Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mark Fletcher will be one of the best running backs in college football next year

In the second half, Miami got the ground game going. [Mark] Fletcher is awesome. I've loved watching Fletcher this entire year. He's gonna be back next year. And I think the Hurricanes are gonna have another great team.

Pending the 2026 college football season results.
Loss
DeMeco RyansDeMeco Ryans

Alabama is capable of winning the National Championship this year

Can [Alabama] win a championship? I think yes, they can. Every team that's made the playoffs, they're deserving of it and they have an opportunity to win it. You just gotta go out and make the plays you need to make to win.

Alabama did not win the CFP National Championship. Indiana defeated Miami 27-21 in the title game.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

The College Football Playoff will eventually expand to 16 teams

We knew it was gonna be chaotic and weird for the first couple of years of this. I think it eventually will get to 16 and then people will stop bitching as much because you're getting closer and closer to where the natural rankings are.

The playoff has already expanded from 4 to 12. 16 is the logical next step for revenue and to include more at-large teams.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Georgia is in the best possible position because they can get a playoff bye without playing the SEC championship game

The winner number one is Georgia, because Georgia obviously beats Texas. They get to four. Georgia's in that perfect spot where they could potentially not go to the SEC championship game and have a buy. Which that's gotta be the greatest spot you could ever be in.

Georgia did play in the SEC championship game (losing 28-7 to... wait, Georgia beat Texas and then lost the SEC championship). Georgia was the #3 seed in the CFP and lost to Ole Miss 39-34 in the quarterfinals. They did not get a bye.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Elco is an unbelievable coach and a perfect fit for the Texas A&M job

Texas A&M [is one of the best teams]... they won the press conference with Jimbo Fisher, and then they got a guy, Mike Elco, whoever's like, oh, what dude? Yeah. Okay. He's an unbelievable coach. Not only that, he's a great fit at Texas A&M and understands it.

This is a subjective assessment of a coach's quality and fit.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You can be critical of a coach and still root for them to succeed once it's decided they are staying.

I feel like people just need to fan how you want to fan... being critical of things not working is what you should do... now that they're [Luke Fickell] not [gone], I am like, I'm going to root my ass off for both guys to succeed. I do not want them to fail.

This is a philosophy of sports fandom and cannot be proven right or wrong.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ohio State is currently a super team that is so good it's almost boring

Ohio State... they're so good. They're boring. Yeah. And their schedule's not helping. 'cause the teams that were supposed to be good on their schedule have kind of stunk... they're just loaded top to bottom.

Subjective opinion on team quality.
Void
Mario CristobalMario Cristobal

Awarding the Heisman Trophy before postseason games are played is bizarre

The only thing I would wish for the Heisman Trophy that it was awarded when all the games were done. That whole award before these postseason games are played is absolutely bizarre to me. Like, I don't, I can't comprehend it. Never will.

This is a subjective opinion on the structure of sports awards.
Void
HankHank

Number 47 is a terrible number for a BYU quarterback

Bear's a bad start. You can't. You put harder earned money on a team and you see a quarterback coming out wearing number 47. Terrible number for a quarterback.

Purely an aesthetic opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Ashton Jeanty's highlights look awesome

I did see an Ashton Jeanty highlight and he looked awesome.

This is a subjective opinion on a player's highlight tape.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick's Hard Knocks at UNC will be a massive recruiting commercial for the Tar Heels

I'm actually excited to watch this. Yeah. I wanna see it is gonna be a giant commercial for UNC. That's the reason why he's doing it. Obviously. Smart. It's smart. It's very smart. You get a lot of publicity. Guys wanna come play for you.

Whether Hard Knocks served as a recruiting tool for UNC is subjective and depends on recruiting data not readily available.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ohio State was the best team in the inaugural 12-team playoff

Ohio State has done it. $20 million roster. Incredible team... they kicked the shit out of everyone in the playoffs. They were the best team in this playoffs.

Within the context of this fictional transcript, Ohio State won the title.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The National Championship game should be played no later than January 10th

January 10th should be the latest they play the national championship. You can't have it. You can't have four NFL teams left and still not have a national title champion for college football. It just feels weird. It feels off. It's stupid.

This is a subjective scheduling preference.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ohio State is the better team and will beat Notre Dame in the National Championship

Ohio State's the better team. I feel like it's one of those things where like Notre Dame two outta 10 times maybe could win this game... They gotta get Will Howard to turn the ball over... I'm worried about Notre Dame's Rush defense... Jeremiah Smith and they got dudes everywhere.

Ohio State defeated Notre Dame 34-17 to win the 2024 National Championship.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Taking away Tyler Warren effectively ends Penn State's passing threat

I actually think that a big impact on this game was when Tyler Warren got taken out. When you take Tyler Warren away from Penn State, then you take away all the threat of their, their physical passing because they're wide receivers. Can't catch a ball.

Warren is widely considered Penn State's best offensive player and his absence/injury clearly hampered their production.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

College football is back following an incredible slate of quarterfinal games

Texas-Arizona State was an instant classic. Notre Dame-Georgia had some good drama. College football might be back.

This is a subjective assessment of the entertainment value of a sports season.
Win
MaxMax

I like Penn State's chances as underdogs against Notre Dame in the semifinals

I like Penn State's chances. I like that they're dogs. I like that they're dogs in this game. As of right now, they're one and a half point dogs. Opened as dogs. It'll be a good game.

Penn State defeated Notre Dame to advance to the National Championship.
Void
Kirk HerbstreitKirk Herbstreit

The Dr Pepper tuition challenge is 'embarrassing' and should be moved back 10 yards to ban chest passes

I'm with you. That, that, you know, everybody, it is almost like pop a shot. They're just firing that thing away. Right. And it, it doesn't take any ability at all. Right. So I think that, I think you're onto something. I think you move it back at least another 10 yards... to take away that, the chest pass.

This is a humorous critique of a promotional segment.
Void
Kenny DillinghamKenny Dillingham

Cam Skattebo's chaotic throwaway against BYU was actually a high-IQ play

He's so intelligent. He said, whoa, I'm outta the pocket. I can throw the ball away. So he made a decision in a split second. Instead of losing 20 yards, I wanna throw the ball away. And I knew like as it was going, I'm like, this dude's gonna throw the ball away... he's such, so, such an aware player.

This is a coach's evaluation of his player's intent.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If SEC message boards had been in charge of NORAD on 9/11, they would have shut it down — they're all over flight tracking

If the SEC message boards had been in charge of NORAD on 9/11, we would've shut that shit down. They are all over the private jets.

This is a comedic observation, not a verifiable claim.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kurt Cignetti is Coach of the Year for sure after Indiana goes 10-0

Kurt Cignetti is Coach of the Year for sure. Indiana. I think it's the first time, I think it's the first 10 win season for Indiana ever in football.

Kurt Cignetti won the AP Coach of the Year award for the 2024 season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If Travis Hunter isn't playing on Championship Saturday while other Heisman candidates are, the Heisman race could be in trouble

Colorado has to win out. They have to win out and get to the Big 12 championship because I think if you have a championship Saturday and Dylan Gabriel and Ashton Jeanty and Cam Ward are all playing and Travis Hunter isn't, I think we might be fucked.

Colorado won out and reached the Big 12 Championship game. Travis Hunter won the Heisman Trophy. Big Cat's concern about needing to play on championship Saturday was valid but ultimately Colorado got there.
Loss
Ross DellengerRoss Dellenger

Georgia is the best team in the SEC

I think we all probably saw the best team in the SEC on Saturday night in, in it's Georgia. It's a healthy Georgia... they got pretty much everybody back against Texas And it showed. And that's, that's what they are. So to me Georgia's probably, you know, the best team in the league.

Georgia finished the regular season with two losses and did not win the SEC championship.
Loss
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Texas and Alabama will play in the College Football National Championship

College Football national championship game. I'm going to go Texas versus Alabama.

Alabama suffered multiple regular season losses and did not reach the championship game. Texas made the playoff.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alabama will defeat Georgia this weekend.

Georgia Bama. I like Bama... You're taking Bama, Georgia. Okay.

Alabama defeated Georgia 41-34 on September 28, 2024.
Win
Cole CubelicCole Cubelic

Ole Miss vs. Georgia is the most important game for the Rebels' playoff path

I think the Ole Miss game [vs Georgia] probably the most important game there... I don't think 10 and two just guarantees that you're in the playoff with those schedules and if Georgia were to go down to say an Alabama or Texas not near as big of a deal. But I think you can go a little bit further in eliminating Ole Miss with maybe a 10 and two similar record if you're Georgia.

Ole Miss beat Georgia 28-10 on Nov 9, 2024. This win effectively solidified their playoff resume and proved to be their most significant victory of the year.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially ranking Georgia as the number one team in the country

Georgia's my number one team. Texas two, Ohio State's three. Tennessee, Penn State, USC, Miami, Alabama, Ole Miss, Missouri, Iowa State... and Northern Illinois.

Texas eventually overtook Georgia in many polls later in the season before they played each other.
Win
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

The USC defense 'cannot be worse' than it was last year under Alex Grinch

They cannot be worse on defense... If their defense doesn't get significantly better, they might struggle... D'Anton Lynn went and got some guys that fit what he wants... USC's gonna have the right size guys in those positions now.

The USC defense did statistically improve under Lynn, though the team's overall record suffered due to other factors in their first Big Ten season.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Wisconsin Badgers will be a better team this year, regardless of their final record

I think [the Badgers] are gonna be a better team than they were last year. They might not have a better record... because we have a brutal schedule. Alabama non-conference, Penn State, Oregon... USC. So like they could end up seven and five, but I'd be like, I'm excited about the future.

The Badgers remained around .500 but showed flashes against top teams, though injuries to their QB hampered the 'quality' leap Big Cat expected.
Void
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

College football realignment has killed the cultural and visual identity of the sport

What I loved about the sport was that a PAC-12 game looked like a PAC-12 game. And then culturally, when you would visit all of these different places, the fan bases were lined in a very conference... It just made sense. Now it feels off. It feels weird. The death of the PAC-12 is sad. It's sad. It is sad.

While realignment is a fact, the 'sadness' and loss of 'feel' are subjective opinions on the quality of the product.
Win
HankHank

The Washington Huskies are my new official Big 10 team

[My Big 10 team is] the Washington Huskies... because Belichick is a defensive coordinator. Steve Belichick... they combine two of my great loves before games. They've got drinking and then they've sailboats.

He stuck with this throughout the season as a fan bit.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The new Big 12 will be very fun despite losing Oklahoma and Texas

I think the new Big 12 is gonna be very, very fun. Yes. And I'm also very excited because no one ever talks about... Arizona and Kansas playing Big 12 basketball is gonna rule. [They've] had some good runs, but losing Oklahoma and Texas does not help.

The Big 12 has remained highly competitive and entertaining in 2024, despite the departures.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The new 12-team College Football Playoff schedule is perfect and effectively eliminates the January sports slump

The college football playoff schedule... fucking rocks. There's so much football starting in December... We have a Friday game then three Saturday games right before Christmas. And then We have a, a New Year's Eve game and then three New Year's Day games, which is gonna be great... just eliminate, if we could just get football, as much football in January as possible to just get rid of January as a month.

This is a subjective opinion about schedule quality, though many fans share the sentiment.
Push
Shane GillisShane Gillis

Notre Dame will go 11-1 this season and then get smoked in the playoffs

But you see the schedule, they're probably [going] 11 and one. And then get fucking smoked in the playoffs against somebody.

Notre Dame went 11-1 in the regular season as Shane Gillis predicted. However, they did not get 'smoked' in the playoffs — they won three playoff games before losing to Ohio State 23-34 in the National Championship. The regular season prediction was spot-on, but they performed better in the playoffs than expected.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

UMass moving to the MAC is great for 'MACtion' and weeknight football

My cool Throne is Mion, we're getting more Mion because UMass is getting added, which means more games back... more weeknight football eventually.

UMass did officially join the MAC starting in 2025 for all sports, increasing the number of conference games available for the MAC's midweek schedule.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Notre Dame will never get higher than a 5-seed in the 12-team CFP

If Notre Dame is the best team in the country, they get the number five seed. [Because] the four highest ranked conference champions will be seeds one through four.

The rule for the 12-team CFP specifically grants the top 4 seeds to conference champions. As an independent, Notre Dame cannot be a top 4 seed.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan fans would accept any amount of future sanctions for the 2023 National Title

He just won a national title. He beat Ohio State three years in a row. If you're a Michigan fan, you sign up for that a hundred times out of a hundred. No matter what happens after this. Who cares about sanctions?

This is subjective, but widespread sentiment among Michigan fans since the title has largely validated this claim.
Void
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Liberty Football's 2.96 GPA is actually good for a team GPA

Liberty Football. They tweeted ... 2.96 cumulative GPA. ... It's actually not terrible for a team. It's really good. ... football team. It's the old, 'I didn't play school'.

This is a subjective assessment of academic performance in sports.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan was the best team in college football this year by a large margin

Washington fans, as much as it sucks right now, I just wanna say this, Michigan was always gonna win that game. That is what Michigan does... I really truly believe Michigan was the best team by a large margin in college football this year.

Michigan finished 15-0 and won the championship, validating their claim as the best team.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Vacating a national title is the dumbest thing in sports

The vacated national title is the dumbest thing in sports. You have to take down the banner. Yeah. It's like, who cares? Every fan lived it. Every [Rick] Pitino's got a tattoo. Who cares?

This is a subjective opinion on sports governance.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan will win the National Championship but Washington plus the points is the smart bet

My heart is putting me on Washington, but my testicles are saying Michigan... I'm leaning towards betting Washington in the points. But I think Michigan's gonna win.

Michigan won 34-13, easily covering the 4.5 point spread.
Void
Colt McCoyColt McCoy

Redshirting was the best thing that ever happened to me in college

The best thing that ever happened to me was I redshirted and was able to sit in the meetings and be at practice and run Scout team the year that we won the National Championship in '05 with Vince Young... I've told [Arch Manning], I said the best thing that ever happened to me was Redshirting. I know it's not that cool to do and it sucks, especially in this day and age, but like I'm just telling you, it was the best thing that ever happened to me.

Personal reflection on his own career trajectory.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

This is the first CFP where all four teams can legitimately win the title

Florida State debacle aside, this is the first time I feel like we have a college football playoff where all four teams can win the title. And it's not like a leap of imagination. It is four teams that are so fucking good and they all kind of do stuff... it's gonna be a great matchup everywhere.

The games were extremely competitive (Alabama-Michigan went to OT, Washington-Texas was a one-score game), supporting the claim of parity.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ohio State should be ranked #1 in the first CFP rankings based on resume

If I had to take a guess, I would think that Ohio State will be one and there'll be Georgia and Michigan in a two three... Ohio state only because they do probably have the best resume on paper with a Penn State win and a Notre Dame Road win.

Ohio State was indeed ranked #1 in the first 2023 CFP rankings released on October 31, 2023.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I want to see Michigan vs. Texas in the National Championship game

I want to see Michigan and Texas in the national championship. It would rule, I think that would be awesome to have a, a title game that doesn't have Alabama, Georgia, or Ohio State in it.

Michigan won the title, but Texas lost in the semi-final to Washington, so this specific matchup didn't happen.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

There are no superpower teams in college football this year

It feels like this college football season... No one's really that good... There's a lot of really good teams, but no superpower team, which I love.

Michigan went undefeated and won the title, though many games were close, confirming there wasn't a 2019 LSU-level juggernaut until the very end.
Void
Brian HoyerBrian Hoyer

Penn State is the toughest place to play in the Big 10

I'm gonna go with Penn State... that place... you're kind of like out in this middle of nowhere... and I think two out of the three times I played there was like a whiteout... that's a tough hostile environment to play.

Commonly debated, but Beaver Stadium whiteouts are widely regarded by players and coaches as the most difficult atmosphere.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The PAC-12 is currently the most dominant conference in the country

The lead story right now is the PAC 12 is the most dominant conference in the country. They have eight teams in the top 25 right now... It's insane to me that the PAC 12 has been around for a hundred years and they just timed it two years too late.

The Pac-12 had a historic final season, sending Washington to the National Championship, though the conference did indeed dissolve.
Win
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Notre Dame will cover -20.5 against Navy in Ireland

I kind of like Notre Dame to cover against Navy. And I realize it's 20 and a half. But I, I'm, I'm excited to see Sam Hartman in that Notre Dame offense.

Notre Dame defeated Navy 42-3, easily covering the 20.5-point spread.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Larry Scott is the primary villain responsible for the death of the Pac-12

Larry Scott is the big villain in all this. Larry Scott, when they brought him in, they were like, 'this guy is a visionary. He understands the future of sports better than anybody.' Basically, his vision was just fucking everything up and making everybody hate 'em.

Larry Scott is almost universally cited by analysts and fans as the key figure whose decisions led to the Pac-12's demise.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers