Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Conor McDavid's team-friendly contract was designed to make him easily tradable to a contender

This seems like it would be very easily tradable. Very, very easily tradable contract. He basically, I mean smart by him. If in a year and a half the Oilers aren't competing and he can go somewhere for a year and a half and it doesn't fuck up some team's cap.

McDavid has not been traded, and the Oilers have remained competitive.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Toronto Maple Leafs were the second-best team in the NHL this year because they were the only ones to take the Panthers to seven games

I mean, if you had to pick a second best team, PFT, it's probably the Toronto Maple Leafs. 'cause they took 'em to seven. [PFT]: I was about to start the show by congratulating the Toronto Maple Leafs on being better than the Edmonton Oilers.

OpinionHockeyHotSarcastic
The Oilers made the finals, while the Leafs were eliminated earlier; series length against a common opponent is a humorous but logically flawed metric for 'second best.'
Loss
Matt MurleyMatt Murley

The Oilers will win the Stanley Cup Finals in six games

Oilers in six. I don't wanna go to Edmonton for seven, maybe, maybe, but Oilers in six there.

The Oilers lost the 2024 Finals in seven games to the Panthers.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Getting into a line brawl is the best way to shift momentum when you're losing a playoff series

As a hockey expert, my plan, whenever you're getting your ass kicked in a series and you wanna shift it around, just get into a massive line brawl at the end of that game and just try to change the energies up somehow.

The Oilers did enter a brawl at the end of Game 3 but went on to lose the series in 7 games after being down 3-0.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Oilers are winning the Stanley Cup because I finally won a golf tournament.

Win a tournament leading. And that's why when we won it, I said the Oilers are winning the Cup. I just won something. I never win anything. Never.

The Oilers did NOT win the Stanley Cup. The Florida Panthers defeated the Edmonton Oilers 4 games to 2 in the 2025 Stanley Cup Final, winning their second consecutive championship.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Oilers will win the Stanley Cup in seven games

I think it's Oilers. I got Oilers in seven. I think it's Oilers.

The Oilers lost the Stanley Cup Final to the Florida Panthers in 6 games (4-2). They did not win the Cup.
Loss
HankHank

The Florida Panthers will win the Stanley Cup in five games

I'll go Panthers in five.

The Florida Panthers won the Stanley Cup but in six games against the Oilers, not five as predicted.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Oilers will win the Stanley Cup based on the historical pattern of rematches

Oilers Islanders. Gretzky lost the first time and then won second year. Crosby loses the first time to the Red Wings, second time comes back and wins. Now McDavid loses to the Panthers the first time. Second time I think I like the Oilers boys. I think it's coming home.

The 2024 Stanley Cup was won by the Florida Panthers, defeating the Edmonton Oilers in seven games.
Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Mitch Marner will not be back with the Toronto Maple Leafs next season

[Mitch Marner] ain't coming back. ... he just hasn't lived up to what, not only he's being paid, but what the hype is in, in crunch time. ... my theory would be that you bring back [Nylander], you bring back Matthews and you can build around those guys. ... he won't be back. It sucks.

Mitch Marner remained on the Toronto Maple Leafs roster for the 2024-2025 season.
Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Dallas Stars will defeat the Edmonton Oilers in seven games

I picked the Oilers and then Whit said, no, you can't, you're a mush. Stay away from my team. So then I switched my pick to Dallas in seven. ... I'll be heartbroken for either of these teams because Pete DeBoer... has never won a Stanley Cup. ... he's nine and oh in Game sevens in playoff history.

The Dallas Stars did not defeat the Edmonton Oilers. The Oilers won the Western Conference Final 4-1 (not 7 games), then advanced to lose the Stanley Cup Final to the Florida Panthers 4-2.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alex Ovechkin will score, Tom Wilson will break the glass, and Pierre-Luc Dubois will score an empty-netter in Game 5 against the Hurricanes

I think Ovy is gonna get a goal. I think Wilson's gonna put somebody through the glass. I think TROs gonna have two assists. And I think Pierre Luke Deis is gonna get an empty netter. Mm. Fuck Yeah. That's what I think.

The Capitals lost Game 5 and none of these specific statistical events occurred.
Loss
Keith YandleKeith Yandle

The Stanley Cup Final will be the Florida Panthers vs the Dallas Stars

I've said it from the beginning that it, it's gonna be Panther Stars. So I'm sticking with that... I'll still stick with Dallas coming out of the west and Florida coming out of the east and you know, just another, no, no Tax City Stanley Cup finals.

The 2025 Stanley Cup Final was Florida Panthers vs. Edmonton Oilers. Dallas was eliminated by Edmonton in 5 games in the Western Conference Final.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets won't win their series against the Stars because Connor Hellebuyck is terrible on the road.

The Jets aren't gonna win this series 'cause Hellebuyck on the road stinks. He gave up five goals. He's just not good on the road.

The Jets (Winnipeg) lost the series to the Stars 4-2, but not because of Hellebuyck's road play being the sole factor. The Stars won the series legitimately, but the Jets did lose as predicted.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Dallas Stars are going to win the Stanley Cup

The Stars took the first game of the series on the road and it feels like the stars are gonna win the cup. I don't know, maybe that's the stupid thing to say, but it feels like they're really fucking good.

The Dallas Stars lost to the Edmonton Oilers in 5 games in the Western Conference Final. The Florida Panthers won the 2025 Stanley Cup.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

It might be Canada's year to win the Stanley Cup

I'm starting to think it might be the Leafs year. It might be Canada this year because we also had the Oilers win Tonight Game One against the Knights. And we have, so the Oilers are up one. Oh, the leaves are up one. Oh. And the Jets are still there.

In 2024, the Florida Panthers (an American team) won the Stanley Cup, defeating the Oilers in the finals.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Washington Capitals can physically beat up the Carolina Hurricanes in the second round

I think Washington can really kind of beat them up... I don't know if physically the, the Canes can play with Washington... Carolina fans are kind of all always all over biz... I don't even think if Carolina gets by Washington, like they can win the cup.

The Hurricanes actually beat the Islanders in the first round (not the Caps who were swept by the Rangers), so the premise of the matchup was incorrect for that specific year's bracket.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals are going to 'skull fuck' Paul Bissonnette and the Maple Leafs in the Eastern Conference Finals

Paul Bissonnette, you better hope that you get your ass kicked in the second round because I wouldn't like nothing better than the skull fuck you in the Eastern Conference finals. And I will, I will skull fuck you. Tom Wilson will skull fuck you.

The Capitals were swept by the Rangers in the first round of the 2024 playoffs, making this impossible.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

This might finally be the Capitals' year to win it all

I'm pumped to watch the [Capitals] playoffs. I do think that this might be our year. Yeah. And the issue is we don't really have a goaltender. We've got two goaltenders and neither one, you have to pick which one is gonna get hot at the right time.

The Capitals were eliminated by the Hurricanes 4-1 in the second round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Colorado Avalanche will win the Stanley Cup

I've made my future bet because Whitney told me that he thought maybe the abs I took AVS plus seven 50. I've also told PFT not that he cares that I would cash out if they played the caps in the finals. 'cause I, I would rather you win.

The Avalanche lost to Dallas in 7 games in the first round. The Florida Panthers won the 2025 Stanley Cup.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Alex Ovechkin might actually be 46 years old due to age technicalities with Russian players

The most amazing thing about the Ovy Gold chase is... He could be like 46 years old. Like you never know with Russians. So the fact that he's like, could be a little older is even crazier.

There is no proof Ovechkin's birth certificate is falsified; it remains a conspiracy theory.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Colorado Avalanche will beat the Toronto Maple Leafs in the Stanley Cup Final

Stanley Cup finals prediction teams and winner: Colorado. Toronto. Colorado beats him. It'd be an awesome series. Yeah. And, and that's if only I'm saying that is if Florida and Tampa play in the first round.

The Cup Final was Florida Panthers vs. Edmonton Oilers. Colorado lost to Dallas in 7 games in the first round, and Toronto lost to Florida in 7 games in the second round.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Colorado is the best team in the West and will return to the Cup Finals

Colorado to me is, they're the best team in the West. And if they play Dallas, which I think they will in the first round, one of those kind of unfair, like either team could win the cup and somebody losing first round.

Colorado was eliminated by Dallas in the first round in 7 games. They did not make it to the Cup Finals.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

David Pastrnak should be a top five MVP candidate for carrying a talentless Bruins roster

The coolest story of the Bruin season is Pastrnak. He has a hundred points. The next guy has 55 points. That's crazy. It's actually one of the, he should be like probably top five in MVP for what he's done because he has nobody.

Pastrnak finished 7th in Hart Trophy voting in 2025, just outside the top five.
Loss
Brady TkachukBrady Tkachuk

The Four Nations Face-Off final was equivalent to an All-Star exhibition game for Team USA

That term meant a lot... [Big Cat: You agree right, that was just the All-Star break?] I don't know if I answer that... Give's a shit about that. That's exhibition.

OpinionHockeyMediumSarcastic
The tournament was a high-stakes best-on-best event, making the 'exhibition' label objectively downplaying the result.
Loss
Brady TkachukBrady Tkachuk

The Ottawa Senators are a tough team to handle in a seven-game series and can do damage in the playoffs

I'm very confident in our team. I think just, we're a tough team to handle for seven game series, so we just gotta get there. But no, I think, no, all stars are kind of aligning for this year and just find a way to get in and I think we can do some damage.

The Senators' 2024-25 playoff performance or lack thereof is known in the 2025 context.
Loss
Brady TkachukBrady Tkachuk

Winning a Stanley Cup in Canada would make me 'Captain Canada'

I think about it all the time... [PFT: It'd be Captain Canada at that point.] Yeah. It's made me think about it too much. But I feel like I have my whole day planned when we win.

The Senators did not win the Cup in the 2024-25 season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alex Ovechkin will break the NHL goal record this season against the Penguins on April 17th

I think he's gonna do it this year. I think he's gonna do it against the [Penguins] at the end of the season... having him break it right in Sidney Crosby's face would be incredible. It's the last game of the regular season at Pittsburgh.

Ovechkin broke the NHL goal record on April 6, 2025, against the New York Islanders at UBS Arena, not against the Penguins on April 17th as predicted. He scored goal #895 to pass Gretzky's record of 894.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Washington Capitals will win the Stanley Cup this year

The caps are... legitimately a good team. They've got a bunch of great players... I think it is the caps year. I believe they have the best record in hockey.

The Capitals were eliminated by the Hurricanes 4-1 in the second round. The Florida Panthers won the 2025 Stanley Cup.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Final will go to overtime

I think it's going overtime, which I didn't think it ever happened. Somebody told me it did. It might've been in the twenties or thirties for all I know. But game seven overtime for the Stanley Cup. I feel like this season's been so crazy that it might happen tonight.

The game ended 2-1 in regulation, so it did not go to overtime.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Oilers will win Game 3 of the Stanley Cup Finals at home

I feel like they are, the Oilers are going to win game three at home though. They need the tits. They need the tits.

The Oilers lost Game 3 to the Panthers 4-3.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I'm rooting for the Edmonton Oilers and Canada to win the Stanley Cup

I think I'm rooting for Canada. Sorry Jake. Sorry about your [Florida Panthers]. Me versus the world. I am as well. Yeah. I just, Canada, you're just so nice. Just cares so much.

The Oilers lost to the Panthers in 7 games.
Loss
MemesMemes

I want the Rangers to win Game 6 and then lose Game 7 in historic, embarrassing fashion

I would like the Rangers to win game six. And then lose in historic fashion [in game 7].

The Rangers lost Game 6 to the Panthers and were eliminated; the historic Game 7 loss Memes wanted never happened.
Loss
PK SubbanPK Subban

The Rangers will beat the Panthers in the Eastern Conference Finals

I'm gonna pick the Rangers... I think that the winner could be coming out of the east this year... if the Rangers can play their game, move pucks, break out clean attack... they will have a ton of success. And I hope they do. I 93, 30 years, I wanna see it happen.

The Florida Panthers defeated the New York Rangers 4-2 to advance to the Stanley Cup Finals.
Loss
HankHank

The NHL is rigging the playoffs for a Panthers-Rangers Eastern Conference Final

I something's fishy with the NHL and and this Panthers team... They didn't suspend [Bennett], which is crazy... I don't understand why... The NHL is trying to rig a Panthers, Rangers Eastern Conference Finals. They much rather have that than Bruins-Rangers.

While the Panthers and Rangers did meet in the ECF, there is no evidence the league rigged it.
Loss
MemesMemes

There is a 0% chance the Rangers win the Stanley Cup

[Big Cat: What are you gonna do if the Rangers win the cup?] They're not gonna win the cup. [Big Cat: How could you say a team that's up three one in the second round has a 0% chance to win the cup?] Who cares? [Islanders] won four in a row.

While the Rangers didn't win the Cup, saying a team in the second round had a 0% chance is hyperbole. They reached the ECF.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Canucks are a team of destiny

Are the Canucks a team of destiny? ... The way Biz described them last week was like, no one expected them to be here. They won a very tough division. and everyone's like, nice story, but they're not gonna win it all. I think they might be team of destiny.

The Canucks lost in the second round to the Edmonton Oilers.
Loss
Keith YandleKeith Yandle

The Oilers aren't good enough to win the West because they lack the depth and defense of other top contenders

I don't think it's [the Oilers'] year... I just think those other teams are a little bit more deep, better goal tending, better defensively... I think the west is too stacked and at the end of the day, I think the east is gonna win it this year.

The Oilers actually did win the West, defeating the Stars in the Western Conference Finals, though they ultimately lost the Cup to the Panthers.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals are actually leading the Rangers 2-0 based on my advanced analytics

Using the proprietary algorithm that we set forward after game one, I have the Capitals actually winning this game, three goals to two. So the Caps take a commanding two-nil series lead on the road. And also during the game, it was pretty obvious that the real score to the game was three for the Caps, three for the Rangers, one for the referees because the refs just absolutely gave that game to the Rangers.

The Capitals literally lost the game and were trailing 2-0 in the series at this point. They eventually got swept.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals technically won Game 1 against the Rangers if you ignore three specific minutes of play

If you take out like three minutes in the second period, we actually tied this game. One. One. ... If you take out that 10 seconds and the two and a half minutes in the second period, the caps actually won. This game won nothing... and it turns out that we technically kind of actually won that game.

Hot TakeHockeyScorchingSarcastic
The Capitals literally lost the game 4-1 and were swept in the series.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Dallas Stars are the best team in the NHL and a strong Stanley Cup future bet

If anyone else is gonna get it done, I think Dallas is okay. If you want to make a future bet, Dallas... Dallas is the best team in the league.

The Dallas Stars reached the Western Conference Finals but were eliminated by the Edmonton Oilers, so they did not win the Cup or finish as the definitively 'best' team.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Penguins faked the Jaromir Jagr bobblehead truck hijacking because they forgot to order them.

I've got a car filled with Jaromir Jagr bobbleheads that I'm trying to get rid of... I don't think the bobbleheads existed. I think maybe I, I think that maybe there were no bobbleheads and the Penguins were like, 'fuck it's bobblehead night, we forgot to order these things.' It's Jussie Smollett head night. They're like, 'well we don't have—oh yeah, the cops, we called the cops, they're looking into it right now.'

Hot TakeHockeyScorchingSarcastic
The bobbleheads were indeed stolen in a legitimate hijacking of a cargo truck and were later recovered by the authorities, proving the theft was real and the bobbleheads existed.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I would bet I could score 20 goals in a season if I played on a power play with Connor Bedard

If they put [me] net front on a power play for even a full season, I bet you he'd put 15 off [my] ass and in the net... I'm pretty sure [I] can get 20 playing with Connor Bedard.

PredictionHockeyHotSarcastic
While purely theoretical, the likelihood of a media personality scoring 20 NHL goals is near zero, though the 'off the ass' qualifier adds a layer of satirical possibility.
Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Maple Leafs will beat the Bruins in the first round and win the Stanley Cup

I am hoping that they draw Boston as a first round matchup... I feel if the Leafs end up matching up with Boston the first round. I think they beat 'em and then they go on to March to win the Stanley Cup.

The Maple Leafs did play the Bruins in the first round of the 2024 playoffs and lost in 7 games. They did not win the Cup.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Buffalo Sabres are ending their 13-year playoff drought and I'm officially on the bandwagon.

I'm on the Buffalo Sabres bandwagon. I'd love to see them get in the playoffs this year. They actually have the longest playoff drought streak in pro sports right now... I think the [Sabres] might get in this year.

The Sabres finished 39-37-6 and missed the playoffs again in the 2023-24 season.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Edmonton Oilers will win the Stanley Cup

I picked the Edmonton Oilers [to win the cup]. The way the season starts, it's obviously not ideal... I pick the Edmonton Oilers.

The Oilers lost the Stanley Cup Final in 7 games to the Florida Panthers.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Colorado Avalanche will win the Stanley Cup

I've got the B's avalanche. I'll go with you on the Avalanche Hank. I've got back to back. [Vegas] I've got the avalanche.

The Florida Panthers eventually won the Stanley Cup. The Avalanche were eliminated in the second round.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Florida Panthers will be unbeatable if Sergei Bobrovsky continues his current level of play.

If Bobrovsky's playing like this... he's 11 and two in the playoffs with this insane save percentage and goals against and he's in one of those zones. If he continues to play like this, I don't know if they can be beat. I don't think they can be beat.

Bobrovsky did not maintain that elite level in the Finals (save percentage dropped significantly), and the Panthers lost the series 4-1.
Loss
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Florida Panthers will win the Stanley Cup.

I picked Florida... now I'm at the point of like, alright, something special is going on here and the goal tending [and] what [Matthew] Tkachuk's doing. It's just leading me to think they'll somehow get it done.

The Vegas Golden Knights won the Stanley Cup, defeating the Panthers 4-1.
Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The Black Hawks should sign Ryan Reaves to protect Connor Bedard

If the team's not that great, he's gonna get to play a little bit. If anyone goes, if anyone breathes on him, [Ryan Reaves] goes up and just... I would sign the two toughest guys... Just put a goon line on the fourth line. And nobody's gonna go near him.

The Blackhawks did not sign Reaves (who went to the Leafs), but they did bring in veterans like Nick Foligno for leadership and toughness.
Loss
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl are the best duo since Michael Jordan and Scottie Pippen

I say he's Pippen and Jordan, I say the best duo since Pippen and Jordan. Wow. They're gonna, I think they're gonna win win a championship.

While elite, the duo had not won a Cup at this point and were eliminated shortly after this take. They did reach the Finals in 2024.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers