Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Big Cat

Big Cat

Host
2016 — Present
2,824W·2,257L·552P·291 open
@barstoolbigcat
footballbasketballlife5,633 scored

All Takes

Open
Big CatBig Cat

The College Football Playoff will eventually expand to 16 teams

We knew it was gonna be chaotic and weird for the first couple of years of this. I think it eventually will get to 16 and then people will stop bitching as much because you're getting closer and closer to where the natural rankings are.

The playoff has already expanded from 4 to 12. 16 is the logical next step for revenue and to include more at-large teams.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Group of Five teams like James Madison, Tulane, and North Texas have zero chance of winning the national title

If you said to me right now, does James Madison, Tulane or North Texas have a chance of winning it all? I'd say no. Does Texas or Vanderbilt? I'd say maybe.

While subjective, historical precedent strongly supports the idea that G5 teams cannot win a national title in the modern era.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers have become a retirement home for players

The Steelers did sign Adam Thielen today, who is a 2018 pro bowler... Mike Tomlin has gotten to the point where you can just perfectly troll him and predict everything he does. And the Steelers are just become a retirement home for players. It's crazy.

Subjective assessment of team management and roster age.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Ed Orgeron will return to LSU as part of Lane Kiffin's new coaching staff

I think there's a high chance that he [Kiffin] puts Coach O on his staff... Why wouldn't you want Coach O on the LSU staff? You want him back.

Big Cat predicted Ed Orgeron would return to LSU as part of Lane Kiffin's new coaching staff. While Kiffin was hired as LSU head coach, Orgeron confirmed Kiffin did not ask him to join the staff. The coaching staff was filled with former Ole Miss assistants. Coach O was open to it but was not offered a position.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Tomlin and the Steelers are likely to break up after this season

My Hot Seat is Mike Tomlin and the Steelers. Because I actually think that he might, this might be it... they don't change anything. And it's, I mean, TJ Watt said it. I think the bills ran the same play 27 times on Sunday. Yeah. That's insane. It feels like this is finally [the end].

Tomlin signed an extension through 2027 in the real world, but the sentiment of the 'break up' is a recurring narrative every time the Steelers struggle.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is officially in his stat-padding era

My Cool Throne is LeBron because congratulations to LeBron. He kept his streak alive of scoring 10 games, which is a totally made up streak... Can we just admit that LeBron's in his stat padding time, like it's fine. It's fine.

This is subjective, but LeBron's emphasis on scoring streaks and playing with his son Bronny supports the narrative of focusing on legacy milestones.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Texas should not be in the College Football Playoff because they lost to Florida

I have a take and, and people will probably say this is wrong, but it's my take... Texas is out... That Florida lost. I know they have three very good wins... that's not a playoff team.

Texas did end up making the playoff in reality, proving Big Cat's 'should be out' stance was contrarian to the committee's actual logic.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Julian Sayin is a much better quarterback than Will Howard

Julian Sayin is way better than Will Howard... The second Michigan took out their gun... that game was over.

Subjective comparison of two players' talent and performance.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan players saying they were 'protecting the logo' after getting crushed is pathetic

If you're a Michigan fan, you have to be completely embarrassed that that was actually said afterwards... to come a to afterwards be like Yeah, we were making sure that they couldn't do anything with the m we're gonna protect the m... That's so pathetic.

This is a subjective opinion on the optics of the rivalry aftermath.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ole Miss fans have every right to be furious at Lane Kiffin for leaving during the playoffs

Ole Miss fans have every right to be upset... I think Ole Miss AD did the right thing and being like, no way are you going to coach this team in the playoffs like that. Lane was lane to the most lane he's ever been... I do stand with Ole Miss fans though. You have every right to be pissed off.

The validity of a fan base's anger is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dak Prescott deserves to win the award for being 'in the conversation' for MVP

Dak is my official pick for, he will not win the MVP, but a lot of people will say in the next month, he should be in the conversation for MVP. So he wins that award. He wins the award for being in the conversation for MVP.

This is a subjective meta-award based on media narratives.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 2025 Bears win over the Eagles was their biggest victory since 2018

Bears Eagles... That was the biggest Bears win since Sunday night Football 2018 when the Rams came to town and they absolutely throttled that Rams offense. It was awesome. They absolutely man footballed, the Philadelphia Eagles.

Historical significance of a single regular season win is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Polls deserves an apology for building a Bears offensive line with a true identity

I do owe an apology to Ryan Polls. I've been critical of Ryan polls at times... What he did with this offensive line in the off season is insane because the Bears have a true identity... they have an identity they can fucking smash guys like through four quarters.

The Bears' offensive line performance in the 2025 season is subjective but the take reflects a mid-season realization of team identity.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ben Johnson is the true alpha in Detroit who built the culture of aggression, not Dan Campbell

Who is the alpha in Detroit? Was Ben Johnson or Dan Campbell? Ben Johnson can fucking run the football. Ben Johnson is jacked. Ben Johnson is a culture builder... the violence, the aggression, the way they, the offensive, like of violence that he, it imposes on other teams.

Determining the 'alpha' of a coaching staff is inherently subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 2025 Houston Texans will be the second team since 2000 to start 0-3 and make the playoffs

2018 Texans are the only team since 2000 to start 0 and three and make the playoffs... history seems to be repeat, be repeating itself, where the Texans could be an 0 and three team to make the playoffs, which has only happened with the Texans in 2018. And they're my pinky team.

Big Cat predicted the 2025 Texans would be the second team since 2000 to start 0-3 and make the playoffs (after the 2018 Texans). The Texans did start 0-3 and rallied to finish 12-5, making the playoffs, becoming the first NFL team to accomplish this feat multiple times.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan's obsession with 'protecting the logo' after a blowout loss is pathetic

If you're a Michigan fan, you have to be completely embarrassed that that was actually said afterwards... to come afterwards be like Yeah, we were making sure that they couldn't do anything with the m we're gonna protect the m... That's so pathetic.

Whether an action is 'pathetic' is subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 49ers are good enough to overcome multiple turnovers from Brock Purdy

To be up at half after your quarterback throwing three interceptions... it just shows that the Niners are starting to, you know, they're good enough that they can overcome those things.

The 49ers beat the Panthers 34-17 in the game discussed despite Purdy's three interceptions.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jeremiah Love should win the Heisman Trophy

Let me hear hear have your Alexa hear me say Jeremiah Love should win the Heisman and then get it in the algorithm.

Jeremiah Love did not win the 2024 Heisman Trophy; Travis Hunter won it.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 'Players Era' tournament is ruining the tradition of Feast Week college basketball

The players era fucking sucks. There's not even a real tournament... They've taken away and no one's in the stands there. Feast Week used to mean something, man.

This is an opinion on the quality and atmosphere of the tournament.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers will beat the Lions on Thanksgiving because their defense is the best unit on the field.

I kind of like, I think the Packers might win this game. I just, I feel like the Packers defense is the best unit in this.

The Packers beat the Lions 31-24 on Thanksgiving 2025. Big Cat was right that Green Bay would win, and their defense played well with Micah Parsons logging 2.5 sacks.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am suppressing the thought that the Bears are legitimate Super Bowl contenders if they beat the Eagles on Black Friday.

I'm keeping those [thoughts] suppressed because why not though? I, I think superstitious wise, I need to stay in that mode... why don't we just fucking beat the Eagles and go nine to three? Yeah. And like just start fucking ripping on.

Big Cat was suppressing thoughts of the Bears being Super Bowl contenders. The Bears went 11-6 and won a playoff game (Wild Card vs Packers 31-27) but lost in the Divisional Round to the Rams 20-17. They did not make the Super Bowl.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Colts -4.5 vs. Texans is a suspiciously low line that favors the Colts

I'm gonna take the Colts minus four and a half. I feel like the, that that's, that's a field goal line. Why is it four and a half? They know something.

The Colts beat the Texans 24-21, failing to cover the -4.5 spread.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jameis Winston is a starting quarterback in this league

This should prove that Jameis Winston should be a starting quarterback in the NFL. There are so many bad games that we watch and bad quarterback play that we watch. Jameis Winston is not. Yes, sometimes he throws interceptions. Yes, sometimes he makes mistakes. He is so much fun.

Subjective opinion on roster talent and entertainment value.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears can compete with anyone in the NFL right now

I also think the Bears can compete with anyone at this point. And they've got a belief that they are not gonna blink when those tough moments come.

Subjective claim about competitive parity.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Jaxon Smith-Njigba is the best wide receiver in the NFL this season

I have been saying Jaxon Smith-Njigba has been the best wide receiver this season for a month and it is facts. He's incredible... He's on pace to break an NFL record of 2,029 yards.

While 'best' is subjective, the yardage pace is a verifiable claim. JSN finished 2025 with elite numbers, though record-breaking is rare.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Raiders are the worst team in the NFL

I think the Raiders are the worst team in the NFL. Their two wins are against the Titans and the Patriots. They have lost—they won against the Patriots week one. They've had one win since.

Subjective ranking based on performance and win-loss record.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams are currently the best team in the NFL

The Rams are the best TEAM IN THE NFL. Does anyone disagree? I don't know who would make the case for any other team right now. They're just destroying people.

Power ranking style take. Outcome would be proven by a Super Bowl win or late season collapse.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is the NFL MVP right now

Matthew Stafford's the MVP of the league right now. What is the current odds on DraftKings? ... [He] makes football look easy.

Matthew Stafford was the MVP and officially won the 2025 NFL MVP award.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin is the hottest team in college football right now

Wisconsin's hottest team in the country. Two back. They've won two home games against ranked opponents in November. Pretty cool.

Purely subjective based on momentum and personal bias.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Pirates leaking interest in Kyle Schwarber is just 'red meat' to appease the fans with no intent to sign him

I feel like the Pirates' version of them actually signing a big free agent would be just leaking it that they're thinking about signing. Correct. That was... their red meat to the fan base. Be like, look, we tried.

The Pirates did not sign Kyle Schwarber despite making a four-year, $125 million offer. Schwarber re-signed with the Phillies on a five-year, $150 million deal at the Winter Meetings in December 2025. Big Cat's take that the Pirates' leaked interest was just 'red meat' for fans with no real intent to sign him proved accurate — they were outbid and the interest appeared performative.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers will play like an elite quarterback against the Bears because he wants to spite them one last time

That is my fear of this game is Aaron Rogers, who I don't think is like an elite quarterback anymore, will become an elite quarterback because he wants to stick it to the Bears one last time.

Big Cat feared Aaron Rodgers would play like an elite QB against the Bears in Week 12 to spite them. But Rodgers did not play at all due to a fractured left wrist sustained in Week 11. Mason Rudolph started instead, and the Steelers lost to the Bears.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Vikings should cut and immediately re-sign J.J. McCarthy so he can be a reclamation project

What the Vikings really should do is cut JJ McCarthy. Yep. So he's a bust and then sign him back. So he is a reclamation project. Then it'll be good. Cut JJ McCarthy, officially declaring a bust, sign McCarthy former draft bust and have KOC fix him. Smart.

This is a satirical suggestion and won't literally happen.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I bet the Cowboys to cover +3 against the Eagles

I'm gonna take the Cowboys plus three... I think the Cowboys are gonna cover the spread. The Eagles can win the game.

Cannot verify the specific Cowboys vs Eagles Week 12 2025 spread result. The Cowboys beat the Commanders on Christmas Day, but this was a different game.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Georgia is in the best possible position because they can get a playoff bye without playing the SEC championship game

The winner number one is Georgia, because Georgia obviously beats Texas. They get to four. Georgia's in that perfect spot where they could potentially not go to the SEC championship game and have a buy. Which that's gotta be the greatest spot you could ever be in.

Georgia did play in the SEC championship game (losing 28-7 to... wait, Georgia beat Texas and then lost the SEC championship). Georgia was the #3 seed in the CFP and lost to Ole Miss 39-34 in the quarterfinals. They did not get a bye.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Texas Tech will jump into a first-round playoff bye if they win the Big 12 championship

The other big winner to me is Texas Tech. Because if Indiana and Ohio State, when they play in the Big 10 championship game, if Texas Tech can win the Big 12 championship game, I would imagine Indiana, the loser of the Indiana, Ohio State game might drop out to the five seed and Texas Tech... would slip up into the buy.

Texas Tech won the Big 12 championship 34-7 over BYU and earned the No. 4 seed in the CFP, which came with a first-round bye. Big Cat was correct that Texas Tech would slip into a bye if they won the Big 12 title.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Duke is a bad football team and I am done considering them in any ACC or playoff scenarios

Duke is not gonna win out. I'm done with Duke. ... Duke is bad. I'm done with Duke. I'm done with Duke in any scenarios. ... They're five and five. They're, they're not a good team.

Duke's quality is subjective, but their record (5-5) supports the claim that they aren't a top-tier team.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

NFL teams should be required to win at least four games to receive their first-round draft pick

Dumb rule: teams should have to win four games to get their first pick. So at the end of the season, a Raiders Monday Night Football game has actual consequences where it's like they need to desperately win this game to get their allotted first-round pick.

This is a proposed rule change and not a verifiable claim.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

James Franklin is leaving a $50 million buyout because he has a competitive drive to coach, not just for the money

I feel like you don't get to a point where you are successful enough to get a $50 million buyout unless you have that like killer instinct, competitive drive. ... James Franklin's going after being an awesome coach, coaching, he needs football to live.

The move to Virginia Tech is stated as fact in this pod's timeline.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Billionaires who don't own a professional sports team are losers

I've said it a million times, I think it's a very strong take. If you are a billionaire and you don't own a professional sports team, you're a loser. ... The only reason you get that much money is to go buy a team.

This is a purely subjective value judgment.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears could be a dangerous team if they get healthy and play a complete game in all three phases

They have won seven games already this year and they haven't really put together... a great game on all three phases. And if that happens, especially if we get some of our secondary healthy, like this team could be better than we think.

Subjective evaluation of 'better than we think'.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The best way to surprise a girl with a proposal is to do a fake one at a sports game first

The surprise is already over because you already are planning it. ... The only way he could truly surprise you is doing it at a sports game... center court at a mid-tier college basketball game. ... He does a fake proposal to you at a sports game and then he's like 'piss you off! Just kidding!'

OpinionLifeHotSubjectiveSarcastic
This is satirical advice and cannot be truly 'correct'.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears have officially graduated to being a good team

I do officially think we've graduated to good. We're obviously not great, but we're good for right now. Seven and three. You can't deny that they just find ways to win games.

A 7-3 record usually qualifies as 'good' in the NFL, though the point differential remains an issue.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If the Bears beat the Steelers next week, not making the playoffs would be a total disaster

If we beat the Steelers next week, I will then officially declare if we don't get to the playoffs, it'll be a disaster. Winning next week will then have me be like, alright, now I'm thinking about, hey, we're gonna probably go to the playoffs.

Cannot verify the specific Bears vs Steelers game result. The Bears did make the playoffs at 11-6, winning the NFC North and a Wild Card game. They lost in the Divisional Round to the Rams.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

We are officially done with the Bengals for the 2025 season

Can we be done with the Bengals? ... They're not making the playoffs. Joe Burrow, don't rush back. We're done. I think Bengals fans would agree. We're done with the Bengals this year.

The Bengals' playoff chances were mathematically very low at this point.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Jaguars loss wounded Jim Harbaugh's soul and is likely the worst loss of his career.

I think this is going to be a game where if you, if we have Jim Harbaugh on in 10 years and we're like, 'what's the worst loss you ever had?' he might say this game because the Jaguars outmanned and out-physicaled and were more violent and just played Jim Harbaugh football right down his throat... I think this loss wounded Jim Harbaugh's soul.

We cannot definitively know Harbaugh's internal state or his career ranking of losses.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams are a Super Bowl championship level team

I think the Rams are Super Bowl championship level team. 'Cause their defense is also elite... the Rams to me are the best team in the NFC right now.

The Rams were 12-5 and reached the NFCCG. Close to championship level but lost to Seahawks 27-31.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks defense is Super Bowl caliber.

The Seahawks defense is elite... I think the Seahawks defense is Super Bowl caliber defense.

Subjective evaluation of unit potential.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers is not very good anymore

I don't think Rodgers is very good anymore. Aaron Rodgers has not been playing elite football. The offense does not look explosive at all.

Rodgers' stats in 2025 had declined compared to his MVP years.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Broncos are better than the Chiefs right now

Bo Nix outplayed Patrick Mahomes... The Broncos are better than the Chiefs right now. Like, that's just a fact. And they are a legitimate threat and...

The Broncos beat the Chiefs in the game being recapped.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are the most easily bullied team in the NFL

The Eagles are the number one can-be-bullied team. It definitely felt like that... they are a tough watch right now, but it works.

Subjective view on team psychology and media influence.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers