Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

There is a specific feeling of being in a movie when the perfect song hits at the right time

When you have the perfect song Come On whether it be in the car or when you're walking and you feel like you're in a movie... when that perfect song hits for your mood for the weather for everything and it just feels like you are in the middle of your own movie.

This is a subjective emotional experience.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The perfect bite of pizza is the 'transition bite' right before you reach the full crust

My third one is going to be when you get the perfect bite of pizza and what I mean by that is it's got some crust but it also has some tomato sauce and cheese left right before you get full crust. So it's the transition bite... that is so deep to me.

This is a subjective food opinion and cannot be factually proven or disproven.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alex Smith will eventually land a front office job and make a lot of money

[Alex Smith] is regarded as one of the most solid dudes in the NFL... he's going to go somewhere in a front office and make a lot of money for a long time.

Alex Smith retired and became an analyst for ESPN rather than taking a front office role, though the door may still be open in the future.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The 2020 football season will feature the greatest tailgates of all time if fans are allowed

every football tailgate this is probably the greatest thing ever do you think that when we get back but I don't... it just doesn't seem realistic... if we hit the bars and we're like you know what I kind of miss being at home.

The 2020 NFL season mostly occurred with empty or limited-capacity stadiums, meaning the 'greatest tailgates ever' didn't happen until at least 2021 when full crowds returned.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dennis Rodman made rebounding 'cool' and 'sexy'

I love Dennis Rodman. I've always loved Dennis Rodman. He made rebounding cool. He made rebounding like seem like a sexy thing. He was so fucking incredible.

This is a subjective opinion on the aesthetic or 'cool' factor of a basketball skill.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dennis Rodman is a role model for finding a niche and becoming the best at it

I actually do think that Dennis Rodman is role model in a weird way in that if you can figure out something that you're the best at, it doesn't matter what weird little niche category it is in life. If there's one thing that you're better than everybody else that are more focused on, steer into that and get well really, really good at that and be known as the best to ever do that and you will be extremely successful.

The value of specializing in a niche is a widely accepted business and success philosophy, though calling Rodman a 'role model' is the provocative part.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michael Jordan's switch-hand layup against the Lakers was completely unnecessary

The layup that Michael Jordan had in the finals against the Lakers where he jumps in the air and switches hands—completely unnecessary to do that. It's a cool-looking highlight, he didn't need to do that. You could have just done a finger roll with his right hand; he switched to his left hand because it looked cool.

While physically true (he had a clear right-handed lane), the take is a value judgment on the necessity of style.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Michael Jordan will always view Scottie Pippen as 'weak' because of the migraine game

I honestly think the MJ Pippen relationship is so fascinating because I know that Michael Jordan knows deep down that Scottie Pippen was all time player and he needed them every bit for all these championships. But he has that one the migraine game... I think there's a part of Michael Jordan who will always look at [Pippen] and be like when the chips are down, you're just weak.

The documentary itself and subsequent interviews suggest Jordan did harbor lasting frustration over Pippen's physical setbacks, supporting the 'spirit' of this take.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Michael Jordan's hatred for Isiah Thomas is the strongest he's ever had for anyone

The last grudge I had and it's the best by far, Michael Jordan has never hated anyone as much as he hates Isiah Thomas and it's fucking awesome to watch how much he still holds onto it to this day... MJ just his hatred is so goddamn deep for him and it's fantastic to watch.

The documentary explicitly highlights this specific grudge as being uniquely bitter and lasting decades.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Phil Jackson is the master of managing different personalities to get them on the same page

What keeping these guys together—that's always been my biggest argument for Phil Jackson is how many times do you see teams win or not even teams win but like a bunch of different personalities and trying to get them all on the same page and he's clearly the master of that and figuring out a way to tap into every single guy and figure out exactly how every guy works and what makes them tick.

Broad consensus among NBA historians and players supports Phil Jackson's elite ability to manage ego-heavy locker rooms.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I don't think Roger Goodell has any friends

I am a little bit concerned about our Commish... I don't think that Roger Goodell has any friends. I don't think that a person would that personality? Yeah, like there's why is this a new news breaking because usually when you're that rich you have at least some people that will hang out with you... I think he has like business partners that he sees occasionally like the owners but just like going off his personality. I don't I want to volunteer to be his friend because I feel bad for him.

This is a subjective character judgment based on public persona.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL should adopt a hybrid draft format where the first round is live but later rounds are remote

If they can do a blend if they could do a hybrid it would be perfect. I would want the first round live with people in the draftees in the spot... but I agree with you like if we could do rounds 4 through 7 where everyone is remote and you can see into the room like living rooms of all the coaches and GM's that was fascinating.

The NFL has essentially moved in this direction, keeping the big stage for Round 1 but utilizing remote elements and varied locations for Day 2 and 3 picks.
Loss
HankHank

Jake Fromm will be the best quarterback from the 2020 draft class

I still think the potential is there. I think [Jake Fromm] is gonna be the best quarterback that comes out of this draft.

This take proved to be significantly incorrect. Joe Burrow, Justin Herbert, Jalen Hurts, and Jordan Love all became high-level starters, while Fromm has been a journeyman backup.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The best NFL draft strategy for teams who don't know what they're doing is to just load up on SEC West and Ohio State players

I like the Redskins strategy which seems to be—this is what I've been saying for a while is—if you don't if you have no idea how to draft just load up on SEC West players and then mix in Ohio State players every now and again and you'll get it.

While effective, this is a subjective opinion on roster-building strategy.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jameis Winston will start at least six games for the Saints this year

I have a bold prediction. I think Jameis is starting at least six games this year... I think Drew Brees is gonna get injured and miss at least six games this year and then Jameis would start those six games.

Drew Brees did get injured in 2020 (missing 4 games), but Taysom Hill started those games, not Jameis Winston. Winston only saw limited action.
Void
HankHank

Taysom Hill would have won the Saints' playoff game if he had played the whole time

[Taysom Hill] would have won the playoffs if he had been playing the whole game... Best player on the field against the Vikings fact, according to the Troy Aikman and everyone who had eyes.

Hill did have a massive game (50 yards rushing, 50 receiving, 50 passing), but whether they would have won if he started over Brees is purely hypothetical.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am 'Team J' in the Jay Cutler and Kristin Cavallari divorce

I'm team J. I don't know anything, I literally don't know anything, but I'm team J. ... That's my quarterback. Frat bros gotta stick together... I am team J forever and always unless noted he gets arrested for a felony.

This is purely a matter of personal show loyalty and cannot be objectively proven correct or incorrect.
Void
CA
Criss Angel

I consider myself an athlete because of how physical and MMA-focused my magic shows are

I consider myself [an athlete] because of the type of show I do—very physical show. I do a lot of MMA training... I have to really be especially at 52 now. I got to be really flexible and really athletic or else I'll not be able to do a lot of these things.

This is a subjective self-assessment of his profession and physical capabilities.
Void
CA
Criss Angel

The media is adding to the COVID-19 hysteria and needs to focus more on hope and positivity

I just think that the media is not helping because they're adding to the hysteria. Yes, we need information. We need to know but we also need to have hope... we also need to put positivity in the world and love in the world... It's not going to be the end of the world. We are all going to go on. We're all going to move on and we're going to thrive.

The effect of media tone on public psyche is a matter of psychological and social opinion.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL teams should be allowed to use a draft pick to own the rights to a college coach

Is it possible that you could draft a coach? Could you use a draft pick on a college coach to prevent another team from hiring them to be on their roster? ... If you think that hypothetically the Los Angeles Chargers are going to hire Urban Meyer as coach next year, why wouldn't you if you're in the AFC West draft Urban Meyer and then you have his rights for at least the next year so they can't hire them?

Mike Florio calls in later to confirm this is absolutely not allowed under NFL rules as coaches must be signed to contracts, not drafted like players.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Doing the dishes is the absolute worst chore because it deters people from ever cooking at home

Doing the dishes is the worst because you also just ate so you're like all I want to do is sit down and just relax and then you got to get up and do the dishes... Doing the dishes have deterred millions upon millions of people from ever cooking at home because they suck so much.

This is a relatable subjective observation about human behavior and chores.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Contracting toxoplasmosis from cats will make you a fearless 'Berserker' warrior

45% of the population has this parasite called toxoplasmosis that comes from cat feces... it makes mice not fear predators so they just wander on and then the cats eat it... I want to be fearless. The Berserker cult has to contract toxoplasmosis and we'll all just be fearless Berserker warriors... when I contract toxoplasmosis, I will be an absolute fearless warrior and it will be sick.

While toxoplasmosis is linked to behavioral changes in rodents and some studies suggest links to risk-taking in humans, intentionally contracting a parasite for 'warrior' traits is medically ill-advised and doesn't function as a superpower.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

The 'giant baby' on the internet should be put on a steroid and protein schedule to become an NFL left tackle

I want to find that baby and start putting creatine and whey protein in its formula and then make it like an All-Pro left tackle... It's child abuse to not be abusing his childhood putting it to work... he needs to be put on schedule now where he's not going to you know where else we can put this giant.

This is a satirical/absurd proposal that is not meant to be a verifiable claim.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Vrabel won the night for best NFL Draft home setup.

Mike Vrabel clearly won the night in his room. He had a guy that looked like a mix between the Waterboy Adam Sandler and Joe Dirt. The other was taking a shit. I believe he's sitting on a Barstool intentionally looking like he's making sure in my professional opinion.

This was a widely agreed-upon sentiment on social media during the draft night.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The gap between Tua Tagovailoa and Justin Herbert is massive.

The smoke of Justin Herbert jumping Tua [Tagovailoa] was making me so mad because Tua is so much better than Justin Herbert. No offense, Justin Herbert. He might end up being good but Tua is control good and the gap between Joe Burrow and Tua is miniscule. The gap between Tua and Justin Herbert is massive.

While subjective, Justin Herbert won Offensive Rookie of the Year and statistically outpaced Tua in several early seasons, making this highly debatable if not arguably incorrect based on early career trajectories.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Roger Goodell was definitely drunk during the first night of the 2020 NFL Draft.

Let's talk about Goodell for a second. Is he okay? Because no, he was drunk. How is he that bad at talking in his living room when all you had to do was like two lines every 10 minutes? He was sluggish, he was not pronouncing words correctly, he was turning red in the face. He changed outfits to get more comfortable halfway through. He tried to hug Caesar Ruiz through his television. He saw a big dude getting drafted and was like 'this is the guy I gotta give the bro hug to.'

While Goodell's performance was widely mocked for being awkward and low-energy, there is no proof he was actually intoxicated.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Roger Goodell is depressed because the new CBA took away his hobby of collecting urine samples.

I think Roger Goodell is depressed because in the CBA they gave up his rights to go collect piss from everybody. That's like his hobby. That's like taking away that one week of fishing that Nick Saban does every year.

This is a purely comedic claim based on the changes to drug testing in the 2020 CBA.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys will have an elite offense but finish 8-8 and miss the playoffs.

I feel like [CeeDee Lamb] is the best wide receiver in the draft and now we can perform, now we can have even more of the 'Cowboys are incredible but they're going to finish 8-8.' And they're going to score a million points and it's going to be like statistically the greatest offense in the world, but they somehow only scored 14 points when they played the Redskins and they're going to miss the playoffs.

In 2020, the Cowboys finished 6-10 and missed the playoffs. While they didn't go 8-8, the prediction that they'd miss the playoffs despite offensive hype was correct.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers squandered their first-round pick by drafting a backup quarterback while in win-now mode.

The Packers were in the NFC Championship Game this year. You would think that a team that was that close to the Super Bowl... should probably draft a position they can start right away. They absolutely needed a wide receiver. The funniest part about this whole thing was if you were to list their needs, it was number one by far we need a wide receiver and instead they took a quarterback. I feel like look, the Packers just basically squandered a first-round pick when they're in win now mode.

The Packers did not draft a WR in the 2020 draft, and Jordan Love did not contribute for several years, supporting the 'win-now' squander argument.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers will demand a trade following the Packers drafting Jordan Love.

As an owner of the Packers, I feel like Aaron Rodgers might demand a trade. I feel like he's the kind of guy that is going to want to get out of town as soon as possible because this is going to be disrespect to him. Either that or he'll tell Danica like give him one of those crystals you got from Chernobyl.

Rodgers famously became disgruntled, eventually demanded a trade in the 2021 offseason (though he stayed), and was finally traded in 2023.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

People with square jaws are naturally more trustworthy and competent.

John Lynch just looks super competent all the time. He looks like a guy that you would trust. His square jaw... square jaws can be trusted a lot. And he's always like leaning forward. Just the body language makes me believe that whatever he's doing, he's doing for all the right reasons and that he knows exactly what he's going to get out of it.

This is a subjective observation on physical appearance and leadership perception.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McCarthy always looks like he's having an allergic reaction to shellfish.

Mike McCarthy always looks like he's having a reaction to shellfish. Yeah, it's like swelling up a little bit. Yes, a little like but got stung by maybe like three or four bees.

Purely subjective visual observation.
Push
JL
Jordan Love

Candy sent out for Heisman campaigns is good forever and will not expire.

I heard it's a good forever as lifelong candy... [Tom Fornelli] should be good. But if you get sick, you know, I didn't say anything.

While hard candy lasts a long time, most food items eventually expire or degrade in quality.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The legal system would break if everyone collectively stopped responding to jury summons.

What if we all just stopped going to jury summons? They can't bring in new juries to try us. Solidarity. They also can't arrest people right now. That's illegal. If a police officer tries to arrest you, you can arrest him.

While a total lack of jurors would stall trials, failure to respond to a summons is still a punishable offense.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Tomato juice only tastes good when you are on a flight.

Tomato juice is so gross to pick and anyone who says 'oh, it's not that bad' they're just lying because they like it with vodka... I've noticed that people only drink tomato juice on flights... Tomato juice tastes better on an airplane.

Scientific studies by Lufthansa and others have confirmed that dry cabin air and low pressure reduce sensitivity to sweet and salty, but leave umami (found in tomatoes) relatively intact, making it taste better by comparison.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dasani is the worst bottled water in the world.

My first one I'm going to go straight forward and say Dasani. Dasani water is trash, all of it, it's the world's worst water. It just tastes like shit.

Subjective taste preference, though Dasani is famously mocked on the internet.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Coconut water is a lie and tastes terrible.

I'm gonna go with coconut water. Trash. Someone tried to sell us that coconut water fixes hangovers. That's a fucking lie. Coconut water stinks. I don't like it. It just gives you a weird aftertaste. Just drink regular water.

Taste is subjective; scientific studies on its hangover-curing properties are mixed.
Loss
HankHank

There is no difference between 1%, 2%, and whole milk.

I do [drink whole milk]... I just have strong bones. I bet you big guy, we do a taste test, I would be able to... there's no difference.

A blind taste test on a subsequent episode proved that there is a very obvious difference between the types of milk, and Hank failed.
Void
HankHank

Any soda with 'Zero' in the name is not a real soda and is trash.

Any soda that has a zero is just not a real soda. You try and get it as an option called Mountain Dew Zero, Sprite Zero... Trash.

This is a subjective taste preference.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Brooks Koepka looks like a crooked Florida highway patrolman with his mustache.

He looks like a combination of every host of Cum Town. He looks like a crooked cop. With the mustache, he looks like a crooked Florida highway patrolman. A crooked cop that will just take the cocaine right off of you and send you on your way.

Subjective aesthetic observation.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tom Brady's Twitter game is currently terrible.

Tom Brady's Twitter game sucks already. Can someone tell Tommy he doesn't have to have the '@' in front of his name? He said unnecessary '@'. I quote one of his tweets and said 'can someone tell Tommy he doesn't have to have the at in front of his name?' 20 minutes later it was gone. It was gone because someone did. I shamed him.

Brady's social media management was highly scrutinized at the time for being too polished/fake.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Byron Leftwich can throw a ball farther than Tom Brady can right now.

I bet you Byron Leftwich can throw a ball farther than Tom Brady right now. He's another one of those guys saying like 'where's the... I just get out there and pearl cannons to each other.' Leftwich could be 70 years old and having his old offensive lineman carry him around on one leg and throw an 85 yard bomb.

While Leftwich had a cannon, Brady's arm strength in 2020 was still elite for his age. This was never tested on a field.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm pivoting Leroy into grading the scoops of actual insiders instead of breaking news

I'd like to pivot [Leroy] out of the breaking news game, put him out to stud, put him out to retire... and then use the account to grade the scoops of actual insiders. Leroy serves as the judge and says this scoop goes to [whoever].

The Leroy account did occasionally interact with other insiders, but the formal 'grading' system was not consistently maintained.
Win
HankHank

I don't think Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski will retire as Buccaneers, unless they win a Super Bowl

Do you think Tom Brady and Gronk will retire as Buccaneers when they go into Canton? No. I think it might [happen] if they win a Super Bowl, but there's definitely like a one side of me [that] makes it sense... it's like a one last hurrah, to Florida, nice weather... I just can't do it. I can't be like the biggest Bucs fan.

While both had iconic careers in New England, winning a Super Bowl in Tampa Bay cemented their Bucs legacy; however, Brady ultimately signed a one-day contract to retire as a Patriot.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Bill Belichick is cold-blooded and will always choose assets over personal beef

Belichick is the most likely [to make the Gronk trade]. He's like, oh I get a free asset. Most other coaches would be like no. I'm going to let my personal beef standing between me and making the right choice. Belichick is so cold blooded. He'll just be like, yes, I will get something for nothing.

The Patriots successfully turned a retired Gronkowski into a 4th-round draft pick (which became Justin Rohrwasser).
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Patriots only let Tom Brady go to Tampa Bay because they couldn't prove tampering, and it's actually a master plan by Bill Belichick to get draft picks

The only reason the Patriots let Tom go to Tampa Bay was that they couldn't wrap them into a tampering charge... this could be Belichick's master plan to get Tampa docked all the draft pictures and to have both Tom and Gronk returned to New England with like three extra third rounders.

No tampering charges were ever filed, and Brady and Gronkowski went on to win a Super Bowl in Tampa Bay.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Buccaneers should use Rob Gronkowski as a wide receiver instead of a tight end

I think Bruce Arians... he sees Mike Evans and he's like, Rob Gronkowski has lost 25 pounds, 30 pounds. If we can have one big wide receiver, that's awesome. Let's just use Gronk as a wide receiver.

Gronk remained a tight end for the Buccaneers, where he was a key part of their blocking and receiving scheme.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Chargers' new uniforms are objectively amazing

The Chargers release theirs and they're amazing. The Chargers proved—I actually love that... we needed a uniform drop to keep the internet honest. Whereas like, these are objectively amazing.

Uniform quality is subjective, but the general consensus and sales data supported the claim that they were a massive success.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA will never play again in 2020

I don't think they're going to play again ever. I heard a nasty rumor today... I've canceled sports for 2020 you guys got mad at me for that.

The NBA did return in 2020 with the Orlando Bubble.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

College football will not happen in 2020

College football's not happening. I don't think it is until the spring. How can you make kids who are not getting paid go and play if there's a pandemic?

College football did happen in the Fall of 2020, though with varied schedules and some conferences (Big Ten/Pac-12) initially postponing.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers