Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Irish Goodbye is the single best way to leave a social gathering

Irish goodbye is our first pick. There's no better goodbye than Irish goodbye. When you just are, you can just leave and you don't have to worry about saying goodbyes and you're just gone... The Irish goodbye is one, one of goodbyes.

Purely subjective opinion on social etiquette.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The 'Notes App' social media post is a top-tier way to announce a career change

We're gonna go with posting a notes app on social media to announce a career change. Thanking everybody involved... a lot of people, public figures do this, right? They say goodbye via notes app. And it usually puts their name in the trending column. So I think it moves the needle.

This is a subjective ranking of a social media trope.
Win
Craig KilbornCraig Kilborn

The Daily Show was the most dysfunctional place I have ever worked

The daily show was easily the most dysfunctional place I've worked because the network set it up the wrong way. They hired the executive producer first and then they didn't, they hired me second. And so it was very dysfunctional. I just ignored it and scored on the air and got out of there.

This is Kilborn's personal professional experience, which is a matter of factual record from his perspective.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL is in trouble because watching on a couch is 10 times better than going to a stadium

The NFL's in trouble. I think in terms of like ticket sales, they're gonna start building smaller stadiums, I think in the future. Cause like it is the, the cat's outta the bag. Your couch is 10 times more comfortable than going to a stadium.

While stadium attendance remains high, there is a trend toward smaller, more 'boutique' stadium designs (like the Titans' new stadium plans).
Void
Craig KilbornCraig Kilborn

I would pay any price for NBA League Pass

For the NBA league pass, I would pay anything. I have to watch those games. So I think it's like, I think it's 300 bucks. I don't know what it is, but don't tell Adam silver, but if it was higher I would pay higher.

Subjective personal value judgment.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Fields is in such a bad situation that we might not know if he's actually a bad quarterback

He is going to be the perfect test case of if he's good, it's in spite of everything that's been stacked against him. And if he's bad, we're not even gonna know if he's truly bad because it's been that much of like, he has nothing. So I could totally see him being terrible for the bears and then getting a second chance somewhere else and flourishing.

This proved remarkably accurate. Fields was traded to the Steelers after three years where fans debated whether his failure was due to his own play or the Bears' lack of talent around him.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am going to win the $1.2 billion Mega Millions drawing

By this time tomorrow, I'm going to be 1.02 billion in debt with a B... I've worked my own way into that sort of situation. Cuz I went out to the store. I bought $500 worth of mega millions tickets... I've fairly confident that I'm going to win the drawing tomorrow night.

PredictionLifeScorchingSarcastic
He did not win the $1.2 billion jackpot.
Win
Billy FootballBilly Football

Wolverines are more closely related to seals and sea lions than they are to wolves

Wolverines are related to seals and sea lions closer than actual wolves.

Biologically correct. Wolverines are in the suborder Caniformia, but within the family Mustelidae. They are more closely related to Pinnipeds (seals/sea lions) than they are to Canids (true wolves).
Void
Big CatBig Cat

We are actively trying to never be nominated for a Sports Emmy unless it is for the John Cena interview

We are actively trying to never be nominated for everything... if they wanna nominate us and only do it on our John Cena interview, we're in.

This is a statement of intent for the show's awards strategy.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Collecting signatures is objectively weird and has been replaced by the selfie

I don't think that as a society, we talk enough about the fact that collecting signatures is just fucking weird. Yeah. It is. Especially if you have a picture and you're like, 'Hey, can you write your name on the, on this picture that I have of you?'... I do think that the selfies have taken the place of it, which is a hundred percent, way more meaningful.

Subjective opinion on social norms.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is actually 0-10 in NBA Finals appearances if you apply the proper asterisks

LA Fraud is actually 0 and 10 in the finals in my eyes. 2007, lost swept. 2011 lost. 2012, baby thunder doesn't count. 2013, Ray Allen also rigged. 2013, Ray Allen doesn't count. 2014 lost. 2015 lost. 2016, injured warriors doesn't count. 2017 lost. 2018, lost swept. 2020 Mickey Mouse doesn't count.

LeBron James has won four NBA championships (2012, 2013, 2016, 2020).
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ben Simmons' claim that playing with Kyrie Irving and Kevin Durant would be 'scary' meant he was literally scared to play

[Ben Simmons] said, quote, 'It's going to be scary.' So I actually think he was correct about this. He was talking about, he was just expressing his emotions. He was like, 'I'm scared to play. I'm scared to play basketball.'

Hot TakeBasketballHotSarcastic
Simmons literally didn't play for the remainder of that season, so in a satirical sense, Big Cat was 'correct' that he was scared to take the court.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Dan Orlovsky will do a one-on-one sit-down interview with Deshaun Watson to teach him how to 'not be horny'

I think that we are going to get a, one-on-one sit down interview with Dan Orlovsky and Deshaun Watson. And he is going to set him straight on how to not be horny... Dan Orlovsky, according to his rules, it would be like, 'Deshaun, don't ever go to a room by yourself. Don't ever be in the same room as a woman.'

This interview never happened.
Loss
HankHank

LeBron James will respond to Skip Bayless and try to 'Time's Up' him

I think this is the year that LeBron responds to Skip. Tries to get him off the air... Skip's gonna start going after Bronny Jr. And then LeBron's gonna be like, 'that's a bridge too far. Time's up.' He's gonna try and time's up Skip.

LeBron has largely continued to ignore Skip Bayless directly, and Skip remained on FS1 until his eventual departure in 2024 (unrelated to LeBron 'canceling' him).
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The LIV Tour could eventually take over everything in our lives, including this podcast

I mean, it's a possibility that live tour could just take over everything that we like. Yeah. In every single branch of our life in this podcast. Yes. Open for business.

Hot TakeGolfHotSarcastic
LIV did not take over the podcast, though it did disrupt golf significantly before the eventual PGA/LIV 'framework agreement'.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

It is time for Bill Belichick to retire because the game has passed him by

It's time for Bill Belichick to retire. Has the game passed him by?... If Mac Jones is not the answer this year... I think we're gonna have the conversation: 'Bill, is it time to go coach lacrosse?'

Belichick did not retire after that season, though the Patriots continued to struggle, eventually leading to his departure in early 2024.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Paul Rabil retiring was the best thing to happen to professional lacrosse

Is it a coincidence that the PLL had their best year ever after Paul Rabil retired? Was Paul Rabil bad for professional lacrosse? Some are saying.

Whether Rabil was 'bad' for the league is subjective, but the league continued to grow after his retirement.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

A team that a PMT member roots for will win a championship in the next year

A team that a PMT member roots for will win a championship. We have so many opportunities.

The Denver Nuggets (PFT is a fan) won the NBA Championship in June 2023.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

2023 will be the 'year of normality' and a return to normalcy

I'm gonna say that it's gonna be the year of just normality. A return to normalcy.

2023 was far from 'normal' for PMT, especially for Billy who ended up leaving the regular cast in July 2023.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 'Finger of the Year' award should be permanently named after Urban Meyer

The winner of finger of the year... it's Urban Meyer's finger at the bar. Of course it is. I knuckle deep in a butthole... I feel like this one's gonna stick around. And it might be named after Urban Meyer going forward. I think that's how impressive his performance was this year.

The show has not yet officially renamed the award, but Meyer remains the gold standard for the category.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The LIV Tour paid Cameron Smith too much money

I think that they paid [Cameron Smith] too much. Yeah.

Smith reportedly signed for over $100 million; whether that is 'too much' is a matter of market opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The LIV Tour paid Cameron Smith too little money

I think they paid [Cameron Smith] too little.

The value of Smith's contract is subjective based on his talent and the tour's business model.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Odell Beckham Sr. deserves credit for getting his son a Super Bowl through his viral baker Mayfield video

[Odell Beckham Sr.] released a video on YouTube that said Odell Beckham is always open... It was just a breakdown of all the times that Baker Mayfield didn't throw it to Odell Beckham, Jr... He got his son a Super Bowl. Yes. Yes. He got his son a Super Bowl.

OBJ did win the Super Bowl with the Rams after being released following the video.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Anna Lynn McCord's open letter to Vladimir Putin is the ultimate form of narcissism

It's not only the ratio of the year, but it's might be narcissism of the year to be like, 'if I was your mother, I would've stopped all war.' It's also fucked up like towards Putin's actual mom. How do you know she wasn't a nice lady?

Whether the video is 'narcissistic' is a subjective interpretation of her intent.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Winning 'Blake of the Year' carries a performance curse for professional athletes

Everything sort of went downhill after last year's Blake of the Year. I had a rough year fellas, and I think it started with those ping pong balls. Now I can't even look at a ping pong ball without thinking of the devastating loss... This kind of begs the question: is there a Blake of the Year curse?

Griffin's numbers and role did decline significantly with the Nets following his previous win, though attributing it to a podcast award is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 2022 'Blake of the Year' is a legitimate title despite the suspension of Brooks Koepka

I'm gonna get ahead of this... the people out there, 'cause I'm sure there'll be a few, say this is a Mickey Mouse Blake of the Year because you're only competing against Blake Bortles and this were not Blake Koepka. I remind you that I believe for the first two Blake of the Years, these are the original Blakes. So don't bring that Mickey Mouse shit to this.

The legitimacy of a podcast award is entirely subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Historic NFL franchises should not use alternate helmets because they look 'candy ass'

The bears unveiled their new helmets. It's now cool for every team. ... that doesn't mean every team needs to do a alternate helmet and the bears kind of were the first team to show up and be like, oh yeah, not every team needs to do this. ... historic franchises should just keep with their regular helmets because there's no reason we're... we're not the Jaguars. ... It's Mickey mouse. It's it's it's candy ass.

This is a subjective aesthetic opinion about team branding.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bears and Commanders Thursday night game will be a low-scoring, boring affair with multiple coaching and kicking errors

it is gonna be against the commanders and the greatest Thursday night game that this podcast has ever seen. ... I feel like that is a vibe where it's like the coach [Eberflus], he's gonna lose two challenges. The wind is gonna blow the ball off the kicking tee at least twice in the course of the game. ... It's gonna be one of those that basically has a running clock the entire time, because both teams are just gonna run the ball and nothing exciting is gonna happen.

The Oct 13, 2022 game was indeed a low-scoring 12-7 mess with multiple mistakes, including missed field goals and poor red zone play, though the specific 'wind blowing ball off tee' didn't happen literally.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

There should be extra enthusiasm for Aaron Judge hitting 62 home runs because it is the post-steroid era

Aaron judge has been mashing race to 62. I want everyone to get involved in that because it does look, I'm a, I'm a pro steroids guy. So I, I definitely think Barry Bond's the best player of all time. And I also think his records stand, but there should be like an extra enthusiasm. If someone can hit 62, just knowing that we're not in the steroid era anymore.

Judge did go on to hit 62 home runs later that season, breaking the AL record.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Beachfront spray kiosks for sunscreen would be a 'godsend' invention

I have a beach idea. ... it's a spray tan booth, but it's got sunscreen, spray sunscreen in it. So you just walk through it, they set up like a kiosk and you walk through it on your way out to the beach. You pay like 10 bucks and then you turn around like your Tony Hawk, your entire body gets coated in sunscreen. I feel like for kids, especially if you got kids, this is like a godsend of an invention.

While some localized versions of this exist, it hasn't become a universal 'godsend' staple yet.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Stephen A. Smith taking a month off for a shoulder injury in August is a 'soft move'

Stephen A. Smith is, but I do think, I do think he's talking about anything because he's taking the entire fucking month of August off with his shoulder injury, because he's not man enough to go on the air in August and talk about sports. This is, this is actually what really separates the good take Smiths from the bad ones. ... this is a soft move by Steven A. Smith.

This is a subjective insult based on sports media work ethic.
Void
Andrew SchulzAndrew Schulz

I hate acting and am bad at it, and it's ironic that people keep offering me roles precisely because I tell them not to cast me

I only care about comedy. Right? You gotta force me to act. ... I'm saying this right now. And every time I say it, I get offered another gig. I don't like acting right. I'm bad at it, but they keep offering shit. ... It was like literally the director [of White Men Can't Jump] almost didn't put me in it. And I was like, why? He was like, well, I listen to brilliant idiots. And you specifically said, don't cast me. I'll ruin your movie.

Subjective opinion on his own skills and desires.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Malcolm Gladwell is a guy who is just smart enough for dumb people to think he's a genius

Malcolm Gladwell is the, is the perfect case of a guy who's just smart enough that dumb people like ourselves think he's a genius. And then real smart people are like, no, no, no, no, this guy's full of shit.

This is a subjective evaluation of a public figure's reputation and intellectual depth.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Any rich person who doesn't buy a sports team is untrustworthy

Any guy who or any person, because I'm a feminist, any woman guy who has that much money and doesn't buy a sports team, can't be trusted... Piece of shit. Because it's like, what is the point of having that much money and not owning a sports franchise? Like that's, that's the end goal of society. ... The end goal is like buy an NFL team. That's what rich people do.

This is a philosophical/lifestyle take on wealth management and priorities.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Mets' season will inevitably implode in 'fantastic fashion' despite their current success

I'm sure the Mets are still good. ... Yeah, yeah. They'll be fine. I'm sure this won't just implode in, in fantastic fashion.

PredictionBaseballMediumSarcastic
The 2022 Mets won 101 games but lost the division lead late and were eliminated in the Wild Card round at home, fulfilling the 'implosion' narrative for many fans.
Void
Andrew SchulzAndrew Schulz

The reason people are so outraged today is because they are waiting too long to have kids

I think part of like the, everybody being outraged about things is we're waiting too long to have kids. ... because there is like, once you have kids, the little things, the little things do not bother you as much. ... I don't have time for that. I just want my kid to be like a good kid.

This is a social observation that cannot be definitively proven or disproven.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jeffrey Epstein was definitely a CIA asset running a honey pot operation

I'm fully, I have Alex Jones myself on, on the whole Epstein situation because I know if you, if you connect all the dots, the dude was working for the CIA. ... He cultivated all these different networks of people... befriending the most powerful people in the world got them in a honey pot operation... And he was working for the CIA as well on their payroll.

While heavily speculated and supported by circumstantial evidence, this has never been officially confirmed by the CIA or court records.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

James Dolan's 'Moneyball' approach to overpaying for good-but-not-great players is relatable

I kinda actually like, now that I'm saying it, I kind of like James Dolan's process strategy. ... as a gambling brain, I think the same thing where it's like, maybe this is maybe it's just like, everyone just plays their best for an entire season. ... let's sign people and just hope for the absolute best case scenario all the time. ... That is a gambling brain of like, yeah. Yeah. This is the one that's gonna work.

This is a subjective comparison between team management and gambling psychology.
Win
Andrew SchulzAndrew Schulz

Jalen Brunson is an 'alpha' who will succeed in New York because of his Villanova background

Jalen Brunson actually might be one of those guys. He has a little that alpha. Cause like at Villanova, like you can see it. ... And like when Luka [Doncic] was down in that series, he picked it up. Like he does have that quiet, alpha, like I know what I can do and I'm gonna do it.

Brunson became a transcendent star for the Knicks, leading them to the playoffs and becoming an All-NBA player, proving the 'alpha' leadership take correct.
Push
Andrew SchulzAndrew Schulz

If my special is successful, it will force major streaming services to stop giving notes to comedians

Let's just teach these streamers that like, you know, people like funny jokes and it doesn't matter if they're messed up... if this is successful, they can't give comics and notes anymore. ... because you can't compete.

While Schulz's special was a success, streamers still exert significant creative control and 'notes' remain a standard part of high-budget production, though the YouTube-to-Special pipeline has grown.
Void
HankHank

A pet is the absolute worst gift to receive

Any animal that you have to take care of? It's like, not a, it's not something that let's say you don't like the gift you can, you know, pretend to like it. And then kind of just forget about it. If you get an animal, like you have to take care of that animal.

This is a subjective ranking for a Mount Rushmore segment.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

A gym membership is a terrible gift because it implies the recipient is fat

Number one, a gym membership, because the double double, like whammy of basically saying that you're fat and you need to get in shape. And then like the gift is you just have to go punish yourself at the gym, a gym membership fucking sucks to give someone.

Subjective opinion on gift etiquette.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Statue of Liberty was a bad gift from the French because of high maintenance and war obligations

The statue of Liberty was low key, a pretty shitty thing for the French to do to us. They just made this giant sculpture outta bronze. And it's like, here, you have to clean this every day or else it's gonna turn green and it's a big fucking woman and you ha it's so big that you have to find an island to put it on and oh yeah. It's also gonna make, you have to fight on our side in every war that happens from now until the end of eternity.

This is a humorous, satirical interpretation of history.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Trey Mancini is the Comeback Player of the Year

Comeback player of the year. We're going to [Trey Mancini]. I think that's well-deserved came back from cancer. I mean, who can top that? ... Trey Mancini has won the first Taiki of 2022.

Trey Mancini did in fact win the 2022 American League Comeback Player of the Year award.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Russell Wilson is reaching 'turn on tweet notifications' territory because of how corny he is

I was thinking about that yesterday. [Russell Wilson] is dangerously close to crossing into turn on tweet notifications territory. Because like, you never know what you're gonna get with [Russell Wilson] and it's going to be extremely corny, but extremely funny.

This is subjective social media commentary.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The LIV Golf tour is a failure as a sports-washing operation because it only makes people talk about Saudi Arabia's human rights record

The entire premise of the LIV tour through the public investment fund is to be like a giant commercial for Saudi Arabia... It's been a gigantic failure on that respect because all anyone talks about is how bad Saudi Arabia is when LIV tour comes up... it's definitely the Streisand effect.

While LIV gained traction later, its early years were dominated by controversy rather than positive PR for Saudi Arabia.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bengals' white helmets will make them faster on offense but a liability on special teams

I think that the Bengals white helmets, it makes them faster on offense. They'll score... but special teams will be liability, kick coverage, especially, and kickoff returns. I don't see that working out well.

This is satirical and cannot be verified by stats.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cardinals overpaid Kyler Murray with his new contract extension

How much do you think they overpaid for Kyler? ... I think they overpaid for him too. I really do. They only offered Pat Tillman $9 million. Kyler is sick at Call of Duty though.

Contract value is inherently subjective and based on market rates at the time.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Cardinals Week 1 against the Chiefs is a lock

I think [Arizona] Cardinals week one's when we a lock of the week... he's [Kyler Murray] engineered to be an early season guy with a home against the Chiefs... he's got a great line. Track meet and the chiefs don't have Tyreek.

The Chiefs dominated the Cardinals 44-21 in Week 1 of the 2022 season, making this prediction definitively incorrect.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyler Murray is an early-season betting lock, but Colt McCoy is the guy to bet on in mid-to-late November

I think that there are certain quarterbacks that you can do that it's like [Kyler Murray] is engineered to be an early season guy... [Colt McCoy] is a good quarterback to bet on for like one week it's mid-November... maybe late November. That's Colt McCoy territory.

This is a gambling theory based on player trends and is subjective.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers