Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Antonio Brown will not be traded and will stay with the Steelers in 2019

I'm so excited for Antonio Brown to have to stay with the Steelers next year, and it's going to be such a circus... He's staying with the Steelers. I'm guaranteeing it.

Antonio Brown was traded to the Oakland Raiders on March 10, 2019.
Loss
HankHank

The Carolina Panthers will be on Hard Knocks in 2019

I'm predicting the Panthers for hard knocks officially... they got it in my head, so now I'm just going with it. They have a new owner. We're going to spend three episodes with him.

The Oakland Raiders were the featured team for Hard Knocks in 2019.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is more of a television star than a basketball player at this point in his career.

I think of LeBron more as a TV star than a basketball player at this point on his own show... LeBron is more of a TV star than a basketball player at this point.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Michael Jordan is the GOAT because he doesn't have to say it

You know who doesn't say they're the GOAT? Michael Jordan, because he knows he's the GOAT. You don't have to say it if you know you're the GOAT... Michael Jordan was asked if he was the greatest of all time and he was like, my career is not over.

This is a subjective opinion based on personality traits and career accomplishments.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeBron James is the Donald Trump of basketball

LeBron James actually has the exact same take on LeBron James being the goat that you had... LeBron won while he was in Ohio. Won in Florida, both of them. Check, check. They've both got weird hair. Check. Check. LeBron can't win in California. Neither can Trump. Check.

This is a humorous comparison that is inherently subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Garrett is the dumbest person alive for playing his starters in Week 17

Jason Garrett wins the Are You the Dumbest Person Alive Award for playing all his starters because he desperately – now, I don't know what you think, but I think it was clear that Jason Garrett wanted to win 10 games so that when Jerry Jones goes to his office next year and is like, hey, I'm thinking about firing you, he's like, but I won 10 games.

The Cowboys beat the Giants 36-35, and while they didn't suffer a catastrophic injury to a star in that specific game, the logic of risking players for a round number in wins is a common point of debate.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The rest of the AFC North should be terrified of the Browns in 2019

By the way, if I'm in the AFC North next year, I'm terrified [of the] Browns. That's the big thing. I don't care who their coach is as long as his name isn't Hue [Jackson].

The 2019 Browns were a major disappointment, finishing 6-10 despite the hype, leading to Freddie Kitchens being fired after one season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike McCarthy will be the next head coach of the Cleveland Browns

It's going to be Mike McCarthy. Yeah. He's interviewing them, I think, tomorrow. Oh, and he's got it. Yeah. It's just a formality.

Freddie Kitchens was hired as the Browns head coach for 2019; McCarthy did not take a coaching job that year.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I would rather play the Vikings than the Eagles in the playoffs

I actually went back and forth because, listen, I'm not on the team, so I can say this. I would rather play the Vikings than the Eagles. This is not bulletin board material. I think playing the Super Bowl champs, Nick Foles... versus playing Kirk Cousins who cannot beat anyone. Ever. Who has a winning record.

The Bears played the Eagles and lost on the 'Double Doink' field goal miss. Nick Foles won the game, essentially proving Big Cat's fear correct.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

John Elway is the primary problem with the Denver Broncos' front office.

John Elway, the problem is probably you. Because his defense is really good. They've got a really good running back. And then they go out and they get Case Keenum.

The Broncos continued to struggle under Elway's management until he stepped back from personnel decisions in 2021.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Adam Gase will get hired as a head coach almost immediately after being fired by the Dolphins

Dolphins, Adam Gase. I don't even consider this a firing because he's going to get hired almost immediately. And this is just a product of you had Ryan Tannehill as your quarterback.

Adam Gase was hired by the New York Jets on January 11, 2019, just days after this episode aired.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I will fight Darren Rovell in Rough N' Rowdy with one hand tied behind my back.

Rovell, if you want to answer Dana White's question, what do you know about fighting? The offer is still out there. I will fight you in rough and rowdy with one hand.

The fight never occurred, as Rovell never accepted the challenge.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is definitely paying LaVar Ball to stop talking to the media.

Can we all agree LeBron [James] definitely pays LaVar Ball to shut up? ... He just hasn't talked. ... We just agree it's a fact.

There is no public evidence of such a payment, and it remains a humorous conspiracy theory.
Win
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

John Gruden loves himself too much to build the Raiders into winners

I think what you're seeing now is that John loves John. It's about John. And, you know, you get rid of Khalil Mack, you get rid of Amari Cooper. Not sure why in the hell you do that because they're two really, really good players, cornerstones you build around... I don't think he can adapt to this player in this day and age right now... He's still about coming in at 3:17 in the morning, writing his own cue cards. He's got to change that. If he can't, he won't be successful.

Gruden never had a winning season in his second stint with the Raiders before resigning in 2021 amid a scandal. Booger's skepticism of his success was largely validated.
Win
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Andy Reid has completely reinvented his offensive coaching style to thrive in the modern NFL.

Andy Reid is a classic example of a guy that's reinvented everything he does. Think about Andy Reid at Philly. West Coast offense, dink and dunk... Now, it's RPO. It's Tyreek Hill. It's Jet Sweeps. It's Patrick Mahomes. He's changed the entire game.

Reid's dominance with Mahomes and subsequent Super Bowl wins confirm his successful adaptation to the modern game.
Win
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Rob Gronkowski is no longer the same player and will be available this offseason

This offseason, I'd bet your money and my money, Rob Gronkowski is probably going to be available this offseason. And people are going to say, man, Gronk's available. But if you watch Gronk play, Gronk isn't the same Gronk anymore. Like he can't run the way he used to.

Gronkowski retired in March 2019, confirming he was 'available' in the sense of being done with the Patriots. He eventually returned with the Bucs in 2020.
Loss
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

I could beat some professional golfers on the senior tour

I could beat, not be one, I could beat one [professional golfer]... Trevino, all the old guys... At some point, the father time is on my side. I'm 41... An average round for me, if I go out and just play average, I'll shoot in mid-80s.

Mid-80s golfers do not beat professional golfers, even older ones on the senior tour, who still regularly shoot in the 60s and 70s.
Void
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

It is more logical for a football player to piss their pants on the field than to miss a snap by going to the locker room.

Why would I go all the way back to the locker room and maybe miss an important snap that I can help my team? Why not just let it go and move on? ... Especially when you're in the middle of a game, the pants you have on are already sweaty anyway. They got to wash them anyway.

This is a subjective matter of personal hygiene versus competitive necessity.
Loss
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Chargers and Saints will meet in the Super Bowl.

I'm going for a little bit of, let's go Chargers [versus] Saints. Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, all that. Revenge game against his old team. I like that.

The Super Bowl featured the Patriots and the Rams.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers will trade Antonio Brown

I think he's going to get traded. I think the craziest part of the story was you've got to really fuck up to get benched, to be the best player on your team and get benched during a game or for a game that would get you into the playoffs.

Antonio Brown was traded to the Oakland Raiders in March 2019.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The strategy of not paying quarterbacks is only true if the quarterback is Kirk Cousins or Matthew Stafford

So essentially the argument that people are tweeting out that you shouldn't pay a quarterback boils down to just don't pay Kirk Cousins or Matt Stafford. That works. That's it... Essentially the entire theory that you should just draft a young quarterback and never pay a quarterback makes no sense because half of the playoffs are quarterbacks that are going to be paid $20 million or more.

This has become a lasting debate in the NFL. The 'QB middle class' (Cousins/Stafford types) often struggled to lead deep playoff runs compared to elite veterans (Brady/Brees) or cheap rookie stars (Mahomes).
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Being as rich as Kirk Cousins while remaining as lame as he is should be considered a crime.

Being rich and being that lame is a crime. It is a crime. ... Kirk Cousins is a crime against humanity. He should be fined $84 million for having $84 million and being lame with it.

Lameness is not a criminal offense, making this an inherently subjective and hyperbolic take.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

New Year's resolutions only work because everyone agrees to be collectively annoying at the same time.

It's annoying in general to hear people talking about any change they're making... But if you preface it by saying it's a New Year's resolution, it's slightly less annoying. It's all everyone decides to be annoying together. We're in like group therapy.

This is a social theory that can't be objectively proven but resonates with many.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will play all their starters in Week 17 because they can still get the two-seed

I do think the Bears are going to play all their starters because they do need... Like, they can still get that two seed, and to give up that two seed would be kind of stupid, just willingly.

The Bears played their starters in Week 17 against the Vikings, winning 24-10.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am taking the over on the Alabama-Oklahoma game regardless of the total

Alabama playing Oklahoma. I'm taking the over no matter what. It's like 80, but that's one of those ones they're challenging me. Let's do it. They're telling me you won't do this, and I fucking will.

The final score was Alabama 45, Oklahoma 34, for a total of 79 points. This missed the over by a single point.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I think Notre Dame might beat Clemson because I can't bet on two favorites in the same night

I can't take both favorites, so I'm taking Notre Dame, and I think they might win the game. Solely because of the other game [Alabama-Oklahoma].

Clemson dominated Notre Dame 30-3.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dabo Swinney is the second best head coach in the country

I think Dabo is probably the second best coach in the country. I think he's way better than Brian Kelly. I like the Clemson. I like the Rock.

This is subjective, but Clemson won the national title shortly after this episode, making Dabo's case for #2 behind Saban very strong at the time.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Alabama always struggles with mobile quarterbacks like Kyler Murray

No, Alabama always struggles with quarterbacks like Kyler. [Mobile quarterbacks]... If you look at their losses, they've only had like four in the last 10 years. They all came against mobile quarterbacks. So is the blueprint out?

Statistically, Alabama's losses during this era (Manziel, Newton, Watson) did frequently come against high-level mobile quarterbacks.
Void
Baker MayfieldBaker Mayfield

I would love to run the same offense in the NFL that I ran at Oklahoma

To me, yeah, obviously the easiest answer would be, yeah, I'd love to run the offense I did at Oklahoma. That's because I had three years to do it, and I got so comfortable in it.

Baker eventually found his most NFL success in Kevin Stefanski's more traditional system, but his early success with Freddie Kitchens (2018) involved more of these college concepts.
Win
Ed OrgeronEd Orgeron

My dream for LSU is to win a national championship

National champs. I won a national championship for the state of Louisiana, for these players. They yearn for it, they work for it, and I want to win a national championship there.

Ed Orgeron led LSU to an undefeated season and a National Championship in 2019.
Void
Gordon HaywardGordon Hayward

It is human nature for an injured player to sometimes root for their team to lose

I don't think you'd be human if there wasn't a part of you that was like, I hope that we lose. It's the competitive nature in you. Kyrie's probably going through the same thing. Like, I wish I was out there. I wish I was helping the team win. I think to compete at this level, you have to have that mentality.

This is a psychological insight rather than a testable prediction.
Void
Mark WahlbergMark Wahlberg

Eli Manning deserves more respect from Giants fans despite being benched

Why are they still playing Eli Manning and benching Blake Bortles? That makes no sense. Eli brought them two championships, even though they were bullshit wins. They count. Eli should get the kind of respect that he deserves from the Giants fans, and all these guys are flipping so quick.

Subjective legacy debate. Eli's relationship with Giants fans remains a polarizing topic between loyalty and production.
Loss
Von MillerVon Miller

Brock Osweiler has the ideal size you want for a quarterback and an arm like nobody else

No, I think that's the size that you want [Brock Osweiler]. If you're tall like that, you have long arms. And his delivery, he can... If he can master it, it's like nobody will have an arm like that.

Osweiler never mastered his delivery or reached that potential, retiring shortly after his stint with the Broncos.
Open
Von MillerVon Miller

I believe I can play 10 more years in the NFL

I probably got like 10 more. Yeah, I probably got like six or like seven real years in me than the last three I just steal. Just get in on third downs.

Von is still playing in 2024 (age 35), entering his 6th year since this prediction. He is on track to hit the 'seven real years' part of his claim.
Void
CJ McCollumCJ McCollum

There is no asterisk on my 50-point game just because the Bulls were tanking

I don't think there's an [asterisk]. Because when I have kids, I can say I scored 50 in three quarters. They're not going to remember. I just don't think the Chicago Bulls, oh, the team Jordan played for. Yeah, Jordan was guarding me... Look, 50 is 50. I don't care if you do it at your church.

The legitimacy of a stats game is purely subjective.
Win
CJ McCollumCJ McCollum

The Cleveland Browns will win at least six games this season

Shout out to the Cleveland Browns. You're going to win a game this year. We're going to win at least six games.

The Browns finished the 2018 season with 7 wins, making this prediction correct.
Win
Kevin SmithKevin Smith

Investing in professional sports is a much smarter financial move than investing in movies

Putting money into movies is one of the most foolish investments you'll ever make in your life. Invest in sports. You know why? Because sports, people always want to go. Sports are seasonal. It's cyclical. Going to see a movie, that's a crapshoot, man. That's like Vegas.

As of the late 2010s and 2020s, sports franchise valuations have skyrocketed while the film industry has been disrupted by streaming.
Win
Kevin SmithKevin Smith

Jay and Silent Bob Reboot will make money because people will pay for the freak value of seeing the characters return after 17 years

17 years later we're going to make a sequel, man. People are going to want to come out and see that just for the freak value of it alone. Even if they're like, fuck Jay and Silent Bob, they're going to be like, I want to see what these two old men are up to. So I think we're going to make our money.

The film was highly profitable through Smith's 'Roadshow' tour model, despite modest traditional box office numbers.
Void
Peanut TillmanPeanut Tillman

Modern NFL rules favor the offense so much that it is no longer good quality football

It [pisses me off] because the rules favor the offense so much. They favor the offense, and it's frustrating to watch. And fans, for whatever reason, they want to see high-scoring games. And to me, it's not fun. That's not good quality football.

Subjective opinion of a former defensive legend.
Void
Peanut TillmanPeanut Tillman

NFL defensive backs today have terrible eyes and look in the backfield too much instead of watching their man

The DBs, their eyes are in the backfield. They have terrible eyes. Your eyes should be on your man... Look at the man. Look at who you're covering. It's the one thing that pisses me off more than anything as I'm looking at this.

Fundamental technical critiques by experts are subjective assessments.
Win
Peanut TillmanPeanut Tillman

The 2018 Bears defense reminds me of our era; they are doing a great job creating their own identity

I think they look good [2018 Bears]... remind me of us. We didn't want to live in the 85 Bear era. No one does. No one wants to live in anyone else's shadow... so I think they're trying to create their own identity. And so far, I think they're doing it, and they're doing a really good job of it.

The 2018 Bears defense finished #1 in scoring defense and became an iconic unit in franchise history.
Void
Peanut TillmanPeanut Tillman

Cam Newton should have dove for the fumble in the Super Bowl

What do you think about Cam's business decision? Yeah, I think you just go for the ball, man. Be a team player.

Subjective, but it represents the majority view of NFL players regarding high-stakes effort.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kobe Bryant is not even a top five Laker anymore now that LeBron James is in Los Angeles

My sit-em is Kobe Bryant. He's not even a top five Laker anymore now that LeBron's there.

Kobe's ranking in Laker history is subjective, but almost all experts rank him in the top 3.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Vikings are just one win away from the playoffs

The Vikings are now one win away from the playoffs, and as my good friend Shaquille O'Neal famously once said, Can you step on digit? Vikings 27, Lions 9.

The Vikings lost to the Bears in Week 17 and missed the playoffs, so while the 'one win away' claim was technically true at the moment, they did not achieve it.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens are the NFL team of the weekend

Our team of the weekend has to be the Ravens. What they did on Saturday night, going to San Diego and beating Phil Rivers and a super hot Chargers team by playing 1940s offense is unbelievable. They do bully ball.

The Ravens finished the season 10-6 and won the AFC North, proving Big Cat's praise of their momentum at the time was well-founded.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm not selling my Chargers stock yet

I'm still hanging on to my Charger stock. It's going to turn around just like Bitcoin. I completely agree that was a nightmare matchup for the chargers.

The Chargers actually went on to beat the Ravens in the Wild Card round a few weeks later, proving PFT right that they would turn it around.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The AFC East has consistently sucked worse than any division in the history of sports

The AFC East has consistently sucked worse than any division in any sport in the history of balls. Ever since a ball was invented, no team has had it easier than the Patriots.

While the division was often weak, 'history of all sports' is a subjective and hyperbolic claim typical of PMT.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Browns will be the 'Regis Philbin' sneaky team everyone picks to make noise next year

Still a pretty incredible season, the fact that they [Browns] fired their coach and almost made the playoffs. They will now be our Regis Philbin team to make some noise next year. Everyone will pick them. They're the sneaky team.

The 2019 Browns became one of the most hyped 'sleeper' teams in recent memory before finishing 6-10.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick tricked the world into thinking Rob Gronkowski was unhealthy this year

I think that it's a major stay woke that the greatest trick Bill Belichick ever pulled was convincing the world that Rob Gronkowski was unhealthy this year so he's just been playing possum.

Gronkowski was indeed crucial in the Super Bowl that season, though most analysts agree his physical decline was real, not a ruse.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Patrick Mahomes' unorthodox fundamentals will eventually fail him as his athleticism dips

The league is going to catch up to Patrick Mahomes throwing sidearm. 20 years from now, when his athleticism starts to dip, you can't rely on bending, contorting your body and running sideways and throwing sidearm passes. You just can't. So I have my doubts.

Mahomes has maintained this level of play and won multiple Super Bowls since this take, though PFT's timeline is 20 years.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers