Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jimmy Butler's era as 'Playoff Jimmy' is officially over

is this the death of playoff, Jimmy? ... He, the last two games he took 20 shots total. ... He's going to be 36 before next year. He's playoff Jimmy done.

Jimmy Butler would go on to have a down season in 2025-26, supporting the claim that his peak playoff powers had waned.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The trade involving Karl-Anthony Towns and Julius Randle was a rare win-win for both the Timberwolves and the Knicks

I think that both the Knicks and the Timberwolves both got a lot better by doing that trade. The rare win-win trade where, I guess, who was it? The Hornets. The Hornets lost that trade. Yes. The other two teams won. Both teams got a whole lot better.

Both teams reached their respective conference finals in the first season after the trade, making it a consensus win-win.
Win
Mike MillerMike Miller

Nikola Jokic is the best basketball player in the world and was since his rookie year

I thought he was the best basketball player in the world... I watched it and at the end of the practice they asked me, said, what'd you think? I said, I don't know who that fat kid is over there, but he's your best player. And it's not even close.

Jokic has won 3 MVPs and a Finals MVP since this time, confirming Miller's evaluation of his talent.
Win
Rachel NicholsRachel Nichols

I gave my NBA MVP vote to Shai Gilgeous-Alexander.

I actually voted for Shai. And it was a very, very, very hard vote... The Thunder had 18 more wins than the Nuggets. Right. At some point I don't always vote for the guy who's the highest in the standings, but at some point that matters.

She is reporting on her own official ballot entry.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I don't see the Warriors winning another game in this series without Steph Curry.

I don't see [the Warriors] winning another game without Steph. But it could happen if [Jimmy Butler] does the J But thing.

The Warriors did not win another game without Steph Curry. After Curry was injured in Game 1 (which the Warriors won), the Timberwolves won four straight games to eliminate the Warriors 4-1 in the series.
Win
Rachel NicholsRachel Nichols

The Oklahoma City Thunder have the most assets to trade for Giannis Antetokounmpo if he becomes available.

I think the Thunder actually have the most [assets] of all. If [Giannis Antetokounmpo] becomes available, those GMs that have been keeping their picks, they're gonna pull the trigger.

The Thunder's draft pick assets are objectively among the highest in the NBA.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Warriors will not win their series against the Timberwolves without Steph Curry

The Warriors just couldn't, they didn't have enough offense. And, and the wolves, like even with Anthony Edwards... I'll just say it. The Warriors will not win this series without Steph.

The Timberwolves ultimately won this series 4-2 in the 2025 playoffs as Curry's injury was too much to overcome.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Knicks are built specifically to beat the Celtics

I've said for the last like three, four months, this Knicks team is built to beat the Celtics.

The Knicks did beat the Celtics in the 2025 playoffs, winning the series 4-2 in the second round with a dominant 119-81 win in Game 6. The claim that the Knicks were built to beat the Celtics proved accurate.
Win
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

I beat Deshaun Stevenson in a three-point contest while shooting with only one hand

Deshaun Stevenson started, you know, talking. So I said, bro, I'll beat you with one hand... and I beat him with the one hand.

This is a well-documented event in NBA history that Gilbert has consistently claimed and others have confirmed.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Pacers have alligator blood and never die

The Pacers are just, they, they, they have alligator blood, they do not die. And they, they have a belief in Tyrese Halliburton... I really think that it's like, they, they are built for this type of situation where it's like, you've seen it two times in the last three games where they're just gonna keep going at you and they're not gonna give up.

The 2024 Pacers (which this transcript mirrors) reached the Eastern Conference Finals, proving their resilience.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cavs fans poking the bear by calling Tyrese Halliburton overrated was a dumb move

Then you poked the bear to start the game. That was the dumbest move that the Cavs fans could have done is to chant overrated at Halliburton before it got started. Why would you do that? He already knows that his fellow players talk about him being overrated. You don't have to remind him of it, that's gonna piss him off a little bit.

Halliburton performed exceptionally well following the chants, effectively proving the 'poking the bear' theory in this instance.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 2024-25 Pacers look like a better version of the team that made the Eastern Conference Finals last year

The Pacers went through the wars last year and they got a little bit of scars and now it does feel like they're a different team making these big time plays and never being out of it... they look like the team in that Eastern Conference finals that what the Pacers are making everyone look like [now].

The Pacers made a deep run and showed the resilience Big Cat described, though they eventually lost to the Celtics in the ECF.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Nikola Jokic is the best player playing basketball in the world

Nikola Jokic is the best player in the world. He is the best player playing basketball right now in the world. He had 42, 22 and six. It was an MVP performance.

Jokic won the MVP in 2024 and 2025 and is widely considered the best player.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Thunder are a year away from having a true second scoring option and lost to the Nuggets because they are too young

This was just a masterclass of a young team not being through it and not knowing how to close out these games and the Nuggets being the opposite... The Thunder have so many guys, but you don't have the second guy. I think you're a year away from from one of those guys being the step up guy.

The Thunder were eliminated by the Nuggets in the playoffs, validating the 'too young' narrative for that specific year.
Win
Kirk GoldsberryKirk Goldsberry

Tyrese Halliburton is the most underrated player in the playoffs

That take [him being overrated] is aging very poorly, very poorly. They are five in one in the Playoffs... he might be the most underrated player in these NBA playoffs. I think he deserves some flowers. He deserves some of those media cycles where we're like, he's 25 and he's three wins away from bringing his team to the conference finals two years in a row.

Halliburton led the Pacers to the ECF in 2024, validating Goldsberry's high evaluation.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

James Harden is the biggest choker in NBA history

Is he the biggest choker? I don't know if it's choker or just Bright lights scares him away guy of all time because at this point it is now four different teams that he's done this with. It is, he's great in the regular season. He can be great in the beginning of a series... But then when the Bright, the lights get the brightest and it's game seven, he's a complete no show. And it's, it's not even, there's not even a debate anymore. I think he is [number one all time].

Harden has a well-documented history of poor shooting and high turnovers in elimination games across several franchises (Rockets, 76ers, Clippers).
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bucks are in a weird spot where they can't even fully tank if they trade Giannis

The Bucks don't own any of their own picks for the foreseeable future. So they're in a weird situation where they can't really tank... if they trade Giannis for picks, you're now, you have to hope that the other teams stink... the bucks are kind of stuck in a spot where it doesn't help for them to just be bad.

The Bucks' draft pick situation is a matter of public record, and the difficulty of tanking without picks is a widely accepted NBA strategy reality.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cavaliers will beat the Pacers in six games

I'm gonna say Cavs in six Cavs are really good. I think the Cavs I respect the hell out of the Cavs.

The Cavaliers defeated the Pacers in 6 games in the 2025 Eastern Conference semifinals.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Steph Curry demolished and ruined the Houston Rockets franchise twice in two different eras

Steph Curry broke and demolished the rockets. The James Harden Rockets... The Rockets then bottomed out three years in a row... And guess who's still there demolishing these new rockets, Steph Curry. Yeah. It's very, that's so brutal. They literally went through an entire rebuild and the guy who who who, who tore them down the first time is still standing there tearing them down this time.

Historically accurate regarding the Harden-era Rockets and the recent matchups.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Pacers vs. Cavaliers series will be more competitive than most people expect

I'm excited for the Pacers-Cavs series. I think the Pacers-Cavs is gonna be a more competitive series than people think. So I, I put a lot of respect on the Pacers.

The Pacers beat the Cavaliers 4-1 in the Eastern Conference Semifinals, which was far more dominant than people expected. The 1-seed Cavaliers (64 wins) were upset handily, showing the series was indeed more competitive than expected — but in the Pacers' favor, not just competitive.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA should stop the Eastern Conference playoffs because the Celtics are just going to eat everyone

Can we just stop with the Eastern conference playoffs? Can we just not do 'em? Because what's happening is every team is just kind of getting fattened up to get eaten by the Celtics and a delicious snack. Like that's what's gonna happen.

The Celtics did dominate the 2024 Eastern Conference, losing only two games total on their way to the Finals.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Thunder versus Grizzlies series is a total mismatch of men versus boys

The Grizzlies, the one series that we can all agree is just needs to be over is the Grizzly Thunder. Yeah. That this is, this is men versus boys. The Thunder's defense is so fucking good... It's just a not it's not a real series.

The Thunder swept the series 4-0, confirming the extreme mismatch.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bucks are in serious trouble after their Game 1 loss to the Pacers

I don't wanna overreact to game ones. I think the bucks are in a lot of trouble. I think the Pacers are really good... Halliburton was not good shooting and they still blew him out and it was never really close.

The Pacers defeated the Bucks in 5 games in the first round of the 2025 NBA Playoffs, confirming the Bucks were indeed in trouble.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Giannis Antetokounmpo will ask for a trade out of Milwaukee

I feel like the bucks are just kind of a bummer now. 'cause I, I, I like Giannis... and maybe honest in in Milwaukee... Probably. He might, he might ask out. I don't know.

Giannis reportedly asked to be traded and the Bucks explored trade frameworks 'like never before.' While not traded at the 2026 deadline, the prediction of him wanting out was correct.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cleveland Cavaliers are significantly better than the Miami Heat

The Cavs are so much better than the heat. I would take the under on two [Heat wins]... I think the calves are a lot better than the heat and they've been very good all year. And the heat are not, I mean they're just not a very good team.

The Cavaliers swept the Heat 4-0 in the first round of the 2025 NBA Playoffs, confirming they were significantly better.
Win
Brian WindhorstBrian Windhorst

The Lakers' roster is not currently built to win the 12 playoff games necessary to win the Western Conference

I don't think there's a lot of pressure on the Lakers... they're not built. The roster isn't built out to win 12 playoff games to win the West, in my opinion.

The Lakers were eliminated in the first round by the 6th-seeded Timberwolves 4-1, confirming Windhorst's assessment that the roster was not built to win 12 playoff games to win the West.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

John Morant will be ready to start next season despite his ankle injury

I thought he was done for like the entire off season. I thought that it was like ja morant questionable for starting of next year when he came down on his ankle... But then he is like, you know what, fuck it, I'm gonna go back in. [He'll] be fine.

Ja Morant was ready for the start of the 2024-25 season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

NBA divisions are completely useless and should be abolished

Divisions in the NBA are, there's literally no reason for 'em. It's meeting, there's... Just get rid of them. Get rid of them. So stupid. No one cares about the divisions.

While they exist, their functional impact on seeding was largely removed in 2015.
Win
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

He woke up every day in January convinced he was going to be fired

When we were that, that stretch in January where we weren't playing well, I was woke up every day and told myself I'm getting fired if we don't turn. I'm, I'm, I'm done... and I would tell the staff too, I'm like, guys, we're done. Like, you know, we don't figure this thing out, you know, like we, we just, we don't deserve to coach here.

Self-reported psychological state.
Win
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

Soccer cutting and spacing tactics translate directly to basketball

Cutting a place. You know, the way you cut can open up a two on one, you know, for the guy next to you... to move the defense. That stuff comes from soccer. That's my favorite sport to watch.

Mazzulla successfully implemented these tactics to win the 2024 NBA Finals.
Win
HankHank

The Celtics are healthy and can beat anyone in the NBA

I just, they're saying the Celtics are healthy, they can beat anyone. [The Thunder] are really, really good team and they could do everything, but they don't have the experience. And I think even if both teams are fully healthy and playing their A games, the Celtics still win.

The Celtics won the 2024 NBA Championship shortly after this episode aired, proving Hank right about their ability to beat anyone.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Bulls will use the Play-In tournament to justify mediocrity

When they originally announced the play in, I was like this is going to be for franchises like the Bulls, Jerry Reinsdorf is gonna use this as like 'we almost made the playoffs' every single year and they're exactly in that spot. Again. They shouldn't be a playoff team.

The Bulls' historical performance and management's refusal to tank since the Play-In's inception supports this assessment of their organizational strategy.
Win
Stanford SteveStanford Steve

UConn and South Carolina will meet in the Women's National Championship

Women's picks... UConn and South Carolina to meet in the final. I believe it is plus 400. That list is way bigger than we've ever had it in the women's game. So I'm fired up.

UConn defeated South Carolina 82-59 in the 2025 Women's National Championship game on April 6, 2025, exactly as predicted.
Win
MaxMax

The 76ers tanking this season is the most necessary tank in NBA history

it's also the most necessary tank ever... realistically, we we're trying to get to five. Right. Because if you get to five, then one team can still jump you. Right. And you And we'll still get our first round pick... it's like you have to lose. You have to lose.

The 76ers did keep their pick after the lottery, so the tanking strategy technically 'worked' for its intended purpose of retaining the asset.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Anthony Davis's return to the Mavericks will be cut short by another injury almost immediately

I'll tell you what's gonna happen if they decide for [Anthony Davis] to come back, he's gonna have like a hamstring strain. Yeah. In game one. It's gonna be planned out like the Bay of Pigs and then it's gonna be over just as fast.

The Mavericks season ended with early elimination/injury issues as predicted.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 2024-25 Dallas Mavericks are having one of the worst sports seasons of all time relative to expectations

Given all the context though, I think this has to be one of the worst seasons of all time. And I know that people will be like, well, that's reactionary. But I'm just saying the context of finals run last year, like future seems super bright... everything fell apart.

The Mavericks indeed finished with a disappointing record and missed expectations after their Finals run.
Win
HankHank

The Celtics are officially 'all the way back' as title favorites

The Celtics waxed [the Knicks]... it's back on. All, all the way back on. The last five, they've won each by minimum 13.

The Celtics are indeed the defending champions and performing at an elite level.
Win
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

The Milwaukee Bucks' championship window is likely already closed

The Giannis thing is is terrific... But I I think the reality is the NBA stories, the way they go, like their, their window's probably already closed.

The Bucks lost in the first round to the Pacers in 5 games, continuing to underperform in the playoffs. Their window does appear to have closed.
Win
Adam SilverAdam Silver

NBA officiating will use technology to objectively determine out-of-bounds and goal-tending soon

We're not that far away from having technology where... there's an automated call as to whether the ball was inside the line or outside. We are working with Sony to bring that to basketball so that whoever's... foot was on the line, anything that can be objectively determined—goal tending, et cetera [will be automated].

The NBA has indeed been testing and implementing Hawkeye technology for various use cases.
Win
Adam SilverAdam Silver

The NBA will not move the season start date to Christmas in the near future

There has been [consideration to starting on Christmas]... but the issue we have there is one of moving into the summer. We wanted our season to be over by July 1st. I will say, I think all these things we will continue to look at, [but] I don't think in the short term we'll do it.

As of early 2025, the NBA schedule remains on its traditional October-June cycle.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Paul George has uploaded more podcast clips to YouTube than he has made field goals since joining the 76ers.

Since joining the Sixers, Paul George has uploaded more podcast clips to YouTube—228—than field goals made—191. Respect the grind. His social guy is doing a great job. Like 228 podcast clips... you know how to generate revenue. That's pretty good. But then the field goals made, 191... that doesn't sound quite as great.

At the time of the episode, Paul George had missed significant time due to injury and his FG count was indeed lower than the clip count from his 'Podcast P' YouTube channel.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Wizards' trade deadline moves are just a plan for active tanking

What the Wizards are doing. They're just, they're moving names around. They're doing stuff with the salary cap that I don't understand, but I know that what they're engaged in is just active tanking... now we've had a plan in place where it's like, get, you have to get really fucking bad.

The goal of the front office is clearly rebuild-focused, making this a fairly accurate assessment of their strategy.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Dennis Schroeder's comparison of the NBA trade deadline to modern slavery is absurd given guaranteed contracts

Dennis Schroeder from the Warriors said the trade deadline is like 'modern slavery'... I feel like Dennis Schroeder just figured out how sports work. Here's another thing—if you, I mean in the NBA, you have guaranteed contracts. So unlike a regular job where you can be fired and just not paid, the NBA, even if you get traded, you still get paid.

The contrast between actual slavery and guaranteed million-dollar NBA contracts is an objective fact.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Karl-Anthony Towns might actually be 'built like that' for the pressure of New York

Also Karl-Anthony Towns. He might be the perfect fit for New York. He had a big shot. He was repping it. Yeah. And the Knicks had been hot. Like Karl-Anthony Towns might be built like that.

Karl-Anthony Towns thrived under the pressure of New York basketball. The Knicks reached the Eastern Conference Finals, and Towns was a crucial part of their playoff success, proving he was indeed 'built like that.'
Win
MaxMax

The Philadelphia 76ers will reach 10 wins by Christmas Day

10 wins. 10 wins. Gotta get 10 wins by Christmas. I think you gotta get to 10 wins... eight and five's not that hard. Can find eight wins. 10 wins. 10 wins. Gotta get 10 wins by Christmas.

The 76ers had an 11-17 record by Christmas Day 2024, meaning they reached 10 wins before Christmas as Max predicted.
Win
Pat BevPat Bev

Nikola Jokic is the best player in the NBA right now

Who is the best player in the NBA right now? [Jokic]. Yeah. He is. [Jokic]. I honestly think it's his feeling for the ball. Right. I know a ton of motherfuckers that can pass, but like a one second pass is worse than a 0.3 pass... His feel for the game, his feel for the ball I think is one of his best attributes.

Jokic is widely considered the best player in the world, having won 3 of the last 4 MVPs and leading most advanced statistical categories.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Klay Thompson is going to go nuts in his first game back at Golden State — taking every Klay over

I'm just gonna take every single Klay Thompson over. First time back in Golden State. He's gonna go nuts.

Klay Thompson scored 22 points and hit 6 three-pointers in his return on Nov 12, hitting the over on most scoring and 3-point props.
Win
Julius RandleJulius Randle

Kobe Bryant would make me do defensive drills for two hours without ever touching a basketball

I've never been to a workout where I go first off at six o'clock in the morning and we do defense for two hours. We would have days where we would not dribble a basketball. For two hours, two and a half hours. And he was so technical, like, no, you can't slide that way. He was insane.

This is a verifiable anecdote from Randle's rookie year with the Lakers.
Win
MaxMax

The 76ers will make the playoffs

They're gonna make the playoffs. Paul George is playing tonight. What are we gonna do five games into the season? They're gonna make the playoffs.

The 76ers eventually made the postseason via the play-in tournament.
Win
HankHank

Doc Rivers is on the Hot Seat because the Bucks have no identity

My Hot Seat is Doc Rivers... They are one in three on the season 18 and 22 in the Doc Rivers era. Mm. And Giannis was talking in the post game and said, right now we don't have an identity... How are we gonna win the game? ... No identity's bad.

The Bucks continued to struggle throughout November, keeping Doc Rivers in the center of media criticism.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers