Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
PFT Commenter

PFT Commenter

Host
2015 — Present
1,592W·2,310L·383P·205 open
@pftcommenter
footballbasketballlife4,285 scored

All Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bengals should bench Jake Browning for Mike White

I don't really know what to make of the Bengals... I say hit the Mike White button. Right? That's the button that... hit the Mike White button.

This is a personnel recommendation that may or may not be followed.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Broncos will win 8 or 9 more games this season and are still very much alive

I still think that if you just look at their schedule, they have probably eight to nine more games that they should win and they might be able to steal one or two. So, they're still very much alive.

PFT predicted the Broncos (around 1-2 at the time) would win 8 or 9 more games and still be very much alive for the playoffs. The Broncos finished 14-3, winning far more than 8-9 additional games, earning the AFC's #1 seed.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Titans head coach Brian Callahan is destined to be another forgettable name in the franchise's coaching history

The Titans, they're starting the conversation regarding their head coach because he falls firmly into the Ken Whisenhunt, Mike Malarkey pantheon of kind of forgettable guys that have coached the Titans over the years.

Brian Callahan was fired after just one season in 2025, confirming PFT's suspicion that he wouldn't last or leave a mark.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I don't think Carson Wentz is fixable as a quarterback due to his extensive scar tissue

I'm not ready to say that about Cars. I don't, I don't think that Carson Wentz is fixable. Yeah. I think he's got too, too much scar tissue.

Wentz's tenure with the Vikings was short-lived and he did not reclaim his Pro Bowl form, supporting PFT's claim.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Marcus Mariota is the best backup quarterback in the NFL

I think [Marcus Mariota] is probably the best backup quarterback in the NFL. He was great last year. He was awesome against the Cowboys. And this is actually... for all the talk about Jayden [Daniels] possibly being injury prone, this is the first start that he will miss.

Whether Mariota is the 'best' backup is subjective, but he played well in relief during the 2025 season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Spencer Rattler will get his first NFL win as a starter this week against the Seahawks

I think, I think they're gonna win. [Spencer Rattler] is gonna get his first win this week. First win as a starter.

Rattler and the Saints did not beat the Seahawks in this matchup.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bears-Cowboys matchup is a 'Gateway Game' specifically for how people view Caleb Williams as a quarterback

I think it might be a gateway game for your feelings about Caleb Williams as a quarterback... Because if they go 0-3, it's gonna be just full, like Caleb's gotta look good.

Williams had a standout performance in this game, which cemented his status as a franchise piece despite early team struggles.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Derwin James should be in the conversation for NFL Defensive Player of the Year

I walked away from that game thinking that we should be talking more about Derwin James. I love watching him play... I feel like he should be in that conversation for defensive player of the year.

Derwin James finished in the top 5 for DPOY voting in 2025, validating PFT's take.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders should bench Jaden Daniels this weekend to protect him from the FedEx Field turf

I act, I don't wanna see Jayden this weekend. Oh, I, I think we should sit him. Okay. Because I, I'm still dealing with my PTSD Post-Traumatic Snyder disorder. When Robert Griffin had a sprained knee, came back too soon, everything was bad after that... Every quarterback has gotten injured on that turf.

Subjective strategy for injury management, though Daniels' health throughout the 2025 season will be the indicator.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bengals should only run the ball with their current backup quarterback room

They [the Bengals] should not try to pass. They should just try to run the football. That's because those four [backup] names—Jake Browning, Sean Clifford, Brett Rypien, and Mike White—that's literally a Mount Rushmore of 'hand the ball off.' Do not try to pass the ball.

The Bengals did rely more on the run after Burrow's injury, but obviously continued to pass. Browning actually performed surprisingly well as a passer later in the 2024 season.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

This will be the final season of the Tush Push as the NFL prepares to ban it

And now we're getting everything that we need, all the ammunition necessary for at the end of the season for it to be banned. It's gonna be, this is the last season of the push. It's banned.

The NFL Competition Committee's offseason ruling in 2026 will determine if this prediction holds.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brandon Aubrey could be a first or second-round draft pick if re-drafted

If he entered the NFL draft next year, if somehow he got reclassified back and he wasn't in the NFL and was eligible to be drafted, there would be a team that would take him in the second round. I'm saying he is so much better than any other kicker in the NFL.

Kickers almost never go in the early rounds, making this highly debatable but Aubrey's talent is real.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers are better when they have a shitty quarterback

I think the Steelers are better when they have a shitty quarterback... I think that they're better when their defense knows that they have to be like impregnable.

It's a psychological theory that can't be objectively proven but fits Mike Tomlin's historic patterns.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons signed Kirk Cousins as a smoke screen to draft Michael Penix Jr.

I think that the Falcons when they, they probably signed Kirk Cousins and said, Hey, this is a smoke screen. No one's gonna think that we're gonna draft Michael Penix. So a fall to us. So let's just pay this guy a hundred million dollars. So we get our guy and it worked.

It's an interpretation of the Falcons' front office strategy which cannot be definitively proven true or false.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders will win 10 games but are not good enough to beat elite teams

I think we're like an above average team right now. I think we're like a 10 win team. But that's like our, our, we're not gonna beat the good teams, the very good teams. It was just, it was ugly.

The Commanders went 5-12 in 2025, not 10 wins. Jayden Daniels was injured and played only 7 games. The team severely underperformed from PFT's 10-win projection.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I wouldn't trade Jaden Daniels for any other player in the NFL right now

I wouldn't trade, I don't think that there's a player in the NFL that I would trade for Jaden [Daniels] right now. He had a bad game. I think that's fair. I but he, he wasn't the main problem tonight.

The take is subjective as it's a personal preference on trade value, though most would value Mahomes or Allen higher.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jaxson Dart will get his first start for the Giants against the Chargers

My prediction was that Dart gets in against the Chargers. That would be his first start I think. I don't know if it's gonna be a clean benching for Russell Wilson. I think they might do the Dart packages and they might like slowly incorporate Dart into the games.

Jaxson Dart's first NFL start was indeed against the Chargers in Week 4 (September 28), exactly as PFT predicted. The Giants won that game.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Buffalo Bills are going to go undefeated and win the Super Bowl

Bills have the easiest schedule now. Undefeated. Would it, wouldn't it be funny if the bills went undefeated? It's week one. I'm not gonna overreact, but I think that the Buffalo Bills are gonna go undefeated. Win the Super Bowl.

The Bills would need to go 20-0 to make this true.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Indianapolis Colts are going to make the playoffs this year

I think the Colts are gonna make the playoffs this year. I'll tell you that much. I, I, looking at their schedule... they don't have a hard schedule. And Anthony Richardson looked awesome. I think he's gonna be good enough to win a majority of their games if he stays healthy.

The Colts finished 9-8 and missed the playoffs in the 2024 season.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

John Harbaugh has a problem with second-half collapses and poor game management

This is a John Harbaugh loss. He's got several of them... double digit leads that [blow]. It does feel like he does something like that every year where whether it's like, oh, you forgot that you had a running game or why did you punt there? Or your running back fumbled or your defense didn't play anything resembling your defense from last year.

The Ravens blew a 10-point lead in the 4th quarter against the Bills in Week 1 2025 (in the show's fictional timeline).
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JJ McCarthy is the number one 'gamer' in the NFL

JJ McCarthy, gamer dude. Is he the number one gamer that we got right now? ...I think he's become the number one gamer now in the NFL. It's like, well yeah, as bad as things can look. So he's just gonna figure out a way to win.

JJ McCarthy missed his entire rookie season due to a meniscus injury, so he never actually 'won' games on the field in 2024.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JJ McCarthy is basically a younger version of Tim Tebow

I've got JJ McCarthy on Tebow watch. He feels like early, early stages Tebow. Where it's like things go poorly for him, but guess what? He's gonna figure out a way to win. And he is gonna drive people insane watching because he'll be like, this guy stinks. Oh wait, this guy's actually really good.

Subjective comparison between two players' archetypes.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jackson Dart will take over as the Giants starter after their game against the Chiefs

Jackson [Dart] will be the starter soon. Yeah. I feel like it's gonna be right after that Chiefs game. What was it? Charger at home? Yeah. Yeah. That's what I've got circled. But yeah, if you're taking two days to announce your starter in week two, that means that that guy's not gonna be your starter much longer.

The Giants played the Chiefs in Week 4. Russell Wilson remained the starter through Week 6.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

USF should be ranked in the top 10 after beating two ranked opponents

USF... Are they the only team that's beaten two ranked opponents? I believe so. So they beat Boise State and then they beat Florida. I think they're, I think you can make the case. They should be ranked higher. Top 10.

USF was ranked #14 at the time of the recording.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers can win a playoff game this year

Aaron Rodgers, to his credit... he looked better than any Steelers quarterback that I can remember since Big Ben could move. This is what I was talking about when I said that I think the Steelers can win a playoff game this year.

The Steelers made the playoffs as the 4 seed (10-7, AFC North champs) but lost to the Houston Texans 30-6 in the Wild Card round. They did not win a playoff game.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michael Penix Jr. is the greatest goal-line reacher of all time

Michael Penix Jr. is also the greatest... reacher at the goal line of all time. I mean you had the Indiana one, this one... he reaches at the goal line. He scores touchdowns in improbable ways.

This is an inherently subjective ranking of goal-line reaching ability.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Russell Wilson is officially bad

Russell Wilson looked bad. He looked very, very bad. He is bad. Yeah, he is bad. He both appeared to be bad and I know it to be true and he is also bad. And he looked it.

Subjective evaluation of performance, though widely supported by the game stats.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Matthew Stafford will be 6th all-time in passing yards by the end of the year

Matthew Stafford also reached 60,000 yards. He's now 10th all time in yards... If he has 3,600 yards this year, he's gonna end end the season sixth all time.

Matthew Stafford had 4,707 passing yards in 2025, putting him well above the 3,600 needed to reach 6th all-time. His career total reached 64,516 yards. He likely moved into or near 6th place all-time.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lions' offensive struggles are proof that Ben Johnson was the 'secret sauce' in Detroit

this is good for the Bears... Because the offense didn't look as good without Ben Johnson. Meaning that you guys [Packers] have whatever made that offense look good last year... Ben Johnson as offensive coordinator for the Lions was five and one against the Packers. The Lions without Ben Johnson, Owen won against the Packers.

Evaluating the impact of a coach's departure based on a one-game sample is subjective.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If the Commanders beat the Packers, I am expecting a Super Bowl

If we beat the Packers, anything less than a Super Bowl championship this year will be a, a massive crushing disappointment to me. If we win against the Packers, I'm thinking soupy, soupy.

The Commanders had a disastrous 2025 season regardless of the Week 1 result. They were eliminated in Week 14. No Super Bowl.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am betting heavily on Daniel Jones and the Colts to beat the Broncos next week

I'm gonna hammer Hammer Danny Dimes... Hammer Danny Dimes [against the Broncos].

Daniel Jones and the Colts beat the Broncos 29-28 in Week 2 on a last-second field goal. Jones completed 23 of 34 passes for 316 yards with a passing and rushing TD. PFT's bet on Danny Dimes cashed.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jake Moody should be cut by the 49ers next week

Jake Moody has been a problem for the Niners... 12 of 23 is insane. He's gotta be cut this week... I'd be shocked if he was on the team next week.

Jake Moody was not cut by the 49ers the following week. He remained on the roster and the 49ers went 12-5, making the playoffs as a Wild Card team.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Phillies fan who yelled at the man over a home run ball should be banned for life from Citizens Bank Park

I think she should be banned for rest of Citizens Bank Park... She should be banned from Citizens Bank Park... she almost fought somebody over a home run ball.

This is a subjective moral judgment and opinion on stadium policy.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am officially back in on Kyle Pitts this season

I'm officially back in on Kyle Pitts. Oh no. I'm officially back in. Hear me out... [Kirk Cousins] is a different quarterback than has been throwing the ball to Kyle Pitts over the last two years. He might be smart enough to realize that Kyle Pitts is really theoretically good at football.

Insufficient data on Kyle Pitts' 2025 stats to evaluate. Falcons went 8-9.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers will win a playoff game this year

I think the Steelers are gonna win a playoff game this year. One, I think they're gonna win one playoff game this year.

The Steelers lost in the Wild Card round to the Texans 6-30. They did not win a playoff game.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will beat Hank in an 18-hole match play golf game for $5,000

I am now very excited about beating you [Hank] at golf and taking the thing that you love the most in this whole world away from you.

Personal golf match between PFT and Hank. Cannot verify the outcome of this specific private bet.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

My worst-case scenario for the Commanders is Jayden Daniels suffering a major knee injury

My worst case scenario because it does, I think about this every Sunday. Is Jayden Daniels' knee exploding? Oh, I think I think about it way too much every time he gets hit. I think about it.

Subjective fear/scenario; cannot be 'correct' unless it actually happens.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Charlie Woods cemented himself as the future of golf after his hole-in-one

Charlie Woods is back. He got a hole in one on the third hole at Sawgrass today... Charlie Woods is the future golf. I think he cemented that today.

Charlie Woods is a promising junior golfer but 'cementing' him as the future based on a fictional event is hyperbolic.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michael Jordan needs to be allowed back on the UNC football sidelines with a headset for decision making

I would say maybe Jordan needs to be allowed back on the sidelines headset. Why are you kicking Jordan out of all decision making from the team and then acting surprised when you get the shit kicked out of you by TCU week one?

Hot TakeCFBHotSarcastic
This is part of a satirical simulation; Michael Jordan is not part of UNC football decision making.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alabama is back to being a regular program like it was before Nick Saban

This is going back to Bama. This is what you were before Nick Saban was there. That's what you're gonna be after Nick Saban leaves, unless you find the next Nick Saban.

While Saban's departure is real, Alabama remains a top-tier program in the 2024 reality.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nico Iamaleava should transition to being a wide receiver

Nico, I'm a receiver. Yeah, that's, that's what I'm calling him... I think he's very fast. I think he's got great change of direction. I think he has no idea how to throw like an intermediate pass whatsoever.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
Iamaleava is a highly-touted starting quarterback and unlikely to switch positions.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Putting a 'C' on an NFL player's chest is overrated

Listen, putting a C on somebody's chest is overrated. And that's what Max has always told you.

This is a subjective opinion on the value of team captains.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Luis Suarez's passion for soccer is so high that he's still spitting on staff members in MLS games

I kind of admire Luis Suarez's passion in that he's still so fired up for soccer that he's spitting on an old guy in a Seattle Miami MLS game... that passion's never gone away. He just blacks out. I think that's why he's not retired from soccer.

Subjective interpretation of a player's behavior and motivations.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders will win 11 games despite a tougher schedule

I'm gonna say 11 wins for the Commanders this season, so... I think they're gonna be a better team, but they're gonna only win 11 games this year.

The Commanders had a disastrous 2025 season, starting 3-10 through 13 games. They were eliminated from playoff contention in Week 14, far from 11 wins.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Terry McLaurin's 'hold in' only worked because he didn't miss mental reps and stayed in shape

I like to think that Terry is a consummate pro... they were just giving him all the assignments, the playbook, all that stuff he was doing mental reps. He's gonna be in shape.

Subjective assessment of a player's preparation during a holdout.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Terry McLaurin has already secretly signed a new contract with the Commanders

My report now is that he [Terry McLaurin] did in fact sign on Friday and it's a secret contract and we don't know about it yet, but they're gonna release the details of the secret contract soon.

PredictionFootballMediumSarcastic
Terry McLaurin's contract status is public; there are no secret contracts in the NFL.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A Super Bowl in London is definitely going to happen

Gella [Roger Goodell] started getting like multiple games over in Europe. He had a semi and now he's got a raging boner for having a Super Bowl in England. It's not just a football game... it's going to happen.

The NFL has held discussions about international Super Bowls, but no official game has been scheduled for London as of the 2025 context.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Terry McLaurin will sign his contract extension today

I think [McLaurin] is gonna sign today, I think Friday. I think this is the day it gets done. Terry is fully on board. I really, I think he's gonna sign on Friday and then I think it's full, full steam ahead.

Terry McLaurin signed his extension on August 27, 2025, not on the specific Friday date PFT predicted.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Paige Bueckers will be better than Caitlin Clark in the WNBA

I said when she was a senior or her last year at UConn. She's gonna be better than Caitlin Clark... I think she's a better team player than Caitlin Clark. I think that she's a better winner than Caitlin Clark.

Requires long-term career comparisons in the WNBA.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Paige Bueckers will break all of Caitlin Clark's WNBA rookie records

She's gonna break all of Caitlin Clark's rookie records and I think she's a better team player than Caitlin Clark.

While Paige Bueckers won 2025 WNBA Rookie of the Year with impressive stats (19.2 PPG, 5.4 APG), she did not break all of Caitlin Clark's rookie records. Clark's rookie season records in several categories remained intact.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers