Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jim Gaffigan's claim that he played football at Georgetown is a 'perfect crime' lie

I don't think you actually played football at Georgetown. Because you say that you played football there, but that's the perfect crime to say that you played football at a school that is Division III and no longer really keeps records of those games back. I could say I was the starting center on the Hartford Whalers.

Jim Gaffigan did indeed play football at Georgetown (and Purdue) as a lineman.
Loss
Jim GaffiganJim Gaffigan

I think Tom Brady is going to sign with the Tennessee Titans

I think [Tom Brady] is going to the Titans. Because of Vrabel. They've got a running back. They've got a good team. They've got salary cap.

Tom Brady signed with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in March 2020.
Void
Jim GaffiganJim Gaffigan

Men turn uglier and uglier as they get older

As you get older, men turn uglier and uglier... George Clooney and Brad Pitt, those guys are flukes. That was like a mistake. I would say that most guys are disgusting, right? It's just a known fact.

Purely subjective comedic observation.
Void
Jim GaffiganJim Gaffigan

Comedy will see a trend back toward heckling in the next few years

There's going to be a trend towards [heckling], back to it. You know, like the whole roasting trend has really kind of brought that out too.

While crowd work and 'roast' culture have grown on social media, whether this constitutes a 'trend back to heckling' is subjective and difficult to quantify.
Loss
HankHank

Madison Prewett will win The Bachelor because her dad is the Auburn coach

My prediction is there is a girl who is a four-time state championship basketball player, and she goes to Auburn, and her dad is the coach of Auburn... My money's on her. Clearly, she knows the long haul, the grind.

Peter Weber initially became engaged to Hannah Ann Sluss; while he and Madison Prewett attempted a relationship after the finale, she did not 'win' the show.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

John Green was a much better online researcher than Deanna Thompson

John Green dominated [Deanna Thompson] in terms of researching things online... At the end, when he and [Deanna] were sitting at the diner, and she was like, 'I would have quit without you,' and he was like, 'I know you would have.'

This is a subjective ranking of the two individuals' contributions as depicted in the film.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The online cat-hunter group is somewhat responsible for the murder in 'Don't F*ck With Cats'

Media and our obsession with crime documentaries and their obsession with finding someone... they are somewhat responsible. There are psycho people out there, but [Luka Magnotta] wanted to be chased and they chased him. We kind of gave it all to him.

This is a moral and sociological opinion on the events of the documentary.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The murderer in Don't F*ck With Cats was not a genius mastermind

This guy is not as smart as everyone's making him out to be. He is not some mastermind. He's a fucked up piece of shit... he's narcissistic and he got caught in like three days.

Magnotta was indeed caught shortly after fleeing and left his own name/address in the trash, supporting the 'not a genius' claim.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 2020 Wild Card weekend was the most thrilling in NFL history

That was an insane, insane Wild Card weekend. Probably, I wouldn't say the best Wild Card weekend because I honestly just can't remember all the Wild Card weekends off the top of my head. But it was probably the most thrilling.

Subjective; 2020 Wild Card weekend was highly rated, but 'most thrilling' is an opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Deshaun Watson is the Michael Jordan of the NFL

When Dabo Swinney says [Deshaun Watson] is Michael Jordan, that's what he's talking about. The fact that he has that poise and that one play where he got sacked twice, spun around and made a play.

Subjective comparison of greatness across sports.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is like Brett Favre with ADD

He was playing like a little kid just hopped up on sugar, just running around, making plays. He was like Brett Favre if Brett Favre had ADD.

The comparison is a matter of opinion regarding playing style.
Loss
HankHank

The Patriots dynasty is not over despite losing to the Titans

The season is finished. The dynasty is not done. ... I don't see Brady going anywhere else. I understand that it's the first time in his career he can do whatever he wants, but realistically, it's one of those things where you can do whatever you want, but you don't want to leave your job.

Tom Brady left the Patriots for the Buccaneers in March 2020, and the Patriots failed to win another Super Bowl in the post-Brady era, effectively ending the dynasty.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bill Belichick is the reason for the Patriots' sustained success because he knows exactly when to cut players

The reason why you guys have had such sustained, insane success that probably we'll never see again in the NFL is because [Belichick] always knows when a guy needs to go. ... Bill Belichick essentially is like those hackers that the FBI hires to, like, hack into their own mainframe to find all the loopholes.

General consensus among NFL analysts regarding Belichick's philosophy.
Loss
HankHank

The Patriots are on the verge of starting a third dynasty

They've had two dynasties. People aren't really giving it like, the dynasty's over. The second dynasty's over. Double dynasty. Started the third act for the Patriots. ... I think if they win next year, it would be part of the second dynasty. But then if they win the year after that, then it's like... a third dynasty.

The Patriots did not win another Super Bowl with Tom Brady (he left and won with the Bucs), and they entered a period of significant struggle following his departure.
Loss
HankHank

Jameis Winston is worth more money than Tom Brady right now

Who's worth more money, Jameis Winston or Tom Brady? Jameis. ... He's just got more years. Yeah, he's 26. And he's a future Hall of Famer.

Jameis Winston became a career backup shortly after this while Brady won another Super Bowl. Winston is not tracking toward the Hall of Fame.
Void
HankHank

I would rather have a bad quarterback than draft Tua Tagovailoa

I don't want to deal with the bullshit media for like a year being like Tua and Tua and Tua. ... I'd rather have a bad quarterback than a good quarterback. ... A Big Ten, some Big Ten, or like random MAC quarterback.

The Patriots eventually drafted MAC QB Mac Jones in 2021, and while Tua has faced media scrutiny, he has been significantly more successful than Jones.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Saints would have won if they kept Taysom Hill on the field

But if Taysom Hill stays out there, they win that game. ... Taysom Hill was electric. He was the best player on the field.

Taysom Hill did have a massive impact (passing, rushing, receiving), while Brees struggled with turnovers. However, we can't definitively know the outcome if Hill played every snap.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kirk Cousins will fail against the 49ers in the divisional round

Kirk Cousins wasn't incredible in this game. Oh, he's going to shit down his leg in San Francisco in a week.

The Vikings lost 27-10 to the 49ers on January 11, 2020. Kirk Cousins had only 172 yards and one interception, largely failing to move the offense.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jadeveon Clowney's hit on Carson Wentz was assault

Jadeveon Clowney with the cheapest hit on Carson Wentz concusses him. ... Anyone who's calling Carson Wentz injury prone off of that is fucking bullshit because Jadeveon Clowney assaulted him.

The hit was highly controversial and not flagged, though later the league admitted it should have been a penalty. 'Assault' is hyperbolic but reflects the mood.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Capitals will win the 2020 Stanley Cup

My who's back of the week is the Washington Capitals. So it is 2020. It is even year bullshit for the Capitals. They win the Stanley Cup every year. They won in 2018. They're about to win it again.

The Tampa Bay Lightning won the 2020 Stanley Cup. The Capitals were eliminated in the first round.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Derrick Henry would rush for 400 yards in an NFL game if given 57 carries

If he played the worst team in the NFL, he could probably get, if he ran him 57 times, he could probably get 400 yards.

The NFL record for rushing yards in a game is 296 (Adrian Peterson) on 30 carries. 400 yards would require over 7 yards per carry on 57 attempts, which is statistically improbable but theoretically possible for Henry in his prime.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Titans and Ravens will have one of the shortest games in NFL history because they both just run the ball

It's going to be interesting seeing the Titans play against the Ravens next week because, I mean, that's probably going to be one of the shortest games in NFL history. It's going to be run the ball, run the ball, run the ball, run the ball.

While it was a run-heavy game (Derrick Henry ran for 195 yards), the game lasted a standard amount of time for a playoff broadcast.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sean Payton will leave the Saints for the Dallas Cowboys and take Taysom Hill with him

Ooh, what about... You think what I'm thinking? Sean Payton. Sean Payton just lost today. It's true. He's been linked. He's got family in Dallas. ... Taysom Hill goes with him. Like Al Pacino and Willie Beeman.

Sean Payton stayed with the Saints through 2021 and eventually joined the Broncos in 2023. Mike McCarthy was hired by the Cowboys in 2020.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jerry Jones will fire Jason Garrett at halftime of one of the wild card games

I actually think at this point he will fire Jason Garrett like at halftime of one of the wild card games just so that we can talk about it or he might just give him a contract extension on the 14th.

Jason Garrett was officially fired on January 5, 2020, following the wild card games, but not during a halftime show.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Dave Gettleman is only hiring 'computer folks' for show and won't actually listen to them

He's hiring computer folks. I was joking when I when I saw that clip that it really is like your dad when he gets too many viruses on his laptop... He's not going to actually listen to them. No, that's the thing. He's just hiring them to say that he has computer folk.

Gettleman's tenure was widely criticized for failing to modernize, and he was eventually replaced by Joe Schoen who fully overhauled the analytics department, suggesting the initial 'computer folks' hire didn't change much.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Rhule will be the next head coach of the New York Giants

Who do you think gets the job for the Giants? Matt Rhule. If [Rhule] can get his own Smock I think is going to be the Giants.

Matt Rhule signed a massive contract to become the head coach of the Carolina Panthers just days after this episode aired.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer coaching the Cleveland Browns would be assisted suicide

Urban Meyer coaching the Browns would be assisted suicide. He cannot—he is the man who losses kill him. They take away part of his life like the battery life in his body. If he goes to the Browns he will die.

Urban Meyer did not coach the Browns; he eventually coached the Jaguars, which was indeed a catastrophic failure that ended early, supporting the spirit of the take.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Redskins will win eight games next year under Ron Rivera

I'm dangerously close to being back all in on the our words [Redskins] and by all in I think maybe they win 8 games next year. Woah. Yeah, that's a lot.

The Washington Football Team won 7 games in 2020, narrowly missing the 8-win mark but winning the NFC East.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin will never be a national title contender

Wisconsin never going to be a national title contender. The Rose Bowl is the Super Bowl and I'm fine with that. Some people call that loser talk that's called being a realist fan.

Wisconsin has not made the CFP since this take and has generally declined from their 2010s peak.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Gus Johnson is not a good football announcer

I just firing off some takes that I've been sitting on and I got ratioed because I don't think Gus Johnson is a good football announcer. Okay. And people got mad.

This is entirely subjective.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Buffalo Bills will beat the Houston Texans 17-10 on Saturday

The final score will be 17 to 10. Yep, and the Buffalo Bills will win. Whoo. Okay, put it in stone.

The Texans beat the Bills 22-19 in overtime. Big Cat got the winner and the score wrong.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Patriots will beat the Titans easily and make everyone look stupid

This feels like one of those games where everyone is going to talk themselves into the Patriots being done... they're going to beat the Titans easily and everyone's be like damn we Feel stupid.

The Titans beat the Patriots 20-13, which turned out to be Tom Brady's final game as a Patriot.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ryan Tannehill is not afraid of Tom Brady and the Titans will win

I'm taking the Titans. Okay, I think that Tannehill is the one quarterback that is not afraid of Tom Brady. He's beaten him four times... now we got Tannehill he's going to go in there. I think that the Titans are going to win.

The Titans won 20-13.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins is going to look 'so short' playing in the Superdome

Kirk Cousins on the road and the Dome. He's gonna look so short. You know look so short. You know what else this is—this is also I just thought about this but Sean Payton hasn't done any weird motivational gimmicks this year.

This is a subjective aesthetic opinion that Big Cat applies to many quarterbacks, notably Cousins and Drew Brees.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Xavier Rhodes is going to get torched and be terrible in the Wild Card game

Can we just get Xavier Rhodes' name trending before the game because it's going to happen. He's going to get torched and get mad about it. So we should like pre-trend him so that everyone just knows like hey, here's a heads-up Xavier Rhodes is going to be terrible.

The Vikings actually upset the Saints, and while Rhodes had a difficult season in 2019, he didn't have a signature 'torched' performance in this specific playoff win.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are my lock of the year against the Seahawks

I'm taking the Eagles because it's Tony's it's my Tony Danza lock the lock of the Year. Okay. I mean, I'm not an idiot. I'm going to also take Tony Danza.

PredictionFootballHotSarcastic
The Seahawks beat the Eagles 17-9.
Void
Doug FlutieDoug Flutie

Frosted Flakes milk is a top-five milk

Frosted Flakes milk is a top-five milk. I think. Oh, no doubt. No doubt.

This is subjective cereal ranking.
Void
Doug FlutieDoug Flutie

I would be much more successful in today's NFL spread offenses

I'm a little jealous of what's going on right now with the spread offenses. It makes it a lot easier for a smaller guy to be successful in run the quarterback draw... we were running RPOs [in Canada] in '94, '93.

While testable in theory, it's a hypothetical claim about the evolution of the game.
Win
Doug FlutieDoug Flutie

Notre Dame will not win a national championship anytime soon

Are they gonna win a National Championship? Not soon. I don't think so. They're not bad. They will be in that college football playoff picture every year to be a top ten team... but there are some things that make it much more difficult at Notre Dame to win a National Championship.

As of the 2023-24 season, Notre Dame has still not won a national championship.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am going to bench press 215 pounds in 2020

My New Year's resolution is to... be able to bench press 215 pounds. So what would be—which will be really helpful for you... 215 once. Yeah.

Personal fitness goal (Big Cat benching 215 lbs in 2020). COVID lockdowns complicated gym access, and the outcome is unverifiable from public records.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Juggling is the ultimate flex move and only exists to make other people feel inferior

The problem with juggle guys is when were you break it out where everyone isn't like fuck you man. I've said every time someone I was like what? Okay, cool. Dude. Juggling is such a flex move... they're just like rubbing your face.

This is a humorous subjective opinion on social etiquette.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Pete Carroll took a deliberate delay of game to avoid another goal-line mistake with Marshawn Lynch

I actually think conspiracy theory here that Pete Carroll took the delay game on purpose because he didn't want to be stuck in a situation where he screwed up on the one-yard line again with Marshawn Lynch back... Pete Carroll kind of saved himself from himself by backing it up to the 6-yard line.

While the delay of game was a major mistake, there is no evidence it was a psychological ploy by Carroll to avoid a goal-line decision.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Russell Wilson is the best quarterback to have with the ball at the end of a game

In terms of quarterbacks I want to have the ball at the end of the game, [Russell Wilson] is my number one. Yeah, he's my number one, even though they didn't score there, he's still my number one because he did everything to get them to score.

Subjective opinion on quarterback clutchness.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kyle Shanahan lowered the 49ers' win probability by 19% by punting on fourth and one

Kyle Shanahan you kind of let me down by punting there on fourth and one when your offense is so good... their percentage to win the game went down by 19 percent by punting instead of going I thought they should have gone for it.

Analytical models at the time generally agreed that punting in that specific high-leverage fourth-and-short situation was a significant win-probability error.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jameis Winston's entertainment value to the NFL is worth over $30 million a year

I actually think that as far as entertainment value goes [Jameis Winston's] worth for the NFL is worth well over 30 million dollars. Yes because of what he delivers to the fans... please give Jameis the bump so we can see him in Sunday night and Monday night all next year.

Jameis did not get $30M; he signed a one-year, $1.1M deal with the Saints for the 2020 season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Falcons are the clear 'Dark Horse' team for the 2020 NFL season

They are perfectly perfectly placed to be one of the Dark Horse teams in 2020 because they finished the season on a high note... this will definitely be the you'll be sitting September 2020... and someone probably Strahan will probably say you know which team I really got my eye on the Atlanta Falcons.

The Falcons finished the 2020 season 4-12, proving once again that the 'hot finish to a losing season' narrative rarely carries over.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Patriots will beat the Titans in the Wild Card round but then lose to the Chiefs

I feel like the [Patriots are] going to roll the Titans and everyone's going to buy back in and then they're going to lose the Chiefs.

The Patriots lost to the Titans in the Wild Card round (20-13), so they did not roll them or play the Chiefs.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Titans will beat the Patriots in the Wild Card round

I think I think the Titans take [the Patriots].

The Titans defeated the Patriots 20-13 on January 4, 2020.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kevin Harlan is the best play-by-play announcer in all sports

Kevin Harlan I actually was thinking about this because he... honestly might be my favorite play-by-play like all sports.

Subjective opinion on broadcasting quality.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers looks miserable and doesn't seem to love playing football anymore

Does Aaron Rodgers love football? Yes. He he has the worst body language I've ever seen... deep down you have to ask yourself is something up because he looks miserable playing football. The first half he was missing wide-open guys.

While Rodgers went on to win MVPs in 2020 and 2021, the 2019 season was statistically one of his least efficient, lending some weight to the observation of his frustration at that time.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers