Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

UCF is the number one team and national champions

I've got UCF number one. Number one, national champions. The program that Blake Bortles built. Undefeated.

UCF was the only undefeated team and was recognized as national champions by the Colley Matrix, leading the NCAA to officially recognize the claim.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Big Ten won the bowl season

The first one is... the Big Ten. Won the bowl season. Many people are saying the Big Ten won the bowl season. Seven and one in bowls. And dominated, just dominated everyone.

The Big Ten went 7-1 in the 2017-18 bowl season.
Win
Geoff SchwartzGeoff Schwartz

Chip Kelly won't be as successful in his return to college because his system is no longer unique

Chip's going to... coaching in college football again. You think he's going to be just as good as he was the second time around? Probably not. Think about it. Everyone now runs what we ran in college. We were the first team to do this up-tempo, spread offense... Now everybody does it... So he is not going to be coming into a situation with a brand-new concept.

Chip Kelly went 35-34 at UCLA, never reaching the heights he achieved at Oregon.
Win
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Josh Rosen is too smart to play for the Cleveland Browns

Between him leaking out that he doesn't want to play for the Browns and between his answer about why he's sitting out and why some players do sit out, I feel like he's way too smart to end up in Cleveland.

The Browns passed on Rosen and took Baker Mayfield. Rosen went to the Cardinals and struggled significantly.
Win
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

The under is the best bet for the LSU vs. Notre Dame Citrus Bowl

I like the under in that game more than anything, although I do think Notre Dame's going to win... I like the under more than anything, just because I think it's going to be kind of a rock fight more than most.

The final score was 21-17, staying well under the 51.5 total.
Win
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Alabama will win the National Championship

My heart wants to say Oklahoma, but my head says Alabama, just because, like I've said, I think Alabama's the best team in the country... I just don't think anybody's beating Alabama this year... I think they're going to finish as national title champions once again.

Alabama defeated Georgia in the championship game.
Win
Jim RossJim Ross

Baker Mayfield is the best college quarterback in many years

They have arguably the best quarterback we've seen in college football in many, many years. [Baker Mayfield] is a natural [heel]... He should win the Heisman Trophy.

Mayfield did win the Heisman in 2017 and is widely considered an all-time great college QB.
Win
Matt LeinartMatt Leinart

Baker Mayfield is going to win the Heisman Trophy

TMZ video... I think he's got probably a great shot at winning. I can't confirm or deny [my vote], but I think he's got probably a great shot at winning.

Baker Mayfield won the 2017 Heisman Trophy.
Win
Matt LeinartMatt Leinart

Josh Rosen is a more refined and natural thrower than Sam Darnold

I think you look at Josh Rosen. Rosen is really refined. He's a great thrower. He's got a great arm, but he's a natural thrower. Sam [Darnold] is a little more funky, a little more unrefined, but a different type of player.

This matches the scouting consensus at the time regarding Rosen's mechanics vs Darnold's playmaking ability.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin will never win a national championship because they don't get fast five-star recruits

I'm sticking with what Wisconsin has, even though I know in my heart of hearts they'll never get the fast guys, they'll never get the really good guys, so they'll never win.

Wisconsin has not won a national championship since this take and continues to struggle with elite speed/recruiting compared to SEC/Big Ten elites.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Alabama is a better team than Ohio State regardless of the committee's logic

The only thing I care about, I actually have no problem with Alabama being in because I do think that they're a better team than Ohio State. I just think the committee is full of fucking shit. At the end of the day, all that fucking matters is losses and big losses. And if Ohio State doesn't lose by 31 to Iowa, they're in.

Alabama went on to win the National Championship, supporting the claim that they were the better team than an Ohio State squad that was excluded.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Leach was born to coach in the SEC

When he was at Kentucky, he used to try to get horses to drink beer... He was born to coach in the SEC. I can't wait for it. Coach Leach, you're our guy.

Mike Leach eventually did move to the SEC (Mississippi State) in 2020 and was a perfect cultural fit until his passing.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Arizona State AD only hired Herm Edwards because they fell for agent posturing

Herm Edwards did the thing where we say that, you know, the agents all every couple of years throw a name out there just to make their guys ego. And then they threw the name out there and Arizona State's like, wait, we'll take Herm Edwards.

The hire was widely ridiculed as a 'leadership' experiment that eventually failed after an NCAA investigation and poor results.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin will lose the Big Ten Championship in heartbreaking fashion because of Alex Hornibrook

One side of my brain says that Wisconsin has everything they need to win this game. The other side of my brain says Hornibrook's going to have to make four or five passes in key points... and he's not going to be able to. And we're going to lose in heartbreaking fashion.

This was extremely prescient. Wisconsin lost 27-21, and Hornibrook threw two critical interceptions in a game they had a chance to win late.
Win
Blake BortlesBlake Bortles

Undefeated mid-majors like UCF should be in a 16-team playoff

As a mid-major school, it's tough with the way the system is now to get a chance to get into the college football playoffs. I think they should do it like how they do the 1AA or the FCS or whatever it's called, like a 16-team playoff. Because then you give them a chance, you never know until they go play the Power Five conference teams.

College football expanded to a 12-team playoff starting in the 2024-25 season, giving mid-major/Group of Five teams a better path to compete. Bortles' argument for expanding the playoff to give mid-majors a chance was vindicated by the eventual expansion.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Blind resume season is going to be tough on Wisconsin's CFP chances

Blind resume season is going to be tough on Wisconsin. That's going to be bad luck. It's going to be like, here are four teams that have beaten three top ten teams, and then there's Wisconsin that has beaten a team ranked number 80.

Wisconsin finished the regular season 12-0 but remained at #4 until losing the Big Ten Title game to Ohio State, which ultimately kept them out of the playoff. The 'blind resume' was indeed their biggest hurdle.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Lane Kiffin definitely knows the spread and plays to it

I've said this for many years, that Lane Kiffin is one of the only coaches that I will put my fucking life on it, that he knows the spread and plays to the spread. He used to do it at Tennessee, too, where he would go for two in random spots. I know Lane Kiffin knows the spread.

Kiffin has all but confirmed this over the years with his tweets and bizarre late-game decisions (e.g., the safety at the end of the 2017 WKU game).
Win
Mike PereiraMike Pereira

Targeting fouls in college football are up 40% this year and it is hurting the game

The rule makers have to be concerned when they look at the fact that the number of fouls for targeting are up 40% this year. I mean, that's a big number. That's a big number that leads to longer games and really more questionable decisions.

NCAA statistics from the 2017 season confirmed a significant spike in targeting ejections compared to 2016.
Win
JS
Jim Sorgi

Wisconsin will never have another quarterback reach the level of Russell Wilson

Ever since Russell Wilson came and spent that one year there and everything he's done, you're never going to have a quarterback again that's going to kind of get to that level I don't think.

While Wisconsin has had decent QBs since, none have approached Wilson's NFL success or collegiate efficiency as of 2024.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin will lose in the Big Ten Championship game this year

Wisconsin, this is their year. Oh, yeah. They're probably going to lose in the Big Ten championship this year.

Wisconsin went 12-0 in the regular season but lost 27-21 to Ohio State in the Big Ten Championship game.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Sam Darnold isn't actually good, he just throws 'good looking' interceptions

I also have a theory that I'm working on that Sam Darnold's not actually good, but his interceptions look good. So even when he makes a bad play, you're like, this guy's good.

Darnold's NFL career has been defined by high interception numbers (legacy 'good looking' bad plays), validating the spirit of this take.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

USC football is officially back.

USC is back. Is USC back? USC is back. [Jake Olson]: USC is back.

USC went 11-3 in 2017, winning the Pac-12 Championship and finishing in the top 12 of the AP poll, which was their best season in nearly a decade.
Win
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Oklahoma will beat Ohio State 28-21

I'm going to say 28-21 Oklahoma [over Ohio State]. ... It's going to suck, but I got to be confident, you know. You got to support your squad.

Oklahoma actually won this game 31-16 on September 9, 2017 (the episode aired just after the game happened, but the interview was recorded before).
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Texas can never lose to Maryland in football

[Texas], you can't lose to Maryland in football. No, you can't do it. You can't.

Texas lost to Maryland in both 2017 and 2018.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ohio State has a 0% chance of losing to Indiana

I said, nope, I'm just going to say it on the show. There's a 0% chance Ohio State loses this game [to Indiana]. So now if it happens, it'll be funny.

Ohio State won the game 49-21 on August 31, 2017.
Win
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Nick Saban smiles for less than two minutes after winning a national championship

Oh, fellas, you said two minutes. I'd take the under. I really would. That's a lock of the decade. Because even after we won the national championship, in the locker room, not kidding, we have the crystal ball in hand... He went into the locker room and said, 'hey, guys, great job... you know that's not how we play in the second half.'

Anecdotal but widely corroborated by other former Alabama players.
Win
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

I was carried by my defense while playing quarterback at Alabama

The national championship ring still meant something because I knew that I was carried by my defense, so just being a good teammate was a big part of what I wanted to do that year.

The 2009 Alabama defense was historically elite, allowing only 11.7 points per game. McElroy was a solid game manager, but the defense was the primary engine.
Win
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Under 4.5 SEC teams will finish in the AP Top 10

Over, under, four and a half [SEC] teams in the top 10 at the end of the season? I'm going to lean towards the under... I'm going to jump wholeheartedly on the under four and a half teams in the top ten.

The final AP Top 10 featured only three SEC teams (Alabama, Georgia, Auburn).
Win
Sean SalisburySean Salisbury

The Texas Longhorns are not a nine-win team yet and are at least a year away from contending

I don't think they're [Texas] a nine-win team this year. I think they're about a year away... I don't think they're a top-ten team. They may be a little bit overrated.

Texas went 7-6 in 2017, falling short of 9 wins, but won 10 games the following year.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ralphie the Buffalo is actually a female

People forget Ralphie's actually a woman. I knew I was right. Ralphie has been called one of the best live mascots in sports, and she is often erroneously labeled male.

The University of Colorado uses female bison for Ralphie because they are smaller, less aggressive, and more manageable than males.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Ole Miss will return to sucking at football now that they can't cheat under Hugh Freeze

Hugh Freeze is out, and it looks like Ole Miss is going to have to start playing it above the board here. No more cheating. So they're going to suck at football again.

Ole Miss did see a decline, going 6-6, 5-7, and 4-8 over the next three seasons before recovering under Lane Kiffin.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Coach Ed Orgeron once held a live worm in his mouth for an entire speech to fire up his team

Today, a story came out that Coach O had a live worm in his mouth for an entire speech to his team. He said it was just to fire up the team... He said, I do whatever it takes to feed my family. Whatever it takes to win, I'll do the same thing. He then, after that line, pulled out a wiggling worm from his mouth that he had had in his mouth the entire speech.

This story has been confirmed by multiple former players and is a well-known part of Orgeron's coaching lore.
Win
Bob StoopsBob Stoops

Lincoln Riley is the right character and guy to lead Oklahoma forward

Lincoln's the right guy. He's got all the right attributes and character to be the guy to continue to lead the program forward. And I knew that. And I believed strongly that the administration would believe that as well.

Lincoln Riley was highly successful at Oklahoma, winning four consecutive Big 12 titles and making three College Football Playoff appearances before leaving for USC.
Win
Bob StoopsBob Stoops

Adrian Peterson was the clear alpha on the team from the day he arrived at Oklahoma

That guy from the day he walked on campus... he was the man. I mean, you know it, right? You know something's up when all the seniors come through your office, they're like 'Coach, have you seen him?'... he was running the show from the day he stepped on campus.

Adrian Peterson rushed for nearly 2,000 yards as a true freshman and was a Heisman runner-up, confirming he was immediately 'the man'.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Gundy has decided to be a crazy person for the rest of his career as a branding move

I think what happened was he went out and he saw how good it felt to say something crazy and be perceived as like a crazy dangerous person in public that he's like you know what I'm just going to be fucking nuts for the rest of my career that's my brand that's what I'm going with I'm going to out crazy Mike Leach.

Gundy has continued to lean into his unique persona, including the mullet and various rants, supporting this theory.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Baker Mayfield will get NFL starts solely because he has an all-time great name

I'm going to put a little flyer on Baker Mayfield. You guys know I'm a big name guy. All-time name. That name is going to get him some starts in the NFL. People are going to take some shots with Baker Mayfield solely because of his name.

Correct, though for reasons beyond his name. Mayfield became the #1 overall pick and has started many games for the Browns, Panthers, Rams, and Buccaneers.
Win
Mike GolicMike Golic

Brian Kelly knows he is on the hot seat at Notre Dame

Brian Kelly knows that he's on the hot seat. I mean, the people in the facility, the players and the coaches know that if they don't improve, things are going to change. So going into this year, Brian Kelly knows that he has to improve, and hopefully they can.

Kelly was objectively on the hot seat after a 4-8 season in 2016, but he successfully improved the program immediately after.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alabama could win 10 games with my dick as offensive coordinator

At the very least, Chip's going to win 10 games at Alabama because Alabama could win 10 games with my dick at offensive coordinator.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
While anatomically impossible, Alabama did continue to win 10+ games annually, proving the point about their program's floor.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If a coach with personal issues wants to rehab their career, they should go work for Nick Saban

This is PR 101 in general for any coaches out there who might have a drinking problem... Lane Kiffin looking at you. If you want to be rehabbed, go to Nick Saban. Let Nick Saban scream in your face in front of the nation on Saturday afternoons on CBS... and you'll be back on track.

Steve Sarkisian, Lane Kiffin, and many others successfully used Alabama as a platform to secure new high-profile head coaching roles.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Butch Jones' 'five-star hearts' recruiting philosophy is a spin for missing out on actual talent

Butch Jones, Tennessee, they're back... Butch Jones said this after maybe a less than stellar recruiting class: 'We want five-star hearts and five-star competitors.' So he's not looking for five-star recruits. He's looking for five-star hearts.

Butch Jones' tenure at Tennessee ended shortly after due to poor results, proving 'five-star hearts' don't win as much as five-star recruits.
Win
Paul FinebaumPaul Finebaum

Picking Alabama to win every game isn't being a homer, it's just being smart

The reason I like Alabama, and don't laugh, I've picked Alabama in every single game since the Iron Bowl in 2010... And that doesn't make me a homer. It just makes me smart. Because you guys know how many times Alabama has won since 2011.

Alabama had a .900+ winning percentage during this period, making 'always pick Alabama' a statistically sound strategy.
Win
Paul FinebaumPaul Finebaum

I would bet against Michigan making the College Football Playoff in the near future

I wouldn't lock that down. I mean, it's possible, but I'm not going to be one of these, well, anything's possible. Well, not really. I would probably bet against Michigan [making the final four].

Michigan did not make the College Football Playoff until 2021, proving Finebaum correct for several 'near future' seasons.
Win
Paul FinebaumPaul Finebaum

Nick Saban seriously considered taking the Texas head coaching job

I know he seriously considered going to Texas. I reported in a book that I did... that a group of Texas supporters floated a hundred million dollar offer to him. ...I think he listened.

While Saban never confirmed he was close to leaving, multiple reputable sources besides Finebaum have corroborated that serious talks occurred.
Win
Paul FinebaumPaul Finebaum

Nick Saban owns Mercedes dealerships in Alabama and Tennessee

[Saban] does own two Mercedes dealerships... one in Birmingham and... he owns one in Nashville. He's a part owner of them. I don't mean to say he's a total silent owner... it's public.

It is a matter of public record that Nick Saban is a co-owner of several 'Mercedes-Benz of Birmingham' and other dealerships.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Herbstreit's take on players sitting out bowl games is invalid because he wasn't an NFL prospect

[Kirk Herbstreit] forgot to mention the fact that he only started one season at Ohio State and he wasn't good enough to play in the NFL, so that wasn't even an option for him.

Herbstreit did only start one season and did not play in the NFL, making Big Cat's critique of his perspective factually grounded.
Win
Dana HolgorsenDana Holgorsen

The Big 12 needs a championship game to avoid being shunned by the playoff committee

The 13th game. That's important. ... if [Oklahoma] could have won their last nine games and then played in a championship game, another high-profile game, I think matters. Those guys that play 13 games and they get hot, they have an opportunity to be able to move up. And the Big 12 has fixed that. So next year at this time we'll be playing a championship game.

The Big 12 did indeed reinstate their championship game in 2017 to help their playoff chances.
Win
Dave WannstedtDave Wannstedt

Neither Penn State nor Wisconsin will make the College Football Playoff

No, neither team is going to get in [to the Final Four]. And the committee, let me tell you how this works... they wouldn't have put Michigan at number five if they really were anticipating putting the winner of this game in.

Correct. Penn State won the Big Ten but was ranked #5, missing the playoff. Wisconsin also missed.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Penn State will win the Big Ten Championship game

I like Penn State. I know you didn't ask me, but I'm going to go on the record and say Penn State, and then nothing else changes in the Final Four.

Correct. Penn State won the game and the playoff top four remained unchanged.
Win
Dave WannstedtDave Wannstedt

Ohio State and Clemson are the only teams with the speed to match up with Alabama

Athletically they [Ohio State] had the players to match up with Alabama. And I think right now that Clemson fits in that same mold... Ohio State could [match up], and I think Clemson could also.

Clemson defeated Alabama in the 2017 National Championship, proving they had the speed and talent to match up.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Every team that has ever made the College Football Playoff has been a Nike school

Every team that's made the college football playoffs is a Nike school. A little bit of a conspiracy. Turns out every school is a Nike school pretty much.

At the time of the take (Dec 2016), every CFP participant (Bama, Oregon, FSU, OSU, Clemson, MSU, Oklahoma, Washington) was indeed a Nike-sponsored school.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers