Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A long-haired quarterback has never won a Super Bowl

I don't get the whole Jesus complex thing. When was the last time a long-haired quarterback won a Super Bowl? I can't think of one.

Aaron Rodgers had somewhat long hair (for a QB) when he won, though they debate this in real-time. Later, Patrick Mahomes (curls) and others have had non-traditional short hair, but 'shoulder length' as PFT defines it remains rare for winners.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trevor Lawrence loves his hair more than he loves football

I think he loves his hair more than football. There you go.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Lawrence has played multiple seasons with high commitment, including leading the Jaguars to a playoff comeback win.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Cleveland Browns are my pick to win the Super Bowl because they have three former #1 overall picks

The Browns are now officially, if I had to pick a Super Bowl winner today, it would be the Browns just because they have three number one overall picks in the last five years. ... Miles Garrett, Baker Mayfield, and Clowney. ... That right there just tells me from my own draft analysis, that's the greatest team that's ever been created.

The 2021 Browns finished 8-9 and missed the playoffs.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sucking is better than stinking, and stinking is better than being trash in the NFL

I think that Jadeveon Clowney kind of sucks more than he stinks. I think sucks is better than stinking. ... If a guy sucks, he can still be pretty good, but he's not living up to the expectations that come along with his name. ... If you stink, you shouldn't be on the field. Then if you're trash, you shouldn't be in the league.

Subjective classification of performance terminology.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jadeveon Clowney earned 60% of his career earnings from a single hit against Michigan

How many millions of dollars do you think Jadeveon Clowney has gained in his life, in his career, from that one hit against Michigan? There has to be a number. 60% of his career earnings. Every time you think of him, you think of that hit.

While mathematically impossible to verify, the hit is universally cited as his defining highlight.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets were right to refuse a 1st round pick for Sam Darnold because Kyle Shanahan would have made them look like idiots

I actually am going to side with the Jets here simply because Kyle Shanahan is that type of coach that if he got Sam Darnold, Sam Darnold would be a pro bowler. ... It'd make you look bad. Like, he's the one guy I wouldn't want to trade my quarterback to just knowing that he's going to end up looking good and everyone would be like, oh, the Jets suck even more.

The rumor itself (49ers offering #12) was later largely debunked as fake, and Darnold eventually struggled in Carolina before becoming a 49er later in his career anyway.
Void
Barry PepperBarry Pepper

Vin Diesel is a really intelligent filmmaker who should direct more

When I first met [Vin Diesel], he was a director. ... I would love to see him direct, you know, because he's a really intelligent filmmaker.

This is a subjective professional assessment of an artist.
Void
Barry PepperBarry Pepper

Harrison Ford and Tom Cruise always play themselves, whereas Tom Hanks is a chameleon

Harrison Ford... he's not a character actor. He always plays Harrison Ford or Tom Cruise. He always plays Tom Cruise, whereas Tom Hanks has that sort of ability to chameleonize a bit.

Subjective analysis of acting styles and star personas.
Void
Barry PepperBarry Pepper

Boxers like Floyd Mayweather and Jake Paul should honor the sport by entering the octagon

I always feel like Mayweather or Jake Paul or whatever his name is should really honor their sport, too. They talk such a big game, but they would never go into the octagon. ... Mayweather would never go into the domain of McGregor.

Subjective opinion on sport integrity and cross-discipline fighting.
Void
Barry PepperBarry Pepper

Roger Maris is the real home run king

[The asterisk] represents like the real home run king in my estimation. ... [Mark McGwire] apologized to [Maris's widow] for the shame that he brought to that record and breaking Roger's record and it being so well known that he was juiced the whole time.

This is a subjective debate about baseball history.
Void
Will ZalatorisWill Zalatoris

Tony Romo is a genius when it comes to the mechanics of a golf swing

The guy is a genius when it comes to the mechanics. Like he understands people's golf swings better than I even think some coaches do with their students just because he sits there and he studies them nonstop.

Subjective assessment of Romo's knowledge.
Loss
Will ZalatorisWill Zalatoris

Tony Romo is good enough to play at the PGA Tour level on his best days

So his good days are totally good enough to play at tour level. Um, it's just the bad is just where he's got to fix it and you know i think he's a great chipper and putter he's a pretty good iron player.

Romo has played in several PGA Tour events on sponsor exemptions but has never made a cut and eventually focused on broadcasting.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

It is a 'big sunglasses on the back of the head guy' move to rip a ball away from a 5-year-old at a park

[Speaker 2]: his son was way older than mine, and he just stole the ball from our ball. And I was like, you can't take that. [PFT Commenter]: You know what that is? That's a big sunglasses on the back of the head upside down guy move.

This is a humorous characterization.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Julian Edelman will eventually make the Hall of Fame in 20 years because the 'Patriots Dynasty' narrative will keep it alive

If I had to guess, I think [Edelman] will end up in it in 20 years because people will keep it alive and it will grow in stature... whenever 150 [anniversary] comes and they start opening the door to everyone and they clean up the Hall of Fame. That feels like a Julian Edelman [year].

Edelman is not in the Hall of Fame yet. It will take at least 20 years to see if this specific prediction of him being 'grandfathered' in comes true.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Julian Edelman isn't actually retiring and will try to come back

I have a lot of faith in his work ethic, and I think he definitely is going to try to rehab it and come back. [Edelman] isn't actually retired.

Edelman never returned to the NFL following his April 2021 retirement announcement.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Hall of Fame has a bias against the slot receiver position

Does the Hall of Fame have a bias towards a position like slot receiver? Because it's similar to a nose tackle who doesn't get the sacks. A slot receiver might not have all the receiving yards or all the touchdowns, but he's impacting the game in another way.

This is a subjective debate about voting trends in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You can't tell the story of football without Julian Edelman and Eli Manning

The best argument that Julian Edelman has and Eli Manning is you can't tell the story of football without those guys. Because you can't tell the story of the Falcons Super Bowl without Julian Edelman. You can't tell the story of Tom Brady's career without Eli Manning.

This is a subjective standard for Hall of Fame induction.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

New Washington Football Team tight end Sammis Reyes is a future Hall of Famer

My Washington football team just signed a collegiate basketball player to play tight end. He's never played football before. His name is Sammis Reyes. He's 6'6", 260, runs a 4.65. He's the baby Gronk, the next baby Gronk... in my mind, he's already a Hall of Famer.

Sammis Reyes played sparingly in the NFL and did not become a Hall of Famer; he is currently out of the league.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Nuggets are 'cooked' for the season after Jamal Murray's injury

Jamal Murray tears ACL. So the Nuggets are cooked and that does suck because they actually were like one of those teams like, oh, maybe if they get a nice run going. So we're going to be Jazz fans now.

The Nuggets were swept in the second round by the Phoenix Suns following the Murray injury, failing to reach the conference finals they made the year before.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ronald Acuña Jr. is officially the face of baseball

My cool throne is baseball because we do officially—I'm ready to call it—Ronald Acuña fully the face of baseball already. I just think Ronald Acuña, like, did you see what he did? He beat out the very routine infield hit... scores tagging up from third on a pop-up to the second baseman.

This is a subjective title, though Acuña did go on to win an MVP in 2023.
Void
Bill BurrBill Burr

24-hour news networks should be tried for treason for dividing the country

I am a firm believer that there should no longer be 24-hour news networks because just the sheer panic of having to fill up all that time. I just find that CNN and Fox News, they should be tried for treason. All they do is divide the locker room.

This is a personal opinion on media regulation and national unity.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Overloading dumb fans with statistics actually makes them dumber

Overloading dumb people with a lot of statistics makes them dumber. It just makes them more confident in their ideas and their conclusions they were going to reach anyways.

This is an observation on human behavior and fan psychology.
Void
Bill BurrBill Burr

Julian Edelman belongs in the Hall of Fame for his big game performance

Whenever we needed a first down, whenever we needed a big play, somehow that guy got open. I would put that [Atlanta Super Bowl] catch arguably as one of the greatest Super Bowl catches of all time. I look at him like he was on the modern day Steelers of the 70s and he was our Swan or Stallworth and both of those guys are in. I put him in there.

Whether Edelman belongs is a matter of HOF voter opinion.
Void
Bill BurrBill Burr

Every airline landing where you don't die is a 'great' landing

If you didn't die and they didn't break the plane, it's a fucking great landing because you also don't know what they're dealing with. They can be coming in at the last second... and you got like 300 people and your own life on the line. I don't know how they do that.

Subjective standard for 'greatness' in airline safety.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Clapping when a plane lands is good because it puts everyone on the same team

I do like to clap. Why not? It's incredible that we landed. It puts you all on the same team, Bill... When an entire plane gives a round of applause for a safe landing, you feel like you're all in this together.

Subjective view on social etiquette.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The OMAD (One Meal A Day) diet is going to 'kick everyone's ass'

I'm on a diet. You've got to get your stomach small, bro. Once you reach OMAD (One Meal A Day), it's a level of intermittent fasting... If I never eat again, I will be skinny. OMAD is going to kick everyone's ass.

Big Cat's claim that the OMAD diet would 'kick everyone's ass' is a subjective opinion about a diet trend, not a verifiable prediction.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tiger Woods would have won the 2021 Masters if he had been able to play

I think Tiger [Woods] would have won this Masters, I'll be honest with you. I agree.

This is entirely speculative as Tiger Woods was recovering from a major car accident at the time and could not compete.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Hideki Matsuyama should serve blowfish liver at the Champions Dinner next year

If I'm Hideki, I serve blowfish liver and let the chips fall where they may maybe thin out the field a little bit. See who gets poisoned.

Matsuyama served a menu including Miyazaki Wagyu, but did not serve poisonous blowfish liver.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brooks Koepka is a hero for playing the Masters on one leg

We should also say the real winner of this Masters is Brooks Koepka. Competing on one leg like a warrior. Walking paralyzed man. Exactly. So the fact he was even able to get out there and play two rounds of golf. That's impressive.

Koepka did play through a significant knee injury, but 'hero' status is a subjective characterization used for comedic effect.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Faldo has a more 'nappable' voice than Jim Nance.

I like your take, by the way, that Nick Faldo might have a more nappable voice than Jim Nance. I think he does... when I hear Faldo, it's like you just hit me in the face with a gram of Dramamine.

The 'nappability' of a broadcaster's voice is a subjective preference for listeners who enjoy sleeping through sports.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Will Zalatoris is ready to join the PMT 'stable' of golfers

Will Zalatoris was my guy. I was riding him like a horse. I was hoping that he was going to come through. He is – he's the one to watch. I think we need to get him on the show. I think we need to add him to our stable of Brooks [Koepka], Max Homa, and I think Will Zalatoris is – I think he's ready.

Zalatoris went on to have several more top-10 major finishes and became a recognizable star on the tour.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Augusta National is the Kardashians of golf courses

I think that Augusta National is the Kardashians of golf courses because everyone talks about it all the time. It's perfectly manicured. It always makes sure that it's presented in its best light. Even with the papers that they give you, they give you a wrapping paper for a pimento cheese sandwich... That's green, so even if it falls on the ground, you don't see all the trash getting blown around. It's always got its best foot forward, and they will go out of their way to make sure that it is never presented in a frumpy light.

This is a subjective analogy meant for humor, comparing the brand management of two entities.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Hideki Matsuyama's 2021 Masters win was the most successful run ever for a guy wearing sunglasses upside down on the back of his hat.

I also think that [Hideki Matsuyama] is the most – that was the most successful run that someone has ever had wearing their sunglasses on the back of their hat. That move is usually for a guy with truck nuts who's going to road rage... And so him doing that... there's got to be a group of guys who are probably way too sunburn... cheering in their trailer being like, he did it for us.

This is a humorous observation about fashion and success that cannot be objectively proven.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Hideki Matsuyama will light the Olympic torch in Tokyo this summer

Sir Nick [Faldo] had an awesome take... He said, I think that if he wins, Hideki will be the one who lights the Olympic torch this summer.

Naomi Osaka lit the Olympic cauldron at the Tokyo 2020 opening ceremony.
Void
HankHank

Ronald Acuña Jr. should be the face of baseball.

Ronald Acuna Jr. Face of baseball? Face of baseball. He should be... He had like a 420-foot home run, and he beat out an infield single on the same game. He's got it all. Five tool player.

The 'face of baseball' is an unofficial and subjective title, though Acuña did go on to win the NL MVP in 2023.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL wide receivers wearing single-digit numbers is a 'there goes the neighborhood' moment

The NFL is just, I guess, giving clearance to wide receivers to wear single-digit numbers... It's a major There Goes the Neighborhood moment. I think it's going to happen. Peter King leaked it out, and when Peter King has a scoop like that, it's Roger Goodell just being like, Peter, you are my trial balloon.

The rule change was officially adopted by the NFL later in April 2021, allowing receivers and other positions to wear single-digit numbers.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

James Harden is the best player on the Brooklyn Nets

The Brooklyn Nets this year, they are 36-17. They are 27-7 with James Harden playing, and they are 9-10 without. James Harden is the best player in the Brooklyn Nets.

Harden's impact was undeniable, though 'best player' is subjective among three Hall of Famers. Harden eventually forced a trade away from the team a year later.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alex Rodriguez is buying the Timberwolves specifically to move them to Seattle

It's definitely a move, though, for A-Rod. He is buying that team to move it. To Seattle.

As of 2024, the Timberwolves remain in Minnesota, and ownership has publicly committed to keeping them there, though expansion talks for Seattle continue separately.
Void
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Bryson DeChambeau struggled at the Masters because he lacked specific yardage books

Augusta National, they don't provide [yardage books]... I almost wonder if it kind of jams up [Bryson DeChambeau's] airspace, so to speak, because you've got to sort it out completely on your own, and I think that's why you hear people talk so much about local knowledge and about playing here for years.

DeChambeau has historically struggled at Augusta (T46 in 2021) compared to other courses, supporting the idea that the course's unique restrictions affect his style.
Open
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Winning the Masters will eventually be worth over $1 billion to Hideki Matsuyama

Andy North kept saying to me, you cannot comprehend the amount of pressure that's on this young man's shoulders... He's like, this is worth a billion dollars to him... This guy's 29 years old. He's got to have, you know, give him 40 years of being able to be, I'm the Masters champion in Japan. He's like, you could be a nine figure a year guy... David Duval... told me this morning, he goes, look, that's not, that's not crazy at all. He said, it might be conservative.

While hard to verify exactly, Matsuyama's endorsement potential in Japan skyrocketed, with estimates from experts like Rickie Fowler's agent suggesting $20M+ annually, which over a lifetime makes the $1B figure plausible but pending long-term results.
Void
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

The chicken salad on brioche is the best new food item at Augusta National.

That's not the play, though, by the way, fellas. That's not the play. Chicken salad on the brioche. That was new for 2021. I ate about 11 of those today.

Food preference at a golf tournament is entirely subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Maryland basketball's success is cheap because it's built on transfer portal 'mercenaries'

Do you think that your success next year, which I'm sure you guys will have tons of success at Maryland, is cheapened by the fact that it's all transfers? ... Classy and honorable to talk to a kid when he's 12 years old and keep talking to him until he goes to your college, and then you win with him as opposed to getting just a mercenary from another school.

The concept of success being 'cheap' is an entirely subjective sports-fan argument used for baiting rival fans.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Maryland basketball has to win the national title by at least 20 points for their transfer-heavy success to be valid.

They [Maryland] have to win the national title by 20 points plus.

Maryland went 15-17 in the 2021-2022 season and did not win the national title, let alone by 20 points.
Void
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Wisconsin basketball fans are delusional because they think their team never fouls.

You guys [Wisconsin fans] think you've never fouled anybody because you coach not to foul. And then if someone calls a foul, the entire building acts like an outrageous crime against humanity has taken place.

This is a subjective critique of a fan base's behavior and bias.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Augusta National pipes in bird noises for the Masters broadcast

I'm more convinced than ever that the birds are actually piped in crowd noise. Agreed. There's one bird in particular. They play its call over and over and over. It's a cardinal, I think. They're getting sloppy with it. I think it might be a whippoorwill. But whatever it is, it's very obvious.

While CBS was caught using recorded bird sounds in 1990 and 1991, Augusta National and modern broadcasters maintain the sounds are natural, though the theory persists among fans.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bryson DeChambeau looks fat when he is playing poorly

When you're bigger and you're doing well, you're strong. And when you're doing poorly, you're fat. And he looks fat today. Not to body shame, but there's something about the plus four next to his name that the strength now becomes a little pudgy.

This is a purely subjective observation about visual perception based on athletic performance.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I like Patrick Reed more than Bryson DeChambeau because Reed is a genuine villain

I somehow like Patrick Reed more because he's more of a villain than Bryson is... He's the ultimate heel in golf. Bryson is like, he's an aspiring heel. [Reed] knows everyone hates him, and he kind of has just accepted it.

Subjective opinion on which golfer is more likable or a better villain.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Brooks Koepka playing the Masters on one leg is the most heroic thing in sports history

Brooks is playing on basically one leg. It's probably the most heroic thing I've ever seen in any sport ever. This is like Willis Reed. This is Kirk Gibson. Everything that you can think of where someone just triumphs over all these injuries and hardships, that's Brooks shooting plus two today.

While heroic in a sports sense, calling a plus-two round 'the most heroic thing ever' is objectively incorrect and satirical.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Sean Miller will take an assistant coaching job in the NBA next

Did you see that Sean Miller, apparently he's going to get an assistant coaching job in the NBA. So that seems like his immediate future. Which is hilarious that someone who was... under sanctions and alleged sanctions and all these things and bad dealings with agents and everything. And then someone owes him a favor in the NBA?

Sean Miller did not take an NBA assistant job. He sat out a year and was then hired as the head coach at Xavier in 2022.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Coach K's role with USA Basketball is a major gray area for recruiting

Coach K just, you know, getting to be friends with all of the NBA All-Stars and then, like, when he goes on recruiting visits being like, oh, you want me to FaceTime LeBron? Again, not cheating, but I would say that's a gray area, a major gray area.

While legally permissible under NCAA rules, many peers and analysts agreed it provided an unmatched recruiting advantage.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers