Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The San Jose Sharks might be one of the worst teams in modern NHL history

I think the Sharks are really gonna struggle to score goals. It could be one of the worst teams we've ever seen in modern day NHL.

The Sharks finished the 2023-24 season with a 19-54-9 record and 47 points, the worst in the league.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Macklin Celebrini is going to be the first overall pick and an NHL superstar.

They have a kid named Macklin Celebrini. He's gonna go first... he turned 17 in June or July and he's dominating college hockey already... Macklin Celebrini, what an age... he's defensively very aware... NHL superstar.

Macklin Celebrini was indeed drafted first overall by the San Jose Sharks in the 2024 NHL Draft.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Golden Knights winning the Stanley Cup in six years cements hockey in the desert in a way the Coyotes never could.

The Las Vegas Golden Knights Stanley Cup champions. ... It's incredible. I mean, and to be in two Stanley Cup final in that time. ... What a way to cement hockey in the desert. And this is what the Coyotes never could do.

The Golden Knights won the Cup in their 6th season and have high attendance, while the Coyotes eventually relocated to Salt Lake City in 2024 after failing to secure a permanent home.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Florida Panthers' physical style of play might not work against the Vegas Golden Knights

Florida is like a team that as a team feels like they just want to get in fights and bother you. And Vegas is the most disciplined big team that it might not work for them. It's obviously game one, but it might not work against a team like Vegas who's like, no, fuck this, we'll play hockey.

Vegas went on to win the series 4-1, proving quite dominant and largely unaffected by Florida's physical tactics.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Rob Brind'Amour's post-sweep comments were 'the biggest loser talk' ever

The hurricanes got swept and Rob Brind'Amour afterwards said... 'we didn't lose four games, we got beat, but we were right there.' ... That's quite a quote. ... To come out afterwards and say the history books will show we got swept, but that's not what happened. ... On the surface that's the definition of Loser Talk.

The Hurricanes did literally lose four games and were swept.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am buying Blackhawks season tickets because of Connor Bedard

I watched a highlight video. There's like a 20 minute highlight video I was watching and I did buy season tickets. I hope everyone here likes to go to hockey games. Cause we're gonna go to a lot of hockey games. I got swept up. I mean he looks, I, I know there's a lot of pressure on him, but he does feel like a can't miss guy.

Big Cat did indeed purchase season tickets for the Blackhawks.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Whitney was completely wrong for saying the Kraken would only win one playoff game

The Kraken are fucking... put the Kraken every time they're on the screen. It also, Ryan Whitney's full of shit for saying the Kraken were gonna win one game in the playoffs.

The Kraken won their first-round series against the Avalanche (4 games) and won three games in the second round against the Stars. Whitney was definitively wrong.
Win
Keith YandleKeith Yandle

The Florida Panthers' upset over the Bruins wasn't as shocking as people think

I don't think it was a choke as much as people are saying... You look at Florida's team, they're loaded, they got superstar players... They had been playing playoff hockey for the last month trying to get into the playoffs.

Florida went on to reach the Stanley Cup Finals, proving they were indeed a elite team peaked at the right time.
Win
Keith YandleKeith Yandle

The Florida Panthers will beat the Toronto Maple Leafs in their playoff series

I would love to see Toronto move on, but just not against my Cats. I think Florida's gonna beat them in that series.

The Panthers beat the Maple Leafs in 5 games to advance to the Eastern Conference Finals.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2022-23 Boston Bruins are the biggest chokers in the history of the NHL

How do you feel about your Boston Bruins being the biggest chokers in the history of the NHL? After being the President's Cup trophy winner, they had the most wins in NHL history this year... You lost in the first round to Jake [Marsh]'s Florida Panthers.

The Bruins set records for wins and points and lost in the first round; they are widely cited as the biggest choke in NHL history.
Win
HankHank

The Bruins' historic season was an abject failure

I don't know how he [Giannis] could say that that was a complete abject failure. It just hurt a lot... most points of all time, most wins of all time... it's a complete failure.

In the context of sports high-stakes, losing as a record-breaking favorite in round 1 is objectively a failure.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Rangers are pathetic for blowing a 2-0 lead to the Devils

The Rangers are pathetic. The Rangers are pathetic. They are like, that is a pathetic to be up two-oh with two games at home. And then they obviously lost in New Jersey tonight, but they're pathetic. Four nothing shutout.

The Rangers did indeed lose the series in 7 games after blowing that 2-0 lead.
Win
HankHank

You should bet every NHL playoff game to go into overtime

I hope there's people listening that listen to me. I didn't listen to myself. But if you bet it [overtime], it cashed a lot. So I hope people listened and bet it.

The 2023 playoffs did see an unusually high number of overtime games in the first round.
Win
HankHank

Presidents' Trophy winners rarely do well in the NHL playoffs

I don't know what the stats are, but for my personal feel, it doesn't feel like President's Cups teams do well.

This proved extremely prescient for the 2023 season; the record-breaking Bruins were upset in the first round by the Florida Panthers shortly after this episode aired.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If the Bruins don't win the Stanley Cup, it's a complete failure and they'll be a joke

The Bruins are statistically now... most wins in a NHL season... if they don't win the cup, they're kind of like a joke a little bit... it's win or a complete failure.

The Bruins famously lost in the first round to the Florida Panthers, making this one of the most accurate assessments of the looming disappointment in show history.
Win
HankHank

Winning the Presidents' Trophy in hockey is a curse that leads to first-round exits

The Presidents' Trophy in hockey I think is a bad thing though. I will say that. Like, that is something I'm worried about. Just, you know, as day one on the bandwagon, it's like, do you really want to be flaunting the Presidents' Trophy in everyone's face like Capitals' fans used to do and then they lose in the first round? That might be bad.

The Bruins won the Presidents' Trophy and were subsequently upset in the first round by the Florida Panthers.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Arber Xhekaj is a fan favorite 'unicorn' who will stick in Montreal

Arber Xhekaj and then the boys call him 'Wifi' because his last name looks like a wifi password... this kid was working at Costco last year... young defenseman, tough as shit... he's a fan favorite in Montreal who's exceeded expectations.

Xhekaj became a staple for the Canadiens and a highly popular physical presence in the NHL.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Jacob Chychrun will be the biggest name defenseman moved at the deadline

For trade for defenseman right now the biggest name is Jacob Chychrun and he plays for the coyotes. ... I would say that he's gonna be a big name defenseman that moves at the close to the deadline.

Chychrun was indeed the most discussed defenseman and was traded to Ottawa in March 2023.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Blackhawks will likely trade Patrick Kane this season

Is [Patrick] Kane gonna get traded? That's a tough one. I would say yes. And they made it sound like it would happen at some point during the year... They'd be probably smart to trade him.

Kane was traded to the New York Rangers on February 28, 2023.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Colorado Avalanche were one of the most dominant Cup winners in history

The avalanche incredible team, like an absolute wagon of a team... they went 16 and four in the playoffs. They had, they had a four game sweep [of the Predators]... the Oilers [sweep]... 4-2 against the lightning. They, if you combine it all and he'd take out overtime losses and the regular season, they had, they won a 78% clip, which is insane. It's pretty like dad is just, thrills are just awesome. Awesome hockey team that deserves to win the cup.

The Avalanche went 16-4 in the playoffs, one of the best records in the modern era.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Game 4 is the pivotal game of the Stanley Cup Final

I'd say that it's gonna come down to pivotal game for winner that game... if they lose it, it's over no way that they went three in a row.

The Avalanche won Game 4 to go up 3-1 and won the series in 6.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Avalanche vs Lightning series is over; the Cup is in the building

I'm pretty excited for my Avalanche bet. I'm feeling comfortable about it because this does feel like a game seven now... This is game seven for the Lightning. And it's a game two for the Avalanche... Are we sure the Lightning are good? Are, do they just have Vasilevskiy... The Avalanche just look like the far fresher, far faster [team].

The Avalanche won the Stanley Cup in 6 games.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Cale Makar is a generational talent who could play forward in the NHL if he wanted to

I swear to God he could be a forward in the league. Like he could, if you put them up front, he could probably play wing and be fine and get fricking 80 points. Like he does defensively. So it's just a player, like a generational type talent who I love watching.

Makar's continued dominance and Norris/Conn Smythe awards support the 'generational talent' claim, though his ability to score 80 points as a wing is hypothetical.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

It's a huge disappointment if the Avalanche don't win the Stanley Cup now

The Avalanche looked like the best team. Like if they don't win it now that's would, that's a big disappointment, big disappointment, huge disappointment.

The Colorado Avalanche went on to win the Stanley Cup, defeating the Lightning in the Finals.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The New York Rangers are playing unsustainable hockey and got lucky against Pittsburgh

Rangers fans were losing it because I was like, yes, this team has had success all year, but fuck, do they give up a lot of high, dangerous scoring chances and rely on their goaltending. I think that they're going to get worked in playoffs... believe me when I say they got so lucky that Jarry got hurt and they had to play a three third string goalie, they got [worked].

The Rangers' luck did run out in the Conference Finals as they lost to Tampa Bay in 6 games shortly after this episode.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Cale Makar is as good as Paul Coffey and approaching Bobby Orr status

[Makar] is the greatest defenseman we've seen since Paul Coffey's probably as good as Paul Coffey. If he keeps going on this trajectory easily, right. Maybe right below Bobby Orr could eventually become like a Bobby Orr type. He is a freak. He's a Connor McDavid of defense.

Makar won the Conn Smythe and the Norris Trophy that season, justifying the historical comparisons.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Avalanche will easily advance to the Stanley Cup Finals

Yeah, I would say the Colorado is going to easily advance... [Edmonton is] basically kind of without [Draisaitl]. And also now Kane just got a one game suspension... I think they're going to Colorado is going to advance.

The Avalanche swept the Oilers 4-0 to advance to the Stanley Cup Finals.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Colorado Avalanche will win the Stanley Cup

I think Colorado takes it. ... The premier Southern organization lifts [the Cup].

The Colorado Avalanche defeated the Tampa Bay Lightning 4-2 to win the 2022 Stanley Cup.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Cale Makar is the Connor McDavid of defensemen

He is a freak. He's a Connor McDavid of defense. It's just like, he's just so fucking good. He's so well-conditioned. He always makes the right play. He's sick on offense. He's basically a forward, but he never gets caught up the ice. He is fucking incredible.

Makar won the Norris Trophy and Conn Smythe in 2022, confirming his status as a generational talent.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Oilers vs. Avalanche series will be absolute fireworks

I'm so excited for that series. Oilers verse Avalanche is going to be fireworks... they broke a record in that last game with four goals in like a minute and a half back and forth.

The series was a sweep by the Avalanche, but it was high-scoring (6-8 in Game 1) and featured plenty of offensive 'fireworks'.
Win
MemesMemes

The Lightning will kill the Rangers in the Eastern Conference Finals

And then you kept on saying the lightning are going to kill him... [Memes] Yeah. A four. Not that sweet. Really? No, that's probably not going to happen. It's a rest verse rust.

The Tampa Bay Lightning won the series 4-2 to advance to the Stanley Cup Finals.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Colorado Avalanche are destined to win the Stanley Cup this year

I'm just convinced that the avalanche, that this is their year, this is their, I feel like they're just...

The Colorado Avalanche won the 2022 Stanley Cup.
Win
HankHank

The Lightning are psychological locks to beat the Maple Leafs in Game 7

They've been there. They've experienced it. They've played as a team. They've won championships. This is the first round. ... Toronto has the pressure of a city that needs a championship and an entire country that needs a championship.

The Lightning won Game 7.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Leafs are perfectly set up to lose to the Lightning in Game 6

The Leafs are back, which means that's where they're perfectly set up to lose. And I mean, we might have to game of the year, the Lightning in game six.

The Lightning did beat the Leafs in Game 6 (4-3 in OT) and eventually won the series in 7 games.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

NHL scoring is up because of power play strategies and better talent

The scoring staying up has a lot to do with the power plays and also just the games. Good right now. I think hockey's, I think the ratings are up... I think because of all the penalties called. So people's complaint right now is that it's not even, it doesn't even feel like hockey, some games... It's turned into just survive five on five, wait till you get a power play.

NHL scoring has trended upward significantly in the early 2020s, with league-wide average goals per game reaching levels not seen since the early 90s.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

No Canadian NHL team will win the Stanley Cup this year

I don't think Canada is going to win the Stanley cup. You're a maple leafs hater. You're an Edmonton Oilers alum... I just think the Leafs have this vibe about them... I don't know if [the Oilers] can figure it out.

The Colorado Avalanche won the 2022 Stanley Cup. No Canadian team reached the final.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Maple Leafs have a legitimate mental block when leading series

The maple leafs recently, while leading well down in the series, they're like seven or eight and three, well tied in the series. There are about 500 to eight and eight. And when leading these series, they're one to nine. So it's more of like, it might be a legit mental thing.

The Maple Leafs' struggles to close out series are well-documented, including seven consecutive first-round exits from 2017 to 2022.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Avalanche need Nazem Kadri to keep his cool to win the Stanley Cup.

Three playoffs in a row, [Nazem Kadri] has been suspended. He plays on the edge. He's one of those guys that makes teams good... but he can't control his temper. He has to just keep his cool, right? Because he's actually one of those guys that they need to win the cup.

Kadri played effectively and avoided suspension during the 2022 playoffs, even returning from a thumb injury to help the Avalanche win the Stanley Cup.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The NHL won the sports rivalry tonight because there are no NBA games and hockey has the TNT spotlight to itself.

Thursday night, Cinco de Mayo [is] the greatest achievement of hockey versus NBA rivalry... the NBA is not playing because NHL is on TNT tonight. Like the NHL won tonight.

The NBA indeed had no playoff games scheduled for that Thursday night.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Cale Makar is the next Paul Coffey and the best defenseman in the world

Cale Makar is easily the next Paul Coffey. We hadn't seen a defenseman who's able to drive traffic like him. He's essentially stepped in as the Connor McDavid of the back end. He's probably going to score 30 goals as a defenseman. He is just a freak of nature.

Makar won the Norris Trophy and Conn Smythe in 2022, confirming he was indeed the best defenseman that year.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 2022 Winter Olympics are failing because the NHL players aren't participating

The Olympics are a fucking fact that hockey, like the pros don't play. That's what draws everyone in. Like if team USA was playing Russia tomorrow morning, we would wake up and watch it. We'd wake up and watch it.

The 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics were the lowest-rated ever in the U.S. While many factors contributed, the absence of NHL stars in the hockey tournament was widely cited as a major loss for the Games' marquee event.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Arizona Coyotes should 'Tank for Shane' to save the franchise

For the betterment of the organization tank for Shane [Wright]... you need to get those generational players to start somewhere.

The Coyotes did finish with the second-worst record in the league, effectively tanking, though they didn't end up with the #1 pick.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Seattle Kraken won't make the playoffs in their inaugural season

I personally don't think that they're going to make playoffs, even though they're in the weakest division in the NHL. I think that they're, they're going to be at cusp team.

The Kraken finished last in the Pacific Division and missed the playoffs.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

John Tavares will be out for the remainder of the NHL playoffs

And also that John Tavares got hurt and is probably out. Do you think he's out for the playoffs? I would assume. I don't know.

Tavares did not return for the remainder of the 2021 playoffs.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I will not feel any sadness when NBC loses its NHL broadcasting rights because their current coverage is an abomination.

NBC, I want to give a shout out to NBC... the score bug and no Doc Emmerich... just makes it easy. Like, it's okay to say goodbye to NBC. The score bug is an abomination to the Lord. And not having Doc out there... I want to thank NBC for making this as easy as possible.

The NHL rights did move to ESPN and Turner (TNT/TBS) starting in the 2021-22 season. Whether the coverage improved is subjective, but the transition happened as predicted.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2021 NHL playoffs are under a 'bird alert' because every bird-themed team has lost their opening games.

Sabermetric stat of the week for the NHL playoffs, the entire league's on bird alert. All bird teams have lost so far. It's just the penguins. That counts.

At the time of recording, the Penguins (the only bird team in the playoffs) had lost Game 1 to the Islanders.
Win
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Buffalo Sabres are a 'broken organization' that needs to get worse to get better

It's just one of those organizations right now that seem a little bit cursed, and I would imagine that it's going to have to get a lot worse before it even gets better... They're a broken organization.

The Sabres finished last in the league in 2021 and eventually traded Eichel, essentially restarting a rebuild.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Whoever wins the all-Canadian division will get smoked in the playoffs by the American teams

The all Canadian division is sick... I think that Toronto's a wagon... but I don't know how deep the division is. So people are like, Oh my God, they're going to come... Whoever comes out of that division, they're going to get smoked anyways.

The Montreal Canadiens represented the North (Canada) division in the final four and the Cup final, where they were soundly defeated 4-1 by the Tampa Bay Lightning.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Chicago Blackhawks have no chance of making the playoffs

I said, it's great to watch, but there's no chance they're making the playoffs. No chance. I just don't see it happening there's like the depth isn't there maybe if Toews comes back but who knows what's going on there.

The Blackhawks finished 6th in the Central Division and missed the 2021 playoffs.
Win
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Tampa Bay Lightning are going to win the Stanley Cup again

I can't pick against Tampa... their team is just so stacked. Last year you saw they were like just heads and shoulders above anyone else. And people kind of say, oh, they don't have Kucherov all year. I'm like, yeah, that's great. They're going to get him back right for the playoffs... he'll be ready to go. And then you just throw that guy in with the team they already have.

The Tampa Bay Lightning did win the 2021 Stanley Cup, defeating the Montreal Canadiens 4-1 in the final.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers