Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
Jay CutlerJay Cutler

The altitude in Denver adds 5-8 yards to your throw

I thought you're getting five to eight yards on a throw there. And the ball just cuts... in Denver, the ball just keeps sailing. It just keeps going. [In Denver], probably high 70s [is the farthest I could throw].

Physics supports that thin air reduces drag, allowing projectiles to travel further.
Win
Jay CutlerJay Cutler

Mike Martz had no conscience when it came to calling high-risk plays

I'll give it to Mike [Martz]. He had no conscience. He went into the game, and he was literally playing Madden. With human beings. It was just chess pieces... He always thought the next play was the one. He's dialing it up.

Martz was famously known for his 'Greatest Show on Turf' style which often led to high sack numbers for his quarterbacks.
Win
Jay CutlerJay Cutler

Sam Darnold was likely just being honest about 'seeing ghosts' and it got blown out of proportion

I've said it. Especially when you're young. You're processing. You're figuring things out. And I've probably said that before, too. I'm like, I'm seeing a thousand things out here. And none of them are probably legit. So, I think it's just being honest. And it just got blown out of proportion.

The comment did indeed become a massive meme, supporting his 'blown out of proportion' claim.
Void
Jay CutlerJay Cutler

Vanderbilt is better than every Big Ten team during certain years

[Big Cat: Do you think Vandy's better than every Big Ten team because they're in the SEC?] At this point, no. There's been years, yes. It's a different brand of football.

Vanderbilt has occasionally had strong seasons (like under James Franklin) where they could arguably beat the bottom/middle of the Big Ten, but it's a subjective ranking.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I'm a better swimmer than Jay Cutler and would out-swim him in any stroke

I'm a better swimmer than you. ... You're not going to out-swim me. Yes, I will. I will out-swim you. No. Easily. And if I have to, I'll die in the pool. ... We'll do every stroke. ... I got this. I'm not worried about that.

This race has never been televised/documented to resolve, but given Cutler's elite athleticism, it's highly likely Big Cat is wrong.
Win
Jay CutlerJay Cutler

Mitch Trubisky should stop reading everything and go underground

Don't read anything. Stop reading is your advice. Go underground here, bud. I think you watch some of his press conferences and stuff, and you could tell it [media criticism] really bothered him sometimes. The more he can get away from all that stuff, I think the better for him.

Trubisky famously requested the TVs at Halas Hall be turned off to avoid seeing media coverage of him.
Loss
Jay CutlerJay Cutler

The United States would win Olympic Gold in handball if they fielded a team of pro athletes

I do want to get a team together for the Olympics. I think it's handball... I guarantee we can put a team together that can win gold. Guaranteed. Just from pure, arm speed. I don't think guys in other countries [could compete].

The US did not field a handball team of pro athletes at the 2021 Tokyo Olympics and did not win gold. The US men's handball team has never qualified for the Olympics in the modern era.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL is the ultimate reality show

What about the 28-3 comeback? The NFL is the ultimate reality show. Fact.

This is a subjective comparison of entertainment value.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kent Sterling's take on Cubs fans being 'sluggish' for getting hit by foul balls is trash

Chicago Cubs will protect fans too stupid or sluggish to avoid foul balls by extending nets... This guy sucks. This guy is trash... He basically saying he wrote this entire article to brag that parents are capable of protecting kids because he did it once.

Sterling's article was widely panned for its victim-blaming tone.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kobe Bryant was the bridge that took the baton from Michael Jordan and passed it to LeBron James

Kobe Bryant was the type of guy who [was] bigger than his sport, who was the guy who took the baton from Michael Jordan and passed it to LeBron James, who was basically the guy in the NBA for a decade plus.

This is a subjective assessment of a player's historical role in the league, generally supported by most basketball historians.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kobe Bryant's death is the most shocking athlete death since Dale Earnhardt

I can't think of another case where an athlete of like this stature has passed away suddenly, like maybe the closest thing I can even think of is Dale Earnhardt.

The level of 'shock' is a subjective experience, though widely shared by the sports community at the time.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA should have canceled all games on the day Kobe Bryant died

I think [the NBA] should have canceled the games today because of what he meant everybody in the league. It seemed like Kobe had some sort of influence on every single team... it felt like one of those things where the the whole league was like sleepwalking.

The NBA did not cancel games that night, though they later postponed a Lakers/Clippers game. This remains a subjective opinion on how the league should handle tragedies.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL should implement the XFL's 4th-and-15 onside kick alternative rule

They tried out the Mike Florio rule where you get a one passing down fourth and 15 and you try to make a first down instead of an onside kick... it's a great rule by the way. They should absolutely implement it.

The NFL has not yet adopted this rule as of 2024, although it has been proposed and tested in the Pro Bowl.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm only joining an XFL team if I have a real chance to make the roster

The practice squad offer is apparently legit. Like I'm going to get a contract if I want to go down that road... in which case I'm only going down that road if they give me an opportunity to work my way onto a team. I'm not just going to be on practice squad a year.

PFT never actually signed a contract or played for an XFL team, as the 2020 season was cut short by COVID-19 and the bit eventually faded.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bryson DeChambeau worries too much about angles and should just play golf

He does like the compass and the he does like all the math behind his shots. Just go out and shoot the ball, dude, maybe if you stop thinking about it, you'd be like Brooks [Koepka] and wind shit... You worry too much about angles buddy.

Bryson DeChambeau went on to win the U.S. Open later that year (2020) using his analytical methods, proving they could win championships, though the debate over his pace of play continued.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Antarctica is always freezing, and it is weird to suggest they have a 'summer' where it isn't cold

I was always taught that Antarctica was just always freezing. No one lives there. It's a continent that no one lives on because it's all ice... I assume that it was always cold... there's no houses there, people don't go vacationing there.

While Antarctica is always cold, it does have a 'summer' season (Dec-Feb) where temperatures are significantly warmer than winter, though still below freezing in most parts.
Win
George KittleGeorge Kittle

I throw up before every single football game

As soon as we come back in from warm-ups. I go puke... hundred percent for every game... I always think I'm like, I'm a step faster now. That's my positive mindset.

Kittle has confirmed this in multiple interviews throughout his career as his standard routine.
Void
George KittleGeorge Kittle

I actually prefer blocking to catching the ball

I like blocking a lot like my favorite thing... when it's play call is like, all right, you're just going to go just throw some people out of the club. You're like fuck. Yes. Let's go.

This is a statement of personal preference from an elite athlete about his craft.
Loss
George KittleGeorge Kittle

Jimmy Garoppolo's chin line will lead the 49ers to a Super Bowl win

Jimmy [Garoppolo] I think is one of the strongest chin lines in the NFL and with that, you know that chin line it's going to, you know, definitely let us know Super Bowl this year.

The 49ers lost Super Bowl LIV to the Kansas City Chiefs 31-20.
Void
George KittleGeorge Kittle

If you don't embrace the physicality of football, you are playing the game wrong

If you don't embrace the physicality of football, you're playing the game wrong. I always say that as a kicker... I say that all the time.

This is a philosophical stance on how the game should be played.
Void
Kobe BryantKobe Bryant

I expect excellent work in my office; if the work is average, you don't belong here

I expect excellent work. We all do. So I don't care if you're in the office at 6:00 a.m. and you leave at midnight, if the work that you do is average, then this is not the home for you. Conversely, you cannot be in an office at all and have excellent work, this is the place for you.

This is Kobe's personal management philosophy and standard for his business.
Void
Kobe BryantKobe Bryant

If my accomplishments in the next 20 years don't exceed my NBA career, then I failed

I told somebody said listen if what I do in the next 20 years is not better than my last 20 then I failed... I wouldn't accomplish what I accomplished my last 20 years if I did not have this mentality to begin with.

Due to his untimely death, Kobe was unable to complete the 20-year window to fulfill this personal ambition. In the short time he had, he won an Oscar and built a successful media company, but the take is ultimately unresolvable.
Void
Kobe BryantKobe Bryant

Claiming a bad system or bad teammates ruined your career is just an excuse

That sounds like excuses to me. I mean, you got to figure it out, right? If you really have an obsession to figure it out. You will figure it out, right and every puzzles constructed differently... You just got to figure out Your own puzzles.

This is a foundational philosophy of Kobe's career and cannot be objectively proven true or false, though it is a highly debated topic in sports analytics regarding player environment.
Win
Kobe BryantKobe Bryant

Shaq admitted he used to coast through the summer because he knew I was training

When we sat down we did the interview together. He finally He copped to the fact that after we won championships, she's like I can just relax and Coastal with the summer because I know I got a teammate who's going to be training 8 10 hours a day and I was like see that's the BSS yet that would piss and shit.

Shaquille O'Neal has admitted in various interviews (including the one with Kobe) that he did not maintain the same year-round training intensity as Kobe, often using the regular season to play himself into shape.
Loss
Kobe BryantKobe Bryant

The 2002 Western Conference Finals were rigged

[The 2002 Western Conference Finals] was rigged. Mr. Official's name Tim Donaghy. We definitely have money on it. Yeah, so that's a fact. Yes. Yes. So from that standpoint, yes, but from the Kings missing 20-something free throws in Game 7... we all know what else to tell you.

While the 2002 WCF (specifically Game 6) is widely criticized and Donaghy later claimed it was fixed, Donaghy did not officiate that series, and no official rigging has ever been legally proven.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Enron is due for a massive comeback

A little investment tip, Enron. It's bound to bounce back. It has to. It is due.

Enron filed for bankruptcy in 2001 and its stock is worthless; it is not bouncing back.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Zion Williamson is a bonafide bust

Zion is a bust. Parentheses: I went to sleep at halftime.

Zion had an incredible second half in his debut and became an All-Star, proving this satirical take incorrect.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Zion Williamson is always one bad weekend away from being fat

He is not fat, but he's always a bad weekend away from being fat. A bachelor party, going on a trip. Maybe a trip to New Orleans... you come into work on Monday and everyone looks at you like you got stung by a bunch of bees.

Weight and conditioning became recurring issues throughout Zion's early career, often sidelined by injury.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Coach K is a bad X's and O's guy for not letting Zion shoot threes at Duke

Huge indictment on Coach K as an X's and O's guy. [Zion] hit four [threes] in a row... That's another feather in the cap of old Roy Williams. He would never screw up his prospects like that.

Hot TakeCBBHotSarcastic
Zion only shot 33% from three at Duke on limited attempts; Coach K's decision was based on Zion's elite inside game. Declaring him a 'bad X's and O's guy' is a satirical stretch.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers is not a great quarterback

Eli, Romo, Carson Palmer, Aaron Rodgers, Jay Cutler. These are all people that are not great quarterbacks, but were very good for a long time.

Aaron Rodgers is a 4-time MVP and first-ballot Hall of Famer; he is objectively great by any standard.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Eli Manning's Hall of Fame case relies entirely on beating the Patriots

Does Eli have a— is his legacy seen differently, and is he a surefire Hall of Famer if he beats teams not named the Patriots in the Super Bowl? No. Because that is really when you boil down what Eli is... he had two moments where he beat the best coach and the best quarterback in the NFL history.

The 'undefeated' element and the Brady/Belichick factor are universally cited as the key components of Eli's HOF candidacy.
Void
HankHank

Peyton Manning's Super Bowl win with the Broncos doesn't really count

Peyton won two... The Broncos [win] didn't really count. That's an asterisk per Hank.

Peyton Manning officially won Super Bowl 50; declaring it doesn't count is purely subjective (and biased).
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Eli Manning will be the world's greatest suburban stay-at-home dad

Eli's going to be the world's greatest suburban dad. Can't you see it? Can't you see him being a great assistant coach for his kid's soccer team? He's going to chaperone a lot of field trips... I feel like Eli is going to be a great stay-at-home dad and every day all the kids come over and he spends the entire afternoon throwing them in the pool.

Eli has indeed settled into a very 'dad-like' retirement, though he eventually returned to the spotlight with the ManningCast.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am a better kicker than the kickers at Alabama

Alabama could do a lot worse. Dude, I'm a better kicker than Alabama. Saban would have another chip if he had you as a kicker. That's a fact.

Alabama had significant kicking struggles around this time, but PFT is not a D1-caliber athlete.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Pro Bowl needs to move back to Hawaii to feel special again

They need to move the Pro Bowl back to Hawaii. It is not nearly as special. I need to see them with leis and all that.

The NFL has moved the Pro Bowl around and eventually changed the format to flag football, but it has not returned to a permanent Hawaii residency.
Void
Dog the Bounty HunterDog the Bounty Hunter

The greatest feeling in the world is hunting and catching a human being

Hemingway said that the greatest thing in the world is to hunt another human being and catch him. So that's the greatest feeling you could ever have.

Subjective emotional claim.
Void
Dog the Bounty HunterDog the Bounty Hunter

Truth serum would fix the American justice system

Hit him with truth serum for $69.50. You find out everything. So I think that is real justice. And we don't do it enough. Because the lawyers got to make money, the courts have to make money... let's get down to the real nitty gritty. Hit him with that and find out what's really going on.

This is a philosophical opinion on justice, though scientifically and legally 'truth serums' are largely discredited and inadmissible.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jeffrey Epstein is still alive

We need to find Jeffrey Epstein. Because he's still alive. That motherfucker's still alive. Let's do that. Dog the Bounty Hunter Season Two: On the Trail of Jeffrey... there's no way this guy's dead. This guy is overseas somewhere.

Officially, Epstein was declared dead by suicide in August 2019. There is no verifiable proof he is alive.
Void
Dog the Bounty HunterDog the Bounty Hunter

Rapists almost never commit suicide

All rapists do not commit suicide. A person that does, shot someone else... Rapists are sissies. They like that feeling when a girl [says] 'please, please, please don't.' I've arrested a lot. And they will not most of the time kill themselves.

This is a generalized claim based on anecdotal experience. Statistics on offender suicide vary and don't definitively support a 'never' claim.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

We are 'all fucked' because of the coronavirus

The coronavirus is active. It is live. It's over in China right now. They've shut down cities. They've quarantined entire cities... And I've seen the movie Outbreak recently. So I just think we're all fucked.

While 'fucked' is a loose term, the coronavirus did indeed become a global pandemic that fundamentally altered life for years.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

'The Circle' on Netflix is the worst show ever created

I started watching the show The Circle on Netflix, and it's the worst show that's ever been created, and I started watching it, and I can't stop. It is horrendous. ... You say to yourself, I'm getting significantly dumber as I watch this show. And then you keep on watching.

Subjective opinion on a reality television show.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Baseball Hall of Fame is erroneous without Barry Bonds

The fact that Barry Bonds isn't in the Hall of Fame makes the Hall of Fame completely erroneous to me. Or Roger Clemens. Barry Bonds is the best baseball player of all time. He should be in the Hall of Fame.

Bonds is still not in the Hall of Fame as of 2024. Whether that makes it 'erroneous' is subjective.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Derek Jeter was only the second-best shortstop on the Yankees

Second best shortstop on that Yankees team. Behind A-Rod.

Statistically (WAR, OPS+), Alex Rodriguez was a superior player to Jeter, even while playing 3rd base for the Yankees.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Buy TikTok stock when it goes public

Mike Francesa told me... TikTok. Invest in TikTok. So invest in TikTok, invest in all the apps, invest in all the social media... when TikTok goes public, buy it, buy it again and get back in line three times to buy it some more.

TikTok remains a massive global platform, but ByteDance has not had an IPO as of late 2024.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyle Shanahan's offense is built so he can't forget to run the football

I think, luckily, the way this offense [the 49ers] is built, [Kyle Shanahan] has made it impossible for him to forget to run the football. He's taken that out of his own hands.

In Super Bowl LIV, the 49ers famously moved away from the run game in the fourth quarter while leading, which contributed to their collapse against the Chiefs.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Andy Reid is a Hall of Famer even if he loses Super Bowl LIV

Is he a Hall of Famer if he loses? [Big Cat] Yes. [PFT Commenter] I think he is too.

Andy Reid was eventually inducted into the Hall of Fame, but even in 2020, his resume was considered elite.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Andy Reid is a better coach than Bill Cowher

If Bill Cowher's in the fucking Hall of Fame, Andy Reid should be in the Hall of Fame. Andy Reid's way better of a coach than Bill Cowher. I'm sorry, but that's a fact.

Subjective comparison of coaching careers.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

George Kittle is the best tight end in the NFL

Best current tight end in the league. Travis Kelce or George Kittle. It's Kittle. Greg [George] Kittle. It's definitely Greg [George] Kittle.

Subjective ranking of players.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

It would be offensive if Joe Montana roots for anyone but the 49ers in the Super Bowl

If you're a 49ers fan and Joe Montana doesn't say I'm rooting for the 49ers, that would piss me off... If Joe Montana shows up to the Super Bowl wearing anything but a 49ers shirt, that would piss me off.

This is a subjective matter of fan etiquette.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Fullbacks are officially back in the NFL

So it's going to be Sherman, Juszek, our fullbacks officially back. As first reported by Pardon My Take last year, they are officially back.

The role of the fullback remains niche, though it saw a brief revival in specific schemes like Shanahan's.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers