Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Maxx Crosby to the Ravens is a great move that makes their defense scary

Congrats to the Ravens. Congrats to Jesse Minter. This is a good, a great move. Their defense is gonna be scary. I love the transition from Maxx Crosby was always meant to be playing in a badass uniform. Raiders to Ravens, it's like, okay.

The Crosby-to-Ravens trade was real when this episode aired, and the defensive fit was sound. However, the trade was rescinded days later due to a failed physical.
Push
Chris BermanChris Berman

The Seahawks will beat the Patriots 26-17 in Super Bowl 60

I would, I made the spread five... Somewhere in the game there will be a one yard touchdown run by the Seahawks... I had, and we can massage it, 26 17... Seventeens a normal score. I like to make it enough. Three or four. So that opposite... who's covering. I just think Seattle's [going to win].

Berman correctly picked the Seahawks to win, but predicted 26-17. Actual score was 29-13 - a bigger blowout than expected.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Super Bowl 60 is a quintessential Mike Vrabel game - his underdog record as 3+ point underdog is above .500

I do think that Vrabel is going to take a little bit of that personally, not that he needs extra motivation. This is a quintessential Mike Vrabel game. Mike Vrabel has an underdog. If he's an underdog of three points or more this year, he's been two and oh in those games. His lifetime record in those games is above 500 as an underdog. They gave Mike Vrabel a Mike Vrabel game at the Super Bowl.

Vrabel's coaching and underdog mentality were real strengths (14-3, AFCCG win), but the Patriots still lost the Super Bowl 13-29.
Push
HankHank

The Seahawks will smoke the Rams in the NFC Championship

I also think Rams or Bears are getting smoked by the Seahawks. [Watching them on Saturday night], the thought definitely crossed my mind as like, I don't know how the Bears [or Rams] could potentially do anything against the Seahawks defense in Seattle.

Hank predicted the Seahawks would 'smoke' the Rams in the NFC Championship. The Seahawks did beat the Rams 31-27, but it was a close, competitive game decided in the final seconds — not a smoking. Correct on the winner, wrong on the margin.
Push
HankHank

The Patriots can beat any defense with their current offense

I just think offenses are a strong suit. I think [the Patriots] can beat any defense and I'd rather be playing a team that is known for their really good defense than their really good offense.

The Patriots beat the Broncos' elite defense 10-7 in the AFCCG but lost to the Seahawks' elite defense 13-29 in the Super Bowl. They could beat some elite defenses but not all.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Giants should hire Mike Tomlin

I could see the Giants doing it. This feels like a Giants move. The Giants crave stability. They want Daddy Tomlin to come in and whip him into shape. I don't think it'd be a terrible hire.

The Giants contacted Tomlin during their search, but he declined and is not coaching in 2026. They hired Harbaugh instead.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McDaniel will land a top offensive coordinator job immediately with a team like the Lions, Eagles, or Commanders.

Mike McDaniel is going to get a job instantly and he might get an awesome job. And by that I mean, how would you like coaching the offense of the Detroit Lions? Oh. How would you like coaching the offense of the Philadelphia Eagles? How would you like coaching the offense of the Kansas City Chiefs? How about coaching the offense of the Baltimore Ravens? There are some—oh, and the Washington Commanders.

Big Cat was correct that McDaniel would get a top OC job immediately, but wrong about the specific teams. McDaniel did not go to the Lions, Eagles, or Commanders as specifically named. He was hired by the Chargers as OC. The prediction that he'd land an 'awesome job' quickly was accurate, but none of the five teams Big Cat listed were correct.
Push
Steve YoungSteve Young

Super Bowl prediction: Seattle Seahawks vs. Denver Broncos

I think I, I have, if I was just a gun to my head... I think I'd say Seattle, Denver, I think I'd go chalk. I just, I being at home... defensively both of those squads are showing up with a defense that is elite.

Seattle made and won the Super Bowl (correct). But Denver lost in the AFCCG to New England. SB was Seahawks vs Patriots.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Rams are the overall favorite to win the NFC

I also don't think it's that hot of a take to say that the Rams could, I don't know what the odds are right now, but they feel to me like they might be, in my mind, the favorite to win the NFC.

The Rams were strong (12-5, NFCCG), but the Seahawks (14-3, SB champs) were the true NFC favorites. Rams were close but not THE favorite.
Push
Steve YoungSteve Young

The Super Bowl will be Seattle vs. Denver

I think I'd say Seattle, Denver. I think I'd go chalk. I just, being at home, I don't know. And defensively both of those squads are showing up with a defense that is elite. Elite.

Seattle made the Super Bowl (correct), but Denver did not. The Broncos lost to the Patriots in the AFCCG. SB was Seattle vs New England.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I believe in the Denver Broncos more than any team in the AFC

I believe, as much as I have my doubts about the Broncos, I think I believe in them more than any team in the AFC. So I guess that makes, I guess I'm a Bronco believer... I might just bet on the Broncos to make it to the Super Bowl 'cause I, again, there's a lot of fault in all these other teams.

The Broncos were the #1 AFC seed (13-3) and beat the Bills in the Div Round. But they lost to the Patriots in the AFCCG 7-10.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks should try to lose in Week 18 to ensure a Super Bowl trip via the Pope correlation

2005 new Pope is elected... Seahawks win 13 games advance to the Super Bowl. 2013 new Pope is elected... Seahawks win 13 games, win the Super Bowl. 2025 new Pope is elected Seahawks win 13 games and... Should the Seahawks try to lose on Sunday to stay at 13 games so that it guarantees they at least get to the Super Bowl?

The historical dates and game counts for 2005 and 2013 are correct. The 2025 outcome is speculative.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trevor Lawrence should be in the MVP conversation if the Jaguars secure the number one seed

Trevor Lawrence right now is maybe in the MVP conversation if they get to one seed. He's playing that good. He's playing as good as any quarterback in the NFL right now.

PFT said Trevor Lawrence should be in the MVP conversation if the Jags get the 1 seed. Lawrence was indeed named an MVP finalist after leading the Jaguars to 13-4 and the AFC South title. However, the Jaguars did NOT get the 1 seed (they were the 3 seed; Denver was the AFC 1 seed). Lawrence was in the MVP conversation but without the 1 seed condition being met.
Push
Ryan FitzpatrickRyan Fitzpatrick

My top five most trusted teams for the 2025 playoffs are the Rams, Bills, Texans, Patriots, and 49ers

The Rams, the Bills, Houston, New England and San Francisco. ... If you ask me next week if the Seahawks win this game versus the Rams, they'll move into being able to be trusted. But you know, just like Shane Steichen, I got trust issues.

Fitzpatrick's top 5 trusted playoff teams were the Rams, Bills, Texans, Patriots, and 49ers. All five made the playoffs. The Patriots made it to the Super Bowl, and the Rams made the NFC Championship. However, the Seahawks (who won it all) and Bears were not on his list. Since all 5 of his teams did make the playoffs and some went deep, this is partially correct.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The 49ers are sneaking up on people as a potential number one seed

The 49ers are better than Titans. ... People aren't talking about the 49ers, but the 49ers... if the 49ers win out, they will be the one seed. ... They definitely are sneaking up on people.

The 49ers had a strong 2025 season (approximately 12-5) and made the playoffs as a Wild Card, but they did not become the #1 seed. The Seahawks won the NFC West. The 49ers lost to the Seahawks 41-6 in the Divisional Round.
Push
Dan OrlovskyDan Orlovsky

The Rams are a top Super Bowl contender because their QB/WR connection is 'stupid'

Teams that I truly believe can win at number one Rams... there's no quarterback wide receiver group right now that sees it the same way consistently. The throws and the catches are stupid right now.

The Rams were top contenders (12-5, NFCCG) with Stafford winning MVP. But they lost in the NFCCG to Seattle.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Liam Coen should be in the Coach of the Year conversation for his turnaround of the Jaguars' offense.

Liam Coen is, he should be in the conversation for Coach of the Year. He's completely turned around this team and this offense in a way that feels real and meaningful and sustainable. He's a good coach.

Coen did not win Coach of the Year (it went to Curt Cignetti or an NFL HC), but he was widely praised for Lawrence's development.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Texans will win out, finish 12-5, and be the most dangerous team in the AFC playoffs.

I think the Texans are go 12 and 5. I think they're in the most dangerous team in the AFC right now in terms of just their defense.

The Texans finished 11-6, just missing the 12-5 mark.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Jaguars vs. Colts matchups are essentially a two-game series to determine the NFL Coach of the Year.

I think that this is Leg one of the home and home coach of the year series. ... I think that a sweep, a sweep goes a long way here. ... Liam Coen's done an incredible job.

PFT called the Jaguars vs Colts matchups a 'Coach of the Year series' between Liam Coen and Shane Steichen. Liam Coen finished 2nd in Coach of the Year voting (behind Vrabel), so the Jaguars' coach was indeed in the conversation. However, the Colts collapsed from 8-2 to 8-9, suggesting Steichen was not in the running. The take about Coen being a COTY candidate was validated.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Miles Garrett should be the NFL MVP if he breaks the all-time sack record

Miles Garrett should be the MVP if he breaks the all-time sacks record, which it looks like he's on pace to break/smash/shatter... If Miles Garrett does all this on the Browns, that's equivalent to Lawrence Taylor doing it on crack.

Garrett broke the sack record (23) and won DPOY. But he did not win MVP - Stafford did. A historic season but not MVP.
Push
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Los Angeles Rams are the most trustworthy team in the NFL right now

If you force me to pick one, I'd probably say the Rams. Matthew Stafford is playing at an MVP level. The defense is young, it's outstanding. ... I clearly trust the Rams more than anybody. I think they've been the most consistent team so far.

The Rams were one of the most trustworthy (12-5, MVP QB, NFCCG), but the Seahawks (14-3, SB champs) were ultimately more trustworthy.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams are a Super Bowl championship level team

I think the Rams are Super Bowl championship level team. 'Cause their defense is also elite... the Rams to me are the best team in the NFC right now.

The Rams were 12-5 and reached the NFCCG. Close to championship level but lost to Seahawks 27-31.
Push
MaxMax

The Lions are frauds who only score points against terrible teams

Every—this, it's a Lions suck fest because they score a lot of points against shitty fucking teams... This is just what the Lions do every fucking year. They score a lot of points against shitty fucking teams and everyone thinks that they're the best.

The Lions went 15-2 in 2024 and reached the NFC Championship, but missed the 2025 playoffs entirely, lending some credibility to the fraud label.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Buffalo Bills are officially broken

The bills are the bills. Okay. Because they have now dropped three of their last five games... The bills are broken. It was one of those games.

The Bills made the playoffs as the #6 seed and won a wild card game but lost in the Divisional Round to the Broncos 30-33. Not fully broken but not elite.
Push
HankHank

Drake Maye is a 'total package' and a 'cover two killer'

He's efficient. Accurate. Total package... Cover two killer. [I've] been watching a lot of film. Knows cover two.

Drake Maye had an excellent 2025 season (4,394 yards, 31 TDs, 72% completion rate), but 'total package' and 'cover two killer' may overstate his abilities at this point. He led the Patriots to 14-3 but lost the Super Bowl.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams are officially Super Bowl contenders.

The Rams are for real, for real. They basically are in the, can we get everyone healthy for the playoffs? Can we be healthy when the playoffs come around? ... Matthew Stafford is still just as good as ever. ... Super Bowl contenders.

The Rams were Super Bowl contenders (12-5, Stafford MVP, NFCCG) but lost to Seahawks 27-31 in the NFCCG.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Colts are a legitimately good football team

The Colts are just fucking good. I don't know what else I, I feel like people are waiting for the shoe to drop. The Colts are five in one... Peyton Manning played on some really good offenses. They're good man. They're good. I, again, I think people are just waiting for it to not work, but I think they're just really good.

The Colts finished 9-8 and missed the playoffs in 2024, so they weren't 'elite' but remained solid.
Push
HankHank

The Patriots vs. Bills game will be a shootout

I'm excited. I'm really excited. I think this game is gonna be a shootout. I think it's gonna, you know, Patriots are gonna have to get a little bit lucky, but it's gonna be a good test... One score. Yeah... I love the Patriots team total over, I love the regular over.

The final score was 27-24, which is a one-score game, but not necessarily a 'shootout' by modern NFL standards (Over/Under was 49.5, total was 51).
Push
MemesMemes

The Jets will not win a single game for the rest of the season

After last night's game, I don't think they're gonna win a game. I think they're gonna go... that team did not look like they could win a game.

The Jets finished 3-14, one of the worst records in the NFL. While they did win 3 games (not zero), they were essentially terrible for the rest of the season as Memes predicted.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers offense is for real now that Aaron Rodgers is getting the ball out fast

Steelers offense actually looked for real. Maybe this is what the Steelers offense is going to be, is Aaron Rodgers getting the ball out insanely fast. I think I saw the stat, it was 2.17 seconds to throw. He just was whipping it around. It didn't matter because the Steelers' offense looked better than it has in a while.

The offense led the Steelers to 10-7 and the AFC North title. But Rodgers was terrible in the playoff loss (17/33, 146 yards, pick-six).
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The future is now for the Giants with Jackson Dart and Abdul Carter

If you're a Giants fan, you gotta be pretty pumped about this win because you're like, holy shit, this defense might be legit and we might have a quarterback. Abdul Carter said it after the game. He said, 'the future is now' talking about him and Jackson Dart.

The Giants had a terrible 2025 season (Daboll fired at 2-8). While Dart and Carter may be promising long-term, the 'future is now' was premature.
Push
HankHank

Drake Maye has signs of playing better in year two than Tom Brady did

We got a long ways to go, but [Drake Maye] has signs, he plays better in year two than Brady did. Year two was a Super Bowl win, but he wasn't lighting it up as the quarterback.

Maye's stats (4,394 yards, 31 TDs) exceeded Brady's 2001 stats (2,843 yards, 18 TDs). But Brady won the Super Bowl while Maye lost it.
Push
Greg OlsenGreg Olsen

The Chargers are entering the conversation as a top-tier AFC team

This year does feel like the year that the Chargers enter, like, okay, are we now adding another top tier team to the AFC... it's the year that the Chargers now enter that conversation.

The Chargers made the playoffs as #7 seed but lost in the Wild Card 16-28 to Patriots. They entered the conversation but weren't top-tier.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers will make the playoffs and win a game this season

If we had to say right now, right now week three... Do the Pittsburgh Steelers make the playoffs? Yes. Yes. I would say so too. And I think they win a game.

The Steelers made the playoffs (10-7, AFC North champs, 4 seed) but did not win a playoff game, losing 30-6 to Houston in the Wild Card. The prediction was correct about making playoffs but incorrect about winning a game.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

CJ Stroud is secretly injured and that is why he is playing poorly

Is CJ Stroud hurt? Ooh, I don't know... remember he was having shoulder problems. And they said he's not having surgery, which is not what you want to hear unprompted going into a season... surgery just gets mentioned... he's been bad. Hard. He's been bad. Yeah. And I, I have no idea if he's hurt or not, but it seems like there's something that's fucked up about it.

CJ Stroud did regress significantly in 2025 (3,041 yards, 19 TDs, 8 INTs in 14 games vs 4,108 yards and 23 TDs as a rookie). Whether he was 'secretly injured' is unconfirmed, but his play declined notably.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Buffalo Bills are currently in a mode where they can casually beat teams by 10 points without playing perfectly

It does feel like the Bills are in that mode, that they don't have to play perfect. And they can still, they can still just kind of like casually beat you by 10 points.

The Bills did start 3-0 and were dominant in several early games, though they had lulls later in the season.
Push
ZacZac

The Chiefs' Mahomes and Andy Reid dynasty is finished

I just think the dynasty's over. I think Andy Reid and Mahomes dynasty's finished... usually when they pan the camera to Andy Reid, he's got a certain amount of girth... but this time it almost looks a little hollow. It looks a little empty.

The Chiefs did not return to the Super Bowl after losing LIX and have not been serious title contenders the last two seasons. The dynasty may indeed be over, though Mahomes is only 29.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Kansas City Chiefs are going to win their Week 2 game against the Eagles

I think Chiefs are gonna win this game... I'm just simply taking it because the Chiefs are 21 and 4 straight up off a loss with Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes. I just can't imagine them starting 0 and 2.

The Chiefs defeated the Bengals in Week 2, 2024. However, the take mentions playing the Eagles, who they did not play in Week 2. This is likely a scheduling error in the conversation or a misunderstanding of the opponent.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Jackson Dart will be starting for the Giants by Week 3

I don't understand why if your offensive line is bad, you would put a smaller quarterback who doesn't have the mobility he once had behind it... What week is Jackson Dart starting for the Giants? Three? Yeah, I would say three.

Jaxson Dart started for the Giants in Week 4 against the Chargers, not Week 3 as Big Cat predicted. Very close but one week off.
Push
Howie LongHowie Long

The Raiders and Broncos will surprise people and make the a FC West competitive

Pete Carroll coming to the Raiders and... I think they could surprise some people and make that division a lot more interesting. Denver I think is on its way up.

The a FC West remained dominated by the Chiefs, though Denver showed some improvement.
Push
Mike FlorioMike Florio

The Broncos and Chargers will give the Chiefs fits in the AFC West

I think the Broncos are gonna have their hands full. The Broncos look at how good that defense is. And we know what Sean Payton does with his offenses... Chargers... surprisingly good in the regular season. And and I'm never going to count out Pete Carroll... the Raiders are gonna get the Chiefs fits. I mean the Chiefs are gonna have their hands full this year.

Mike Florio predicted the Broncos and Chargers would give the Chiefs fits in the 2025 AFC West. In 2025, the Broncos won the AFC West (13-3) and the Chargers finished 2nd (11-6), while the Chiefs collapsed to 6-8 and were eliminated from playoff contention. However, he mistakenly mentioned the Raiders instead of properly identifying the Broncos/Chargers dynamic. The core prediction was correct - the Chiefs' reign ended.
Push
Mike FlorioMike Florio

The Dolphins, Browns, and Saints will be the three most disappointing teams

I would be very concerned if I was a fan of the Dolphins. I would be extremely concerned if I'm a fan of the Browns, I would find something else to do on Sunday if I was a fan of the Saints. Those are the three that come to mind.

The Dolphins (7-10, McDaniel fired) and Browns (5-12) were indeed very disappointing. The Saints had a rough season too. Two out of three were clearly among the most disappointing.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The AFC North is officially the 'division of quarterbacks' now that Joe Flacco is back

AFC North quarterbacks: Flacco, [Aaron] Rodgers, Lamar [Jackson], [Joe] Burrow. It's the division of quarterbacks. Listen, two guys have, the two old guys have Super Bowls. The young guys haven't done it.

The AFC North is indeed stacked with high-profile QBs, though Rodgers is in the AFC East. This is a common mix-up in the moment.
Push
ShaneShane

A patella tendon rupture is the worst injury because no player ever returns to 100%

This is the worst thing that can happen. There's been no player that's gone back to a hundred percent off this ever. Like, JC Jackson had the same injury and we know what happened to him.

While a very difficult injury, modern medicine has seen several players return to elite form after patellar ruptures (e.g., Jimmy Graham, though performance varied).
Push
Kevin ClarkKevin Clark

The Chargers will finish third in the AFC West but still make the playoffs

I think Jim Harbaugh is amazing. Yeah. So they'll probably win a bunch. I think they're probably gonna make the playoffs... I think they're, they are going to be third place in the division and like beat teams. They shouldn't or should whatever. And then, and then still like the Broncos... are too good.

Kevin Clark predicted the Chargers would finish third in the AFC West but still make the playoffs. In the 2025 season, the Chargers finished second (11-6), not third, and they did make the playoffs. The playoff prediction was correct but the third-place finish was wrong.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Vrabel will immediately set a no-nonsense tone as a consultant for the Patriots

Vrabel is back and it's no longer the Jerod Mayo. Did you guys see this clip of Mike Vrabel... He's a boss. He's just gonna be a boss. That's a tone set. That's a man that has teenage sons at home.

The Patriots finished 4-13 in 2024, the season this would apply to. While Vrabel's 'tone' is hard to quantify, the team results were poor.
Push
MemesMemes

Jayden Daniels will finish as the worst quarterback of the 2024 draft class in the upcoming 2025 season

The Washington Commanders are gonna miss the playoffs. Jayden Daniels [will] finish dead last out of the 2024 QBs in that draft class.

Memes predicted the Commanders would miss the playoffs (correct — they went 5-12) and Jayden Daniels would finish dead last among 2024 QBs. Daniels only played 7 games due to injuries and had the lowest total stats of the class, but this was due to injury absences, not poor play quality. The Commanders missing the playoffs was correct; the Daniels ranking is technically true by volume stats but misleading.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Caleb Williams is entering the best situation for a second-year quarterback in the history of the NFL

I truly believe this by the way. I think that the situation that Caleb Williams is in right now is the best situation in the history of second-year quarterbacks in the entire NFL. Think about it. They shored up the offensive line. They got rid of Matt Eberflus. That's good for six wins right there. They finally have a GM and a coach that are lined up on the same contract. They've got an offensive wizard at head coach who's got a bag that's deeper than the Mariana Trench.

While Williams had a strong support system, his rookie season and the transition to his second year were marred by offensive coaching changes and O-line struggles in reality.
Push
MaxMax

Jayden Daniels is already a top five quarterback in the NFL

You know what, Jayden Daniels doesn't even need Terry McLaurin, he's still a top five [QB]. You could put Jayden Daniels out with any receiving corps in the NFL, he's a top five quarterback.

By July 2025, Jayden Daniels had a historically great rookie season (OROY) and led the Commanders to the playoffs, but ranking him as a consensus 'top five' QB remains a bold, debatable take.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Longhaired quarterbacks have never won a Super Bowl in the history of the NFL

Longhaired quarterbacks have never won a Super Bowl. Never... Tom [Brady] when he lost [had long hair]. Longhaired quarterbacks never won the big one.

This is a debatable 'fact' depending on the definition of long hair (e.g., Namath, Stabler, or even Roethlisberger). It's famously used as a curse narrative on the show.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers