Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Open
JJ WattJJ Watt

T.J. Watt will be a better player than me if he stays healthy

If he stays healthy and, and I, I hope he stays healthy and I hope he does. He'll break every record I got and he'll absolutely be a better player than me. There's no doubt for a single season, for a single, like being able to do everything. I I I won't give up that title.

T.J. Watt has already won a DPOY and holds elite sack numbers, but JJ's 20.5 sack seasons and multiple DPOY awards set a very high bar.
Open
Chris BermanChris Berman

The Buffalo Bills will reach at least one Super Bowl during the Josh Allen window

I think they'll be in one, at least one. Cause [Josh Allen] is really good. And he was hurt... but they're the best three [Mahomes, Burrow, Allen]. I'm very confident that they'll [get in].

Josh Allen's window is still open. As of the end of the 2024 season, the Bills have not yet reached a Super Bowl with Allen.
Open
Chris BermanChris Berman

Andy Reid will coach the Chiefs for at least five more years

I would think... Will Mahomes play more than five more years? Yes. Let's hope so. I'd be surprised if, if [Andy Reid] is not driven by... where am I going? If I have [Mahomes] and I have this set up.

Andy Reid is still coaching the Chiefs as of early 2025. We need to see if he reaches the 5-year mark from the 2023 take.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

No one will ever win seven Super Bowls again

He is the greatest quarterback of all time. I know that there's now debates going around... Tom Brady was seven and three. I don't think anyone will ever win seven Super Bowls again.

The highest active player is Patrick Mahomes with 3. Matching 7 is nearly impossible in the modern era.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes will have the career numbers, but Joe Burrow might be the one winning more Super Bowl titles.

Maybe it's like one of those things where... Mahomes will put up the numbers and Burrow might win the titles.

As of late 2024, Mahomes has 3 titles and Burrow has 0, making this look unlikely, but it's still pending.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I will root for Aaron Rodgers to win a Super Bowl the moment he leaves the Packers

If Aaron Rodgers goes anywhere else, I will root for him to win a Super Bowl. Because it will be hilarious if he wins the same amount of Super Bowls on another team in like a year or two that he did with the Packers in 16 years. The minute he's gone, it would be very funny if he won a Super Bowl with another team.

Rodgers joined the Jets in 2023 but suffered a season-ending injury in Week 1, and the team struggled, so the Super Bowl scenario has not yet materialized.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Doug Pederson will eventually return to coach the Philadelphia Eagles.

Doug Pederson has not coached his last game for the Philadelphia Eagles. You're gonna bring him back. I think they could bring it back.

This hasn't happened yet; Pederson is currently the head coach of the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Open
Chad KellyChad Kelly

I could start over 50% of current NFL quarterbacks because I know the game better than they do

How many quarterbacks in the NFL right now do you think that you could start over? [Chad]: 50%... I feel like I know the game a lot more than a lot of people. Cuz I started at such a young age and that's all I knew in order to, you know, make it in life. I thought it was just to play in the NFL really.

Kelly has not returned to the NFL since this statement to prove he can start over 50% of the league's QBs.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

London is capable of supporting two NFL franchises right now

Roger Goodell said that he thinks that England is able to support not just one but two franchises right now. So we're gonna do the LA model. It's gonna happen in London. It is gonna happen.

The NFL continues to expand international games but has yet to place a permanent franchise in London.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Dan Quinn will be a head coach again, fail, and then return to being the best defensive coordinator in the league

Dan Quinn is a really fucking good defensive coach. He's gonna be a head coach again. I'm gonna call right out. Dan Quinn will be a head coach again and he's gonna go like eight and eight, then he's gonna go five and 11. Then he is gonna go five 11 again, get fired. Then he's gonna go somewhere, went to a Super Bowl and be the best coordinator in the league again.

Quinn was hired as the Commanders head coach in February 2024. The 'failure' and 'return to DC' portion is pending.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Seahawks fans will eventually cheer Russell Wilson in a few years once the rawness of his departure fades

I think if this game took place at any point, other than this year and especially week one, it might be a little different. So if Russell Wilson plays for eight more years and he comes back to Seattle at the end of his career, I think they will cheer him. I think it's just so raw... The rawness of it, the fact that it was week one, I think that if it happens... eight years from now or say, let's even say Russ goes somewhere else... I think they might be a little bit more receptive to 'em and be like, Hey, that was cool when you won us a Super Bowl.

This is still pending as Wilson hasn't reached the 'ceremonial return' phase of his career yet.
Open
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Fred Taylor belongs in the Hall of Fame

It's Fred Taylor time. I think Fred has a legitimate chance to get in... if you ask the players like Derek Brooks and Ray Lewis, they all think he should be in. It's definitely Fred Taylor time.

As of the 2024 voting cycle, Fred Taylor has been a finalist but has not yet been inducted into the Hall of Fame.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL is in trouble because watching on a couch is 10 times better than going to a stadium

The NFL's in trouble. I think in terms of like ticket sales, they're gonna start building smaller stadiums, I think in the future. Cause like it is the, the cat's outta the bag. Your couch is 10 times more comfortable than going to a stadium.

While stadium attendance remains high, there is a trend toward smaller, more 'boutique' stadium designs (like the Titans' new stadium plans).
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Von Miller will not finish his six-year contract with the Bills

I will bet all the Von Miller's money that they said he's getting, which I don't have, that he will not see the end of the contract. He will not see the end of the contract. Von Miller's going to be 39 by the time it's over.

As of 2024, Von Miller is still on the Bills but had his contract restructured/reduced, and it remains highly unlikely he completes the full original 6-year term through 2028.
Open
Billy FootballBilly Football

Malik Willis will either be a Hall of Famer or a complete bust

Like he could actually like, you know, it's either going to translate and he's going to be like Patrick Mahomes or it's not. One of those things where it's... so like hall-of-famer or bust. Exactly. Yep. I like that.

Too early to call 'bust' vs 'Hall of Famer' definitively, but the 'Hall of Famer' path looks extremely unlikely.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Broncos and Seahawks will combine for exactly three playoff appearances over the next five years

[Big Cat]: How many playoff appearances will the Broncos and the Seahawks have combined in the next five years? ... [PFT Commenter]: Make the playoffs three times, three times.

As of the end of the 2023 season (2 years in), the Seahawks have 1 appearance (2022) and the Broncos have 0. They need 2 more combined over the next 3 seasons to be correct.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford will eventually be a Hall of Famer based on his career passing stats

I'm not saying that. I think that Matt Safford is like an incredible hall of fame quarterback. I've my, my statement has simply been that he will, his career will be there by the end... mass, Sanford's going to end up like top six all time and passing. So, and he's also going to, no, one's saying that he's right now, if he retired, he would be a hall of Famer... My argument was always under the assumption that he plays until he's, I don't know, like 38, 39.

Stafford is still active; his HOF status will be determined after retirement.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is now an automatic Hall of Famer

Matthew Stafford is going to be a hall of Famer. It's almost automatic now. Cause he has it... all the stats are there and then he's got the ring. That's it. If you put him now, if he plays three, four more years, pick a quarterback with one Superbowl, he's going to have a better resume overall.

Stafford has high volume stats and a ring, though his lack of All-Pros/MVPs still makes him a debate topic; he is not yet eligible.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

No starting quarterback will ever touch Tom Brady's record of seven Super Bowl wins

Seven Super Bowls will not — I'm going to safely — I really do not think that will be touched by a starting quarterback.

Patrick Mahomes has three as of 2024, but seven remains a distant and likely untouchable milestone for anyone else.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is officially a Hall of Famer

The, the, the Stafford hall of fame take is aging beautifully for me because I got last. I just went back and looked, people were fucking roasting me for it. And I always said, if he has insane, like he's a mast an insane amount of numbers... all he needed was a deep run. I think this is it. If he wins one, it's an absolute, no doubter.

Stafford won the Super Bowl two weeks later. While his HOF case is debated, the deep run Big Cat required actually happened.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Hiring an executive from the Kansas City Chiefs organization is always a winning move for the Chicago Bears

The Bears got a new GM, Ryan Poles... pretty much the news there is that he's from the Chiefs. Chiefs have good players. It's never been a bad thing for the Bears to hire someone from the Chiefs staff.

Ryan Poles has overseen a massive rebuild with the Bears, including drafting Caleb Williams, but the overall success of the franchise remains to be seen compared to the Chiefs' dynasty.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Stafford will be a Hall of Famer if he reaches the Super Bowl this year

I have the tape that I've been squatting on for like four years. Now that he's a hall of Famer. I remember I got to go find that tweaks people thought I was crazy, but I said, if he can get you an FC championship game or later you will probably have enough... this will be his deep playoff run.

Stafford won the Super Bowl and has elite passing numbers, making him a very strong candidate, though he is not yet eligible.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is a Hall of Famer

That was the Hall of Fame, Matt Stafford that I hope gets there. So I can pull up a tweet from five years ago saying you were going to be in this.

Stafford went on to win the Super Bowl later that season, significantly boosting his HOF resume, though he isn't yet retired or inducted.
Open
Rex RyanRex Ryan

I would return to coach the Jets for $5 million a year

He goes, you got to go back and coach [the Jets]. I said, fine. Give me 5 million a year I'll go back. I told him I used to.

Rex never returned to coach the Jets.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford will be in the Hall of Fame

I actually feel really good about my take, my long standing take that Matt Stafford is going to be in the Hall of Fame... if he can figure out a way to get to a Super Bowl or even win a Super Bowl ring, then it's like, he's a hall of famer.

Stafford won the Super Bowl later this season, significantly bolstering his HOF case, though he hasn't been inducted yet.
Open
Deion SandersDeion Sanders

Gillie Da King could run a sub-5.0 second 40-yard dash

I think he could break a five-flat 40. I really do.

The claim hasn't been officially verified with a laser-timed 40.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Heupel will eventually be an awesome NFL head coach

Josh Heupel, he better not get to the NFL because I love taking pictures of that guy's face. His neck goes on forever. He's my new Frank Beamer... He's going to be awesome. He's going to be awesome [in the NFL].

As of late 2024, Heupel is still the head coach at Tennessee and has not coached in the NFL.
Open
Mitch TrubiskyMitch Trubisky

Patrick Mahomes will be the best quarterback of all time

Mahomes is probably going to be the best quarterback of all time and that's like, you don't get to pick where you're drafted for sure. Then just decides like, Hey, I'm going to be the best of all time. Oh, cool. Just runs up the score every week.

Mahomes is widely considered to be on a GOAT trajectory with multiple MVPs and Super Bowls.
Open
Mitch TrubiskyMitch Trubisky

I want to play in the NFL for 12 or 13 more seasons

[Playing for 12, 13 more seasons] is the goal. Play as long as possible. I mean, this is what you dream of to play football at the professional level as a kid.

Trubisky is still in the league as of the 2024 season, so this goal remains pending, though he is currently a backup.
Open
Jake MarshJake Marsh

NFL jerseys will eventually have advertising patches like the NBA and NHL

The NHL, like the NBA, is adding advertising to the front of the jerseys in 2022. I feel like it's inevitable for NFL.

While not yet on game jerseys, NFL teams already have sponsor patches on practice jerseys, and league momentum suggests it is pending.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Peyton Manning will become the Commissioner of the NFL

I thought that Peyton Manning's speech points us in one direction only, and that is that he wants to follow in the footsteps of his dad and become commissioner of the NFL. So that when Arch [Manning] gets to the league, he can implement some weird draft rule.

Peyton Manning has focused on media (Omaha Productions) and shows no immediate signs of seeking the commissioner role, though it remains a theoretical future path.
Open
Calvin JohnsonCalvin Johnson

Matthew Stafford will make the Hall of Fame if he wins a Super Bowl or has several consecutive winning seasons with the Rams

It all depends how much longer Matthew intends to play. And if he gets that ring out, he's out there. You know, if he goes out there and lights it up and has consecutive, like three, four or five consecutive winning seasons, even if he don't win the Super Bowl, I think he has a chance.

Stafford won the Super Bowl that same season (Feb 2022). While his HOF entry is pending his retirement, he met the criteria Calvin set.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is a Hall of Famer

Dude, I'm rooting for Matt Stafford because there's a few takes that we all have out there that are just lingering, and Matt Stafford being a Hall of Famer, I could retire on that take.

Stafford is currently 11th all-time in passing yards and won a Super Bowl, making his case very strong, though he is still active/not yet eligible.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is a future Hall of Famer

I think [Stafford] is a future Hall of Famer. People get mad at me for that. But... if he plays for another, I don't know, four or five years, he will be, like numbers-wise, up there with everyone else.

While Stafford is not yet retired, winning a Super Bowl significantly bolstered his Hall of Fame case.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Long-haired quarterbacks do not win Super Bowls

Are you concerned that his [Trevor Lawrence's] hair is too long because long-haired quarterbacks don't win Super Bowls? ... It's basically, I think Kenny Stabler is the only one. And he was a little shaggy. I wouldn't call it long hair.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Historically largely true for extremely long hair, though Mahomes and others have had some length. Lawrence has not won a Super Bowl yet.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Julian Edelman will eventually make the Hall of Fame in 20 years because the 'Patriots Dynasty' narrative will keep it alive

If I had to guess, I think [Edelman] will end up in it in 20 years because people will keep it alive and it will grow in stature... whenever 150 [anniversary] comes and they start opening the door to everyone and they clean up the Hall of Fame. That feels like a Julian Edelman [year].

Edelman is not in the Hall of Fame yet. It will take at least 20 years to see if this specific prediction of him being 'grandfathered' in comes true.
Open
Eli ManningEli Manning

I'm not far-fetched as a Hall of Famer, but I'm not conceited enough to say I belong yet

To think of yourself belonging with such legends and icons, I'm not that conceited and not that confident in myself to say that I belong with those people. But if they invite me to join them, I would gladly take a seat and it would be a great honor.

Eli Manning is not yet eligible for the Hall of Fame as of 2021; outcome pending his first year of eligibility (2025).
Open
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL will eventually expand to an 18-game schedule

My hot seat is the 16-game schedule for the NFL because it looks like we're going to 17. And my cool throw will be the 18-game schedule because as soon as we go to 17, we're going to go to 18. It's the greatest, like, sleight of hand that the NFL is doing here.

The NFL officially moved to 17 games in 2021. Expansion to 18 games is still a major topic of negotiation and widely expected by analysts.
Open
Leonard FournetteLeonard Fournette

Jason Pierre-Paul is a future Hall of Famer

He may have seven and a half fingers, but he is a Hall of Famer. He's a two-time champion. And his resume and his credentials he has is remarkable.

JPP's Hall of Fame status will be determined by voters years after his retirement.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Philip Rivers will eventually get into the Hall of Fame

I think [Philip Rivers] will eventually get in the Hall of Fame. He's not a first-ballot Hall of Famer. I think he will eventually get in. But he obviously will get dinged for the lack of playoff wins and the lack of a signature win and the lack of a Super Bowl. But when you actually look at it... Phillip Rivers was the better quarterback in terms of numbers throughout his career [compared to Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisberger].

Philip Rivers is not yet eligible for the Hall of Fame (first eligible in 2026).
Open
Andrew HawkinsAndrew Hawkins

Eventually there will be a QB who runs like Lamar Jackson and passes like Patrick Mahomes

Think about eventually there's going to be a quarterback who can run like Lamar and pass like Patrick Mahomes. And then our minds are going to be just blown at that point.

The league is seeing more dual-threat QBs (Josh Allen, Anthony Richardson, Caleb Williams prospects), but a true hybrid with both Lamar's speed and Mahomes' arm is still the holy grail.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I would probably give up a pinky for a Bears Super Bowl, but I don't want to lose the fun of the chase

Would you give up a pinky for the Bears to win a Super Bowl? Yeah, probably I would... but I don't want to have that fun taken away. Like, why would I do that to myself?

The Bears have not won a Super Bowl since this take was made.
Open
Coach OCoach O

Joe Burrow will be a championship quarterback in the NFL

Joe's gonna get a Supporting Cast will be a championship quarterback. No doubt. Yeah, you know the harder you hit Joe Duffy gets yeah, you know, you know, he's taking some hits for us and that Fiesta Bowl he took you know, I don't know if you'll get out of going for miles to come in he goes, he's one more unexpected of word know about you know, yeah. He just started on that ignites it

Burrow led the Bengals to the Super Bowl in his second season and remains one of the premier QBs in the NFL, though he hasn't won the ring yet as of 2024.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Matthew Stafford is a future Hall of Famer based on his statistics

I'm the one who's on the hook as calling him as a hall-of-fame future hall-of-fame quarterback just based off his ridiculous stats. Yeah. No, he's absolutely going to be in the Hall of Fame.

While not yet in, Stafford winning a Super Bowl with the Rams significantly bolstered this take which was previously based only on volume stats.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

I would hammer the under on Patrick Mahomes winning 3.5 more Super Bowls

If you though said over under Super Bowls for Patrick Mahomes, and you said it at let's say three and a half, I would hammer the under and that's nothing against Patrick Mahomes. That's just the NFL.

Mahomes currently has 3 rings as of 2024. He needs two more to beat Big Cat's 'under' (which was 3.5 additional from 2020, meaning 4.5 total).
Open
Nick SwardsonNick Swardson

Jordan Love will probably be a Hall of Famer because that's how it works for the Packers

Jordan Love will probably be a Hall of Famer just because that's how it always works out for [the Packers]. I just like that they're in, you know, it's just discombobulated for a minute. So just the drama over there brings me joy.

Jordan Love has shown significant promise as of 2023-2024, but Hall of Fame status is pending his full career.
Open
Mike VrabelMike Vrabel

Eli Manning is a Hall of Famer because he played very well in big games.

He's a guy who played really well in big games. I mean if you guys got to vote would you vote Yes? It was not the whole very good and he was very good... he played very well in big games.

Eli Manning is widely projected to be a Hall of Famer, though he isn't eligible for induction until 2025.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A 17-game NFL season is just a bridge to an 18-game season

17 seems like a weird number. It absolutely feels like it's just a bridge to get to 18 games. Like that's the finish line. It's going to be 18 games. No one's going to want a 17-game season.

While the NFL stayed at 17 games for several years, talk of expanding to 18 games became dominant among owners and the commissioner by 2024.
Open
JB
Jason Biggs

Eli Manning belongs in the Hall of Fame

Eli retired. It was time. He belongs in Canton. He should get there. Listen, two Super Bowls, and that last drive, the David Tyree catch, that scramble—that play was dead. I was at that game.

Eli Manning's Hall of Fame eligibility begins in 2025.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Patrick Mahomes will win 10 Super Bowl titles and 10 MVPs

Put this on a quote board right now because I truly believe this. I truly believe that Patrick Mahomes is going to end up being the first quarterback to have double digit Super Bowl titles and MVPs. 10.

While Mahomes has 3 rings currently, 10 is an unprecedented number that seems unlikely given the career length of even the most elite QBs, though he is currently on a record-breaking pace.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers