Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

The stamina-based Home Run Derby format is inferior to the old 'out-based' format

They've screwed it up. I know what it used to be with the 10 outs. It took forever cuz guys were just taking pitches. But yet again, we have a home run Derby where we just, it's essentially a stamina competition of who can hit the fastest home runs and it has nothing to do with the long ball. I want that back.

This is a subjective opinion on entertainment value.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Christian Yelich is a coward for choosing to skip the Home Run Derby

Also of note Christian Yelich, that coward did not compete in the Home Run Derby. Don't do that... He's a coward. That's what he is gonna do. He's, I think he's afraid of how much he's gonna love watching me and you tongue punch each other's spark boxes.

Labeling an athlete a coward for resting is a subjective insult.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 2023 MLB All-Star jerseys were terrible and the league should let players wear their team uniforms instead

The all-star jerseys were terrible. I don't know what they were doing. They looked so, so bad. It feels like it... it should be easy to not mess this up. I also wouldn't hate it if they... did it where it was just roads and, and home. Like you wore your uniform with your grays with like an emblem on it.

Jersey aesthetics are subjective.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A grilled cheese is better the less effort you put into it

I also think that a grilled cheese is one of those things that it's better the less effort that you put into it. Yeah. Like you can make a gourmet grilled cheese with some of the best cheese in the world. But for my money, if you just take like two slices of Wonder Bread and some craft singles that's perfect.

Culinary preference is subjective.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Chief Aholic is a modern-day Robin Hood who we shouldn't be castigating

Chief Aholic is basically a modern day Robin Hood. Stole from the banks, gave to himself and we're, we're castigating him for it. We're throwing him in jail maybe for the rest of his life. It feels messed up.

Chief Aholic (Xaviar Michael Babudar) was sentenced to prison in 2024 for a multi-state bank robbery spree.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Times Square Margaritaville should be subsidized by the government and saved from closure

Margaritaville should be too big to fail. It should be subsidized by the government. Should be saved. Yeah.

Hot TakeLifeScorchingSarcastic
The government did not subsidize the Times Square Margaritaville.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Anyone who says 'I turned out fine' regarding their childhood trauma actually didn't turn out fine

Anyone who says I turned out fine, there you are. Not fine. About anything, anything. It could be like X Y, Z happened to me when I was a kid. I turned out fine. 'I smoked, my father made me smoke cigarettes when I was five years old. Look how I turned out.' I'm fine. Yeah, I'm great.

This is a psychological observation and inherently subjective.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Urban Meyer would be a great choice for the next Northwestern head coach

I think one thing we can all agree on though is a great choice for the next Northwestern head coach would be Urban Meyer. Ooh, yes. Let's get urban back in the conversation. Not afraid to get his hands dirty. The guy is a molder of young men and let's just get urban back into the Big 10.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
Northwestern did not hire Urban Meyer; they promoted David Braun to permanent head coach after the 2023 season.
Void
Dallas GoedertDallas Goedert

The Eagles would beat the Chiefs 10 out of 10 times in the Super Bowl if the field conditions were better

All I can say is it was a great game till the end. You know, if, if the field was better, if we were playing on turf, you know, I'd take us 10 outta 10. But I have to say that.

This is a hypothetical 'what if' scenario that can never be proven.
Void
Dallas GoedertDallas Goedert

South Dakota is the 'cool Dakota' while North Dakota is for people who aren't cool

North Dakota is kind of like where people go that aren't cool. And like South Dakota's the cool Dakota. Okay. Really? It's just like Canada didn't want 'em. So like we'll just give 'em North Dakota.

The quality of 'coolness' for a state is purely subjective.
Void
Dallas GoedertDallas Goedert

The Eagles could successfully run their 'tush push' quarterback sneak on every single down

I think we could go up and down the field [running the sneak every down]. Yeah. I think Jalen would break more than you would think and probably drop a safety and take it.

While the play was statistically dominant, running it 100% of the time is a hypothetical that was never attempted.
Loss
Dallas GoedertDallas Goedert

Jalen Hurts will throw for more touchdowns and rush for fewer this season

This next year though, we, we've been talking and he doesn't want rushing touchdowns. He's good. He broke the quarterback rush touchdown per year, whatever. So now he's, now he's ready to start throwing 'em.

In 2023, Jalen Hurts rushed for a career-high 15 touchdowns (up from 13 in 2022) and threw for 23 touchdowns (up from 22). He did not decrease his rushing score output.
Loss
Dallas GoedertDallas Goedert

Jalen Hurts is a top two quarterback in the NFL

I think Jay has to be at the top. Yes. Personally speaking, Jalen's in the top two and depending on what fan base we want to antagonize. But personally speaking, Jaylen's in the top two.

Following the 2023 season, Hurts was generally not ranked as a top two QB, finishing behind Lamar Jackson and Patrick Mahomes in most consensus rankings after a mid-season slump.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Car time is for listening to podcasts, not for talking

Not for talking. Car time is for listening. When is he supposed to make these business calls in the car? On the golf course? Yeah.

This is a subjective preference for road trip behavior.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Joey Chestnut is the greatest American of all time and saved the 4th of July

Joey Chestnut being the greatest American of all time and saving, literally saving the 4th of July for America. ... if we did a new Mount Rushmore of Greatest Americans of all time, it's Joey Chestnut [and no one] else.

Whether someone is the 'greatest American' is subjective, but Chestnut did win his 16th title in 2023.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

It would be extremely funny if Victor Wembanyama turned out to be a bust

I know that we're a Victor Wembanyama podcast. We've staked our reputation on it. Everyone will remember this. It would be so fucking funny if he was a bust.

Wembanyama went on to have an incredible Rookie of the Year season, making him definitively not a bust so far.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The social media app Threads is boring and already dead because it's too nice

I'm already, it was fun for like two and a half days. ... I don't know what to do with it now because I just don't, there's nothing, it's too nice. ... I think I'm done. I think I'm done with it.

Threads struggled significantly with user retention shortly after its record-breaking launch week.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Golf ball manufacturers should put tracking chips in balls to prevent loss

They need to make a fucking golf ball with a chip in it that you can locate on your phone when you lose it in the Woods or in a bush or in tall grass. ... Let's make a golf ball with a chip in it. We we're way overdue for that

Technology exists (like Topgolf) but hasn't been economically scaled for consumer 'chip' balls due to price and durability.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You can eat for free at restaurants by pretending to be a waiter taking away leftovers

I think we could just eat for free if we just show up to really nice restaurants and we just go to like, people who are just finishing being like, can I take this for you? And then just walk out. ... I handed him my food. Like it was nobody's business being like, this guy will come back with a bag and Yeah. I, I think I found a way that if, if we ever fall on hard times, we can just live off of that.

The effectiveness of this 'scam' is untestable without committing a crime, but the logic of 'acting like you belong' is a known social engineering tactic.
Win
HankHank

The Vegas Sphere is the coolest thing ever and the future of advertising

It's maybe the coolest thing I've ever seen. Like, I feel like it's gonna be everywhere all the time now. Like it's the, it's the future. ... However much it costs to advertise on it is like it's better than a billboard.

The Sphere became an immediate global sensation and remains a high-demand advertising platform.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bob Huggins' legal defense that he never actually resigned from West Virginia is "brilliant" and "ironclad"

Bob Huggins is kind of back. ... He's employing a brilliant legal defense right now. He's claiming that he never actually resigned from WVU... that his wife sent an email saying that he was maybe gonna step down and that they ran with that. ... It sounds pretty ironclad.

OpinionCBBMediumSarcastic
The defense was not successful; Bob Huggins did not return as the coach of West Virginia.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jordan Spieth is wearing a cheap $500 Instagram ad suit that hides 'fat and frumpy' bodies

Jordan Spieth has a lot, a lot of money. But I think I have that same suit and I understand what happened. ... I think he's wearing a $500 Instagram suit. ... It's a stretchy material that doesn't iron well. And so it's like, it's like a, it's like almost like a, it's like an Under Armour shirt in a suit form.

While unconfirmed if it's the exact same brand, Spieth was heavily roasted for the suit's quality, supporting the 'cheap' claim.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

"Girl dinner" is just a new name for the way I've been snacking for 20 years

I've been eating girl dinner for the last 20 years of my life. ... Charcuterie bro. Dude, I've been eating girl dinner forever. I just accidentally eat a full sleeve of crackers and a block of cheese while I'm standing in front of my fridge.

Subjective cultural observation.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

Football players who don't play and then transfer are 'snitches' for reporting hazing

No dudes who don't play in transfer are the biggest snitches ever. ... Cuz they're, they're the only ones who's like, there's something wrong with this program. It's not wrong with me. It's the program that's wrong.

This is a moral/social judgment on whistleblowing in sports culture.
Win
HankHank

Tom Brady is "all natural" and would never date someone with a "fake body" like Kim Kardashian

She's got a fake body and Tom Brady would never do something like that. ... Tom Brady is a real man. He cares about family, brotherhood, love. ... Tom Brady's all natural himself.

While rumored, Tom Brady and Kim Kardashian never actually dated or formed a relationship.
Loss
Billy FootballBilly Football

Tom Brady is a 'trophy husband' who needs a sugar mama like Kim Kardashian

Tom Brady is a stay-at-home dad. He needs to find another sugar mama to pay his bills because he always likes women who make more than him. That's just the facts. ... He's a trophy husband. ... Now he's looking for someone to take care of him.

The dating rumors were never confirmed, and the 'sugar mama' claim is satirical given Brady's own net worth.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The NBA Cup is awesome and gives fans a real reason to care about the regular season in December

My who's back is the NBA cup. It was revealed this weekend. ... I think it's awesome. ... December 9th. I don't think people are circling NBA on their calendar, but now this gives you a reason to do so.

The inaugural NBA Cup in 2023 was generally viewed as a major success for the league, driving up ratings and intensity in December.
Void
Sam DarnoldSam Darnold

I felt ghosts in the pool house at George Kittle's home

It was very creepy. And I had never dealt with anything like that before. ... I like just like couldn't like, I had to like, keep focusing on this thing in the co like there was something else in the room. ... I felt that something was in the room with me. And it was the the freakiest thing.

The existence of ghosts is scientifically unproven, but Darnold is claiming it as his personal reality.
Win
Sam DarnoldSam Darnold

In Kyle Shanahan's offense, receivers are open on nearly every play

Guys are open. I mean, there's a lot of guys open on near every play. It just seems like there's a ton of answers. ... knowing that the coordinator's gonna put everyone in the best position possible.

The 2023 49ers offense was statistically elite, and Brock Purdy led the league in many efficiency metrics, largely due to receivers being frequently schemed open.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially 'back in' on Sam Darnold

I'm back in on Sam Darnold. I think you're back. 100%. ... Sam Darnold's back. Put it, I I said it. Big Cat Big Cat said it.

Darnold served as a backup in SF and later signed as a starter for the Vikings in 2024, showing a significant resurgence.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Pissing in the snow and writing your name is an elite experience

Peeing in the snow. Pissing in the snow, writing your name in the snow rocks, watching it melt. ... You got your own fire hose.

Subjective opinion on outdoor activities.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Shower pisses are elite and I will actually hold a piss just so I can do it in the shower

The shower piss is elite. ... It's like automatic that I pee in the shower. I'll hold a piss to go in the shower. ... It's also kind of badass when you're a little dehydrated and your piss is yellow in the shower.

Subjective opinion on bathroom habits.
Void
HankHank

Shower pisses are gross and I am not a shower piss guy

I'm not a shower piss guy. ... [PFT: How can you not pee in the shower?] I'm not a shower piss guy. ... Shower pisses are so gross.

This is an inherently subjective matter of personal hygiene and preference.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Peeing on a smoldering campfire to put it out is an elite experience

Peeing onto a smoldering fire... putting out the fire. So putting out your fire rules. ... You got your own fire hose.

Subjective enjoyment of a specific activity.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I pee in 100% of the pools I have ever been in

I piss in every pool I've ever been in. Yep. A hundred percent. Yep. All the time. ... Every pool I've ever been in, in my entire life. Every pool I've pissed in.

This is a self-reported fact claim by Big Cat.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Wonton Don was such a great guest that next time we play D&D, he and Nick should both join us.

Wonton Don was a great fill in. It might just be Nick and Donny next time with us because it was that great. So much fun with him.

This is a subjective preference about the show's cast, but Donnie did return for future episodes.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Hank will likely catch a stray and be put in a dangerous situation before the D&D session ends.

I think somebody pro, if I, if I were to guess, because there's always gonna be a little bit of blood lust about somebody wanted to kill Hank very much... I think Hank might have caught a stray. Maybe we put Hank in a dangerous situation after I left.

At the end of the episode, Big Cat's character challenges and successfully kills Hank's character in a duel.
Win
Timm WoodsTimm Woods

If you see me on the street, I will almost certainly have a D20 on my person to roll for you.

If you come up to me on the street, I will roll a D 20 because I will probably have one on my person. Almost definitely.

Timm is sincere about his professional persona and community engagement.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I promise not to kill Hank during this D&D session unless he gives me a reason to.

I promise not to kill Hank unless Hank does something that makes me have to kill him, which he might do. ... I'm not gonna attack Hank. I'm not gonna attack anybody that's in my party. But if Hank does something that's like, he really has it coming, it's gonna be tough for me not to.

PFT kept his word; he did not attack Hank, though Big Cat eventually did.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am promising that I will truce fully and not attack anyone during this D&D session.

I am promising that I will truce fully. I will not attack anyone. I Wonton try to get as far as we've ever gotten where we don't get sidetracked. ... I am dressed nicely today. ... I Wonton have fun with my friends and then, and just go on a nice adventure together.

He broke the truce at the very end of the episode by initiating a duel to the death with Hank.
Win
The Wonton DonThe Wonton Don

The party can always turn on Hank if the mission goes south.

Okay, well, if shit goes south, we can always turn on Hank. As long as it's not me.

The group does eventually turn on each other, specifically targeting Hank at the end.
Win
Timm WoodsTimm Woods

Every group of fans that has played this adventure has successfully finished it.

Every one of the a w l groups who has gone through this adventure has gotten to the end and finished it. But I also told them I wasn't sure if you guys would or not.

As the Dungeon Master reporting on his own sessions, this is accepted as fact.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Using a Bardic Inspiration early in D&D is like using a coaching challenge in the first quarter of an NBA game.

It's like using your challenge in the first quarter. Okay. Even if you can win, win it. But if you win your challenge, you get you, you keep it. I mean three points true. It's three points in the matter. We're not an NBA podcast. Let's, I mean it's NBA, it's final season.

The analogy is sound regarding the strategic conservation of limited resources.
Void
HankHank

The missing children in the D&D campaign deserve their fate for exploring dangerous caves.

The child needs a lesson. You shouldn't go explore caves plug.

This is an in-character opinion during a role-playing game.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

A Warlock is nothing without their spells.

You need your spells. [Hank] is nothing If you don't have spells.

In D&D mechanics, a Warlock's primary utility is indeed their spellcasting and Eldritch Blast.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sending the missing kids to hell was definitely not part of our original rescue mission.

I don't think that our plan was to find these kids and send them to hell. ... I don't think that our plan was to find these kids and send them to hell. It was to [maybe save them].

OpinionMediaMediumSarcastic
Technically correct based on the stated goal of finding the missing children.
Void
HankHank

My Warlock patron is basically just a dealer trying to support his family by taking souls.

He's just going to my dealer's house. Right? ... Maybe he's just trying to support his family and that's the only way he knows how. ... I gotta support the plug.

Subjective justification for an in-game action.
Push
The Wonton DonThe Wonton Don

One teenage hippo can successfully take on three or four ghouls in combat.

I think one hippo can take three GULs or four... I think that's a solid matchup.

The hippo 'Mode' (played by Max) assists in the fight but is eventually killed by collateral damage and rocks, making the 'take' on its solo capability debatable.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I deserve credit for the Necromancer kill because I did the heavy lifting before Hank's final blow.

Stats at the end, that kill would be mine, right? Like I, I was the one who loosened the jar. ... I was the one who did the damage.

Subjective interpretation of kill credit in a role-playing game.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am the Wilt Chamberlain of Dungeons & Dragons based on my performance today.

I'm the Wilt Chamberlain numbers. ... I am the last survivor here, so you get all these experience points survived.

An absurd and unprovable comparison typical of Big Cat's humor.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers