gonna get back to the basics. We're gonna get back to run the football, we're gonna make the offensive line better. We're, we're gonna get back to doing the things and, and tailor the offense to a version of what Sean's run.

Wilson significantly improved his stats in 2023 (26 TDs to 8 INTs), though the Broncos still struggled and eventually benched him for financial reasons.
Void
Howie LongHowie Long

Kyle Long would win a wrestling match against Chris and Howie in their primes

Kyle is frightening. When he puts hands on you, it's a different kind. It's like, some people are, I'm heavy handed, he's heavy handed on a bigger... I would take Kyle [in a wrestling match].

Hypothetical prime matchup between family members.
Win
Howie LongHowie Long

Modern NFL players are undeniably bigger, stronger, and faster than the 80s generation

It's, trust me, I, I I have no problem saying that. It's bigger, it's stronger, it's faster. Yeah. And, you know, that's the way it is... biggest offensive line's three 20 across the board. Different game.

Biometric and combine data confirms that NFL players have steadily increased in size and speed over decades.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The losers of the 2023 Mount Rushmore competition will have to do a 24-hour stream with their partner

This is it. This is a finale of Mount Rushmore season... someone will be in a 24 hour stream with their partner for all of us to watch narrate.

The losers (Hank and Max) did eventually have to perform a 24-hour livestream punishment.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Shohei Ohtani will sign with the Mets and fail to live up to his contract

[Ohtani] goes to the Mets and then does not live up to the contract. It would be very funny though if the Mets signed him and then he just pulled a deGrom and just like every year in June, had to get shut down.

Ohtani signed a record-breaking contract with the Los Angeles Dodgers, not the Mets.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Shohei Ohtani should become the best closer in baseball history

Why doesn't Shohei Ohtani become the best closer in the game? I was thinking about that. I went up, looked up Smoltz's history. He was a great pitcher for the Braves. Moved into the closing role and then dominated for a few years, then came back and started. He would be a lights out closer. Imagine if he was just like ding every day and then closing games. That would rule.

Ohtani did not become a closer; he signed with the Dodgers and spent the 2024 season primarily as a DH while recovering from surgery.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Corey Davis only 'stepped away' from football because he was about to get cut

It probably means you can't fire me. I quit. Because you might not have made the roster. I feel like you don't step away if you're gonna make the roster. Right. But then the minute you see like, oh I might not, I might get cut here. Knowing that it seems like he might've been on the bubble. Even with the 10 million. It's a great move by him. Like 'I never got cut.'

While there was speculation about his roster spot, Davis cited personal reasons and family for his retirement. He later applied for reinstatement in 2024 but was released by the Jets anyway.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers