Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
HankHank

I am not a fan of the Automated Ball-Strike (ABS) system in baseball

I'm not a fan... I just don't understand why you even have umpires in the first place if you're gonna do the ABS thing. There's gonna be so many more [reviews] in baseball.

The take is a personal preference.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Nationals might not be as terrible as originally thought

The Washington Nationals might not be as terrible as I thought that they might be. There you go... I'm gonna overreact a little bit, but I still think they're not gonna be very good. But it's good having young players that are playing well.

Outcome depends on the final MLB season results for the Nationals.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Guardians' historic comeback to win the AL Central will embolden bad GMs to never give up on a season

The fact that [the Guardians] won the AL Central now emboldens every general manager... because when they're 15 and a half games back, they'll be like, 'We're still in this. Remember the Guardians?'

This is an observation on front office psychology and 'copycat' league behavior.
Push
MemesMemes

The Mets are spineless pussies who couldn't get it done

The Mets are just a bunch of spineless pussies and they just couldn't get it done. Pete Alonso was out the door before the game ended. They're gonna get their teeth kicked in by the Dodgers.

The Mets collapsed spectacularly in 2025, going from the best record in baseball (45-24) to missing the playoffs entirely after a 38-55 second-half collapse. They indeed 'couldn't get it done.'
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Miami Marlins might sneak into the MLB playoffs

The Miami Marlins... might sneak away into the playoffs. They're six games out of the Wild Card. I don't know, fun story going on in Miami.

The Miami Marlins did NOT sneak into the 2025 MLB playoffs. They finished 79-83 and were eliminated from contention on September 25.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

MLB is intentionally stealing home runs by making baseball seams higher

Rob Man-fraud is back. They're trying to steal dingers from you... the seams on the baseballs this year are higher than they have been in the past and it's stealing dingers away from everybody.

MLB admitted to a change in drag, though they claimed it was unintentional manufacturing variance rather than a conspiracy.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Rockies firing Bud Black won't change anything because owner Dick Monfort is the real problem.

The Rockies fired Bud Black... the owner, Dick Monfort, being like, 'we're all trying to find out how this happened.' It's you, dude. You're the piece of shit.

Subjective opinion on team management and ownership.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Beards are causing baseball injuries because the face is connected to the elbow

My who's back is baseball injuries 'cause Garrett Cole's out for the year... Bad Tommy John. They should never change the rules about shaving your face. Like this, this would not have happened if he was clean shaven. That's true. That's your, your face. Your face is connected to your shoulder, to your elbow.

There is no medical evidence linking facial hair to ulnar collateral ligament tears.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rickey Henderson is the best lead-off hitter of all time

Rickey Henderson... was such a awesome, awesome baseball player to watch. All his base stealing records are just insane... Best lead off hitter of all time. All his base stealing records are just insane. They're the stats that you can look up and be like, it would, oh, it would take somebody like 30 years.

Commonly held baseball consensus, though technically an opinion.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mets fans can no longer complain about Steve Cohen now that he is signing Juan Soto.

Mets fans, I, I envy Mets fans... I feel like Mets fans, you can't complain about Steve Cohen. No, at all. Like you, you've lost, that's not an option for you now.

Mets fans generally agree that Cohen is doing everything possible to win, making it a subjective consensus.
Loss
HankHank

Juan Soto will sign with the Boston Red Sox

I'm seeing some tweets. I'm seeing some reports... Juan Soto's sister looking at apartments in Boston... Kirk Minihane reported that he's a hundred percent signing with the Red Sox.

Juan Soto signed a record-breaking contract with the New York Mets on December 8, 2024.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 2024 White Sox are a historically bad anomaly, matching a dentist-managed team from WWII

The Chicago White Sox who are on a 20 game losing streak... If you just erased their 14 game losing streak and their 20 game losing streak, they would still have the worst winning percentage in baseball... Only two managers in baseball history have... a winning percentage under .333: Pedro Grifol and a guy named Dr. James Prothro, who was a licensed dentist, who managed the Phillies during World War II.

The White Sox did indeed finish with 121 losses, the most in modern MLB history.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Nestor Cortes' fake pitch is awesome because of how much it bothers baseball traditionalists

I'm Now on Cortez's side. All right. I Now think it's an awesome pitch. I didn't [know] it made people that mad. So, I mean, there's no way this is actually like a strategy that could like [work]... I Now think it's an awesome pitch. If it makes people mad, that rules.

The value of the pitch is subjective, based on its ability to annoy traditionalists.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The obsession with velocity is destroying MLB pitchers' arms

Everyone's obsessed with velocity... everyone just looking at the numbers being like, you gotta throw a hundred, you gotta throw a hundred. And arms are just getting pushed to this max at a early age and everyone's destroying their arms.

This is a widely held opinion among baseball analysts and experts as the data shows a correlation between max effort velocity and ligament damage.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Mets throwing at Rhys Hoskins was 'unanimous Bush league' behavior

The Mets are already a disaster. They threw at Rhys Hoskins on Saturday after he was already four-for-four and it was total just unanimous Bush league. And we're like, why would you do this after he is four-for-four? I think their manager already got suspended.

This is an opinion on sportsmanship and unwritten rules.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The New York Yankees have already won the World Series after their opening sweep of Houston

I'd just like to be the first to congratulate the New York Yankees on winning the World Series. Yeah. Four game sweep in Houston. Congrats. Juan Soto has been incredible. The Yankees have won it all.

The Yankees reached the World Series but lost to the Dodgers 4-1.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Shohei Ohtani to the Dodgers is not more impactful than Jackie Robinson

Ben Verlander... said that Shohei Ohtani to the Dodgers is the most important signing in Dodgers history... Jackie Robinson? ... Pretty impactful. The word impactful was really interesting to us. Most important, most impactful.

Jackie Robinson breaking the color barrier is universally considered the most impactful event in Dodgers (and arguably MLB) history.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Every MLB free agent contract is technically an overpay but it doesn't matter without a salary cap

If the roles were reversed, you would be so over the moon about this. And yes, every contract free agent contract in MLB history is an overpay because you're paying for past accomplishments and who cares? There's no salary cap. It's not your money.

Subjective business philosophy regarding sports economics.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jose Altuve is the most clutch baseball player since David Ortiz

Altuve might be the most clutch guy since Big Papi. Every big moment he comes up huge.

Subjective comparison of clutch factor.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Yankees should extend both Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman

I think they should extend Aaron Boone. Yeah. I think he's the steady hand and Cashman. I think Aaron Boone is a steady hand that the Yankees need to control their franchise. ... We official vote of confidence as they should extend both of them. Yes.

Hot TakeBaseballFireSarcastic
Cashman remains employed and Boone's contract was eventually extended through 2024 (with a 2025 option), so technically PFT's mock-wish came true.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Signing Aaron Judge to a mega-deal was a mistake

Build around Aaron Judge. ... I don't know if you wanna build around Aaron Judge. He's like 32 isn't he? They just signed him to a mega deal. I know that was a mistake. ... He's gonna be 32 before next season. Okay. Whew. And he's got like 14 years left on his contract.

Judge won the 2024 AL MVP and had an all-time great season, making the 'mistake' label look very early.
Void
HankHank

Any player who wins World Series MVP should automatically be inducted into that team's Hall of Fame.

Any World Series MVP for any baseball team should be in that baseball team's Hall of Fame. [David Freese] said he hadn't earned it... but if you're a World Series MVP, you've earned the Hall of Fame. There's plenty of other Cardinals players that aren't World Series MVPs in the Cardinals Hall of Fame.

Whether an award should guarantee a specific team honor is entirely a matter of franchise policy and opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Every MLB team should be required to play a series in Mexico City

Every team should have to play like a series in Mexico City because it was awesome... The Giants and Padres played in Mexico City, which is 2000 feet higher than Denver. And on Saturday it was like a softball game. There were 11 home runs.

Subjective opinion on league logistics.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

The MLB pitch clock makes fans feel rushed and ruins the 'fuck around' time at the stadium

I fucking hate the pitch clock... because I sit down there... I'm trying to chit chat, socialize like how I usually do... I feel like I'm rushed at a table, at a restaurant that's trying to flip table. I want there to be more fuck around time. So if I get food, I don't miss anything.

This is a subjective opinion on the stadium experience, though MLB attendance actually increased in 2023 despite (or because of) the faster games.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If you attend a game in person, the MLB pitch clock is bad because you want that time to never stop

I agree with this take for games that you attend in person... when I go to the ballpark and I watch a daytime baseball game, I want that time to never stop... Take me out to the ballgame, it doesn't say I care if I never get back. I want to be able to be unaccounted for the whole day.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially 100% all-in on the World Baseball Classic

On Thursday we talked about Edwin Diaz and my take was simply like March Madness is going on, I'm not gonna watch the World Baseball Classic... Now that we're in the final, I'm fucking all in.

This is a subjective statement of personal preference.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The World Baseball Classic should allow players to use aluminum bats

In the World Baseball Classic... they should at least if they're not gonna have the bigger bases, let them use aluminum bats. Yeah, that would be sick. Ping. Just here? Yeah, like Schwarber would be going yard. Oh, all over the place.

This is a suggestion for a rules change, not a verifiable fact claim.
Loss
MaxMax

The Phillies will sweep their three home games and win the World Series without returning to Houston

I love my guys. We're gonna win the next three games. We won't even go back to Houston. ... We're gonna score so many runs this week.

The Phillies won Game 3 but lost Games 4 and 5 at home, eventually losing the series in 6 games in Houston.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Bryce Harper has officially silenced all his critics

Bryce Harper... what he has done this playoffs and erased any negative Bryce Harper talk... he's been absolutely insane. I like that everything [Aaron] Judge isn't, Harper is. He was saying into the camera, 'I am that dude.' And it's like, yeah, you are.

Harper won NLCS MVP and led the Phillies to the World Series, proving he was a true franchise cornerstone and playoff performer.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Dodgers' 2020 World Series title doesn't count

The Dodgers have not won anything. We can We agree The bubble, the bubble championship didn't, didn't count.

Inherently subjective and a matter of sports debate.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Aaron Judge will break the AL home run record in the final two weeks of the season

Aaron Judge, two more home runs today. He's at 59, two shy of Roger Maris. These final two weeks got to be locked in. Even if you're not a Yankee fan, this is history. 61 home runs is the Yankee record and the non-steroid record.

Aaron Judge hit his 62nd home run on October 4, 2022, breaking the American League and Yankees franchise record.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Zack Hample is officially the greatest home run catcher of all time

[Zack Hample] is back. ... He's not the worst. He's actually the greatest foul ball guy, catcher of all time. ... How about maybe get better foul ball or home run catchers to compete with him?

By pure volume of balls caught, Hample is factually the most successful ball-hawk in MLB history, though 'greatest' is subjective.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tennessee Baseball are clowns for missing the College World Series

I don't think... it's a fine line between being a bad boy and being a clown. I think if you don't actually make it [to Omaha], then you're a clown. Yeah.

Tennessee was the #1 overall seed and lost before reaching the CWS, which is objectively an underperformance for a team with that much bravado.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bet against the Pittsburgh Pirates in every single road game this season to make money

My algorithm is thus, you just bet against the Pittsburgh Pirates every single game... we're going to bet on road games, every pirates team under and for the other team to win Moneyline against the pirates. And we're going to all make a bunch of money.

The 2022 Pirates went 62-100 overall and 28-53 on the road, meaning betting against them on the road was highly profitable.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Gerrit Cole is a loser for blaming a four-minute delay on a bad start

Garrett Cole said that the game being delayed four minutes was an unforeseen challenge for him. He said the festivities got a little away from the schedule... he's just a loser. Before he came to New York, everyone just assumed he was like the bad-ass dude... then he comes to New York and he's just, he's like sweaty. And he can't answer questions correctly.

Subjective opinion on a player's persona, though the 4-minute delay quote was widely mocked.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 'Sampson Effect' causes players to perform worse when they join the Yankees and have to shave

If you have to cut your hair or shave to change your personal appearance, I bet it throws you off Sampson effect. I bet you it's almost every player that goes there... Randy Johnson shave his beard when he sucked, when he was in the eighties.

While some players declined (Randy Johnson, Cole), others like Gerrit Cole won a Cy Young (2023) despite the shaving rule.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2022 World Series will be the Phillies vs. the Padres

Can you imagine if it's the Phillies and the Padres in the World Series? How right I would be. Yeah, that would be sick. If the AL just imploded. That would be the all-time prediction.

Impossible outcome. Two teams from the same league cannot meet in the World Series.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

MLB should adopt the Savannah Bananas rule where a fan catching a foul ball is an out

Banana ball rule number nine, if a fan catches a foul ball, it's an out and it happened and it went viral... I feel like the majors should consider... if they did that to the majors, that'd be, that would change the game with home field.

This is a subjective opinion on game rules, but MLB has not adopted such a rule.
Win
HankHank

Tommy Tanks is the main attraction of college baseball

Tommy Tanks he's on NC state. I believe it's seven home runs in his first nine... he's kind of the main story, the main attraction of college baseball this year with no [MLB] baseball going on, it's getting even more heightened coverage.

Tommy White became a national sensation in college baseball in early 2022 due to his incredible home run rate.
Push
HankHank

The Braves vs. Astros World Series will not interest a national audience

I feel bad the sport of the MLB. Cause like, let's be honest, Braves Astros. Doesn't really get the needle moving for a national audience.

The 2021 World Series averaged 11.75 million viewers, which was a significant increase from 2020 but historically lower than the mid-2010s.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Red Sox are going to win the World Series

I mean, the Red Sox, I think they're going to win the World Series at this point. I think everything that happens... doesn't it feel like they have those weird vibes going now?

The Red Sox lost in the ALCS to the Houston Astros. The Atlanta Braves won the World Series.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am never going to mention the St. Louis Cardinals' 15-game winning streak on this show.

My who's back is my ability to hold a grudge and not mentioned the fact that the [St. Louis] Cardinals won 15 games in a row. Congratulations, I will never mention it on this show. ... They're winning all these games to fucking play in the one game playoff and get the shit kicked out of them by the Dodgers.

The Cardinals' streak reached 17 games, but they ultimately lost the National League Wild Card game to the Dodgers on a walk-off home run.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

High-fiving the opposing pitcher after hitting a home run is over the line

The high five of the opposing pitcher is over the line and I don't support it. The pitcher runs up to home plate, high fives the batter as he's running around... That's too much for me.

Subjective opinion on sports etiquette.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Tony La Russa will win MLB Manager of the Year

He's gonna win manager of the year. It's going to be so funny when that happens and everyone's going to be [pissed].

Kevin Cash (AL) and Gabe Kapler (NL) won the awards in 2021. La Russa was a finalist but did not win.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyle Schwarber is a National for life and will win several World Series in D.C.

[Kyle Schwarber] is a Nat for life. We love him in this city. We're going to keep him running. We're going to do whatever it takes to keep Kyle Schwarber home in D.C. for as long as we can... He's going to stay in D.C., hopefully win several World Series with us, going to the Hall of Fame as a National.

Kyle Schwarber was traded to the Boston Red Sox on July 29, 2021, and has since played for the Phillies.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Triple plays should replace no-hitters because they are cooler.

Triple plays should replace no-hitters because they're cooler than no-hitters.

Subjective ranking of highlight types.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Defensive teams should score a run if they turn a triple play.

Actually, I think you should be able to get a run for a triple play. On defense, you should be able to score a run if you get a triple play... give us what the fans want, and that's defensive runs.

Hot TakeBaseballHotSarcastic
MLB rules do not currently allow defensive teams to score runs via putouts.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Anthony Rizzo's home run made everyone forget about his vaccination status

Anthony Rizzo was under fire on Friday because he didn't get vaccinated. But then he had like one of those 16-pitch at-bats where he had a home run... pretty much all is forgiven. And nobody's going to bring up the vaccination stuff after an at-bat like that.

Subjective observation of sports discourse.
Win
HankHank

There are more complete-game one-hitters than no-hitters in MLB history

I'll bet that there's more [complete game one-hitters]. I'm not a math guy, but I'm rolling with math on this one.

Statistically, one-hitters are significantly more frequent than no-hitters in Major League history.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cicadas will cause a delay in a baseball game at some point this season.

There's probably going to be a cicada delay in a baseball game at some point this season. But I'm very excited for the influx of cicada content to hit the internet.

There were multiple cicada-related incidents in MLB in 2021, including a swarm at a Nationals/Mets game and an insect hitting a Reds pitcher.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers