Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Green Bay Packers are the least desirable team to play for in the NFL

The Green Bay Packers are a classless organization by cutting Blake Bortles. Probably least desirable team to play for in the NFL, according to Aaron Rodgers, not me, Aaron Rodgers. If you're a free agent listening to the show right now, Will Compton, don't you dare go to the Green Bay Packers because they will mistreat you.

Whether they are the 'least desirable' is a matter of opinion, but Rodgers' press conference did objectively highlight many of these internal issues.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers will retire mid-season before a divisional game to maximize pain for the Packers

If he is actually a man that believes what he says, he's going to retire in the middle of the season before a game against the division rival to inflict maximum pain upon the Green Bay Packers. So Aaron, I would suggest maybe quitting before a game against the Bears, maybe the day of a game against the Bears.

Rodgers played the entire 2021 season and won MVP.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers will become a year-to-year mercenary on one-year contracts after this season

I think this will be the last year for Aaron, because I think what he wants to do is he wants to do a sign-and-trade next year. He wants to go someplace for a one-year contract and then be a mercenary year-to-year, and then just go ring chasing all across maybe another four years after that playing for various teams.

Rodgers signed a massive 3-year extension with the Packers in March 2022 rather than taking year-to-year mercenary deals.
Win
Peyton ManningPeyton Manning

I realized early that to get an edge I had to out-prepare everyone because I couldn't out-throw or out-run anyone

I came to the realization that I couldn't out-throw anybody. I couldn't throw it 85 yards down the field like a Brett Favre. I couldn't outrun anybody clearly. I realized that to get an edge, I had to try to out-prepare anybody. I told myself that I was [working harder]. The main people I was trying to outwork was our opponent. It gave me confidence to go full speed ahead.

Peyton Manning's legendary preparation is a well-documented fact in NFL history.
Push
Peyton ManningPeyton Manning

Rookie quarterbacks like Trevor Lawrence and Zach Wilson should start immediately and play all 16 games to learn

I'm a believer in putting those guys in right away, put [Zach] Wilson in, put [Trevor] Lawrence in and let them play. Let them see how fast these defenses are. They're going to figure it out a lot sooner. I would like to get that [28 interceptions] record off my resume, and if Trevor Lawrence wants to break that this year, I am for it. But you got to be a 16-game starter to do it.

Both Lawrence and Wilson did start immediately. Lawrence threw 17 INTs and Wilson threw 11 in 2021; neither broke Peyton's record of 28.
Void
Peyton ManningPeyton Manning

The quality of a spiral is overrated; wobbly touchdowns count just the same

Every one of my records is getting broken... but nobody's throwing more wobbly touchdowns than me. Okay. I mean, the spiral is overrated, right? As long as it gets there. And the good thing about the wobbly pass, a lot of dropped interceptions. Because these guys playing defense, a perfect spiral right in their hands they're going to catch, but a wobbly pass, there's a good chance they're going to drop it.

The value of a spiral versus a 'catchable' wobbly ball is a subjective debate in football coaching.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I think I am genuinely on Aaron Rodgers' side in his dispute with the Packers

If you want to talk about a real quitter in sports, we're going to talk about Aaron Rodgers on Sunday. I'll do a little teaser. My take on Aaron Rodgers: let's just say, I think I'm on his side. I think he's quitting on his marriage. I think I'm on his side. Just a little teaser. I think justice for it. And like actually on his side, not jokingly on his side, I think I'm on the side.

Subjective stance on a player-team dispute.
Win
Blake BortlesBlake Bortles

I threw between 3 and 8 touchdowns during Packers OTAs

I also got a new job. Yep. And green bay I threw and give or take four touchdown passes during the OTAs. So have you ever take, three to eight? You pick a number of all right. Somewhere in there under 10.

Bortles was with the Packers in May 2021. OTA stats are not officially tracked or publicly verifiable to this degree, but the wide range makes it likely accurate in his own memory.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers' 'Last Dance' post means he's playing one more year just to lose in the NFC Championship

He puts up a picture of Michael Jordan and Scottie Pippen... which I guess they're trying to say the 'Last Dance', which would mean they would both show up. But then what is the 'Last Dance' for Aaron Rodgers? Losing in the NFC Championship game? Like what, they are not going for their sixth title. 'Let's run this back one more time where we disappoint everybody'.

Rodgers did return to the Packers for the 2021 season, but they lost in the Divisional round to the 49ers, not the NFC Championship.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jerry Jones would commit murder for a chance at another Super Bowl

I'm not trying to be sacrilegious here, but the facts are that I would right now, if I could, and I knew I had a good chance to do it, I would do anything known to man to get into a Superbowl. [PFT]: Mike McCarthy, you think would Mike McCarthy die for the super bowl? ... [Jerry] wants to kill someone. I think, I think, I think Mike McCarthy, who would kneel down onto like a, a block and you put the rest, his head on it and have Jerry Jones smash.

Hot TakeFootballFireSarcastic
Jerry Jones' comments were clearly figurative; there is no evidence of him committing murder.
Win
David BakerDavid Baker

Peyton Manning's Hall of Fame debate only lasted 10 seconds

He knew it, it took 10 seconds for him to get in the hall of fame. You know, Mike Chapple from Indianapolis did his presentation. And I think all he said was Peyton Manning dropped the mic. Yeah. And, and, and he, he didn't have to make the presentation. Everybody knew he was going to.

Baker is the ultimate authority on these meetings. It is a well-documented story that the Manning presentation was incredibly brief.
Void
David BakerDavid Baker

Olivia Manning is effectively a Hall of Fame 'contributor' for her role in her family's success

I feel like Olivia Manning should be nominated for the hall of fame as a contributor... [Baker]: Olivia and... frankly, her mom was a world-class sprinter, you know? So I think he [Christian McCaffrey] got some speed from her... Olivia and I, and again, I got to tell you... I've always regarded him [Archie] as one of the great fathers.

This is a subjective tribute to mothers of athletes.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Houston Texans might not even play the upcoming NFL season.

I wouldn't be shocked if the Texans were like, we're not doing this season... we might've reported that the Texans won't play the season like three months ago. It's exclusive. They're going to stink a lot.

The Texans did play the season, finishing 4-13.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Big Ben's year 18 diet is just a relatable attempt to outrun aging

I likened it to, after a long weekend of drinking and eating terrible food. And you say to yourself, you know what, I'm going to eat a salad on Monday. Everything will I'll maybe do 20 pushups. Wow. I'm back. That's what Big Ben is doing as a career where he spent 17 years eating PF Chang and doing whatever he wants. And then year 18. He's like, why is Tom Brady playing still? Oh, because he eats healthy. You know what, honey, get me a vegetable.

Roethlisberger did retire after the 2021 season, showing the diet didn't prolong his career like Brady's.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Jameis Winston and Taysom Hill are on the same level and Sean Payton will tank

Whatever's happening at the Saints organization. I put Jameis and Taysom on the same level. I think Sean Payton is going to tank for a high draft pick.

The Saints did not tank; they finished 9-8 in 2021 and narrowly missed the playoffs. Sean Payton retired after the season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers should retire from football right now following his win in The Match

I think speaking as a football fan, if Aaron Rodgers decided that was his last competitive event in the history of his life, I think us as fans would applaud him, and he doesn't owe us anything more, and next stop Canton.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Rodgers continued playing for several more seasons and won another MVP after this take.
Loss
Youngstown BobYoungstown Bob

The Browns will win exactly 11 games in the 2021 season

I'm thinking 11 wins, regular season, nothing crazy.

The Browns went 8-9 in the 2021 season.
Loss
Stu FeinerStu Feiner

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are a 1,000-unit lock to beat the New Orleans Saints by 40

I'm leaving you with a 1,000-unit game of my career. Tampa Bay Bucs minus 4 by 40. [Referring to the regular season matchup]

PredictionFootballFireSarcastic
In the 2021 season, the Saints swept the Buccaneers in the regular season, including a 9-0 shutout in December.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NHL is ready for gay players and will be supportive

The NFL is ready for it. The players for the vast, vast majority are going to be supportive when it does happen. It'll almost be like a joyous occasion when it does happen.

The reaction to Nassib was generally supportive across the league, validating PFT's claim.
Loss
HankHank

Matthew Stafford will win NFL MVP

Sean McVay was talking to Albert Breer and said, bro, this dude's a bad motherfucker. Whatever people say about him, as good as it can be, he's even better than advertised. ... I saw it. I saw the future. MVP.

Stafford had a great year and won the Super Bowl, but Aaron Rodgers won the MVP in 2021.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is a Hall of Famer

Dude, I'm rooting for Matt Stafford because there's a few takes that we all have out there that are just lingering, and Matt Stafford being a Hall of Famer, I could retire on that take.

Stafford is currently 11th all-time in passing yards and won a Super Bowl, making his case very strong, though he is still active/not yet eligible.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Brady was talking about the 49ers and Jimmy Garoppolo when he said 'you're sticking with that motherfucker?'

Tom was talking about the courtship, the quarterback courtship that happened last year. And there was one team in particular where he said, really, you're going to stick with that motherfucker over me? ... Sabermetrically, it's also most likely to be Phillip Rivers. ... [Billy: I think it was Garoppolo] Actually, that is who it is. No, I really do think that's who it is.

In 2024, Tom Brady finally confirmed the team he was referring to was the Chicago Bears.
Loss
Tony KhanTony Khan

Urban Meyer is an awesome person who will have his players' backs

Urban's great, man. ... He's changed my life in the six months I've known him... And the way he motivates people, and I know you're not going to want to hear it if you don't like him, but if you get to know him, there is something about him. ... I'm just saying, if he came in here and you worked with him, you'd love him. He would have your back on anything.

Meyer's tenure was a disaster and he was fired mid-season amid reports of toxic behavior, significantly undermining Khan's 'awesome person' claim.
Void
Greg OlsenGreg Olsen

The hardest part about playing tight end is having to be an elite blocker and an elite receiver simultaneously.

You have to be an elite route runner. You can catch the ball really well... but then if you can't, like, hold your own in the run game and you can't, like, take in – hit in the face by a 300-pound defensive end, then, like, you kind of have – they kind of have to, like, call plays around you instead of, like, you being able to be the focal point.

This is a fundamental truth of NFL offensive scheme; the best TEs (Gronk, Kittle, Kelce) are valuable because they can do both.
Win
George KittleGeorge Kittle

Super Bowl winning teams always have a talented tight end, so the position should be paid more.

If you look at the last year, 10 Super Bowls, I think every team that's won has had a very, very talented tight end. So, like, it has to do with winning Super Bowls. So, I mean, I think that's the most important thing, so you might as well pay the tight ends.

The recent winners (Chiefs, Bucs, Eagles, Patriots) all featured elite TEs like Kelce, Gronkowski, and Ertz.
Win
Greg OlsenGreg Olsen

I am completely and utterly done with football and will not come out of retirement.

I am not going to be coming out of retirement. I'm completely and utterly done. I've set a record for how many times I've broken and ruptured my feet. So I'm full-time dad and part-time broadcaster.

Olsen has remained retired and has become a successful lead broadcaster for FOX.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Bears are bid posturing for a stadium renovation by looking at Arlington Heights

The Bears did release a statement that they're putting in a bid to buy Arlington International Racetrack... everyone's actually I don't think a lot of people are freaking out. I actually think it's smart of them. They're probably just posturing to get a renovation of Soldier Field.

The Bears did eventually purchase the land and are pursuing a new stadium there, though negotiations with the city of Chicago continue. It was more than just posturing.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tua Tagovailoa's training camp interceptions will fuel the 'Alabama QBs are busts' narrative all season

Tua threw approximately 300 interceptions in practice yesterday. And so now... there's going to be reporters that fire up a tweet every single time he throws an interception in training camp. It's going to snowball, and then that's going to feed right back into the Alabama quarterbacks can't play.

Tua did face intense scrutiny throughout the 2021 season, with his interceptions and performance frequently compared to other young QBs.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears naming Andy Dalton QB1 with no competition is stupid

Only the Bears. Only Matt Nagy would name his QB one before you even have training camp... What I'm not okay with is being like, there's no competition. Every successful football team ever basically is like, yeah, it's always a competition.

Justin Fields did eventually replace Dalton due to injury and performance, suggesting the 'no competition' stance was short-lived.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The next Madden cover will be Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes

Tom Brady and... Mahomes, my guess.

Madden 22 featured both Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes on the cover.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is a future Hall of Famer

I think [Stafford] is a future Hall of Famer. People get mad at me for that. But... if he plays for another, I don't know, four or five years, he will be, like numbers-wise, up there with everyone else.

While Stafford is not yet retired, winning a Super Bowl significantly bolstered his Hall of Fame case.
Win
Will ComptonWill Compton

The internal culture of the Washington Football Team under Bruce Allen was not 'damn good'

Sure, you can watch that clip when [Bruce Allen] says the culture's damn good, but our culture wasn't damn good. It just is what it is... Top floor, bottom floor, all of it, it wasn't that good.

Investigations by the NFL and Congress later detailed the extreme dysfunction and toxicity of the organization during this period.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Wide receivers wearing single-digit jersey numbers is wrong

Julio Jones, he's wearing number two in Tennessee. I'm still not comfortable on a personal level with wide receivers wearing single digits. It's going to fuck my brain up... Number two is a bad kicker or a slow quarterback.

Subjective aesthetic opinion.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers might move to Ecuador and go off the grid entirely

I think there's something telling me that [Rodgers] might just go off the grid entirely. Like Aaron Rodgers might just not show up on a football field ever again. He might move to Ecuador and go live out in the rainforest with Shailene Woodley.

Aaron Rodgers continued playing for the Packers and later the Jets, never moving to an Ecuadorian rainforest.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Blake Bortles could be the starting quarterback for the Green Bay Packers this year

I have a prediction, Big Cat. I'm in the prediction business. I think that Blake Bortles could be the starting quarterback of the Green Bay Packers this year. Right now, Jordan Love, it seems like he's more valuable to the Packers as an asset.

Aaron Rodgers returned to play the full season; Bortles never started for Green Bay.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Arch Manning is already the best Manning to ever play football

That ball flip was sick, though, wasn't it? When he did the pump fake, and then he flipped it. I think he's already better. I think he's already the best Manning to ever play football.

As of early 2024, Arch Manning is a backup at Texas and hasn't yet matched the NFL Hall of Fame careers of his uncles.
Win
Wade PhillipsWade Phillips

Reggie White's 21-sack season in 12 games is a record that will never be beaten

Reggie White... had the greatest year that I've ever coached in that he had 21 sacks, which was the record for a long time. But that was in a 12-game season because we had a strike... So in 12 games, he had 21 sacks. I mean, I don't think anybody's going to ever come close to that.

While the single-season sack record is 22.5 (Strayhan/Watt), they played 16 games. No one has approached 21 sacks in 12 games.
Void
Wade PhillipsWade Phillips

The Titans' Music City Miracle was definitely a forward pass

I was standing there on the sideline, you know, right across from where they were making the play, where he was throwing the ball forward. So I still thought when they scored, I thought they, you know, they're going to call it back... threw it from behind the line and the guy caught it in front of a line. So I don't see how it couldn't have been forward.

The play was reviewed and upheld as a legal lateral; scientific analyses of 'parallax error' generally support the call, but it remains a legendary debate.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Vrabel builds teams based solely on player girth and size

I think I've figured out what Mike Vrabel's strategy is here... He's just trying to get the biggest dudes that he can possibly get his hands on. I think that he has the biggest starting 11, just mass-wise. He is Billy Football as a coach. He just wants pounds. And Julio Jones is a massive dude.

Subjective characterization of roster building, though the Titans did prioritize big, physical players during the Henry/Vrabel era.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If the Cowboys don't win a Super Bowl in the next 20 years, they will become the NFL's version of the Toronto Maple Leafs

The Cowboys, I think, have the element of... They're one of the teams that you think of when you think of football. The Leafs are one of the teams you think of when you think of hockey. They have historical relevance, but it's all in the past... If the Cowboys, if we're sitting here 2045 and the Cowboys haven't gone back to a Super Bowl, they would be the Maple Leafs.

This is a subjective comparison of future outcomes, but the historical parallels of 'America's Team' vs. Canada's most historic franchise in a long drought are strong.
Loss
HankHank

Tim Tebow was signed by Urban Meyer purely to act as a heat shield for Trevor Lawrence

I'm also just a huge fan of the narrative that [Urban Meyer] brought in Tebow just to take off heat off Trevor Lawrence... Tebow is just going to be too much of a natural leader and take all the heat, including from the players, off Trevor Lawrence.

Tebow was cut early in the preseason, and Lawrence faced significant media scrutiny regardless during a disastrous 3-14 rookie season under Meyer.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

This is the week Aaron Rodgers finally gets traded by the Packers

I'm going to do this every week until it comes true. I'm going to predict that this is the week that Aaron Rodgers gets traded. Okay. So, and if it doesn't happen this week, I will do it next week and give me credit when that happens.

Rodgers was not traded in 2021; he played the full season for the Packers and won MVP. He wasn't traded until 2023.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Pace and Matt Nagy keeping their jobs prevents the cycle of failure from breaking

So even if Justin Fields is good, then that means that Ryan Pace and Matt Nagy keep their jobs, which they're probably not very fit for their jobs. So then the cycle continues like that.

Both Pace and Nagy were fired in January 2022 after a disappointing season, regardless of Fields' potential.
Void
Mark TitusMark Titus

If Justin Fields fails in Chicago, it is the Bears' fault, not Ohio State's

If Justin Fields in Chicago does not work out, it is the Bears' fault. Do not blame this on Ohio State quarterbacks. Put that one in the Bears. Don't blame Justin Fields. That's all I'm asking.

Justin Fields was traded after three seasons with poor win/loss results. Debate continues over whether the fault lies with his development, the coaching/ownership, or his own ceiling.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

No visor quarterback will ever win a Super Bowl

We know that a visor quarterback will not win a Super Bowl... No visor quarterback has ever won a Super Bowl, just a heads up.

As of the current date, no starting quarterback has won a Super Bowl while wearing a tinted/dark visor during the game, though clear visors are common.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers has benefited from the Packers' organizational culture he now claims to hate

Aaron Rodgers has benefited from the Packers' organizational culture... that's why they have had success is because they are an organization that is always looking forward... the best time to get a quarterback is when you don't need one. That's what they did. So Aaron Rodgers has benefited... but now he doesn't like it.

This is a philosophical critique of the Rodgers/Packers drama that occurred in 2021.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tim Tebow is a 'Trojan Horse' who will eventually play quarterback for the Jaguars

I think Tim Tebow is kind of a Trojan horse deal. I think he might end up playing quarterback. because if you saw the handshake that he put on the other guy, that is a quarterback's handshake. flalessly executed. Tim Tebow, I think, is going to... If I were Trevor Lawrence, I would sleep very cautiously.

Tebow never played quarterback for the Jaguars; he was cut during the preseason and never made the final roster.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Joe Burrow will be on a mission in Week 1 against the Vikings

Hot seat, the Minnesota Vikings. Because week one, they play the Bengals, and Joe Burrow is all systems go, and he's going to be on a mission week one against the Vikings.

The Bengals beat the Vikings 27-24 in Week 1. Burrow threw for 261 yards and 2 TDs with a 128.8 rating. He was definitely on a mission.
Void
Uncle ChapsUncle Chaps

Tim Tebow is a shysty guy who is all about himself

There could be a chance that Tebow is just a really shysty guy. It's all about himself.

A matter of opinion on a public figure's character.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer is trying to recreate his Florida Gators teams by moving Travis Etienne to wide receiver.

Urban Meyer is just that report that Travis Etienne is taking reps as only a wide receiver... He's trying to create Percy Harvin. I understand what he's doing, I think... He just wants to recreate the Florida team.

Meyer did openly state Etienne would take WR reps in camp, though Etienne eventually became a primary RB under Doug Pederson.