Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Mr. PortnoyMr. Portnoy

Benchining a player for being too fat isn't discrimination if they were already heavy when they signed

They accepted [Pablo Sandoval] as being a loud ass when they signed him. He was heavy. So they didn't discriminate in the beginning. And so they will accept him the way he was, but it turned out that he couldn't hit his weight.

This is a subjective interpretation of labor law and discrimination in professional sports.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm an underrated emailer because I'm more persuasive when people don't have to look at my face

I'm an underrated emailer. What can I say? I'm a lot more persuasive when people don't have to look at my face.

This is a subjective self-assessment of his own communication style.
Void
Jim TresselJim Tressel

The punt is the most important play in football

No, I've said it's [the punt] the most important play. All right, the most important play.

This is a subjective coaching philosophy, though analytics-heavy modern fans would strongly disagree.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 200% deposit bonus on BetDSI has to be a typo

We're going to give you a free $10 just for registering and a 200% bonus. That's got to be a typo, but it says it several times. So it's a 200% bonus with your first deposit.

The bonus was a real promotion at the time, not a typo, though he's using the 'typo' line to sell the value.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cubs will win a World Series before the Knicks win an NBA championship

Of course the Cubs are going to win one before the Knicks. No, I'm not saying it's this year, but here's the answer to your question straight up. As long as James Dolan is the owner of the Knicks, the Knicks aren't winning shit.

Correct. The Cubs won the World Series in November 2016. The Knicks have still not won a championship.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Knicks will never win as long as James Dolan is the owner

As long as James Dolan is the owner of the Knicks, the Knicks aren't winning shit. And you know that. I know that. Spike Lee knows that.

Dolan remains the owner as of 2024, and the Knicks have not won a championship.
Void
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Joe Flacco is elite because he has a Super Bowl ring

Is Joe Flacco elite? Duh. Obviously. He won a Super Bowl. Hello.

Whether Flacco is 'elite' is the ultimate subjective sports debate of the era.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Giants will beat the Patriots in the Super Bowl again this year

We also correctly predicted, I think, that they're [the Giants] going to beat the Patriots in the Super Bowl again this year. Oh. So pat ourselves on the back for that. And if it doesn't happen, we'll just delete it.

PredictionFootballHotSarcastic
Incorrect. The Patriots won Super Bowl LI against the Falcons; the Giants lost in the Wild Card round to the Packers.
Win
Justin PughJustin Pugh

Eli Manning is a prankster who likes to crop dust and fart on teammates

Eli is the kind of guy, like, he's definitely smart, but, like, likes the pranky, slapsticky type stuff. And, like, it'll just – he'll be sitting down in a meeting or something talking to someone, and he'll kind of crop dust you or just, like, drive by, fart you, and then just walk away. He's a big fart guy, yeah.

This is a firsthand account from a teammate.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I will issue a cease and desist to anyone else who tries to do airport reviews

Oh, we're called the Flyboys. I can't wait until someone actually does the airport reviews and we're like, cease and desist. We've been squatting on that idea for five years. We're patent trolls for podcast ideas.

Hot TakeMediaMediumSarcastic
They never actually patent-trolled anyone over airport reviews, as it's a comedic bit.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Grayson Allen should seek treatment for his tripping addiction

He's addicted to tripping. He's got a problem. He should go to rehab. Go to rehab for tripping. Seek treatment.

Grayson Allen continued to have multiple tripping/flagrant foul incidents throughout his career in both college and the NBA.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Grayson Allen is everything I need in college basketball right now

Grayson Allen is everything I need in college basketball. And I think most Duke fans, the rational Duke fans, we have a mutual respect. I hate their guts. But they're like, you know what? [We] need [each other] to exist.

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Coach K uses 'dizzy spells' and gray hair as deflection tactics when Duke is struggling

Look out for Coach K to maybe take a little heat off Grayson Allen, have a little dizzy spell sometime soon... Or he could grow the gray hair out a little bit and be like, you boys are giving me gray hairs. And then once they start playing well again, just dye it totally jet black again.

This is a satirical theory about Coach K's behavior patterns that cannot be definitively proven.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Bet the Under on the first three NBA games on Christmas Day

So everyone remember, Christmas Day, my theory, the Unders in the NBA, if you bet the first three Unders, I think you've won every year in the last decade... The teams are going to take a little too long, eat a little food. It's only for the first three games, though.

On Dec 25, 2016, the first three games were BOS-NYK (119-114, Over), GSW-CLE (108-109, Under), and CHI-SAS (100-119, Under/Over depending on line, but usually 2-1 Over). The theory did not go 3-0.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Any movie made before 1990 sucks

Any movie that's made before 1990 can just piss right off because I don't care about it... It's movies with subtitles and movies that are either black [and white].

This is a purely subjective aesthetic opinion delivered as a parody of modern attention spans.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Savage is a one-week wonder

I think Tom Savage is a one-week wonder.

Tom Savage started the next few games for the Texans but was eventually replaced and never became a consistent NFL starter, proving he was indeed a temporary solution.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Vikings' trade for Sam Bradford was a dumb move

I always told you guys that Sam Bradford trade was a fucking dumb move. The Titans and the Lions. Let's check the tape on that one. Yeah, we'll check the tape maybe after New Year's.

The Vikings traded a 2017 1st rounder and a 4th rounder for Bradford. They missed the playoffs in 2016 and Bradford played only 1.5 seasons for them. Most analysts consider it a panic trade that failed.
Void
Jimmy VeseyJimmy Vesey

NBA superteams and a lack of parity make the league boring

There's not a lot of parity in the league. It's super teams. Why even watch? If you have one unbelievable player, then it's pretty much a guaranteed win.

This is a subjective assessment of the league's competitive balance compared to the NHL.
Void
BS
Brady Skjei

Henrik Lundqvist has flawless, dreamy hair

Mostly his hair... When [Lundqvist] is playing, he kind of either goes with the cap on or the cap off, and when the cap's off, it's... It's dreamy. Yeah, it's flawless.

Win
Ric FlairRic Flair

Steve Smith wouldn't even dare to get in a wrestling ring

Steve Smith wouldn't even get in the ring... But he wouldn't. We can put that challenge out right now to him.

Steve Smith never entered a professional wrestling ring for a match, though he is known for his toughness.
Void
Ric FlairRic Flair

Video games and social media have killed the camaraderie and road life of modern wrestlers

The guys nowadays... pretty much stayed to themselves. A lot of video games, a lot of stuff like that. Social media is tough. The guys don't go out like they used to. It's just different times... it's a different time. And the scrutiny of social media... we all have fun but it's in a place where we're safe from scrutiny.

Void
Ric FlairRic Flair

I've never been with a woman in the wrestling business

I've never been with a wrestling girl. Never, no... and then all of a sudden they want a favor, and I don't like when it holds it back... Don't crap where you eat.

This is a personal claim that contradicts many industry rumors over decades, but it remains his stated position.
Push
Ric FlairRic Flair

Wrestling is definitively real

Is wrestling real? Yes. Great answer. Most definitely. And anybody that doesn't think it is should come down for a workout one day.

While the outcomes are predetermined (scripted), the physical impact and athleticism are real. Flair is using the traditional wrestler defense here.
Void
Ric FlairRic Flair

WWE's production values are superior to the NBA and NFL

WWE's production values are [so good]. Their stuff is better than NBA, NFL, Namath. Their stuff is so good and so far advanced.

This is a subjective opinion, but WWE is industry-renowned for its live event production and video packages.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Michael Floyd should get off for his DUI because sleepwalking isn't a crime

It's a bad visual, but I guess it's better that he was asleep behind the wheel than if he was fully conscious and was thinking to himself, I'm driving drunk... He was asleep, so he couldn't have been thinking, I shouldn't be doing this. So technically, it's not really a crime... he should get off for this one.

Being asleep while intoxicated behind the wheel is a crime and Michael Floyd was convicted.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Every crime headline should include the sports teams the criminal roots for

Every time that there's a crime in the paper, if the detectives are able to figure out what teams they supported, they should include that in the headline. So like Pittsburgh Penguins fan hits Washington Wizards fan in a drunk driving accident.

This is a satirical rule suggestion for newspapers.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James has an irrational fear of walking into new rooms

Do you know LeBron doesn't like to walk into new rooms? That's a fear of his, walking into rooms that he's never been in before... LeBron has an irrational fear of new rooms.

Big Cat admits he made this up on the spot as a joke.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Star players only sit out bowl games when the bowl has poor leadership

If those two clowns of bowls [the Citrus Bowl and the Sun Bowl] had actual leadership running the show, I don't think that the star players would be sitting out.

The outcome is subjective, but the specific claim is satirical and part of a bit about their own bowl game.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Christian McCaffrey lacks the genetic benefits and pedigree of Leonard Fournette

When you look at Christian McCaffrey, this is a guy that's had to scrap and work and motor and study and think his way to everything that he is today. And then you look at Leonard Fournette, and he's got all the great genetics in the world, whereas a guy like Christian McCaffrey doesn't have that benefit, doesn't have the pedigree.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Factually, McCaffrey has elite NFL pedigree. The take is satirizing how white and black athletes are scouted differently.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Herbstreit's take on players sitting out bowl games is invalid because he wasn't an NFL prospect

[Kirk Herbstreit] forgot to mention the fact that he only started one season at Ohio State and he wasn't good enough to play in the NFL, so that wasn't even an option for him.

Herbstreit did only start one season and did not play in the NFL, making Big Cat's critique of his perspective factually grounded.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I have no problem with players sitting out bowl games because the system is corrupt

I have no problem with any of these guys sitting out any of the bowls... I like players taking care of themselves when the system is corrupt.

This is an inherently subjective opinion about player autonomy and the collegiate system.
Void
Amy TraskAmy Trask

The NFL Commissioner is perhaps more powerful than the President of the United States

Al [Davis] believed the NFL was very, very, very powerful. He believed, you know, at one point he said to me... the commissioner is powerful and something to the effect of, you know, perhaps more powerful than the president of the United States.

This is a subjective comparison of power between two very different institutions.
Win
Amy TraskAmy Trask

I would never work for another NFL team because being a Raider is not fungible

I've been approached a number of times... since leaving the Raiders. I don't [have interest] for two primary reasons. I was a Raider. I spent almost 30 years as a Raider. And to me, that's not fungible... I don't know that I could ever wear the colors of another team.

To date, Amy Trask has not taken another executive role with an NFL team since leaving the Raiders in 2013.
Win
Amy TraskAmy Trask

There is a substantial chance the Raiders move to Las Vegas

I certainly think there's a substantial chance that they do, but the end of that story is not yet written... the team seems very, very committed to leaving Oakland.

The Raiders officially moved to Las Vegas in 2020 after the NFL owners approved it in 2017.
Win
Amy TraskAmy Trask

The Raiders are officially 'back' this year

The Raiders are headed for the playoffs. They've clinched a spot, and now it remains to be seen what they do with that opportunity... Of course they're back this year. They're back. Raiders are back.

The 2016 Raiders finished 12-4 and made the playoffs, though they lost in the Wild Card round.
Win
Amy TraskAmy Trask

It is yet to be proven if Derek Carr can win in cold weather

We saw that the team had some problems in Kansas City. Some people want to attribute that to the pinky. I don't necessarily agree that we should be pointing to a pinky... We'll see because the team could have to travel to New England. We don't yet know if that will be the case.

Derek Carr's career record in games below 40 degrees became a persistent negative stat (0-5 through 2019, 2-10 eventually), proving her skepticism reasonable.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

It is an ethics violation for NBA media to vote on the All-Star Game

If you're going to have journalists that cover the NBA determining what's going on in the NBA and who's good or not... That's just a major ethics violation. Conflict of interest. Stay in your lane.

This is a satirical take on journalistic integrity in sports media.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams need to hire John Gruden because a new stadium requires a 'splash' hire

The Los Angeles Rams are moving toward a meeting with ESPN analyst John Gruden... that's really nice because you need a splash, and nothing says a splash like a guy who hasn't been coaching for about 15 years... they need a coach to bring in the new stadium.

OpinionFootballMediumSarcastic
The Rams did not hire Gruden; they hired Sean McVay in January 2017.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Rams should consider rehiring Jeff Fisher for consistency

I think what you need in L.A., and this might go contrary to popular opinion, you need somebody with a steady hand, somebody that's done this type of thing before, someone that's saved the course, consistency, a Jeff Fisher type, for example. So maybe we can get that rumor going, that the Rams are... They're willing to take Jeff back.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The Rams never rehired Fisher and immediately became Super Bowl contenders with McVay.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL is to blame for security guards masturbating because they put hot cheerleaders on the sidelines

Why do they put the cheerleaders at NFL games if we're not allowed to masturbate to them in the stadium?... It is the NFL's fault because they kind of asked for it. You don't put hot women on the sidelines and expect us not to masturbate. A bunch of alpha males just walking around.

This is a satirical moral claim rather than a verifiable fact.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Donald Trump is the Rosa Parks of white presidents

Trump, he'll make it better. White guys. Finally a white guy as a president. He's basically the Rosa Parks of white presidents. He's healing our nation.

Satirical comparison that is inherently non-factual.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Matt Moore is the truth

I think Matt Moore is the truth. Did you see him? He was having so much fun out there.

Moore played well in relief of Tannehill in 2016 but remained a career backup.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I have completely sold myself on Matt Barkley

Since we're in the trust tree, I have completely sold myself on Matt Barkley.

Barkley's run as a starter for the Bears ended shortly after this with a slew of interceptions, and he never became a franchise guy.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL coach, beat reporter, and super fan trades should be more common

I love any non-athlete trade, and there needs to be more of them. ... I think it should be expanded to beat reporters. ... I want to see super fans getting traded.

Coach trades are rare but happen (Sean Payton was eventually traded years later); fan/reporter trades are satirical.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Numbers and analytics are ruining sports

Numbers ruin sports. You made us all robots. Sports was great when it was just men grunting at each other, and there was no number for how much pain you're playing through.

This is a subjective value judgment on the entertainment of sports.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jeff Fisher will become a VP of Football Operations for the Chargers

I think we called it he's going to be vice president of football operations somewhere. ... For maybe when the Chargers move. ... The Chargers fire McCoy.

Jeff Fisher never held a front office or coaching role with the Chargers.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Neil deGrasse Tyson's only job is to tweet nerd shit

By the way, you know what Neil's job is? Just to tweet nerd shit. To just look at stars, right? His job is to stand inside a planetarium with a laser pointer.

While Tyson is a public communicator of science, he is an astrophysicist and director of the Hayden Planetarium, not just a Twitter personality.
Void
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

Retiring NFL players lose their identity and are quickly forgotten

Very few people are going to remember that you played and even less are going to care once you retire. ... your identity better not come from playing football because your identity will be taken eventually or your career will be over eventually.

This is a subjective observation about the nature of fame and identity in professional sports.
Push
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

Kyle Shanahan will get a head coaching job and Mike Shanahan will be his consultant

I think what will happen is his son, Kyle Shanahan, will get a coaching job somewhere, and he'll go with Kyle to be a consultant.

Kyle Shanahan became the 49ers head coach in 2017. Mike Shanahan did not officially join the staff as a consultant, though Kyle has cited his father as an informal advisor.
Void
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

NFL owners care more about profit than winning

There's a lot of owners that don't really, they say they want to win, but they don't want to do what it takes to win. They want to be profitable. They're in the entertainment business. They think it's cool to own a team.

This is a subjective assessment of owners' priorities.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers