Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Push
Big CatBig Cat

Draymond Green is the new Ben Simmons

[Draymond Green] is Ben Simmons... Steve Kerr deserves a ton of credit... for having the balls to pull Draymond out of the fourth quarter. Draymond Green does not want to shoot. He is Ben Simmons at this point where it's like, he could have a completely open look going towards the basket and he will pass it up.

While both players are elite defenders and playmakers who struggle to shoot, Draymond has a much higher competitive motor and has won four rings, whereas Simmons' career stalled due to lack of confidence and injuries.
Void
HankHank

Robert Williams is the most impactful player on the court for the Celtics

When Robert Williams [is out there], he's the most impactful player on the court. As many blocks as he has, he probably has so many more that just because his presence is there, [opponents] don't even try and take shots. He brings the energy for the Celtics.

Williams was arguably the most impactful defender in the series, leading both teams in blocks and altering numerous shots despite playing through significant pain.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Celtics are still the better team than the Warriors

Hank's going to get mad at this comment, but I still think the Celtics are the better team. I mean, if you were looking for a bet after a loss, they've been undefeated this whole playoffs.

The Warriors won the series 4-2, winning three straight games after this take was made, effectively proving they were the better team.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Steph Curry deserves the Finals MVP even if the Warriors lose

Our man Perk [Kendrick Perkins], carry the hell on, he said no matter what, win or lose, Steph Curry deserves this MVP. I'd be willing to trade in Billy not being vegan just for the ensuing takes that would come with Steph Curry winning the MVP and losing.

Steph Curry won the Finals MVP unanimously, though they ultimately won the series, rendering the 'even if they lose' condition untested but affirming his MVP status.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

If Steph Curry wins MVP and loses the Finals, I will go on a carnivore-only diet

If Steph Curry wins, I'm going carnivore diet only... only meat, only.

The condition of Steph winning MVP while losing the series did not happen.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Celtics plus three and a half is a good bet for Game 5

I do think the Celtics plus three and a half is a good bet on Monday night. It looks stupid... but if you were looking for a bet after a loss, they've been undefeated this whole playoffs. You'd expect them to win on Monday.

The Warriors won Game 5 104-94, meaning the Celtics failed to win or cover the +3.5 spread.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I want to bet on the Lightning to win the Stanley Cup despite being underdogs

The Lightning... I think I kind of want to bet on the Lightning to win this series. They just don't lose. Everything says that the Avalanche are the best team in the NHL, but then it tells me like, guess what? The Avalanche—maybe I'll wait till the Avalanche win the first two games... then the Lightning are like, 'all right, now we're going to start playing.'

The Colorado Avalanche defeated the Tampa Bay Lightning 4-2 to win the Stanley Cup.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LIV Golf is the tour for people who are in debt or recently divorced

Somebody pointed out... they said that it was the tour for people who were either heavily in debt or recently divorced. And that's exactly right. Like if you need to make alimony payments, you're going to the fucking LIV. You're going to take the money and run.

While meant as a joke, many early LIV signees were older players or those with rumored financial pressures looking for guaranteed payouts.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The US Open will be incredible because the LIV players will be shunned

I'm telling you, this US Open is going to be incredible. And they're only going to play because they can't play in the PGA Tour events. They're only going to play in the majors, which is kind of what we cared about. How awesome would that be if it's like Phil and Rory dueling it out?

The 2022 US Open was widely considered one of the best in years, featuring a high-level leaderboard and a dramatic win by Matt Fitzpatrick.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tennessee Baseball are clowns for missing the College World Series

I don't think... it's a fine line between being a bad boy and being a clown. I think if you don't actually make it [to Omaha], then you're a clown. Yeah.

Tennessee was the #1 overall seed and lost before reaching the CWS, which is objectively an underperformance for a team with that much bravado.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am rooting for whatever XFL team Greg Williams is coaching

I don't know what the XFL is going to do... but frankly, I don't care because I think I'm just going to root for whatever team [Greg Williams] is coaching. If you think that he was dialing up the heat in the NFL, wait till he gets to the extreme football league.

This is a personal rooting interest and cannot be verified as right or wrong.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Lacrosse goals should get bigger as the game goes along

I think the goal should get bigger as the game goes along. First quarter, it's the regular size and they get bigger and bigger and bigger. So in the fourth quarter you have like chaos where it's like the scoring picks up and everyone's like, 'holy shit.'

This is a humorous rule suggestion for the sport of lacrosse.
Void
Paul RabilPaul Rabil

Bill Belichick would win a PLL title within three seasons if he coached

I feel like [Bill Belichick] would win in the first three seasons of coaching [in the PLL], if not sooner. I mean, I don't think he really coaches football. He just coaches human beings... I think he understands the nuance of sports and blueprint of winning better than anyone... you listen to Bill Belichick coach you on lacrosse and you're bought in.

Belichick has never coached in the PLL, so this remains a hypothetical.
Open
Paul RabilPaul Rabil

The PLL will be a top six sport in North America within five years

The PLL will be a top six sport in North America. There's just so many... it's competitive now. I used to say like, we're always talking to the big four, but it'll be the top six... Someone's got to go. We're probably seven or eight [currently].

Five years from June 2022 is June 2027. Currently, PLL has seen growth but is still behind the 'Big 4' and likely MLS and UFC in terms of North American revenue and viewership.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

A video game is key to opening up the PLL to a wider audience

An awesome video game... if you could get a video game that is very fun to play and the gameplay is great, that is such a key to opening up so many [new fans]. When you were a kid, you loved the sport [because] you played the video game.

General marketing and brand growth theory that is largely supported by industry trends.
Win
Mr. PortnoyMr. Portnoy

Late-night TV news commercials for products like CarShield are frauds

When I see them up there, those products are fraud... I mean, they wouldn't be advertising there if they weren't a fraud. I have an occasional check with the FTC site and the Better Business Bureau to see various of these companies have all sorts of consumer complaints against them. And what a shock!

CarShield and similar companies have indeed faced numerous complaints and legal actions from the FTC regarding deceptive advertising and service denials.
Void
Mr. PortnoyMr. Portnoy

If a commercial starts by saying 'this is not a scam,' it's probably a scam

When they started with the reverse mortgages... the ad started with a sentence: 'This is not a scam.' I mean, that was the furthest thing from my mind until he put it in my head that this might be a scam. Why are they saying it's legit? It never occurred to me that it's not, but now I'm going to start to investigate it.

While logically sound in terms of consumer skepticism, it remains an opinion on marketing rhetoric.
Void
Mr. PortnoyMr. Portnoy

The New York Times was desperate for Alex Cooper to say something negative about Barstool Sports

It was obvious to me... that the New York Times was salivating to get [Alex Cooper] to say something that would be damaging to Barstool. And she didn't. They couldn't resist getting [the sidebar about Dave Portnoy] in there.

The editorial intent of a publication is inherently subjective and cannot be definitively proven.
Void
HankHank

Dell Curry bringing Steven Johnson's ex-wife to the game was a purely spite-driven move

But then on Friday at the Celtics game, Dell was there with Steven Johnson's ex-wife. And he's dating her. He brought her to the game. So clearly he was... that was just purely out of spite by Dell. Like just straight up, just an absolute spite move.

The rumor of the 'partner swap' was widely reported, and Dell appearing in public with the ex-wife of the man Sonya was allegedly seeing is objectively a pointed public statement.
Win
HankHank

There will definitely be a Game 6 in the NBA Finals

I do think there will be a game six, unfortunately. Very scared about game four.

Correct. The series went to 6 games, with the Warriors winning in Boston.
Win
HankHank

The Celtics would have won by now if they didn't constantly throw up stinkers and let down in the third quarter

The Celtics, like what they have gotten better at over the season... they still do it to an extent it happened in the third quarter as they just we'll just let down. And all of a sudden they have terrible runs... they just throw up stinkers. I think that's been, it's been the most, it was like this in Milwaukee series, like this, the Miami series.

The Celtics did have a tendency to lose leads and play inconsistent stretches, famously blowing several big leads in this specific Finals series before ultimately losing to the Warriors.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Warriors are impossible to beat if Steph Curry and Klay Thompson both have a night where they're 'on' from start to finish

If those two guys make all their shots, if they get to a night where they're both on, then they're pretty much impossible to beat. It doesn't matter how good the Celtics can play... but they're not going to be able to do that. Like that's not, it's impossible for them to sustain that type of basketball.

While Klay was inconsistent, Steph had a legendary series (including 43 points in Game 4) that ultimately proved the Warriors were not only beatable but capable of outplaying the Celtics' defense.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm convinced the Celtics are simply the better team and the only team that can beat them is themselves

I'm convinced now the Celtics just the better team. The only, the only team that can beat the Celtics is the Celtics. Like they have to beat themselves.

This turned out to be famously incorrect as the Warriors won the next three games straight to win the title, proving they were the better, more experienced team.
Win
HankHank

The Warriors need their role players to contribute if they want to win any more games in the Finals

They need their role players. If they're going to win games. It's like Steph, I mean, cause Steph and clay are the only ones that can score, but if they just do them up, like it's, I think they should win.

The Warriors did get key contributions from Wiggins, Looney, and GP2 in the final games, validating the idea that they needed more than just the Splash Brothers.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Celtics are simply the better team and the Warriors cannot beat them

I have now like game three, show me that the best, the best version of the Celtics, the warriors can not be. I'm being honest. That's just my honest take on it.

Incorrect. The Warriors won the next three games in a row to win the series 4-2.
Void
HankHank

I'm actually into watching the LIV Golf tour

I mean, if a fan, like I'm watching it... it's entertaining. I can't, I'm not gonna sit here and say, it's not.

Subjective opinion on entertainment.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Brooks Koepka is just messing with everyone and won't join LIV

Brooks, he did the eyeballs emojis. It actually was a good test run for us just in case any of our friends do joined the live tour because the part of my take group chat Brooks was fucking with everyone. He's not joining the live tour.

Incorrect. Brooks Koepka joined LIV Golf on June 22, 2022, shortly after this episode.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL salary cap isn't actually enforced and the league just sends 'strongly worded letters' to teams over the limit

My theory is that the NFL just said, okay, we're going to make a salary cap... but they don't actually have a guy that's tracking it and enforcing actual penalties... They just send a strongly worded letter saying you are currently $2 million over the salary cap... and then they just never follow up on that.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The NFL salary cap is strictly enforced with actual fines, draft pick forfeitures, and contract voiding; the Rams simply use clever accounting and restructures.
Loss
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

Jayson Tatum is the safer bet for Finals MVP

I'm going Jayson Tatum folks... I think Jayson Tatum is going to win the MVP because the Celtics are only, I don't want a series of Jayson Tatum has a few more good games and his passing in particular guys has been great... He's just slightly more complete and slightly more important to the Celtic success.

Incorrect. The Celtics lost the series, and Steph Curry won MVP. Even if they won, Jaylen Brown was often viewed as their most consistent player this series.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Steph Curry should win Finals MVP even if the Warriors lose the series

I'm hoping that we get a Celtic series win and Steph Curry gets his first finals MVP out of that. That would be the ultimate threading the needle.

Incorrect, as Curry won but his team also won the series.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

If the Celtics win the series 10 times, they win it 8 times

I think the Celtic surge is the only thing that can stop the self is this point of the Celtics, but they have to beat themselves... I would say if you play this series 10 times, the Celtics win it eight times.

The Warriors won 4-2, winning three straight after this take, suggesting the Warriors were actually the better team.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Danny Woodhead will eventually play in a US Open

I'll put my money on you someday being in a U.S. Open. I wouldn't, you know, betting against Danny Woodhead in like his will to [succeed].

Pending. Woodhead continues to play high-level amateur golf but hasn't qualified for the major yet.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If Danny Woodhead makes the cut in a US Open, I will shave every hair off my body

If you make the cut it's every hair. If you make the U.S. Open, I'll cut my hair into like regular lengths.

Danny Woodhead never actually made the field of a US Open, so the condition for the body-shaving was never met.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Warriors are dead

My fire Fest is obviously a, the warriors is dead. I truly believe that.

Incorrect. The Warriors won the title 4-2.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm betting on a Subway Series between the Mets and Yankees in the World Series

I'm putting in subway series, future. The Mets and the Yankees to meet in the world series. I think it's 14 to one... I just want to see it in this office and the chaos that ensues.

Incorrect. The Yankees reached the ALCS but were swept by the Astros. The Mets lost in the Wild Card round.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Orangutans regularly take hostages for food

Orangutans regularly take hostages for food.

While orangutans are highly intelligent and have been observed using tools and manipulative behaviors, 'regularly taking hostages' is an anthropomorphic exaggeration of opportunistic or aggressive behavior.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Will Levis is a future number one overall pick

Starting quarterback for the Kentucky Wildcats, Will Levis. Awesome interview with him. Number one pick, future number one pick.

Will Levis was not selected number one overall; he was drafted in the second round (33rd overall) by the Tennessee Titans in the 2023 NFL Draft.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The New York Rangers are the team of destiny

The New York Rangers are one game away from the Stanley Cup final let's go. Congratulations. New York. I just got vibes right now coming from New York Rangers. They feel like the team of destiny. They got the hottest goaltender in the planet.

The Rangers were up 2-0 against the Lightning in the Eastern Conference Finals but proceeded to lose four straight games, failing to reach the Stanley Cup Final.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 1995 Baltimore Stallions winning a Grey Cup more recently than a Canadian team winning a Stanley Cup is the craziest stat in sports

America has won a [Grey Cup] more recently than Canada has won a Stanley Cup. We don't have a team in the CFL anymore. We haven't had a team in the CFL for 25 plus years, but that's a crazy stat that Canada, the last cup they won, I think it was 93 Montreal, the 95 Baltimore Stallions won a [Grey Cup] more recently than they did win a Stanley Cup.

The Baltimore Stallions won the Grey Cup in 1995. No Canadian NHL team has won the Stanley Cup since the Montreal Canadiens in 1993.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 2022 Avalanche-Oilers series was the best four-game sweep in NHL history

That was the best four game series that I've ever seen. Well, the Edmonton Oilers played the best five game series beforehand. It's crazy how good those games were. A couple of them... there were so many exciting games, but unfortunately we only got four games worth out of it.

Subjective opinion on the quality of a series.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

It's a huge disappointment if the Avalanche don't win the Stanley Cup now

The Avalanche looked like the best team. Like if they don't win it now that's would, that's a big disappointment, big disappointment, huge disappointment.

The Colorado Avalanche went on to win the Stanley Cup, defeating the Lightning in the Finals.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LIV Golf should make the holes on the green larger to attract more eyeballs to the sport

I think that they're going to do something. That'll make the scoring a lot lower because they need to, you know, they need to attract eyeballs... make the courses easy. You make the holes a little bit bigger. I'm telling you place. Make the holes bigger though. Yeah, that'd be sick.

A satirical recommendation for a league's marketing strategy.
Void
HankHank

The new iMessage 'undo send' feature will empower gaslighters

The iMessage app in iOS 16 is getting a new undo send feature as well as the ability to edit chats. You've already sent in. Mark threads is unread. So rip to all the young people out there who are going to be getting gaslighted or say, like, I never said that.

The feature was indeed widely discussed for its potential to alter digital footprints and create confusion in interpersonal arguments.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Deshaun Watson should not be allowed to play in 2022 until the civil suits are resolved

I'm about ready to say, like I've seen enough and that I feel like Deshaun Watson should not be allowed to play this year until, until they figure out what's going to happen with the civil suits, because this is now 24 women. And with like strikingly similar details about what's happening.

Watson was eventually suspended for 11 games, so he did play during the 2022 season, albeit missing the majority of it.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The 2022 College Football Playoff field will be Alabama, Ohio State, Georgia, and Clemson

I was talking to people the other day and they were like, what, who do you think is going to be like the top four going into the pre-season next year? I was just off the top of my head, Ohio State, Alabama, Clemson... Georgia, Georgia, they've gotten a lot of transfers and they've gotten some talent.

The 2022-23 CFP consisted of Georgia, TCU, Michigan, and Ohio State. Big Cat correctly identified 2 of the 4 (Georgia and OSU), but Clemson and Alabama both missed.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes is already underpaid

When I first saw this, I thought like, Patrick Mahomes is already kind of underpaid. Oh yeah. So he signed that $500 million contract. What, two, three years ago. And it's crazy to say with a $500 million contract, but if you look at what the other big money being spent around the league is going to right now, it's like, you could very much make the argument that Patrick Mahomes should not have signed that deal.

Subsequent contracts for Burrow, Herbert, and Jackson surpassed Mahomes in annual average value, making his deal look better and better for the team.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Coach John Calipari should receive a 17-year contract extension

Instead of is coach Calipari on the hot seat, it's how many years should we extend him? Because right now, right now, coach Cal has seven lane duck years. You're staring right in the face of it seven years where he does, he might, how can you recruit? Let's get him 10 more years on top of that.

Hot TakeCBBScorchingSarcastic
Calipari did not receive a 17-year extension; he eventually left Kentucky for Arkansas in 2024.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The University of Washington is the new college basketball powerhouse

Washington is a great basketball school. Spencer Hawes, the Pacific Northwest is on the up and up. I mean, you look at the great products. They put out Markelle Fultz, Isaiah Thomas, Spencer Hawes. I mean they are. They're the new powerhouse right now.

Hot TakeCBBHotSarcastic
Washington finished the 2022-23 season with a mediocre 16-16 record and failed to make the NCAA Tournament, continuing a multi-year stretch of irrelevance.
Void
Will LevisWill Levis

Mayonnaise is undeniably a top 3 condiment

Undeniably a top three condiment. So versatile. And I it's just people against big Mayo, but I'm going to stand behind the movement and stay strong with my position on the subject. We've made sure to kind of find a plan that allows me to have Mayo in my diet as frequently as I can.

Condiment rankings are inherently subjective.
Loss
Will LevisWill Levis

Kentucky's goal and expectation is an SEC Championship in 2022

That's, that's the goal. That's, that's what our hearts are set on. And that's what's been established from day one of the off season. I'm definitely going to be stepping in and making sure that I'm the guy for the team.

Kentucky finished the 2022 season 7-6 (3-5 in the SEC) and did not qualify for the SEC Championship game.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers