Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Butts are on the Hot Seat because boobs are back in style

My hot seat is butts. Big hot seat because New York Post... they just wrote a trend piece about how boobs are back. So going to put butts square on the hot seat. Guess what? You thought it was cool to have a big butt? Everyone that went out there and got butt implants, you might want to see if those go two ways and you can just move them up to your chest.

Fashion trends are cyclical and subjective; there is no objective metric to prove one body part is 'back' over another.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are back and have solved Kevin White's injury issues by reminding him that he was once good at football

The Bears have another first round pick this year with Kevin White. This is the third year that he's the first round pick. And we're going to be fine because it turns out the Bears... are trying to remind Kevin White he was once good at football. So, problem solved. We're off to a really good start. Bears are back.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Kevin White played only one game in 2017 and was eventually released, proving the Bears were very much not 'back'.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Honey Nut Cheerios are the greatest cereal of all time

I've got a great value pick at number two: Honey Nut Cheerios. I think they're the goat. I'm just gonna say that... you forget the bee puts his honey in there for you.

Cereal preference is entirely subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Froot Loops are the superior cereal to Apple Jacks because Apple Jacks taste like pink snot

Apple Jacks and Cinnamon Toast Crunch, you can't eat like many, many bowls... they taste like pink snot. It's gross. Fruit Loops are superior Apple Jacks that look exactly the same.

Void
HankHank

Apple Jacks milk is the best leftover cereal milk on the list

Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Apple Jacks are both not only good cereals, but the milk in the cereal bowl after the cereal's gone is better than any other cereal on the list.

Leftover cereal milk preference is subjective.
Win
Kevin MillarKevin Millar

Bryce Harper will eventually sign with the Philadelphia Phillies

If you were to ask me straight up, [Harper goes to] Philadelphia. Philadelphia... Because it's 212 feet to right field, 279 to center, and 175 feet to left. So he's thinking Hall of Fame.

Bryce Harper signed a massive free-agent contract with the Phillies in March 2019.
Loss
Chris RoseChris Rose

Manny Machado will end up playing for the New York Yankees

I think Machado ends up with the Yankees, and I think Harper goes to Philadelphia.

Machado signed with the San Diego Padres in February 2019.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bryce Harper will sign with the Cubs because his dog is named Wrigley and he wants to play with Kris Bryant

I think [Harper] is going to come to the Cubs because he wants to play with Kris Bryant. Went to high school with him. His dog's name is Wrigley. Connect those dots.

Harper signed a 13-year contract with the Philadelphia Phillies in 2019, not the Cubs.
Void
Kevin MillarKevin Millar

Being a great clubhouse guy means having no ego and not intimidating teammates

I'll tell you what makes a great locker room guy: immediately when you're hung like the light switch in the off position. Got it. So I think that immediately lowers a lot of stuff... When you care about guys and truly care about them, you want guys to do well.

The value of clubhouse chemistry is a subjective and debated topic in sports analytics.
Loss
Kevin MillarKevin Millar

The Yankees win the World Series if Sonny Gray remains an ace

The Yankees win the World Series if your boy Sonny Gray stays at number one.

The Yankees did not win the World Series during Sonny Gray's tenure, and Gray was eventually demoted to the bullpen and traded.
Loss
Chris RoseChris Rose

The Yankees win the World Series if Masahiro Tanaka maintains his current level of pitching

The Yankees win the World Series if Tanaka throws the ball the way he's been throwing.

The Yankees lost to the Astros in the 2017 ALCS; the Astros went on to win the World Series.
Loss
Chris RoseChris Rose

The Indians win the World Series if Jason Kipnis and Lonnie Chisenhall return to their top form

The Indians win a World Series if Jason Kipnis and Lonnie Chisenhall return to Chisenhall's first half and Kipnis what he was in 2016.

The Indians lost in the 2017 ALDS to the Yankees.
Win
Kevin MillarKevin Millar

The Astros win the World Series if Francisco Liriano moves to the bullpen and gets out tough lefties

The Astros win the World Series if Liriano could move to the bullpen and get out tough lefties.

The Astros did win the 2017 World Series, though Liriano played a very minor role in the postseason.
Loss
Chris RoseChris Rose

The Nationals win the World Series if Stephen Strasburg stays healthy

The Nats win the World Series if they have Strasburg. Simple. Open and shut.

The Nationals lost in the 2017 NLDS to the Cubs.
Loss
Kevin MillarKevin Millar

The Cubs win the World Series if Jake Arrieta returns to his Cy Young form

The Cubs win it all if Jake Arrieta pitches to his Cy Young form, even give me the 16 version of Jake Arrieta. If he steps up and becomes that guy, because they need him as that guy.

The Cubs lost in the 2017 NLCS to the Dodgers.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Cubs are a different team when Addison Russell is playing at his full potential

I think the Cubs, they're a different team when Addison Russell is who he should be. So that's a guy who, when he's feeling it and he's hitting the ball the way he should be hitting the ball, he's playing defense how he plays defense, I think their lineup completely changes.

While Russell was a key defender, his offensive and personal issues eventually led to him being a net negative for the franchise.
Void
Kevin MillarKevin Millar

Theo Epstein is smarter than most GMs because he trusts his instincts and asks players for feedback instead of just relying on spreadsheets

He's way smarter than a lot of those guys. Just because you're in this certain job title, there's not a whole lot of instincts going on in some of these places, bro. Theo has a unique gift of knowing boys club, of knowing clubhouse stuff... he goes out and asks players for things. Do you think this guy's good?

Void
Kevin MillarKevin Millar

Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens definitely belong in the Hall of Fame

Barry Bonds? Yes. I think yes. Roger Clemens? Yes.

Both players have failed to be elected by the BBWAA, though their inclusion remains a major point of debate.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Space is cold, therefore the sun is actually cold

Why is space cold if the sun is hot? We think the sun is cold. Outer space is black, but it's cold. So shouldn't outer space be really, really hot? [The sun] is not [hot]. Have you ever looked the sun directly in the eyes? Never have. Right. So does it even exist?

Hot TakeLifeScorchingSarcastic
Scientifically, the sun is a nearly perfect sphere of hot plasma. Space is cold because it is a vacuum with few particles to hold heat.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Odell Beckham Jr. is the best wide receiver in the NFL

I'm saying he's the best wide receiver in football. Odell Beckham, is it really the hair that makes him memorable or is it the fact that he's the best wide receiver in football?

This was a highly debated topic in 2017, with Antonio Brown and Julio Jones also in the conversation.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michael Jordan would amputate his own leg just to win a game against LaVar Ball

Michael Jordan is also so competitive that if LaVar responds to him, he might get his leg amputated just to play one game of basketball and beat him.

This is a comedic exaggeration and not a literal prediction.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Ravens team president is named Dick Gass

I was reading an article about [the Ravens], and I forgot the team president's name is Dick Gass. Dick Cass, but it's Dick Gass.

His name is Dick Cass, not Dick Gass.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James is dead and Steph Curry murdered him

LeBron James is dead. D-E-D. Dead. Steph Curry murdered him. Kyrie backstabbed him, went behind his back. Very Shakespearean, this whole thing.

The statement is metaphorical; LeBron James is physically alive and remained the top player in the league for years following this.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA offseason is currently better than Game of Thrones

LeBron James, the NBA offseason has now become, I hate to be the guy who's like the offseason is better than the real season, but it's making a run for its money because it's better than Game of Thrones.

Subjective comparison between a sports league's news cycle and a TV show.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James is definitely the alpha over Steph Curry

You could tell that Steph Curry... practiced that [impression] in front of a mirror a lot. Like, he's so deep into Steph Curry's head. LeBron James is definitely the alpha in this situation.

Subjective assessment of player dynamics and psychological 'alpha' status.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Steph Curry and Kyrie Irving are on the lamer side of NBA players

Those are two of, like – if you look at, like, the coolness factor of NBA players, [Steph Curry and Kyrie Irving] are definitely on the lamer side, and they are clowning on LeBron.

Purely subjective opinion on player 'coolness'.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James will average 30-10-10 this season

LeBron is going to go on a rampage this year. He's like 30-10-10 for sure. Just mark it down. I mean, this is what happened in the NBA Finals... His numbers are going to keep going up.

LeBron had an incredible season (27.5 PPG, 8.6 RPG, 9.1 APG) and played all 82 games, but did not reach the 30-10-10 threshold.
Push
HankHank

LeBron James will lose early in the playoffs and leave Cleveland

He's going to gas himself out, lose in the first or second round of the playoffs, and then leave town.

LeBron did leave Cleveland in 2018, but he led them to the NBA Finals that year, not an early exit.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jon Jones will easily beat Brock Lesnar if he stays clean

Jon Bones Jones, if he stays clean, he will kick the shit out of Brock Lesnar. I mean, he can fight with anyone. He will beat him up.

The fight never took place, so the outcome cannot be verified.
Loss
Phil HellmuthPhil Hellmuth

I will win the World Series of Poker Main Event again

I still think I'm going to win [the World Series of Poker Main Event] sometime, and I'll tell you why. It has the best structure of any poker tournament we have... you just have a lot of time to work your chips up.

Hellmuth has not won the Main Event again since this 2017 prediction, though he has won several other bracelets.
Win
Phil HellmuthPhil Hellmuth

Tobey Maguire is the greatest celebrity poker player in the world

The biggest celebrity winner probably in the world is Tobey Maguire... He's really good. Ben Affleck is an excellent poker player as well, and these guys play in some high-stakes games.

While exact earnings are private, numerous sources in the high-stakes poker world have corroborated that Maguire was the biggest winner in the legendary private games.
Void
Phil HellmuthPhil Hellmuth

Charles Barkley is a good gambler who just gets unlucky

I played blackjack with [Charles Barkley]. We played high stakes blackjack together recently, and he was playing really good. He was unlucky, I've got to say. He was playing perfectly. And I was playing perfectly, and I think I won $30,000, and he went the other way... but I mean, he was just unlucky.

Whether someone is 'lucky' or 'unlucky' in gambling is subjective and impossible to prove, though Barkley's massive losses are well-documented.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Colin Kaepernick clearly should be signed by an NFL team

To start the offseason, I thought the Colin Kaepernick storyline was bullshit. But now it's kind of like, all right, he's clearly – someone's just – like, he should be signed. They signed two backup quarterbacks that I had never heard of.

This is a subjective evaluation of talent vs. baggage, though Kaepernick never played in the NFL again after 2016.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Going through a divorce while your wife is pregnant is a baller move

Congratulations, I will pray for our son. Going through a divorce while your wife is pregnant is a baller move.

Subjective assessment of a 'baller move' in a satirical context.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Every reporter should Google themselves once a week

If you're a reporter, if you're a journalist, you have to be able to take the heat as well. Every reporter should Google themselves once a week, I would say. Got to make sure your name's out there. Read all the hate possible.

This is a subjective career/lifestyle choice for media members.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I want to name my son 'Winner'

I want to name my son, my eventual son, Winner. Okay this is along the same lines of naming him coach. It's an alpha name... who's gonna be like no I don't want to have winner on my team.

Personal desire/hypothetical parenting choice.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

NFL critics who claim they stopped watching are actually still watching every Sunday

You know my favorite are the people on Twitter that say, I can no longer morally watch football. You are a fucking liar because I know you're fucking watching the Red Zone from 1 o'clock to 7 o'clock every fucking Sunday. You can't stop watching the NFL. You can't. Like it or not, it's here.

This is subjective social commentary on viewer behavior, but viewership data generally remained high despite controversy, supporting the idea of 'hate-watching' or empty threats.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Flacco's back injury will actually benefit Danny Woodhead's usage

I think that's just more touches for [Danny] Woodhead. [Joe Flacco's] going to have a great year, and I'm telling you, this is going to be good for Woodhead.

Woodhead only played 8 games in 2017 due to his own injuries, and Flacco had a mediocre year as the Ravens missed the playoffs. The predicted benefit didn't materialize.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Magnus Ver Magnussen is the second greatest athlete ever behind only Barry Bonds

I don't think there's ever been an athlete that's better at what they do than Magnus [Ver Magnussen], with maybe the exception of Barry Bonds.

This is a subjective comparison of dominance across entirely different sports.
Push
HankHank

Roger Goodell skipping the Patriots season opener is a sign of disrespect that will lead to another title

Probably when [Roger] Goodell doesn't show up to game one. That's going to be a clear sign of disrespect that [the Patriots] are going to have to avenge by going to the Super Bowl and winning another championship.

The Patriots did reach the Super Bowl (LII) but lost to the Eagles. They did not win the championship that year.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I would bet on Stephen A. Smith in a fight against LeBron James

I would put money on Stephen A. Smith in a fight against LeBron James.

LeBron James is 6'9" and 250lbs of elite muscle; Stephen A. Smith is a sports journalist. The outcome is obvious but the fight never happened.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is setting up excuses to leave Cleveland by blaming Kyrie and the front office

This is all setting up. You first have the GM situation. You have Dan Gilbert acting crazy as always. You have Kyrie asking for a trade. LeBron can now leave Cleveland and be like, it's not my fault. It was all on you guys.

LeBron did leave for the Lakers in the 2018 offseason after the Cavs' situation continued to deteriorate. Big Cat correctly identified the narrative strategy.
Loss
Cian FaheyCian Fahey

Jimmy Garoppolo is essentially Cody Kessler with a better logo

The way I've described him is it's like if you go into a shop and you've got 10 shirts that are exactly the same. It's like buying the one with the Nike logo on it. It's not necessarily a better shirt. It just looks better. [Garoppolo] and Cody Kessler is not a big difference.

Garoppolo went on to lead the 49ers to a Super Bowl and had a successful (though injury-prone) starting career, whereas Kessler washed out of the league quickly. The comparison was proven wrong over time.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Mitchell Trubisky will win at least five Super Bowls

Kian, tell me, as a Bears fan, that Mitch Trubisky is going to be a franchise quarterback and probably win no less than five Super Bowls.

Trubisky never won a Super Bowl and was eventually replaced by the Bears. He became a journeyman backup.
Void
Cian FaheyCian Fahey

Mitchell Trubisky should start immediately rather than sitting

Normally, you want to sit a rookie quarterback if he needs to fix his footwork or fix his throwing motion... But Trubisky's got good feet. He reacts to pressure well... I would play him so he can learn. He's got good accuracy. He's a good athlete. He's really poised. He can go through reads. And I'd happily take him as a starter.

Trubisky sat for the first four games of 2017 before starting. His career didn't ultimately justify the high evaluation, but the 'should he start' debate was a major topic in 2017.
Win
Cian FaheyCian Fahey

Brock Osweiler has no idea what he is looking at on the field despite his physical advantages

Brock Osweiler is beautiful because he's like a deer in the pocket where he's just falling over himself. And he's got all that height to see everything, but he has no idea what he's looking at. So he just ends up throwing the ball at defenders all day.

Osweiler is widely considered one of the biggest quarterback busts in NFL history, largely due to the exact lack of vision and processing speed Cian identifies here.
Void
Cian FaheyCian Fahey

Even in retirement, Jay Cutler is a better quarterback option than Josh McCown

I think I'd take Jay Cutler, even while retired Jay Cutler, because Josh McCown is, much like Ryan Fitzpatrick, he's one of these brilliant players who fits every system... but throws loads of interceptions, runs into every sack, and can't run any system.

Cutler briefly un-retired to play for the Dolphins in 2017 and was mediocre; McCown had a surprisingly solid year for the Jets. The preference remains subjective.
Void
Cian FaheyCian Fahey

Aaron Rodgers is the best quarterback in the NFL

Well, I think the obvious one is Aaron Rodgers... [His struggles were because] His wide receivers can't catch the ball. Davante Adams can't get open. Jordy Nelson couldn't move because he was coming off an ACL tear.

Rodgers is widely considered one of the greatest of all time, and Davante Adams eventually became an All-Pro, though Cian's specific critique of their 2016 season is subjective film analysis.
Loss
Cian FaheyCian Fahey

Tom Brady showed signs of regression in the 2016 playoffs despite winning the Super Bowl

The playoffs last year weren't great. I know they won the Super Bowl, they came back, but in the fourth quarter of that Falcons game, if you go through it, he threw the ball to defenders. On the Edelman catch, if you look at where that ball arrives and where he threw it, it was straight to the defender... That's just lucky.

Brady went on to win the NFL MVP in 2017 and led the league in passing yards, strongly refuting the 'regression' narrative at that time.
Void
Cian FaheyCian Fahey

Philip Rivers had a better career than Tony Romo because he reached an AFC Championship game

Better career, probably Rivers, because he actually got to an AFC Championship game... Rivers is phenomenal at making the players work as designed... Romo was kind of great at playing outside of the system, outside of structure when the pocket broke down.

This remains a subjective debate, though Rivers does hold the edge in most cumulative statistics and the specific playoff advancement mentioned.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers