Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

The quarterback position has become interchangeable and devalued just like the running back position

Are you basically saying that the quarterback position is like the running back position and it's almost interchangeable?

The value of mid-tier QBs has fluctuated, but the elite QB market continues to reset records, suggesting they are not yet 'interchangeable' like RBs.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Losing three Super Bowls in a row is better than winning one and being irrelevant for 49 years

Losing 15 Super Bowls... this is kind of a mini dynasty you get to go to. Like, just think about how fun Super Bowl week would be. If for the next 50 years I said that your team can win one Super Bowl, but the rest of the 49 years they won't go to the playoffs. Or in the next 50 years, your team can lose 15 Super Bowls. I'd take 15. That means you have 18 months of pure joy in your life.

Purely subjective hypothetical.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Nathaniel Hackett's biggest mistake was trying to be Russell Wilson's friend instead of his coach

His biggest crime, Nathaniel Hackett was he walked into a situation where he just wanted to please everyone and he wanted to please Russell Wilson. And he wanted to kind of be his buddy, not his dad. That's where you get first time head coach. Right? You don't come in and you're not gonna lay down the law.

The subsequent hiring of Sean Payton, who explicitly removed Wilson's private office and staff, supports this analysis of what went wrong under Hackett.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jake Paul will lose whenever he faces a legitimate professional boxer

I've always stood on the stance that Jake Paul, the minute he fights a real boxer he will get beat. Unfortunately I didn't think Tommy Fury was a real boxer. So I was right about my original take that once Jake Paul fought a real boxer, he would lose. I just didn't think Tommy Fury was a real boxer.

Jake Paul lost to Tommy Fury via split decision on February 26, 2023. Paul later lost to Mike Perry and went back to fighting non-boxers.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Jake Paul purposely lost to Tommy Fury to make the rematch more profitable

The conspiracy part of Twitter... they were saying that Jake Paul, in order to sell the next fight purposely knew that it would be bad if he won this fight. I think the storyline's better for a second fight... because no one would want to watch another one if he just beat him.

There is no evidence the fight was fixed, and Jake Paul's subsequent career move to fight Nate Diaz suggests he was genuinely looking to move on after a loss.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sam Hurd was released from prison early to serve as viral marketing for the movie Cocaine Bear

Sam Hurd has been released from Federal penitentiary... after serving a 10 year sentence for distributing cocaine. Timing is very suspicious with the release of Cocaine Bear. A lot of people are saying that this judge might have taken some money to do some gorilla marketing for the movie.

This is a satirical conspiracy theory.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Golf is not a team sport and it will never be one

I don't know why they thought like, golf is not a team sport. No. It's never gonna be a team sport. I'm my four-year-old son Chris walked in the other day and he was like, dad, can we watch the ACEs? He's a Big ACEs player. I don't know why they thought like, golf is not a team sport.

Subjective opinion on the nature of sports competition.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I will bet on Will Zalatoris in every golf major until he finally wins one

Will Zalatoris on the leaderboard. I was like, God fucking damnit. This is the year for sure. I will bet him in every major until he wins a major. That is a guarantee.

Will Zalatoris has not yet won a major championship as of late 2024.
Push
Billy FootballBilly Football

The East River is full of prehistoric bison bones dumped by a developer

Dirty Water Don... he's found a bone. He found a jawbone of a steppe bison, which is just a prehistoric, gigantic bison. He found the jawbone in the East River. So that means that it is true. There were tons of bones dumped there.

While a bone was found, the claim that it was 'dumped' by a specific developer is part of an unproven (though popular) local theory.
Win
Christian YelichChristian Yelich

The shift ban will significantly benefit every left-handed hitter in MLB

Any left-handed hitter, it's gonna be good because even if you weren't a guy that was full shift, you're still losing hits because of it. Analytically teams don't care, it's just more so like just don't hit a homer or a double. You'd get blown up and a ball that would stop in the infield grass basically ended up being a hit, and then you lose the one where you hit a line drive to right field and it hits the third baseman right in the chest.

League-wide batting average on balls in play (BABIP) for lefties increased from .283 in 2022 to .295 in 2023.
Void
Christian YelichChristian Yelich

Robot umpires will have unintended consequences like calling strikes on balls in the dirt

I don't want robot umps. No. Because I think there's gonna be a lot of unintended consequences with that. Because if you just have a square that buzzes ball or strike... there are a lot of breaking balls that'll be like in the dirt that'll clip the bottom of the strike zone technically. I don't want robots.

This is a subjective take from a professional player on a pending technology.
Void
Christian YelichChristian Yelich

Manager and umpire arguments are good for the entertainment value of baseball

I need to see managers getting right up into an umpire's face. That's so good for the game because people, it's entertaining. At the end of the day it's an entertainment business. So make things that are entertainment. It reaches a large audience.

This is a subjective opinion on the entertainment value of the sport.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

A combined no-hitter is still a legitimate no-hitter

It is a no-hitter. Cause they got no hits. You're gonna be in history, you're gonna be in the history books as a no-hitter.

The MLB record books officially recognize combined no-hitters as no-hitters.
Void
Christian YelichChristian Yelich

Bunting to break up a no-hitter in the World Series is acceptable

If it's like seventh, eighth inning, I don't know... but in like a World Series playoff game... you kind of have to. It's the World Series. Anytime it's the World Series, if it's a one nothing or two nothing game, you kind of have to.

Subjective opinion on baseball etiquette.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Baseball unwritten rules dictate that if a team hits your best player, you must hit theirs in return

My favorite [unwritten rule] is just if the team drills your best player, you gotta drill the other guys, the other team's best player.

This is a subjective take on sports etiquette and unofficial rules.
Void
Christian YelichChristian Yelich

Catchers are the biggest psychos in baseball because they stop projectiles for three hours

I think there's different tiers of it... but catchers, yeah, they're crazy. Who would want to crouch for three hours every day? Just stopping projectiles... getting hit with bats and foul tips... I'm like, you guys are crazy. I wouldn't wanna do that.

This is a hyperbolic/subjective opinion on the personalities of different position groups.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers will definitely continue playing football

Trying to figure out if he wants to keep playing football. Spoil alert he will. Yep. Wants to continue playing. Probably win an MVP.

Rodgers did continue playing, being traded to the Jets shortly after.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers will be phenomenal next season and probably win an MVP

I'm fully prepared for him to go back to the Packers and win an MVP. Yeah. Because it feels like this is just the cycle that we're in. And he's probably gonna be phenomenal next year.

Rodgers tore his Achilles four plays into the season and did not win MVP or play phenomenally.
Win
HankHank

The drama surrounding Brandon Miller will actually help his NBA draft stock

My other spin zone is I actually think this helps his draft stock. Think about all the attention he's getting. Everyone knows who he is and then after, you know, all eyes are on him, he drops 40.

Miller was drafted #2 overall, as high as most projected him before the incident, suggesting it didn't hurt and potentially highlighted his 'mental toughness' to scouts.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Anthony Richardson will not be the #1 overall pick in the NFL Draft

I don't think [Anthony Richardson] is the first overall pick.

Anthony Richardson was selected 4th overall by the Indianapolis Colts. Bryce Young was the #1 overall pick.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I would not touch Anthony Richardson with a 10-foot pole in the draft

I've watched him play... I would not touch him with a 10 foot pole.

Richardson showed flashes of brilliance as a rookie but struggled with injuries, making his long-term evaluation still somewhat debated.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I don't believe in Power 5 QBs who were average in college becoming incredible NFL players

Show me a quarterback who played at Power five, who was average, who then ended up having an incredible career. And I'm not saying like, the reason why I say incredible is if you're the number one pick, you should have like, you're projected to have a very good NFL career. And so that's like, if it, if we're talking about the 20th pick, that's different.

While Josh Allen is the obvious counter-example, the general trend supports Big Cat. Anthony Richardson's career is still in early stages but has been hampered by injury and inconsistency.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders will get Lamar Jackson

[Big Cat]: You guys are gonna trade up. I'll help you with that. [PFT]: No, we're getting Lamar.

Lamar Jackson stayed with the Ravens, signing a long-term deal.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA should award All-Star game winners a year off their contract to hit free agency early

What you should do is you should award the winning team. Every player on the winning team should get one year off their contract to become a free agent. So they hit free agency one year sooner. Yeah. And then that, that would incentivize them.

The NBA has not implemented this rule.
Loss
HankHank

NBA Finals Prediction: Celtics over Suns

Celtics Suns. [PFT]: I'm gonna say Sons win. [Big Cat]: All right. Celtics sons.

Neither team reached the Finals; Celtics lost in ECF, Suns in West Semis.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

NBA Finals Prediction: Suns over Bucks

I'm gonna go Bucks Suns... I'm switching back. I I'm going suns bucks again. Because that would be funny if like the suns clinched before the Celtics Bucks series ends.

Neither the Suns nor the Bucks made the 2023 NBA Finals.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NBA Finals Prediction: Nuggets over Bucks

If it's not the suns, I'm gonna say, I'm gonna stick with my nuggets. My nuggets over Hank's Celtics... Nuggets over the bucks.

The Nuggets won the championship, but they beat the Heat, not the Bucks.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

It is not a 'sham' if Nikola Jokic wins a 3rd straight MVP without making the Conference Finals

Everyone's getting pre-mad right now about Jokic winning a third straight MVP... they're like, if he wins an MVP and they don't get at least the conference finals, this is a sham. Why? Again, it's a regular season award. Like that's just what it is.

Jokic didn't win a 3rd straight (Embiid won in 2023), but he did lead the Nuggets to a championship that year, rendering the 'playoff fraud' argument moot.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

NBA Finals Prediction: Warriors over 76ers

I will go with Warriors over Sixers and the City of Philadelphia completes the superfecta of second place.

Neither team reached the Finals.
Void
Max HomaMax Homa

The Masters and The Open are the two tournaments I want to win most

The Masters is special... that in the open are my two favorite events... that would be, that would be definitely way up on that list.

Subjective preference of the speaker.
Void
Max HomaMax Homa

Kyrie Irving would not have fixed the Lakers because they aren't just one piece away

Was [Kyrie] gonna fucking fix us? I don't think we're one piece away here. So no it wasn't super devastating.

The Lakers did perform better after the trade deadline (without Kyrie), making the WCF, supporting the idea that depth was the issue.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Charlie Woods will be better than Tiger Woods and Jack Nicklaus combined

Charlie Woods is gonna be better than Tiger... better than Tiger and Jack combined.

Hot TakeGolfScorchingSarcastic
It is virtually impossible to be statistically better than the two greatest golfers ever combined, especially before reaching high school.
Void
Max HomaMax Homa

Most humor starts with sadness and comedy is often a mask for athlete struggles

I also think like, you know, like comedians, a lot of 'em say like they're depressed. So I think a lot of funny starts with like a lot of sadness. So most of my tweets started with just like constantly having the weekend off to think and then I would probably mask all the sadness with like, 'Hey, how about that sun being so hot?'

This is Homa's personal reflection on his own creative process and mental state.
Void
Max HomaMax Homa

You don't need to be the best at every area of the game to be successful in golf

You absolutely do not need to be the best at every area of the game to be successful. So I'm chasing something that I, I know like that that was unattainable to be that good at, honestly. But besides Tiger Tiger's the only person in history that's been the best at like four to five things in golf.

This philosophy has proven successful for Max, as shown by his rise to #12 in the world.
Void
Max HomaMax Homa

Learning to 'win ugly' when my game feels terrible is the key to my success

What I've worked on with my sports psychologist... for the last couple months is like we've been talking about winning ugly. Like I'm looking at it as exciting to, for a day where my shit feels terrible and I can still be like, 'All right, I'm still beating your ass.'

Homa's continued success and wins in 2023 (like the Farmers Insurance Open) support this improved mental resilience.
Loss
Max HomaMax Homa

If I play my best golf, I can win the Masters

[PFT]: You would say that at your best... you could win at Augusta? [Max Homa]: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Hell yeah.

Homa finished T43 at the 2023 Masters, though he did improve to a T3 finish in 2024.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

The new PLL Sixes format is the best lacrosse product and will replace regular rules

I think the new, the new PLL championship series six is, is actually I think like the best lacrosse product I've ever seen. Like I think it's gonna replace regular, the regular rules. I think this is how the game is gonna be played in the future. It's the best lacrosse product you can put out.

Standard 10-man field lacrosse remains the dominant and primary format of the PLL and the sport; Sixes remains an off-season/Olympic curiosity.
Loss
HankHank

Anthony Richardson will be the #1 overall pick in the NFL Draft

I'm all the way back in on Anthony Richardson... he also knows I love value... Anthony Richardson +10,000 or whatever, 100 to 1 to go number one... I'm reading all the articles, trying to just will him to somehow become the number one overall pick.

Bryce Young went #1 overall. Anthony Richardson went #4 to the Colts.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I could definitely hit the waypoints if given the controls of an F-18 fighter jet

I'm deathly terrified of doing this... [but] I do think that if they gave me the controls, I'd be able to at least like hit the waypoints and shit.

This is a hyperbolic claim based on simulator training that would never be tested in a live F-18 cockpit.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Vacations are for suckers and losers

Full stop. Fucking work hard. Hank vacation. Boy, you're soft bitch. All these vacations you're taking. I didn't even like doing it. I wanted to be working with the boys... vacations for suckers and losers.

Hot TakeLifeFireSarcastic
Clearly a joke statement contradicting his own actions and earlier words.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Eric Bieniemy only joined the Commanders because he was promised they are getting Lamar Jackson

There might be a little deal behind the scenes with Ron Rivera telling Bieniemy 'Lamar gets franchise tag... if it's not exclusive, oh, we're gonna get Lamar now.' Why would he go to Washington, DC... to go to a starting quarterback, Sam Howell, who started precisely one game?

Bieniemy coached the season with Sam Howell and Jacoby Brissett; Lamar remained in Baltimore.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dan Snyder will sign Lamar Jackson to a fully guaranteed contract just to spite the other NFL owners

Dan Snyder, out of spite just to fuck over the next owner would love nothing more than to give those two first round picks away and on top of that, throwing a shitload of guaranteed money in a contract extension for Lamar Jackson... it would be a fuck you to those [other owners] that don't want these guaranteed contracts.

Lamar Jackson stayed with the Ravens on a non-fully guaranteed contract; Snyder sold the team without making this move.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Lamar Jackson is losing out on major opportunities by not having an agent

It is crazy Lamar Jackson doesn't have an agent. I know like you can, I'm all for player empowerment, but I feel like he is probably losing out on opportunities without an agent. And what team wa—he has no idea what team wants 'em.

While subjective, many analysts noted the difficulty Lamar faced without an agent during the tag process before eventually signing a record deal.
Loss
MaxMax

UCLA will win the 2023 NCAA Tournament

So I'm going with the UCLA Bruins. Mostly because Tiger Campbell and Jaime Jaquez are still on the teams. There's two guys that I know... And Mick Cronin, friend of the show.

UCLA lost in the Sweet 16 to Gonzaga in a classic game.
Void
MaxMax

The NBA rigged the 2006 Dunk Contest for Nate Robinson over Andre Iguodala

Nate Robinson was bullshit. He should have lost to Andre Iguodala... well he missed like 32 dunks in a row and then still won. That was the biggest NBA rig thing of all time. Andre Iguodala absolutely dominated that dunk contest.

Whether it was 'rigged' is subjective, but it is widely considered one of the most controversial dunk contest outcomes ever.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Bulls should tank the rest of the 2023 season

Pat Bev coming home to Chicago. It's gonna be—I don't know what the Bulls are doing. They should tank... they suck. They should tank. But I agree, make the Bulls fun with Pat Bev.

The Bulls did not tank; they made the Play-In Tournament and lost, which is the exact 'no man's land' Big Cat feared.
Win
HankHank

Nate Oats' response to the Brandon Miller situation was 'wild' and inappropriate

Nate Oats his response to that said, 'we knew about that. Can't control everything everybody does outside of practice. Nobody knew that was going to happen. College kids are out. Brandon hasn't been in any type of trouble... Wrong spot at the wrong time.' ...It wasn't a coincidence.

Oats later apologized for his 'wrong spot, wrong time' comment, acknowledging it was insensitive.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

College coaches Micromanage every detail but suddenly 'don't know' when a crime occurs

Whenever there's a bad situation, [college coaches] are so quickly to pretend like they are ignorant to what their players are doing. ...To get to the level of being a division one big conference college coach in football or basketball, you have to be a psycho micromanager. Like down to every detail. And then a murder happens. You're like, 'well, I don't fucking know.'

This is a subjective opinion on the culture of college athletics.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Kentucky is a dangerous long shot that could get hot in the tournament

I actually like Kentucky as like a long shot... something about Cal's guys. He's gone through it. He's legitimately on the hot seat... they have couple crazy guards that are like, we'll just be reckless. And I like, whenever I'm thinking of a long shot, I'm like, give me a couple guards that will just throw their body at the basket.

Kentucky won one game in the tournament and lost in the Second Round to Kansas State.
Win
Mark TitusMark Titus

Ohio State is so bad they won't even make the NIT this season

I honestly don't think Ohio State's good enough to make the NIT. They're gonna lose the rest of the season. And the way they've lost is just like every which way.

Ohio State finished 16-19 and did not play in the NIT, making Titus correct.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers