Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

UConn's dominance is ruining women's college basketball

I have not heard enough of the UConn women's college basketball ruining women's college basketball takes this year.

Whether dominance 'ruins' a sport is an unresolvable matter of opinion.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I wouldn't be shocked if Loyola Chicago won the whole NCAA tournament

I wouldn't be shocked if they actually won the whole thing because they are playing unbelievable offense. And I mean, like the Butler team, you know, ...

Loyola Chicago lost to Michigan in the Final Four, failing to win the national championship.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

John Beilein is the best coach in college basketball

John Beilein, he's the best coach in college basketball. I said it before the tournament. Their defense is unbelievable. Their offense has kind of finally shown up.

This is a subjective opinion, though Beilein led Michigan to the title game this year.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Leonard Hamilton didn't foul at the end of the Florida State game to help boosters cover the spread

I still maintain, and I've long time maintained this, that the coaches coach for spreads for boosters... what are the chances if you foul him, are you not going to cover the four and a half? Very high. Right. So you've got to make a business decision, a little Cam Newton business decision, say, no foul.

This is a speculative claim about motive that cannot be verified.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Villanova is hands down the best team in the tournament

I think they're hands down the best team in the tournament. And they have a ginger that dunks. Which is very deceiving, right? It's like, you have it all. What do you get a team that has it all? You got guys who can shoot. You got guys who can play down low. You got NBA draft picks.

Villanova won the 2018 National Championship, confirming they were the best team.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I bet $100 on the Washington Capitals to win the Stanley Cup

I had Hank get us a future. Me, Bubba, and Hank each put in $100. We got a future... The Washington Capitals outright winner... We'll win $4,800 if they win.

The Washington Capitals won the 2018 Stanley Cup, making this a winning bet.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Shark Week sucks until they show a shark eating a human being

Until they show me a shark eating a human being, I will not watch Shark Week... I still think I saw through the fraud of Shark Week... they told me they found Megalodon and they got me all wet and didn't fuck me.

This is a subjective opinion about the quality of a TV program.
Loss
HankHank

I believe the guy who claims to be Bill Clinton's son

He's definitely Bill Clinton's son... I've seen the tweets. The story adds up. I've done the research.

There is no DNA evidence supporting this claim and it remains a conspiracy theory.
Void
Anthony RizzoAnthony Rizzo

Cubs fans have issues if they think Bryce Harper is the solution to turning the franchise around

If Cubs Nation is banking on Bryce Harper to turn our franchise around, they have a lot of issues.

This is a subjective assessment of a fan base's mindset and a team's needs.
Loss
Anthony RizzoAnthony Rizzo

The 2018 World Series will be the Cubs against the Astros

I 100% believe that there will be two teams in the world series this year... i think it goes through Houston again right they they're the defending champ okay so cubs houston i like cubs houston

The 2018 World Series was the Red Sox vs. Dodgers. Neither the Cubs nor the Astros made it.
Void
Anthony RizzoAnthony Rizzo

It is an honor to be invited to the White House regardless of political views

If we win the World Series, am I going to the White House? I think it's an honor to be invited to the White House. No matter your political view or whatnot, there's a lot of history there.

This is a subjective opinion on tradition and honor.
Void
AJ BouyeAJ Bouye

Physical wide receivers are harder to cover than fast ones

I think a wide receiver, that's physical [is harder]. Just for the simple fact, they could push you everywhere, but you're not allowed to touch them at all.

This is an expert opinion based on his professional experience.
Push
AJ BouyeAJ Bouye

Donte Moncrief is a sleeper wide receiver that people are currently overlooking

I like Moncrief. We signed Moncrief... I think people sleep on him a lot. I played him for three years straight... I saw what [he] was capable of.

Moncrief's 2018 season with the Jaguars was modest (668 yards, 3 TDs), making this take only partially accurate as he didn't exactly 'wake up' the league.
Void
AJ BouyeAJ Bouye

The Jaguars defense is elite because of the secondary, not the defensive line

I'm going to say DBs just because of who we got back there. Defensive Baxonville. That's what it should be, not Saxonville. Pick six in Ville.

Determining which unit is more responsible for a team's success is a subjective football debate.
Push
AJ BouyeAJ Bouye

UCF is the true 2017 national champion because they beat the team that beat the champions

We blew out a team [Auburn] that beat the national champions [Alabama], quote-unquote. You know how I go. You don't lose a game. You just keep going until you lose.

UCF was the only undefeated team in 2017 and was recognized as champions by the Colley Matrix, though Alabama won the CFP.
Void
AJ BouyeAJ Bouye

Deion Sanders is the best cornerback in NFL history

Who is the best cornerback in the history of the NFL? Deion Sanders, Jason Sehorn? I'm going with Deion Sanders.

While widely accepted, this is a subjective GOAT debate.
Void
AJ BouyeAJ Bouye

Chris Collinsworth is a biased broadcaster who irks players

You could tell [Chris Collinsworth] is a little bit biased... A lot of people say he irks them... I just didn't like how he was talking... the one play in the Super Bowl when [Zach] Ertz scored and he was saying, 'that better not be a catch.'

Broadcaster bias is a subjective perception held by viewers and players.
Loss
HankHank

Kyrie Irving will be back and fine for the first round of the playoffs

He'll be back in three weeks, first round of the playoffs, no problem... Once [the debris is] out, he's completely fine.

Kyrie Irving was ruled out for the entire 2018 postseason shortly after this episode due to the need for a second procedure on his knee.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The claim that LeBron James gains seven pounds during a single game is stupid junk science

The fact that LeBron James gained seven pounds during a game is probably the stupidest thing I've ever heard. As big junk science fans, we've heard a lot of ridiculous claims.

Athletes lose weight through sweat during games; gaining seven pounds of mass while playing is biologically impossible.
Void
HankHank

Duke only lost to Kansas because of a blown call on a blocking foul

[Duke] just lost when they should have won because they got called for a blocking foul that was a charge.

Whether a foul call was correct or 'blew' the game is a subjective matter of debate.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Duke was guaranteed to win the title this year

I spent the last month, two months, three months saying that Duke was definitely going to win the title this year... guaranteed, locked up, no matter what happens, Duke is winning the title.

Duke lost in the Elite 8 to Kansas.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

College basketball teams should foul earlier because college players cannot hit free throws

The one thing that pisses me off this entire tournament... the fact that teams won't extend games. You should make kids shoot free throws in college. They can't hit free throws. And we saw that later with Kentucky.

Statistically, college free-throw percentages are lower than NBA ones, and in this specific tournament, several games turned on missed free throws (like Kentucky).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

John Calipari is officially on the hot seat

And Coach Cal's on the hot seat. He's definitely on the hot seat.

Calipari remained the head coach at Kentucky for six more years until moving to Arkansas in 2024.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Gonzaga is the 'always a bridesmaid, never a Cinderella' of college basketball

I guess we have to smash the fraud button on Gonzaga. Always a bridesmaid, never a Cinderella.

Gonzaga has reached two national championship games (2017, 2021) but has yet to win a title, supporting the 'bridesmaid' part of the take.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michigan looks as good or better than any team in the tournament except Villanova and Duke

Michigan looks as good, if not better than any team except for Villanova this tournament. And well, Duke.

Michigan reached the National Championship game in 2018, where they eventually lost to Villanova.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Sam Darnold's draft stock improved because he threw in the rain during his pro day

Are you nervous that Sam Darnold could throw in the rain? ... There actually were articles written that was the rainy weather. Did the rainy weather help Sam Darnold's draft stock? I think absolutely.

Darnold was drafted #3 overall, so while it didn't hurt him, it's subjective if the 'rain' specifically helped vs his overall profile.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Jason Pierre-Paul trade to the Buccaneers is not a blockbuster

Do you think that JPP is worth blockbuster trade when tweeted? Because Adam Schefter said JPP getting traded to the Bucs is a blockbuster trade. ... I think four years ago it definitely would have been.

JPP went on to have several productive years in Tampa, including a Pro Bowl and a Super Bowl title, making the trade more impactful than Big Cat suggested.
Win
Chris LongChris Long

Virginia basketball will be fine because Tony Bennett is the best coach in the country

We've got the best coach in the country. We have some of the best players in the country. We will be just fine, buddy.

Virginia recovered from the historic loss to win the National Championship in 2019, vindicating Long's faith in the program.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Losing to UMBC is a win for Virginia fans because it replaces the Ralph Sampson loss as the most notable upset in school history

I've got a spin zone for you. ... People are not going to probably talk about Ralph Sampson and the Chaminade loss now that Virginia has a more notable loss.

While subjective, the UMBC loss did largely supersede the Chaminade loss in the national consciousness as Virginia's most famous defeat.
Void
Jon TafferJon Taffer

Never partner with someone in business who cheats on their family

Somebody said to me, man, don't be partners with somebody who would cheat like that because he'll screw you in a heartbeat. ... If you're cheating someone else, then I'm convinced you're going to cheat me too.

This is a subjective business philosophy, though widely shared by mentors.
Void
Jon TafferJon Taffer

An excuse is nothing more than a rationalization of a mistake

I realized everybody's got a [fucking] excuse for their shortcomings. ... An excuse is a rationalization of a mistake. ... Every time we come up with an excuse, it makes us feel good about something we should feel bad about.

This is a subjective philosophical definition of personal responsibility.
Void
Jon TafferJon Taffer

People with the biggest egos have the thinnest wallets

You ever notice that people with the biggest ego have the thinnest fucking wallet? Because he doesn't listen to anybody. His ego gets in a way that's typically not very successful.

Subjective business observation.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Zing Zang is the superior Bloody Mary mix compared to handmade versions

I've discovered that the best mix by far for Bloody Mary is Zing Zang mix. There are a lot of places that tout their Bloody Marys as being handmade, and I always say, no, I'm not going to deal with that. I want Zing Zang.

Purely a matter of taste.
Void
Jon TafferJon Taffer

A 'hangover bar' is a bad business idea because it makes the establishment look irresponsible

The problem with [a hangover bar] is that when bars start to support hangovers, we're perceived as irresponsible. ... We're giving you more of a motivation to have one.

This is a subjective business judgment based on industry standards.
Push
Jon TafferJon Taffer

A restaurant cannot charge more than $12 for an entree if there are pictures on the menu

Is a restaurant classier if it has pictures on the menu? No. ... The minute they put a picture on the menu, they can't go past like $12 per [entree].

While a general rule in fine dining, chains like Cheesecake Factory successfully use menus with many images (or very dense descriptions) at higher price points, though Taffer notes they are an exception.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ordering a steak 'medium rare plus' is a legitimate and common request

When I go to a steak place, I order medium rare plus. Is that real? ... It's basically asking for medium rare, true medium rare. Because I also always find that really nice steakhouses always undercook it just a little bit.

While not on official charts, 'medium rare plus' is a known order in high-end kitchens to target the 135-140 degree range.
Void
Jon TafferJon Taffer

Millennials drink craft beer that sucks just because they think it's cool

Millennials are very relevancy-driven. Millennials will drink a craft beer that sucks because it's cool. ... Millennials don't react to logical things. They react to what is cool.

This is a generational generalization and inherently subjective.
Win
Jon TafferJon Taffer

Tom Brady was definitely drinking real beer on Colbert's show because of the lacing left on the glass

What that is called on the side of the beer is lacing. ... Lacing is what happens when the foam sticks to the side of the beer glass. So it's beer. ... That was beer.

Lacing is a legitimate physical indicator of beer foam reacting with a glass, making Taffer's observation scientifically sound.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kentucky lost to Kansas State because they missed 12 free throws, proving they aren't actually overrated

Remember when we did our March Madness preview with our friend Mark Titus? And I said free throws are overrated. Kentucky lost by three. ... P.J. Washington missed 12 free throws. Wow. ... That seems like you want to make those free throws.

Kentucky lost to Kansas State 61-58 while shooting 23-for-37 from the line (14 misses), including P.J. Washington's 8-for-20 performance. The misses were the literal difference in the score.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Saban only hires former head coaches as interns so he can eventually beat them

Is this Nick Saban thinking ahead and saying, Butch Jones might get another job in the SEC, so I need to put him under my coaching tree so that I can beat him? Because he's undefeated against his coaching tree.

Saban maintained a long undefeated streak against his former assistants until losing to Jimbo Fisher and Kirby Smart in late 2021/early 2022.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Deion Sanders only considers players great if they call him for advice

If you're a young player in the league and you call him for advice once a week, then you're a good player. If he mentors you, then you're one of the best players in the league. ... If you play in a boring place like Tennessee, then he just doesn't know who you are.

Subjective critique of a media personality.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Skyline Chili is terrible and only worth eating for the laughs

If I never stepped foot into Skyline Chili again, that would be fantastic. But then whenever we're in the Ohio area, PFT's like, it would be funny if we went to a Skyline. ... [We] sit there silently trying one bite and being like, nope, still terrible.

Highly subjective and a major point of debate for Ohio residents.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Duke is guaranteed to win the 2018 NCAA Tournament

We already know Duke's going to win it all. Yes. That is guaranteed. Yes. It's their year. Yes.

Villanova won the 2018 NCAA Tournament; Duke lost in the Elite Eight to Kansas.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kentucky will overlook their opponents and fail to reach the Final Four

I think something's going to happen in Kentucky. Yes. It's too easy for them, isn't it? Yes. It's just too set up for Kentucky to win the Elite Eight and go to the Final Four. Are they overlooking their opponents?

Kentucky lost to #9 seed Kansas State in the Sweet 16, so the prediction that 'something would happen' and they would fail to make the Final Four was correct.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I would kill the horse Nyquist to recruit LeBron James to my basketball team

I'm totally serious about killing Nyquist. That's not a threat. That's an actual thing. We're threatening LeBron that he might get more horse heads in his bed if he doesn't sign with the breakers.

This is a hyperbolic comedic statement. While he didn't actually kill the horse, the 'truth' of the take is subjective to the bit.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Every US taxpayer has a right to see the President's penis

In my opinion, every single United States taxpayer has a right to see the president's [Trump's] dick. I don't care if it's Donald Trump.

OpinionPoliticsHotSarcastic
The US Constitution does not actually grant taxpayers the right to view the President's genitals. This is a matter of law, not opinion, and the claim is legally incorrect.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Nationals will win the World Series based on the Sports Illustrated cover logic

Actually, what this means is that in what, seven years the Nationals beat World Series champions? Because they predicted the Astros, the rise of the Astros. True. So whenever the first time that they picked the Nats was like eight or nine years from then, that's when they're finally going to win.

The Nationals won the World Series in 2019, exactly one season after this take, making PFT's timing calculation surprisingly close.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL should reschedule Valentine's Day for the Sunday after the Super Bowl

Reschedule Valentine's Day for the Sunday after the Super Bowl. So you can have your one day with the family. And then, bam, right back into football before President's Day. Make it a national holiday.

Valentine's Day remains on February 14th regardless of the NFL schedule.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Peeing in the sink is the most environmentally friendly bathroom habit

Peeing in the sink is actually the greenest way to go, so you're welcome. Instead of wasting 1.6 gallons of water on a flush, you pee in the sink. You then wash your hands in the very same sink, simultaneously washing down the urine and preserving nature's most precious resource.

Factually, avoiding a toilet flush saves significant water. While controversial for hygiene, the water-saving claim is scientifically accurate.
Void
David OrtizDavid Ortiz

MLB Opening Day should be a national holiday

I'm extremely excited about opening day because for the first time, you're going to have all 30 teams playing on the same day, March 29th. It should be a national holiday. Everybody should be up for work. Even you guys should be just watching baseball that day.

This is a subjective opinion about public policy and holiday recognition.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers