Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Indiana will beat Miami by double digits in the National Championship

I think Indiana, I think they're gonna do it. I too, and I think they're going to win by double digits.

Indiana won 27-21, a 6-point margin - not double digits as predicted. The winner was correct but the margin was not.
Push
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Ohio State, Georgia, Indiana, Notre Dame, and Alabama are the only teams that can win the national title

Ohio State. Georgia. Indiana, Notre Dame. Alabama. ... Alabama beat [Georgia], so how can you say they are not a believer? ... You just wanna get in and then it becomes matchups.

Indiana won the title (correctly included). Miami made the championship game. However, Alabama and Georgia did not advance as far as predicted.
Push
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Texas A&M might have the best portal receiver haul in the country

[Texas] A&M hit on Mario Craver and Cyrus Allen, the two guys at receiver they got outta the portal. That might be the best receiver hall outta the portal so far this year. We may find out that A&M's offense is just really, really good.

Texas A&M's receivers were solid but didn't emerge as the definitive best group in the country as the season progressed.
Push
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Miami is a complete team and a great value at 16-to-1 to win the National Championship

I would put them [Miami] above LSU in Texas. 'Cause it's easier for them to make the playoffs... they fixed the defense. The defense stunk last year... they're a much more complete team.

Miami made the CFP National Championship game (losing 21-27 to Indiana), validating them as a contender. But the 16-to-1 bet didn't pay off.
Push
Brandon WalkerBrandon Walker

Kalen DeBoer is not built for the SEC and will fail at Alabama

For whatever reason the coach doesn't fit Alabama... it takes a different kind of human to win in the SEC... I don't think Kalen DeBoer fits Alabama. Alabama fan base and the Alabama pressure is different and it fucks people up. And it fucked him up last year. I think it's gonna fuck him up again. He's not built for this shit.

Alabama went 11-4 in 2025 under Kalen DeBoer, making the CFP and beating Oklahoma in the first round. However, they were blown out 38-3 by Indiana in the quarterfinals and lost the SEC title game 28-7. DeBoer showed mixed results - competitive but not elite.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Notre Dame running back Jeremiah Love is my Heisman pick at 25-1

Jeremiah Love. That's mine. 25 to 1. The narrative doesn't—you don't have to do a narrative when it's Notre Dame. If he gets enough carries he's electric and it's Notre Dame and sports writers are going to go crazy for Notre Dame.

Jeremiyah Love was indeed a 2025 Heisman finalist, finishing 3rd in voting. He won the Doak Walker Award as the nation's top running back. Big Cat was right that Love would be a Heisman contender, but Love did not win at 25-1 — Fernando Mendoza won it. Still, being a finalist is a strong outcome for this prediction.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nico Iamaleava's move to UCLA cost him 80% of his earning power when accounting for California taxes and cost of living

[Nico Iamaleava] actually ended up losing, I'm going to guess like 80% of his earning power when you take into account the cost of living in LA and the state income tax in California as opposed to Tennessee, which doesn't have any.

While CA taxes and COL are high, the 80% figure is likely hyperbolic, making this partially correct in spirit but likely incorrect as a hard stat.
Push
Brandon WalkerBrandon Walker

Ohio State will beat Texas by two touchdowns in the semifinal if they stay aggressive

If Ryan Day and Chip Kelly don't hold this team back, if they call plays the same way they've been calling plays, I think they win about two touchdowns... I don't know how you stop 'em.

Ohio State defeated Texas 38-34 on January 9, 2025. While they won, it was only by 4 points, not two touchdowns.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Ohio State could either win the national championship or come out completely flat in the playoffs.

I think Ohio State could either win it all or they could come out and just be like a completely dead team. Totally flat against Tennessee.

Ohio State defeated Tennessee but did not win the national championship, falling to Oregon in the semifinals.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Only Oregon, Ohio State, or Georgia can win the national title this year

I do strongly think that if your name's not Oregon, Ohio State or Georgia, you're not gonna win the whole thing.

Ohio State won the national title, which was one of Big Cat's three teams. However, Oregon and Georgia did not win it. The prediction was partially right — one of his three named teams did win, but the other two didn't make the final.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2024 college football season is on pace to be as chaotic as the legendary 2007 season

The chaos and the fact that we don't know who's good in college football right now... It reminds me of that 2007 season... We're on pace for that right now. It's probably not going to last to the same extent that 2007 did, but the upsets are incredible.

The 2024 season remained highly volatile with the 12-team playoff, though 2007 remains the benchmark for pure number-one-seed carnage.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially ranking Georgia as the number one team in the country

Georgia's my number one team. Texas two, Ohio State's three. Tennessee, Penn State, USC, Miami, Alabama, Ole Miss, Missouri, Iowa State... and Northern Illinois.

Texas eventually overtook Georgia in many polls later in the season before they played each other.
Push
Brandon WalkerBrandon Walker

The Florida Gators have a better roster than head coach Billy Napier is capable of coaching

I think Napier is a bad coach. But I think he's built a pretty good roster. I think the roster is better than the coach. I think they can win... seven games.

Florida finished the 2024 regular season 6-6, which is close to but short of the 7 wins predicted, and Napier was retained.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Alabama's offense is going to be insanely explosive under Kalen DeBoer with Jalen Milroe

Kalen DeBoer taking the job, who's had success everywhere he is gone... I think Alabama's offense is gonna be like insanely explosive and something like you saw maybe five years ago when they had that wide receiver room. Jalen Milroe is probably the best deep passer in college football.

Alabama's offense has remained highly explosive, notably during the win over Georgia, though it has seen some inconsistency in SEC play.
Push
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Cam Ward's season at Miami will be 'feast or famine' given his history of high-risk play

Miami has the roster and the schedule for [a playoff run]. Cam Ward... I will tell you from watching Cam Ward through the years, it's a little feast or famine there. So we're gonna find out how he deals with [the environment].

Ward has been a Heisman frontrunner for much of the 2024 season, though the 'feast or famine' nature was visible in several close Miami wins.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Wisconsin Badgers will be a better team this year, regardless of their final record

I think [the Badgers] are gonna be a better team than they were last year. They might not have a better record... because we have a brutal schedule. Alabama non-conference, Penn State, Oregon... USC. So like they could end up seven and five, but I'd be like, I'm excited about the future.

The Badgers remained around .500 but showed flashes against top teams, though injuries to their QB hampered the 'quality' leap Big Cat expected.
Push
Shane GillisShane Gillis

Notre Dame will go 11-1 this season and then get smoked in the playoffs

But you see the schedule, they're probably [going] 11 and one. And then get fucking smoked in the playoffs against somebody.

Notre Dame went 11-1 in the regular season as Shane Gillis predicted. However, they did not get 'smoked' in the playoffs — they won three playoff games before losing to Ohio State 23-34 in the National Championship. The regular season prediction was spot-on, but they performed better in the playoffs than expected.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan will win the National Championship but Washington plus the points is the smart bet

My heart is putting me on Washington, but my testicles are saying Michigan... I'm leaning towards betting Washington in the points. But I think Michigan's gonna win.

Michigan won 34-13, easily covering the 4.5 point spread.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Jim Harbaugh had no knowledge of the Michigan sign-stealing scandal and is innocent

I'm going with the theory that Jim Harbaugh had no knowledge of it and that Michigan is going to get sanctioned and Jim Harbaugh, 'cause he had no knowledge of it, has to recuse himself from Michigan and go coach the Chicago Bears. That is what I'm going with. Jim Harbaugh's innocent. Jim Harbaugh had no knowledge.

While Harbaugh claimed no knowledge, the NCAA eventually suspended him. However, Big Cat's ultimate prediction—Harbaugh leaving for the NFL (and the Chargers, though not the Bears)—did happen.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If oil reaches $95 a barrel, Jimbo Fisher will get bought out of his contract

I'm setting a price target right now. I'm setting a personal price target. If oil reaches $95 a barrel, then I predict that Jimbo Fisher will get bought out of his contract.

Jimbo Fisher was fired on Nov 12, 2023, with a $77M buyout. However, crude oil prices (WTI) were around $77-78 a barrel at the time of his firing, not $95.
Push
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Washington Huskies will win the National Championship

I'm going to give you [a future bet] and I want you to go put whatever you want to put on it. On the Washington Huskies. Michael Penix is legit. I think their schedule is very favorable. They're going to score 40 on everybody. This is the most wide open season we've ever seen in college football.

Washington reached the National Championship game but lost to Michigan.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

There are no superpower teams in college football this year

It feels like this college football season... No one's really that good... There's a lot of really good teams, but no superpower team, which I love.

Michigan went undefeated and won the title, though many games were close, confirming there wasn't a 2019 LSU-level juggernaut until the very end.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Dabo Swinney's refusal to adapt to NIL and the transfer portal is his downfall

He's so resistant to change when college football has so drastically changed in the last five years. It's kind of great to be like, dude, all you had to do was embrace it and realize that everything is changing around you. You gotta change. Like Nick Saban has always changed.

Clemson has continued to struggle to maintain its previous elite status compared to programs that embraced the portal, though they remain competitive.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Colorado will beat Nebraska by 30 points next week

I'm on your side. You're going to win by 30 against Nebraska.

Colorado beat Nebraska 36-14 on Sept 9, 2023. This was a 22-point win, which is dominant but short of the 30-point prediction.
Push
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Iowa will score 31 points per game and win the Big 10 West

I'm on record. They're gonna score 31 points per game and I think they're gonna win the west. I think they are the best team. They're the one I have the fewest questions about.

Iowa won the Big 10 West but averaged only 15.4 points per game, the second-worst in the FBS.
Push
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

College Football Playoff prediction: Georgia, Michigan, Oregon, and Alabama

I'm gonna go Georgia, Michigan. I'm gonna go Oregon. I'm gonna say Oregon wins the Pac-12. First Pac-12 playoff participant since 2016. And then Alabama.

Staples correctly predicted Michigan and Alabama, but Georgia and Oregon failed to make the Playoff.
Push
Billy FootballBilly Football

The 'horns down' gesture is officially back and allowed in the SEC

You can use horns down because according to John McDade, the SEC's coordinator of officials on penalizing for horns down signal in '24... he said that you can use horns down against Texas.

SEC officials later clarified that it still depends on the context of taunting, but the general ban used in the Big 12 was lifted.
Push
Billy FootballBilly Football

Malik Murphy is the real sleeper in the Texas QB battle and has the best arm on the team

In reality in the UT quarterback competition, there was a big dark horse sleeper that no one saw coming in Malik Murphy... I think has the best arm out of any of the quarterbacks on the team. Quinn Ewers did have an amazing day... but this Malik Murphy guy just was throwing bombs out there.

Murphy did start several games for Texas when Ewers was injured and performed well before transferring to Duke.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Kirby Smart is the new standard of college football

Kirby Smart is the new standard. It was actually a great moment where David Pollack told Nick Saban to his face that everyone's trying to catch up to Georgia... Kirby Smart looks like the new Nick Saban. I know, I know. That might sound ridiculous, but it, I mean he just won back to back national titles.

Kirby Smart led Georgia to back-to-back titles and maintained elite status, though Saban remained the gold standard until retirement.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nathanial Vakos will be the number one kicker in the nation next year

The kicker from Ohio [University] just committed to Wisconsin... Nathanial Vakos. I'm ranking him as the number one kicker in the nation going into the next year.

Vakos had a solid career at Wisconsin but wasn't universally ranked as the #1 kicker in the nation.
Push
Kirk HerbstreitKirk Herbstreit

The TCU vs. Georgia National Championship game will be a high-scoring shootout over 60 points

Somebody told me the over-under's like in the sixties. I think this is another game over that. I think it's another game early kind of feel each other and then after that it's gonna be back and forth. You know, I think it's in the high thirties, low forties kind of like the two semi-final games. I'd be surprised if it's not a shootout.

Georgia won 65-7. The total score (72) went over the total of 62.5, but it was the opposite of a shootout—it was one of the most lopsided blowouts in championship history.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Ohio-Wyoming Arizona Bowl is for true football guys because there will be a lot of running and punting

Ohio and Wyoming. I think we're gonna get some, this is gonna be one of those games where it's the true football guys, cuz there's gonna be a lot of running, a lot of punting football guys.

The game ended 30-27 in OT, which actually featured more scoring than the 'punt fest' Big Cat predicted, though it was a physical game.
Push
Will ComptonWill Compton

Nebraska's 2021 team was nine plays away from a perfect 12-0 season

Can you confidently say Nebraska of 2021 was not the greatest three win football team... You can easily say that... nine plays away from a perfect 12 and 0 season.

Statistically true that they lost 9 games by single digits, though 'nine plays away from 12-0' remains a highly subjective interpretation of those results.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Madison University will be ranked in the Top 25 if they are undefeated heading into the Marshall game

They should be wins [Arkansas State/Georgia State]. And then they got Marshall at home. They will be ranked at least 23 if they go into that game... It's pretty crazy the fact that they, this is their first year as a big boy program and they're undefeated.

JMU actually entered the AP Poll at #25 on October 9th (after beating Arkansas State) but lost to Georgia Southern before the Marshall game.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Texas is 'back' because their defense is finally legitimate

I'm counting Texas as back because their defense played better than they've played in, I don't know, 15 years. I can't even remember the last time that defense was 100% legit. It was awesome.

Texas finished 8-5 in 2022, a step forward but hardly 'back' to national championship contention until the following year.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Gene Chizik should be fired as North Carolina's defensive coordinator

Gene Chizik, like what? He, I don't even know. I, you have to fire him. The fact that it happened [giving up 40 in a quarter] and then the next day Jackson state... shut down [FAMU] and like UNC gave up 24 points to them.

Chizik was not fired immediately but did eventually leave the program after the 2023 season due to poor defensive performance.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cincinnati proved they still belong in the top tier of college football despite losing to Arkansas

I actually think that Cincinnati's loss to Arkansas is better for Cincinnati. Like it proved that they still kind of belong... I think they're still very good. I think that they're like a top 20 team.

Cincinnati finished the 2022 season 9-4 and unranked in the final AP Poll, suggesting they didn't quite maintain their 'top tier' status from the previous year.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Pitt is overrated heading into the Backyard Brawl

I'm just going to say Pitt's overrated. I think Pit's overrated.

Pitt won the game 38-31 in a close battle, though they were favorites. They finished the season 9-4, which is respectable, though they weren't elite.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Texas is 'back' as soon as they get one big win in September

My threshold is one big win in September. They're back... If they cover against Alabama, they might be back. Yes, that might be what makes them back right there.

Hot TakeCFBHotSarcastic
Texas lost to Alabama 20-19 but covered the spread. They were declared 'back' by many after that, though they finished 8-5. They truly became 'back' in 2023 by making the Playoff.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The 2022 College Football Playoff field will be Alabama, Ohio State, Georgia, and Clemson

I was talking to people the other day and they were like, what, who do you think is going to be like the top four going into the pre-season next year? I was just off the top of my head, Ohio State, Alabama, Clemson... Georgia, Georgia, they've gotten a lot of transfers and they've gotten some talent.

The 2022-23 CFP consisted of Georgia, TCU, Michigan, and Ohio State. Big Cat correctly identified 2 of the 4 (Georgia and OSU), but Clemson and Alabama both missed.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer will be back on Big Noon Kickoff within a year and win another college title in three years

Everyone should be ready for this urban Meyer sliding back into that desk on the Fox, big noon kickoff. I don't even know, might even be as early as this year if they have a bowl game. Pre-show but that will happen. And in like three years, he'll be linked to some big time job. Probably go take it, win a national title, and this will all be like, oh, remember when urban Meyer coach the Jaguars for 15 games.

Meyer did return to Fox's Big Noon Kickoff in 2022. However, he has not coached another college team or won a title since.
Push
Deion SandersDeion Sanders

Travis Hunter will not be the only five-star recruit to join an HBCU

I liked it as well stated. And I don't think he's [Travis Hunter] going to be by himself. I'm just telling you that he's not going to be alone. I promise you. He is not going to be alone. You're going to hear about that real soon.

While several high-profile recruits did follow Deion to Jackson State (like Kevin Coleman), the movement largely slowed down once Deion moved to Colorado, with Hunter also transferring there.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brian Kelly's tenure at LSU will probably blow up due to the bad culture fit

I'm super excited for Brian Kelly in Baton Rouge because it's such a bad culture fit, obviously. So it's going to probably blow up. Now. He can either win really quickly and he should, because if he doesn't, it's going to get bad and it's going to get bad really fast. And it can be very funny to watch like Brian Kelly pretending to be a southerner.

Kelly won 10 games and the SEC West in his first season (2022), avoiding an immediate 'blow up'.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially done ever thinking that anyone can score on Georgia

I'm officially done ever thinking that anyone can score on Georgia. That first drive by Tennessee... and then they just destroying everyone. There's just no way that you can keep up with that defense.

Georgia's defense was indeed historic, leading them to a National Championship while allowing just 10.2 points per game on the season.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Clemson dynasty is officially dead and Dabo Swinney is a system coach

Clemson is officially—is the dynasty over? Clemson is dead. The dynasty's dead. Dabo was a system coach. He can't do it without an elite quarterback. He can't do it without Deshaun Watson or Trevor Lawrence.

Clemson made the 2024-25 expanded CFP as ACC champions but lost to Texas. Dabo has not returned to the national championship game since this take, though 'system coach' remains debatable.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Cincinnati will only make the CFP if no one-loss Power 5 team exists

The details are... it has to be Cincinnati will get into the college football playoff over a one-loss Power 5 team. So one loss. It can't be two losses... I just know how the college football playoff works and the bias that happens.

Cincinnati actually made the CFP as an undefeated team, but they didn't have to go 'over' a one-loss Power 5 team in a way that controversial; they were clearly better than the alternatives that year.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

If the College Football Playoff started today, my final four would be Georgia, Alabama, Oregon, and Penn State

If they started the college football playoff today, my final four would be Georgia and Bama, which obviously not new colors, but Oregon and Penn state new colors. And that's our color update.

Georgia and Alabama both made the playoff, but Oregon (10-4) and Penn State (7-6) fell off significantly later in the season.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Notre Dame is not a good football team and they will lose to either Wisconsin or Cincinnati

You don't think Notre Dame is good? I think Notre Dame might be... They barely beat Toledo... Notre Dame will loose either Wisconsin or Cincinnati. Hopefully Wisconsin.

Notre Dame beat Wisconsin 41-13 the following week but did lose to Cincinnati 24-13 on October 2nd, partially validating the take.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

I'm not getting off the Graham Mertz train

The Badgers fell on their face. I'm still going to believe in Graham Mertz. I'm not going to get off this train. That sucked, though.

Mertz's career at Wisconsin never lived up to the 'wagon' hype, though he found some success later at Florida.
Push
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Chip Kelly has UCLA rolling and they can beat anyone in the Pac-12

I think [Chip Kelly] does. I mean, if they can do that to LSU, where the talent gap is pretty big between UCLA and LSU, there's nobody UCLA is going to play in the Pac-12 that has that kind of talent. UCLA can beat anybody in the Pac-12.

UCLA went 8-4 in 2021. They were competitive but not the dominant force predicted here, as Utah won the Pac-12.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers