Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
Big CatBig Cat

The relief in the Raiders' locker room after Josh McDaniels' firing will be insane

Josh McDaniels has to be the number one guy... thank God that asshole's gone. Like the relief in that locker room has to be insane.

Reports following the firing confirmed significant player celebration and a major shift in locker room atmosphere.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills vs. Bengals Sunday night game is a must-win for both teams

I think it's a must win for both these teams. Separation Sunday. Joe Burrow looks healthy. Everything looks like it's clicking. I'm so excited for this game.

The Bengals won the game, significantly boosting their momentum at the time, while the Bills' struggles continued.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Jaguars vs. Steelers game is the best matchup of the early Sunday slate

I think the best game is Jaguar Steelers in the noon slate. Jaguar's about to go on their buy, Steelers off a big win. Mike Tomlin is a home dog... it's a terrible towel statement game.

The Jags beat the Steelers 20-10 in a game that was mostly defensive; while it had some intrigue, other games that day (like Bengals-Niners) were arguably 'better' in quality.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Warren is a great running back and the Steelers need to give him the ball more

The Steelers are finally realizing that Jalen Warren is really fucking good... give Jalen Warren the ball more. Maybe make Najee Harris like a junior tight end.

Warren finished the 2023 season with over 1,000 total yards and was widely considered the most explosive back on the roster, proving Big Cat's assessment correct.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts' knee injury is a significant concern that is affecting his play

I think that Jalen Hurt's knee is a problem. And he also was asked about it... he said, 'I hope not.' The fact that we're even talking about it is kind of an issue. I just, he's throwing a lot of picks. Fumbles. The knee.

Hurts played through the injury but his rushing production dipped and the Eagles eventually collapsed in December, validating the concern that something was 'off'.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Arthur Smith is a sneaky genius for limiting Bijan Robinson's touches to keep him fresh

Could Arthur Smith be a sneaky genius? Could he be saying we just spent a lot of money on this first round pick running back. Don't put too many miles on him early in the season. Bijan is gonna look that much faster late in the year.

Arthur Smith was fired at the end of the season partly due to offensive underperformance and poor usage of star players. Robinson's production did not significantly peak later.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Trent Williams is the most important player on the 49ers offense

I think Trent Williams is [the most important player on the offense] for sure. Christian McCaffrey at 85% without Deebo Samuel and without Trent Williams... things look different.

Inherently subjective as it's an opinion on player importance.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Seahawks defense is genuinely elite and for real

I do believe in the Seahawks defense. I feel like they are, they're for real. They're, I'm gonna say it, really good Seahawks defense for real.

Seattle's defense fell apart late in the season, finishing 30th in total yards allowed and 25th in points allowed. They were not for real.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jared Goff is a top-five quarterback this season

I think Jared Goff has been playing... I think he's a top five quarterback in terms of this season.

Goff had a stellar 2023 season, finishing 2nd in passing yards and 4th in touchdowns, making this a very defensible top-5 claim for that year.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jared Goff is currently playing at an MVP level

And Jared [Goff] is playing, I'm gonna say he's playing at MVP level right now. Agreed. He's, he's in the MVP discussion. We just added him to the conversation right now.

Goff had a great season (4,575 yards, 30 TDs) and finished 7th in MVP voting, but was never a top-3 finalist.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Benching Desmond Ridder would mean the Falcons are giving up on the season

I think if you benched Desmond Ridder right now, it's, you're done, you're done over him... You're giving up.

The Falcons did eventually bench Ridder for Heinicke later in the season, and it coincided with their season falling apart and Arthur Smith's eventual firing.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills' Week 6 win over the Giants was actually a 'loss win'

The bills that they had, the win that they had against the Giants on Sunday night... it might be a loss win. A loss win. It might be a loss win.

Subjective label for a specific game performance.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL London games have lost their allure and are now a burden

I'm kind of sick of the London game. I like the early football. I'm sick of the fact that they have made something that was unique and different into just every week. This is the third week in a row. They're just changing the schedule on us. Now it doesn't feel cool and unique, it just feels like a burden.

This is a subjective consumer opinion on the entertainment value of the NFL's global expansion.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially back in on Justin Fields as the guy for the Bears

The Bears might be back if they win this game. And I am all the way back into Justin Fields. I liken it to a relationship where, listen, Justin Fields threw some interceptions, I said some things... but at the end of the day, don't go to bed angry. So I'm no longer going to bed angry. He's the guy again.

Fields was traded the following offseason after the Bears chose to draft Caleb Williams, proving Big Cat's 'he's the guy' stance was incorrect long-term.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

David Tepper is a meddling owner who is hurting the Panthers

[David Tepper] basically in those two quotes was like, 'Yeah, this guy is putting his nose where it shouldn't be and micromanaging a football team.' And that's not how a successful organization runs. You can't have the owner forcing the coach to have a meeting multiple times a week. He sounds like a miserable person to work for.

Tepper fired Frank Reich less than two months after this episode. His reputation as a meddling owner has only grown since.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dante Scarnecchia was the actual GOAT coach of the Patriots dynasty

I think as a podcast we should actually change the debate and make it Dante Scarnecchia was the GOAT. Why not? Option three.

This is a subjective opinion about the relative value of a position coach versus a head coach and QB.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brock Purdy is an MVP candidate

Should we be talking about Brock Purdy MVP Watch? If you look at his stats right now, Brock Purdy has MVP level stats right now. That's all I'm saying. He's the number one quarterback in the entire NFL in yards per attempt.

Brock Purdy finished 4th in the 2023 MVP voting and led the league in several efficiency metrics.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Russell Wilson has only looked better because he's played terrible defenses

Is there a chance that Russell Wilson, he's looked better, but he has not played a good defense? ...he played the Raiders, bad defense. Commanders, bad defense. He played the Dolphins, bad defense. And then last week they played the Bears, the worst defense. So is there a chance that we see bad Russ here against the Jets defense?

Wilson struggled in a 31-21 loss to the Jets, completing only 20 of 31 passes for 196 yards and lost a fumble that was returned for a TD.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders are the best 'bad' team in the NFL

I think we might be the best bad team. Really good, bad. Like if there was a Super Bowl of bad teams, the losers. The NIT. If the NFL had an NIT, I'd put the [Commanders] as a one seed.

The Commanders finished 4-13 in 2023, which actually made them one of the worst teams in the league, not even the 'best' of the bad ones.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL points are a finite resource; scoring 70 means you'll have fewer points later

I feel like points are a finite resource... They might have scored too many points last week [scoring 70]. Too many points.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
The Dolphins went from 70 points in Week 3 to 20 points in Week 4 against the Bills, supporting the 'regression' part of the theory even if the 'finite resource' logic is satirical.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Defense wins championships

Defense wins championships. I'll go to my grave thinking that. The Bucs defense smothered Patrick Mahomes [in the Super Bowl]. That was completely a defensive effort. The Patriots' last Super Bowl was a defensive effort when they stopped the Rams.

Subjective sports philosophy, though recent Super Bowl winners (Chiefs) often rely on elite QB play as much as defense.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

I want Jim Harbaugh to coach the Bears and draft Caleb Williams

I want Caleb Williams. I have said the names Caleb Williams and Jim Harbaugh probably a hundred times in the last four days. I want to bring back man football. Let Jim Harbaugh just stuff all the dorks in Halas Hall into a locker and just go back to being a man football team.

The Bears did draft Caleb Williams #1 overall in 2024, though Jim Harbaugh went to the Chargers.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL is officially bigger than Taylor Swift

Travis Kelce went to a Taylor Swift concert, right? Taylor Swift has gone to two Travis Kelce's games after this week. Seems like I was right. The NFL's bigger than Taylor Swift.

This is a subjective joke about cultural reach, impossible to factually resolve.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lions only have one player, Aidan Hutchinson, actually playing defense right now

The Lions... they've only got one dude playing defense. Yeah. [Aidan] Hutchinson and then nobody else.

While Hutchinson was their star, the Lions defense improved as the season went on, finishing mid-pack in many metrics and reaching the NFC Championship.
Void
HankHank

You can't appreciate a lighthouse if you don't go out to sea

It's good to get away from the lighthouse. It makes it that much better when you see it on the way back. You know, as any sailor knows, you can't appreciate a lighthouse if you don't go out to sea.

This is a poetic, subjective sentiment that cannot be proven or disproven.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Trevor Lawrence is phenomenal but lacks consistency

Trevor Lawrence is phenomenal, but it doesn't feel consistent. And we saw that against the Kansas City Chiefs.

Lawrence's 2023 season was marked by high variance and injuries, ending in the Jaguars missing the playoffs after an 8-3 start.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears vs. Chiefs game will be a fun game because of the circus surrounding Chicago

Even for the Bears, this is record speed for them to become a complete and utter circus... I am back to believing in Justin Fields because I have no other option... this is a complete clown gong show... and I'm excited. Yeah. This is gonna be a fun game.

The game was actually a miserable 41-10 blowout for the Bears, which was arguably only 'fun' for Chiefs fans or fans of comedy.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift are not actually dating

I think that Travis Kelce is not actually dating Taylor Swift. I think that this is, listen, we've been in the podcast game for a long time. We know it does numbers. Jason Kelce's a very smart guy. I think him going on the air and saying the rumors are a hundred percent true... You don't say a hundred percent if your brother's dating Taylor Swift.

The relationship was confirmed to be genuine and continued through the season and beyond.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Buffalo Bills must win convincingly against the Raiders to get their swagger back

It feels like the Bills have to win this game and they have to win it convincingly to get their swagger back a little bit. It does feel like it's kind of, I don't want to sound the alarm so bad, but the bills just, they need to win. They need to win this game and they need to do it well and they need to win by a lot.

The Bills won 38-10, fulfilling the 'convincing' requirement.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bears must implement designed runs for Justin Fields to make the defense uncomfortable

I speak on behalf of America and probably all Bears fans. When I say let Justin Fields run the ball. Let him everything, put in some design runs for him. Let him stretch the defense out. Let them let the defense get uncomfortable and try to figure out where he's going to go. And then the passing game opens up when you do that.

The Bears eventually leaned more into Fields' running, but it didn't solve all their offensive issues.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cardinals defense is sneaky good and they are coached to be a dirty team

I still think that their defense is gonna be pretty good. No, I'm saying that because if you watch the X videos and the Twitter chrome on it Max that defense was headhunting. They, they, they were coached that way. I'm telling you, watch the Cardinals this week. Tell me that they don't take like sneaky violent shots. They're, they're a dirty team.

The Cardinals defense was 31st in points allowed in 2023, though they were often more competitive than their talent suggested.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Deshaun Watson is the perfect quarterback for the Browns because his off-field issues prevent the media from over-hyping the team

Deshaun Watson, everything off the field, I think he's the perfect quarterback for, for the Browns... because a lot of people don't wanna talk about the Browns 'cause of Deshaun Watson. So it tempers the Browns hype. And the Browns are one of those teams I put in the category of like never overhype the Browns.

The Browns did fly under the radar for much of the season and made the playoffs, though Watson was injured for much of it.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Bill Belichick is the best head coach in the NFL to lead a team right now

Bill Belichick [is the first pick]. I was taking it no matter what Hank said. I'm a neutral journalist, [picking] the best of the 32.

Belichick went 4-13 in the 2023 season and mutually parted ways with the Patriots, showing he was no longer the elite coach he once was.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

John Harbaugh is a top-tier coach who would improve almost every team in the NFL immediately

John Harbaugh could step into any situation in the league except for maybe three and improve it. He's got a track record now... he's reinvented himself a couple times. And now he's really good at going with what his best players do best.

Subjective opinion on a coach's value, though Harbaugh remains highly regarded.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Getting the Lions to the precipice of the playoffs is equivalent to an NFC Championship for any other team

I'll take Dan Campbell. I think that coaching the lions is, everything's on a curve. So if you get the lions on the precipice of, of the playoffs, that's essentially like the NFC Championship game.

The Lions actually exceeded this 'curve' by reaching the real NFC Championship game later that season.
Void
MaxMax

Fernando Tatis Jr. is a 'vibes guy' you want in your clubhouse despite the PED suspension

Tatis is a vibes guy. I mean, that's a guy you want. That's a guy. I wanted my clubhouse... Tatis is a vibes guy. I mean, that's a guy you want. That's a guy. I wanted my clubhouse. [PFT: He's always suspended] Nah, he's a great guy.

Clubhouse 'vibes' are entirely subjective and can't be measured.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

CJ Stroud is a risky draft pick because he is an Ohio State quarterback

CJ Stroud is a very good QB. Very, very good. The only thing is that I got against him is that he's an Ohio State quarterback. And how many really great Ohio State quarterbacks we've seen coming out that just haven't really panned out

CJ Stroud had one of the greatest rookie seasons for a QB in NFL history, immediately debunking the 'OSU QB' stigma.
Push
Billy FootballBilly Football

Bryce Young is too small and has a slender frame that will lead to injuries

I get the Bryce Young hype. I get it. The thing is... you can't put 30 pounds on Bryce Young. His frame is, his frame is just, it does, it's not gonna work. If you look at his frame, he's slender at the shoulders... Because of that, like, he's gonna be more injury prone.

Bryce Young has struggled in the NFL, partly due to size concerns, though injury hasn't been the primary issue so much as performance behind a bad line.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

The New York media ruins Jets quarterbacks by sensationalizing negative news to gain clicks.

The New York media sensationalizes quarterbacks' performances to gain clicks and remain competitive in the big media market. Amplification of negative news and critiques elicits greater responses from the consumers, leading to a lack of confidence in the fan base, ultimately resulting in a destructive impact on the team and the quarterback's confidence.

This is a social/media theory that is inherently subjective, though the hosts argue it has some merit regarding click-driven journalism.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

Derek Carr would not work in New York because he is too sensitive to media criticism.

Derek Carr would not work [in New York]. He's too sensitive. He cries, he blocks everybody on Twitter. Like, his excuses wouldn't suffice for the New York [media].

Carr signed with the Saints, so his fit in New York was never tested, making this impossible to definitively verify.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL is rigged against the Cincinnati Bengals

If you wanna point fingers at the NFL being rigged against Cincinnati, this is probably their most legitimate complaint... they were kind of forced to play their starters last week to a certain extent so that they could guarantee themselves a home playoff game. The fact that they played their starters, they got some of them hurt last week, that's kind of fucked up.

The Bengals were indeed vocal about the unfairness of the coin-flip rule and did lose starters like Alex Cappa to injury in the final week.
Void
HankHank

I would rather watch the playoffs fan-free than have the Patriots make it just to get smoked

Honestly, I know I have to watch these games anyway. I would rather just watch the playoffs completely fan free because I know it's get my hopes up and be like, oh, you know, I have to worry about and like, kind of put myself up for them winning. Even though if they won the first game, they're getting smoked the second game. They're probably getting smoked the first game.

This is a subjective opinion on his own fandom experience.
Void
HankHank

Mac Jones is a dirty player

I think that was a, a cheap shock going at his Eli Apple's ankles for sure. He's had some dirty plays.

Subjective label of 'dirty' but based on a specific, widely-criticized tackle on Eli Apple.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets are a good team with Mike White and a bad team with Zach Wilson

I'm back on the Jets. Mike White. I really do think that they're, they're actually a good team with Mike White. They're such a bad team with Zach Wilson. I think the defense will get like a, you know, juiced up from it. I, the Seahawks have been very, very bad.

The Jets with Mike White lost to the Seahawks 23-6 and failed to score a touchdown in his final starts, contradicting the idea they were 'good' with him.
Void
MaxMax

Nathaniel Hackett is the worst coach of all time

Nathaniel Hackett officially fired... worst coach of all time.

This is a subjective opinion, though Hackett's tenure is widely regarded as one of the least successful for a first-year head coach in the modern era.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bills-Bengals is the best Monday Night Football game of all time based on records

I am so fucking excited for this game. Yes. It's, it's I think the best Monday night football game of all time considering the records of the teams playing in it.

The game was suspended and eventually canceled following the on-field medical emergency of Damar Hamlin, making it impossible to evaluate as a 'game' of any historical rank.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Russell Wilson has gotten fat this season

Is Russell Wilson fat? ... I think he's gotten fat. ... I think he's thick. He's fatter this year than he was last year. ... I think he's gotten chubby now.

Subjective physical observation, though Wilson's mobility and play were widely criticized that year.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Zach Wilson being benched for Mike White might actually light a fire under him and lead to a comeback

Big time with Zach Wilson being QB two now. I know. So there's a little fire underneath him... And then they win. And Billy Football's like Zach Wilson, future Patrick Mahomes. Zach's been begging to get let back in the house... they cracked the door. They're like, I know you're homeless. You can come inside, but you're sleeping on the couch.

OpinionFootballMediumSarcastic
Wilson eventually got back on the field due to injuries but his performance didn't significantly improve in 2022 or 2023, eventually leading to him being traded.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Minnesota Vikings are absolute frauds

I'll tell you why. Billy, let me take you to school real quick. You wanna hear some cold hard facts? Out of every single team to ever be 10 and 2 since the 1970 merger... the Vikings are by far and dead last for point differential. Their point differential is three times smaller than the second worst team. The Vikings, they're frauds.

The 2022 Vikings finished 13-4 with a -3 point differential. They were subsequently upset at home in the Wild Card round by the Giants, largely validating the 'fraud' label.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Detroit Lions are actually a good football team and America needs to realize it

The lions are good, the lions are, America needs to come to the realization that the, the Detroit lions are good at playing football.

The 2022 Lions finished 9-8, winning 8 of their last 10 games, including a Week 18 win to knock the Packers out of the playoffs, proving they were indeed a 'good' team by the end of the season.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers