PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
#PMT-2019-0429-18200
HankHank

The Vladimir Guerrero Jr. hype will get old by mid-season

MLB, I will say, they're kind of overdoing. Every time he does anything, they're like, Vladimir Guerrero, Vladimir Guerrero... I think halfway through the season, it's going to get a little old.

Guerrero Jr. remained a focal point of MLB marketing, especially during his historic 2021 season, though the initial debut craze did settle somewhat.
Win
Take Slip·Apr 29, 2019
#PMT-2019-0429-18202
Christian YelichChristian Yelich

The visiting clubhouse at Wrigley Field was extremely small and inconvenient

Same one. It's like this. Yeah, no. It's about this big. It really is like this wide... it wasn't just not good for the visiting team, the visiting clubhouse staff. Everybody that had to be in there, it was just making life difficult.

This was widely reported by players for years before the 2019 renovations were completed.
Loss
#PMT-2019-0424-11013
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Baseball players should start smoking cigarettes and drinking whiskey in the dugout to prevent modern muscle injuries

Yeah, I think that baseball players should start smoking cigarettes and drinking whiskey in the dugout again because you never heard of guys back in the 20s tearing their ACL. They just limped around like fools for the last 40 years of their life if they were lucky.

There is no medical evidence that smoking and drinking whiskey prevents sports injuries; this is a comedy bit.
Void
#PMT-2019-0417-2800
Big CatBig Cat

Blake Snell was actually having sex in the shower when he hurt his toe

Dude, you're having sex in the shower. Like that was a really long way of just saying, hey, I was having sex in the shower and I stubbed my toe.

This is purely speculative and meant for comedic effect, though Snell's actual story involved a granite decorative stand.
Void
Take Slip·Apr 17, 2019·PR 101
#PMT-2019-0417-2802
Big CatBig Cat

Christian Yelich will ruin his swing if he participates in the Home Run Derby

Real talk. It's going to mess up his swing if he competes in the home run derby... You're going to fuck up your swing.

Yelich did participate in 2019. He had a great second half but dealt with a back injury, making this take partially supported by superstitious fans but statistically debatable.
Void
#PMT-2019-0412-14366
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Chris Davis's hitless streak is actually fun to watch

Do you feel bad for Chris Davis, who is now 0 for 53? [PFT]: No, because it's so much fun to watch. And if the Orioles were going to be a threat to do anything this year, then maybe I would be. But he's helping them.

This is a subjective opinion on the entertainment value of a statistical outlier.
Win
Take Slip·Apr 5, 2019
#PMT-2019-0405-4300
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially panicking about the Cubs in the first week of April

I've already taken the panic button out of my closet for the Cubs. It's April. I know. I don't care... If I have to watch Yu Darvish pitch more fucking walks and Jason Hayward hit into more double plays, I will smash the fuck out of that panic button.

The 2019 Cubs missed the playoffs, finishing 84-78, suggesting the early panic was somewhat warranted.
Loss
Take Slip·Apr 1, 2019
#PMT-2019-0401-279
Big CatBig Cat

I will eat PFT Commenter's ass if Christian Yelich wins the Home Run Derby.

They were talking about the Home Run Derby and if Christian Yelich ever got in it and won, that [Big Cat] would eat PFT Commenter's ass. Yes. And so when I saw that tweet, it just reminded me... I'll fucking eat PFT's ass, whatever.

Pete Alonso won the 2019 Home Run Derby. Christian Yelich participated but did not win, so the condition was not met.
Void
Take Slip·Mar 29, 2019
#PMT-2019-0329-3436
Big CatBig Cat

The fact that Philly fans booed Bryce Harper on the first day is why Philly is great

Reacting to a 13-year contract on the first day is so fucking awesome, and that's why Philly is great. It does set a tone.

Subjective opinion on fan culture.
Loss
Take Slip·Mar 29, 2019
#PMT-2019-0329-3437
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Baseball managers should be required to manage shirtless

If you're a manager, it should be mandatory that you're shirtless. Just the pants and the belt. We should do bodies of baseball, and it's just all the managers.

Clearly a comedic proposal that will never happen.
Loss
Take Slip·Mar 27, 2019
#PMT-2019-0327-3263
HankHank

The Detroit Tigers will win the AL Central

The Tigers are in the Central, right? Oh, wow. Tigers... Is Vegas always right? [Vegas win total 68]

The 2019 Tigers finished with a record of 47-114, the worst in MLB.
Loss
Take Slip·Mar 27, 2019
#PMT-2019-0327-3264
HankHank

The Giants will win the NL West

And then in the NL West, we'll go with the Giants.

The Giants finished 3rd in the NL West with a 77-85 record.
Loss
Take Slip·Mar 27, 2019
#PMT-2019-0327-3265
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cincinnati Reds will win the NL Central

Then in the Central, I'm going to go my Reds. My Reds are looking pretty good. Central's going to be tough this year. They got Puig. People forget.

The Reds finished 4th in the NL Central with a 75-87 record.
Loss
Take Slip·Mar 27, 2019
#PMT-2019-0327-3266
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Cubs will have a rebound year and win the NL Central

NL Central, the Cubs are going to win. This is the rebound year. I can feel it.

The Cubs finished 3rd in the NL Central and missed the playoffs entirely in 2019.
Loss
Take Slip·Mar 27, 2019
#PMT-2019-0327-3267
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bryce Harper will retire by midseason due to the Philadelphia media

I also predict that Bryce Harper is going to retire by midseason because the Philadelphia media and fans will be too much for him to handle.

Hot TakeBaseballFireSarcastic
Harper did not retire and went on to win an MVP with the Phillies.
Void
#PMT-2019-0322-7718
Big CatBig Cat

The MLB retiring Ichiro at 7 AM in Japan is the worst way to stay relevant

Way to Stay Relevant Baseball, having one of the most liked superstars in the past probably 50 years retire at 7 a.m. when no one was watching in Japan... And on top of all of that, I actually woke up and... I went to Twitter to try to find some clips. Well, another one, MLB. I forgot. No one can tweet any clips from your product. So I couldn't even see Ichiro's last thing until you uploaded it on yourself. So good job, MLB.

Subjective opinion on marketing efficacy.
Open
#PMT-2019-0322-7719
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Baseball writers will hold Ichiro's unannounced retirement against him in Hall of Fame voting

This is going to cost him some votes in the Hall of Fame. When he's eligible, people are saying that he might be another unanimous entry... but I would not put it past baseball writers to get upset about not getting the heads up about his retirement and hold that against him five years from now.

Ichiro is eligible for the Hall of Fame in 2025. It remains to be seen if he will be unanimous, though he is a lock for induction.
Loss
Take Slip·Mar 1, 2019·Picks
#PMT-2019-0301-15678
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The city of Philadelphia will turn on Bryce Harper within five years

I have a prediction. I think that the city of Philadelphia is going to turn on Bryce Harper within five years. Give it four, actually. I think that given Bryce's history... He's such a streaky player. He's got a little bit of an attitude sometimes. But when you're making this kind of money, there's a big, big target on your back.

Five years later (2024), Harper is arguably the most beloved athlete in Philadelphia and led them to a World Series, so the city has not turned on him.
Win
#PMT-2019-0225-3015
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bryce Harper will sign with the Philadelphia Phillies

I think it's pretty clear he's going to go to the Phillies. They're the last team that's willing to deal with this bullshit. It's basically he's doing a pretty good job of weeding out all the teams that would get pissed off at him if he did sign that big contract.

Bryce Harper signed a 13-year, $330 million contract with the Phillies on February 28, 2019, just days after this episode.
Void
Take Slip·Feb 20, 2019
#PMT-2019-0220-5154
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Manny Machado is effectively early retiring by signing with the San Diego Padres

This is basically a — he almost is early retiring. He's quitting. It's a great situation for him because they're not going to win shit, and he doesn't really care about winning shit. He's going to be able to stomp on all the feet that he wants out there. He's going to be able to dog infield ground balls.

The Padres remained largely irrelevant for the first year of Machado's contract (2019), but eventually became a postseason contender, though they still haven't won a World Series.
Void
#PMT-2019-0220-5163
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trevor Bauer is the smartest man in baseball, according to Trevor Bauer

The thesis that you can give after reading this is Trevor Bauer is the smartest man in baseball, according to Trevor Bauer. [Big Cat]: Jesus Christ. What a fucking wacko.

Bauer has spent much of his career making this claim about himself through his actions and social media, though many in the sport disagree.
Win
Take Slip·Feb 18, 2019
#PMT-2019-0218-6335
Big CatBig Cat

Bryce Harper is going to sign with the Philadelphia Phillies

Bryce Harper, it's alleged that he's going to be signing with the Phillies any day now... I think he's going to be a Philly.

Bryce Harper signed a 13-year, $330 million contract with the Phillies on February 28, 2019.
Void
Take Slip·Feb 15, 2019
#PMT-2019-0215-13373
Big CatBig Cat

MLB is the only All-Star game that still gets the juices flowing

I feel like MLB is the only All-Star game that really gets the juices flowing now... at least still you can't half-ass baseball. A pitcher is still going to throw their stuff. Pro Bowl, NHL, NBA, everyone's just going through the motions.

Subjective opinion on entertainment value.
Win
#PMT-2019-0208-19466
Big CatBig Cat

I support a three-batter minimum for MLB relief pitchers

Three batter minimum, love it... I actually think they should go further with that. I think they should have a, if you come in on an inning, you have to finish the inning. Just watch guys get fucking torched.

The three-batter minimum rule was officially implemented by MLB starting in the 2020 season.
Loss
#PMT-2019-0208-19468
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A ground rule double in baseball should count as a home run

I also think that a ground rule double should be a home run. Not the weird one where it gets stuck in the ivy, but just if it bounces over, I think that should count as a home run.

The rule has not been changed; it remains a ground-rule double.
Loss
#PMT-2019-0130-6039
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Colin Kaepernick will get Baseball Hall of Fame votes

Colin Kaepernick hasn't been offered a job in baseball... As a contributor to the game, I think he would get Hall of Fame [votes].

PredictionBaseballFireSarcastic
It is highly unlikely he ever receives votes for the Baseball Hall of Fame given he never played professionally.
Loss
#PMT-2019-0111-13346
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tim Tebow will be called up to the Major Leagues this year

Tim Tebow is going to get called up to the Mets this year... You'd have to be a major league idiot to not call Tim Tebow up.

Tebow never reached the Major Leagues, retiring from baseball in early 2021 after hitting .163 in Triple-A in 2019.
Loss
Take Slip·Dec 24, 2018
#PMT-2018-1224-15652
Ricky WilliamsRicky Williams

Kyler Murray should choose baseball over the NFL

Hell yeah. No doubt. I just think his size and his skill set, I just think it's just a smoother path to baseball. He can play baseball forever. Make more money. Exactly.

Kyler Murray chose the NFL and won Offensive Rookie of the Year, becoming a franchise QB, suggesting football was a highly lucrative and successful path.
Win
Take Slip·Dec 19, 2018
#PMT-2018-1219-6105
HankHank

Bryce Harper will sign with the Philadelphia Phillies

Bold prediction. Phillies.

Bryce Harper signed a 13-year, $330 million contract with the Phillies in February 2019.
Void
#PMT-2018-1212-7783
Big CatBig Cat

Adam Ottavino could strike out Babe Ruth every single time

Adam Ottavino says that he can strike out Babe Ruth every single time. Well, he definitely can right now, Babe Ruth's dead body... [But seriously] Adam Ottavino, I agree. Well, I definitely think so.

This is an unprovable hypothetical debate about cross-era performance.
Void
Take Slip·Dec 5, 2018
#PMT-2018-1205-18835
Alex RodriguezAlex Rodriguez

The late 90s Mariners are one of the best teams to never win a World Series

The sad thing is that I found out very quickly the difference between good and great is very small... That's a great – I think that's one of the best teams that's never won... very seldom do you have a team that you have the best pitcher in the game in Randy Johnson, the best player in the game in Ken Griffey Jr., the best pure hitter in the game in Edgar Martinez, and the scariest, baddest motherfucker in Jay Buhner.

This is a widely held opinion among baseball historians given the talent on those rosters.
Void
Take Slip·Dec 5, 2018
#PMT-2018-1205-18836
Alex RodriguezAlex Rodriguez

I earned my Yankee pinstripes by the 2009 season

[Speaker 3]: Have you officially, do you think you earned your pinstripes? [A-Rod]: Yes. 100%. Not even a flinch... To 2009.

Subjective claim about legacy and team acceptance.
Open
Take Slip·Dec 5, 2018
#PMT-2018-1205-18837
Alex RodriguezAlex Rodriguez

I hope to get into the Hall of Fame despite my mistakes

Look, I really hope and wish that I get in. But ultimately, that's not my decision. But I do think that I have a great opportunity... if that cost me the Hall of Fame, then I have no one to blame but myself.

A-Rod debuted on the HOF ballot in 2022 and has not yet reached the 75% required for induction.
Win
#PMT-2018-1116-14474
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Wilbon thinks analytics have hijacked baseball

Wilbon... actually thinks that we're under an analytics hijacking... Analytics have hijacked his sport, baseball. And he says that we've gone so far and we undervalue wins. He doesn't care about ERA... He cares about wins.

Wilbon did publicly state that wins should matter more and deGrom shouldn't have won.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 7, 2018
#PMT-2018-1107-6192
Cal Ripken Jr.Cal Ripken Jr.

Joe DiMaggio's 56-game hitting streak is likely the most unbreakable record in sports

I agree. My longest hitting streak was 16 games. And so to think somebody could go 56 games without going 0 for 4 is amazing to me. And I think the pressure of the consecutive games hitting streak... because of the media coverage and the scrutiny, that creates more pressure. And so I think that's almost unattainable.

DiMaggio's record hasn't been seriously challenged in decades, supporting the idea of its unbreakability.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 7, 2018
#PMT-2018-1107-6194
Cal Ripken Jr.Cal Ripken Jr.

Certain players have an intangible value that isn't captured by modern sabermetrics

I think that certain players have an intangible value that's not measurable in the way that they're measuring everything nowadays. But, I mean, it's like Eddie Murray was our fourth hitter. He could be 0 for 50... But if Eddie was not in our lineup, we felt like we didn't have a good lineup. He stabilized the whole lineup.

This is a philosophical debate in sports analytics; data often fails to find evidence for 'protection,' but players and managers swear by it.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 7, 2018
#PMT-2018-1107-6196
Cal Ripken Jr.Cal Ripken Jr.

Players should act like they've been there before and avoid bat flipping

I don't like that [bat flipping]... you were considered more of a sportsman. So your entertainment value was in the quality of your sport and how you competed... but I always felt that and maybe it's John Riggins like if you score a touchdown, you know, act like you've been there before.

The culture of baseball has moved toward 'letting the kids play,' making Ripken's view somewhat contrarian today.
Void
Take Slip·Nov 5, 2018
#PMT-2018-1105-3036
Big CatBig Cat

Gold Glove is the dumbest award in sports

Gold Glove is the dumbest reward possible. And I'm not saying that just because Javi Baez didn't win one he should have. It's still the dumbest reward. ... I feel like if you get one gold glove you just end up getting gold gloves for life.

The award is inherently subjective and based on voting, so its 'dumbness' cannot be proven or disproven.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 29, 2018
#PMT-2018-1029-12727
Big CatBig Cat

Clayton Kershaw is still kind of a bum in the playoffs

Clayton Kershaw still kind of a bum. Whew. That was tough. If [David] Price had done what Kershaw did, you'd be killing him. Bum is hard. But today was a moment... when you give up a two-run homer in the first inning, that's tough.

Kershaw had a 7.36 ERA in the 2018 World Series and famously struggled in postseasons for much of his career until 2020.
Void
Take Slip·Oct 29, 2018
#PMT-2018-1029-12728
Big CatBig Cat

Manny Machado is the perfect villain for baseball

Manny Machado, the world's biggest jerk. I love Manny Machado. I don't want him on the Cubs, but I love this guy... It was his coming out party as a real asshole, and I love it. Because the world... we need villains. And Manny Machado was the perfect villain.

This is a subjective opinion on entertainment value, but Machado remained one of the most polarizing figures in the sport.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 29, 2018
#PMT-2018-1029-12729
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dodgers' bullpen would be their undoing

I said that the Dodgers' bullpen was going to be their undoing. From the start. I also said Red Sox in five. So not to brag, but I called it.

The Red Sox did win in 5 games, and the Dodgers' relief pitching (Madson) was a major factor in the collapse.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 26, 2018
#PMT-2018-1026-19310
Big CatBig Cat

David Price officially has the clutch gene

Does David Price have the clutch gene? That is the question. That is the segment. And I'm going to say yes. He does. When it matters the most.

Price won the 2018 World Series with a 1.98 ERA in the series, including the series-clinching win.
Loss
#PMT-2018-1022-19950
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tommy Lasorda will die if the Red Sox win the World Series

I'm still going with Tommy [Lasorda]. He's going to die if the Red Sox win.

The Red Sox won the 2018 World Series, but Tommy Lasorda lived until January 2021.
Win
Take Slip·Oct 19, 2018
#PMT-2018-1019-2200
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

David Price's postseason demons won't be fully exercised until he wins in the World Series

I'm not ready to declare the demons exercised. The demons are warmed up. They're jazzercising right now. To be fully exercised, it has to be in the World Series.

David Price went on to win Game 2 and Game 5 of the 2018 World Series, earning the series-clinching win and effectively silencing critics.
Win
#PMT-2018-1015-14308
Big CatBig Cat

David Price's good postseason game was actually mediocre by normal standards

Strive in life to be like David Price where you set the bar so impossibly low for yourself that pitching four and two-thirds and four earned runs is actually, people are saying, you were dominant.

Statistically, 4.2 innings with 4 runs is an 8+ ERA, confirming the bar was indeed very low for a 'good' Price start.
Push
#PMT-2018-1012-7993
HankHank

The Red Sox will beat the Astros in 7 games in the ALCS

Hank, are you worried at all about the Red Sox against the Astros? The Astros are a wagon. [Hank:] I think it's going to go seven games where the Red Sox are going to win.

The Red Sox won the ALCS, but they did it in 5 games, not 7.
Push
#PMT-2018-1012-7994
Big CatBig Cat

The 2018 World Series will be a Dodgers vs. Astros rematch

I think it's going to be a repeat. Dodgers, Stros. I think the Dodgers are going to – Rich Hill is going to do something. But playoff Kershaw.

The Dodgers made the World Series, but the Astros lost to the Red Sox in the ALCS.
Void
Take Slip·Oct 10, 2018
#PMT-2018-1010-12201
Big CatBig Cat

Giancarlo Stanton is a bum

Giancarlo Stanton, I'm ready to say he's a bum. No pinstripes for you, Giancarlo. If it were an April game between the Miami Marlins and the Atlanta Braves, I'm sure you would have hit a home run in a big spot.

Stanton's tenure with the Yankees remained controversial with fans due to injuries and postseason streaks, though 'bum' is a subjective harsh label for a former MVP.
Loss
Take Slip·Oct 10, 2018
#PMT-2018-1010-12203
Big CatBig Cat

The Yankees should fire Aaron Boone because anyone would be better

You probably should fire Aaron Boone, and you will get someone better than him because everyone is better than him. Anyone. Luis Severino bringing him out for the fourth inning in game three on Monday night was maybe the most inexcusable thing I've ever seen a manager do.

Boone was not fired after the 2018 season and actually stayed for many years, though he remained a frequent target of fan ire.
Loss
Take Slip·Oct 5, 2018
#PMT-2018-1005-11370
Big CatBig Cat

The Yankees will win their playoff series against the Red Sox

I actually think the Yankees will win this series because you need—the Yankees to be full Yankees. They need that guy who everyone's like, whether even like the Yankees fans would die for him and everyone else universally is like, that guy's the biggest scumbag in the world.

The Red Sox beat the Yankees 3-1 in the ALDS and went on to win the World Series.
1...1214...21