Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bobby Petrino is a man of character who will clean up the North Carolina locker room as offensive coordinator

Bobby Petrino is going to be their new offense coordinator for next season. And I think that's a great hire. This is fun that Bobby Petrino, a man of character can get in, clean up that locker room and, and really change it from being a circus into a, a run of the mill workman like professional football organization.

OpinionCFBHotSubjectiveSarcastic
Petrino's history makes the 'man of character' claim factually dubious in the eyes of many, but as a satirical opinion, it is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The College Football Playoff should expand to a 16-team format

We do love Cinderellas in the first couple of rounds. And this is why they should go to a 16 team playoff and we should give the Cinderellas a chance. I'm excited to see JMU play. Fuck it.

This is a structural opinion on how the sport should be governed.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JMU isn't like Liberty; they will be competitive in the playoff

We're not fucking Liberty, dude. We have sex at James Madison University. It's encouraged, it's mandatory. ... If one of those teams keeps it competitive, they might not change the format too much.

JMU was blown out in their playoff appearance, leading to further format debates.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Miami deserved a spot in the College Football Playoff over Notre Dame

You can't eliminate the fact that the games need to matter. It's why we said that Miami should be in over Notre Dame. It's why that if you win games, you should have a seat at the table.

This is a subjective debate about playoff selection criteria.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Notre Dame's relationship with the ACC is irreparably harmed after the CFP snub

Notre Dame is now going scorched earth on the college football playoff and more specifically the ACC. The athletic director, Bevacqua... saying that the ACC absolutely fucked them over, that they did irreparable harm to the relationship with Notre Dame. This business relationship might be done.

The long-term status of Notre Dame's alignment with the ACC is an ongoing situation, but the immediate friction was a matter of public record.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JMU making the CFP will force a rule change to ensure it never happens again

JMU getting into this playoff, they will rewrite the rules for the playoffs. So this never happens again. And you'll be fine... But they're very upset that the ACC did not advocate strongly for Notre Dame.

Rule changes for the 12 or 14-team playoff often follow controversial seedings.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JMU is not one of the best 12 teams in the country

I'm not saying JMU is one of the best 12 teams in the country. I think that that would be an insane take to have. I'm just pumped that we're in it.

Ranking 'best' teams is subjective, but PFT is admitting they aren't Top 12 quality.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Ed Orgeron will return to LSU as part of Lane Kiffin's new coaching staff

I think there's a high chance that he [Kiffin] puts Coach O on his staff... Why wouldn't you want Coach O on the LSU staff? You want him back.

Big Cat predicted Ed Orgeron would return to LSU as part of Lane Kiffin's new coaching staff. While Kiffin was hired as LSU head coach, Orgeron confirmed Kiffin did not ask him to join the staff. The coaching staff was filled with former Ole Miss assistants. Coach O was open to it but was not offered a position.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LSU is Lane Kiffin's forever home and he will never leave the program

I don't think Lane Kiffin would ever leave. This is the one destination for him.

This prediction covers the remainder of Kiffin's career and is currently pending.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

James Franklin is leaving a $50 million buyout because he has a competitive drive to coach, not just for the money

I feel like you don't get to a point where you are successful enough to get a $50 million buyout unless you have that like killer instinct, competitive drive. ... James Franklin's going after being an awesome coach, coaching, he needs football to live.

The move to Virginia Tech is stated as fact in this pod's timeline.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am betting everything on Notre Dame because of Pat Narduzzi's weird press conference comments.

Pat Narduzzi, the coach of Pitt... had one of the weirdest answers to a press conference question I think I've ever seen... I wanna just bet everything on Notre Dame. They are not going to cover the spread against Notre Dame.

Notre Dame demolished Pitt 37-15 on November 15, 2025. Big Cat bet everything on Notre Dame and they won by 22 points, covering easily.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin Football is currently the worst program in Power Four football

Wisconsin football just because they're the worst team in college football, Power Four college football. It's an absolute joke what's happened to the program. They haven't scored a touchdown in two games. The culture's broken, the program's broken.

While Wisconsin is struggling, programs like Purdue or lower-tier ACC/SEC teams may statistically be 'worse'. This is mostly hyperbolic frustration.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin Football will be bad for at least the next five to seven years

I'm starting to think now they're gonna be bad for five to seven years minimum. And if they just keep going down this path, it's gonna be a decade. To the sunk cost fallacy of essentially saying, we made a mistake... let's throw more money at it.

This prediction will take years to resolve based on the program's winning percentage and conference standing.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Sherrone Moore's 'blue-collar' jacket is a cheap, ineffective imitation of Jim Harbaugh

[Sherrone Moore] has his blue collar jacket on and he basically was like, Hey, I'm back to work. ... It worked for Jim Harbaugh because Jim Harbaugh had won... This feels like a cheap knockoff and it's not gonna work.

Subjective opinion on coaching style and branding.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Lane Kiffin's daughter's relationship with an LSU player is a 'coordinated attack' to get intel

He definitely knew. They've been dating for a while. He posted a picture of her... he's already talked to Weeks about what they're gonna run on defense.

Highly unlikely to be a literal 'coordinated attack' for coaching intel, but a funny sports theory.
Void
HankHank

Number 47 is a terrible number for a BYU quarterback

Bear's a bad start. You can't. You put harder earned money on a team and you see a quarterback coming out wearing number 47. Terrible number for a quarterback.

Purely an aesthetic opinion.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Auburn adding four historical national titles is the beauty of college sports

Auburn football won four national championships today. They updated their official national titles. They added a championship in 1910, 1914, 1958, and then most notably they added 2004. They finished the season undefeated, but they didn't get invited. This is kind of the beauty of college sports. That you can just claim whatever you want.

Auburn did indeed update their media guide to include these 'selective' titles.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 'Underground Talent Railroad' transfer strategy is a genius college football idea

Let's create a network where we're all transparent with each other every fifth year. Each one of us can take its turn having the A team... PIT gets to have the 22 best players between the five programs... I don't hate it. I love it. I actually don't hate it at all. I love it.

Void
MaxMax

Fox's Big Noon Kickoff is 'bullshit' because it ruins the atmosphere of Penn State's White Out games.

That's Fox's fault. Big 10. Fucking Big 10 kickoff is big Noon kickoff is bullshit... it's like a really big thing in college football... they burn your whiteouts on, on Lame Games.

The sentiment that morning kickoffs diminish the White Out atmosphere is inherently subjective to fans.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

The Big 10 and SEC are likely to add Florida State once the ACC officially dissolves.

If Clemson and Florida State leave the ACC, they're not gonna survive. So the Big 10 and SEC basically are saying we don't want 'em unless the ACC is gone. Which if they leave, they'll be gone. In which case we want 'em.

The ACC has not dissolved yet and Florida State is still currently in the conference.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LSU should find a way to vacate Nick Saban's wins to be real haters

What I think LSU should do, find something that happened when Nick Saban was there, because Nick Saban is up for eligibility next year. And if they took away his wins at LSU... If you want to be a real hater, you could do that to a coach that left you and then came and coached for your rival.

OpinionCFBHotSarcastic
LSU has not vacated Saban's wins and Saban's win percentage is high enough that it wouldn't matter anyway.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The 60% winning percentage rule for the College Football Hall of Fame is bullshit and Mike Leach should be in

The rule that you have to have 60% to make the college football Hall of fame is bullshit and should be changed. Because I did see this last week. Mike Leach is like 0.03% away. They need to let Mike Leach in the Hall of Fame. Because who's to say that you weren't a giant contributor to the game if you didn't happen to have 60%?

This is a matter of administrative policy and opinion on 'greatness' vs 'winning percentage.'
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

UMass moving to the MAC is great for 'MACtion' and weeknight football

My cool Throne is Mion, we're getting more Mion because UMass is getting added, which means more games back... more weeknight football eventually.

UMass did officially join the MAC starting in 2025 for all sports, increasing the number of conference games available for the MAC's midweek schedule.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Notre Dame will never get higher than a 5-seed in the 12-team CFP

If Notre Dame is the best team in the country, they get the number five seed. [Because] the four highest ranked conference champions will be seeds one through four.

The rule for the 12-team CFP specifically grants the top 4 seeds to conference champions. As an independent, Notre Dame cannot be a top 4 seed.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Liberty Football's 2.96 GPA is actually good for a team GPA

Liberty Football. They tweeted ... 2.96 cumulative GPA. ... It's actually not terrible for a team. It's really good. ... football team. It's the old, 'I didn't play school'.

This is a subjective assessment of academic performance in sports.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Oregon is going to destroy Liberty in the Fiesta Bowl

17 points is not nearly enough points. They're so strong... They're way bigger than Liberty. So I'm hammering Oregon this weekend.

Oregon defeated Liberty 45-6, easily covering the 17-point spread.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Betting against the Miami Hurricanes in cold-weather bowl games is the easiest bet in sports

Miami just having to play in a cold weather city is like the easiest bet against every single year in Bowl season. Rutgers just wanted it way more.

Miami lost to Rutgers 31-24 in the Pinstripe Bowl in New York, supporting his claim.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Dylan Raiola is already a bust after his commitment poem

What is this? So fellow fans await with hope in the air for Dylan to choose his purpose to declare in a weekend's decision, destiny calls to fulfill his purpose. Where a new dynasty enthralls... He's already a bust in my eyes. I'm happy for Nebraska fans, but you can't be feeling good about that poem.

Raiola is a true freshman in 2024; his career is just beginning.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Syracuse football is having the best off-season in all of college football

My Cool Throne is my alma mater. Syracuse football. They are having arguably the best off-season in all of college football. Almost... in my book.

Purely subjective comparison of transfer portal and coaching successes.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NCAA's new compensation rules will create a major/minor league divide in college sports

The NCAA is putting forth a new... regulation... so that certain colleges, any college as a matter of fact can contribute up to $30,000 a year... once this gets into place, it's gonna be like the major leagues, right. Of college sports. Yes. And then everybody else is the minor leagues if this actually ends up happening.

The landscape of college football has rapidly shifted toward a 'Power 2' (Big Ten/SEC) dominance based on financial resources, validating this outlook.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

You cannot leave an undefeated Florida State out of the College Football Playoff

If Florida State can be kept out if they're undefeated? I don't think you can... They won't leave out an undefeated Florida state. I'm pretty confident.

Florida State finished 13-0 but was left out of the 4-team playoff in favor of one-loss Alabama and Texas.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels is the only logical choice for the Heisman Trophy

I had Jordan Travis actually as my Heisman Trophy winner, but I don't think that you can give it to him now. So you have to go to [Jayden] Daniels. Jaden Daniels would be the only logical choice.

Jayden Daniels won the 2023 Heisman Trophy.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dabo Swinney deserves at least one bad year given the high expectations he's fulfilled at Clemson.

Dabo came, they won more than 10 games seven years in a row, won two national titles. Bad year. I think he deserves at least one bad year.

This is a subjective opinion on how a coach should be treated by fans/media.
Win
HankHank

Dabo Swinney is cooked because he refuses to embrace the transfer portal and NIL

Clemson though, done. Dabo. It's so bury—so great. Burying Dabo. Bury him... Dabo is not a likable guy. You had your run. And it does—it is kind of nice. If Dabo didn't say all the stuff about NIL and transfer portal, I, I would feel a little bit worse. But he's so resistant to change when college football has so drastically changed in the last five years.

Clemson finished the 2023 season 9-4, their first season with 4+ losses since 2011, supporting the idea of a significant decline from elite status.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Dabo Swinney's refusal to adapt to NIL and the transfer portal is his downfall

He's so resistant to change when college football has so drastically changed in the last five years. It's kind of great to be like, dude, all you had to do was embrace it and realize that everything is changing around you. You gotta change. Like Nick Saban has always changed.

Clemson has continued to struggle to maintain its previous elite status compared to programs that embraced the portal, though they remain competitive.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jim Harbaugh's self-imposed three-game suspension is a genius move to avoid missing the Texas game in 2024

Jim Harbaugh, Michigan self-imposed a three game suspension on him. Genius. Genius Moves. So he misses all the out of conference games... Michigan was like, okay, tell you what, you pressed our hand. We'll go as far as three games. Well, I mean it would, I would guess... they're playing like no one. It's at all the, at a conference stuff.

Harbaugh missed games against East Carolina, UNLV, and Bowling Green, allowing him to return for Big Ten play.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Northwestern football should be given the death penalty

As a fan of Northwestern, I think they should be given the death penalty. True. I think that as Northwestern goes, we're more than a football team. We're, we're an institution that develops and builds young minds and teaches them to be ethical... death penalty to Northwestern.

Hot TakeCFBFireSarcastic
The program was not given the death penalty and continued to play.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

College football is headed for a Big Two conference structure

Geographics do not matter in college football anymore. We're headed for the big, big two. Maybe big three... I don't know why we don't just do, we should just do NFL model and just have divisions... The big, the big 10 and the s e c of the conferences.

With the collapse of the PAC-12 and the Big 10/SEC expanding to 16+ teams, the 'Power 2' era has essentially arrived.
Push
Billy FootballBilly Football

The 'horns down' gesture is officially back and allowed in the SEC

You can use horns down because according to John McDade, the SEC's coordinator of officials on penalizing for horns down signal in '24... he said that you can use horns down against Texas.

SEC officials later clarified that it still depends on the context of taunting, but the general ban used in the Big 12 was lifted.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Urban Meyer would be a great choice for the next Northwestern head coach

I think one thing we can all agree on though is a great choice for the next Northwestern head coach would be Urban Meyer. Ooh, yes. Let's get urban back in the conversation. Not afraid to get his hands dirty. The guy is a molder of young men and let's just get urban back into the Big 10.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
Northwestern did not hire Urban Meyer; they promoted David Braun to permanent head coach after the 2023 season.
Void
Billy FootballBilly Football

D3 football is better at molding young men than D1 football

So D3 football is actually better than D1 football... In terms of molding young men probably. Because I would end up, if I tried walking on a D1, I'd see D1 parties and be like, oh shit, why am I doing this?

Inherently subjective and personal to the speaker's experience.
Push
Billy FootballBilly Football

Malik Murphy is the real sleeper in the Texas QB battle and has the best arm on the team

In reality in the UT quarterback competition, there was a big dark horse sleeper that no one saw coming in Malik Murphy... I think has the best arm out of any of the quarterbacks on the team. Quinn Ewers did have an amazing day... but this Malik Murphy guy just was throwing bombs out there.

Murphy did start several games for Texas when Ewers was injured and performed well before transferring to Duke.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

UGA 10 is the greatest bulldog mascot of all time

AGA 10 is the greatest AGA of all time. AGA 10 won back to back national titles. AGA 10 went 84 and 15 as the mascot of the Georgia Bulldogs.

Subjective. It depends on whether you value championships (UGA 10 has the most) or longevity.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Saban's 'wrong place, wrong time' comment was a direct shot at Nate Oats

Nick Saban has just suspended freshman defensive back, Tony Mitchell... and Nick Saban said everybody's got an opportunity to make choices and decisions. There's no such thing as the wrong place at the wrong time. Seemed like a direct shot at Nate Oats for using the wrong place, wrong time excuse for Brandon Miller.

While Saban didn't name Oats, the timing and specific phrasing ('wrong place, wrong time') made it widely interpreted as a rebuke of the basketball program's handling of Brandon Miller.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Texas A&M is a cult

Texas a and M is a cult. Yeah. I, I say this as somebody that knows a lot of Aggies. I lived in Texas for about 10 years. They're cult. A lot of 'em are nice people, but nice people who are in a cult. What was the thing the guy was doing where he, like, he would do that every time? That's that's the horse laugh. Oh my God. They've got entire, they have an entire like catalog and encyclopedia of different hand motions and body motions that these yell leaders have to make at certain points. They're just, they're just cults.

While legally a university, the 'cult' label is a subjective social critique of the school's unique and intense traditions.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Coach Orgeron is the most well-adjusted human being out of all major college coaches

I think Coach O is actually the most well-adjusted human being out of all the major college coaches. Most normal people, you give anybody 20 million and you don't have to work again, that's the goal. That is actually a very well adjusted outlook on life, unlike just about every other head coach out there.

Subjective opinion on Orgeron's state of mind following his departure from LSU.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Dabo Swinney would be a serial killer or a Scientology leader if not for football

If it weren't for football, like Dabo Swinney would be a serial killer. Like he's, he's unhinged. He's an unhinged human being. He's not a well-adjusted human being... He probably would take over for David Miscavige and just be the next fucking Scientology guy.

This is a satirical/subjective character assessment that cannot be factually verified.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brian Kelly already regrets moving to LSU

You can see the look in his eye. He's already thinking to himself, like I fucked up, I made the wrong decision. I don't know what I'm doing down here.

While Kelly had a rocky start, he won 10 games in each of his first two seasons (2022, 2023). It's subjective whether he 'regrets' it, but the immediate disaster narrative cooled.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Billy Napier will succeed at Florida while Brian Kelly bottoms out at LSU

I'm rooting for Florida to win a national title and LSU to bottom out... Everyone look around and be like, 'Wait, what? That guy [Napier] was in the state of Louisiana and we had to go get the shiny object [Kelly] because he won a bunch of games at Notre Dame.' I'm rooting against Brian Kelly.

In 2022, LSU won the SEC West (10-4) under Kelly, while Florida went 6-7 under Napier. Napier was eventually fired in 2024.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Watching Beth Mowins call a low-scoring Big Ten game early on a Saturday morning was the perfect way to ease into a day of college football

The Big 10 has their new contract... That means, unfortunately, ESPN will not have the Big 10 and we will not have Beth Mowins putting us in a perfect spot on a Saturday morning, watching Purdue and Northwestern have a punt off. And I'm gonna miss that, because that game means a lot to me. It was a great way to ease you into Saturday because I don't like having a huge game right away.

This is an inherently subjective opinion about viewing habits.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers