Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Peter King should have his driver's license revoked

It's time to start asking, should Peter King have a license? He should have his license revoked. I agree with that. He is a menace. He's a threat.

Peter King did not have his license revoked, though the hosts maintained this was a matter of public safety.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Adam Schefter is an undercover warlock casting spells through the media

I can't think of a story I'm rooting for more than Adam Schefter to be an undercover witch... Could you imagine if he's just casting spells on people?... Two cell phones. One of them is a magic wand. And that's why he does the whole like, oh, I have to pee every 10 minutes to make himself seem un-witch-like.

Hot TakeMediaScorchingSarcastic
Adam Schefter is a human journalist and does not possess magical powers.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Francesa invented the concept of a podcast co-host

He invented co-hosts. Mike Francesa, in addition to Daily Fantasy, has invented co-hosts. My idea.

Fact ClaimMediaMildSarcastic
The statement is factually incorrect and intended as a joke.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Witten's return to the NFL is a genius move to save his broadcasting legacy

What Jason Witten has just pulled off... with the one year of broadcasting that he did. And he was bad. He was very bad. He is now going back to the NFL, and now he can forever be the guy where, well, he never got his second year, so we don't know. The jury's still out on whether or not Jason Witten is bad, and history will be kind to him and not mock him.

Witten is widely remembered as a poor broadcaster on MNF despite his return to the field, so history was not as kind as Big Cat predicted.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tony Romo is receiving the coordinators' play-call audio in his earpiece during broadcasts

I know someone who works for the CBS football production team, and CBS is pulling play-call audio and hot routes from the same radio channel that the coordinators send to play into the QB's helmet. They direct the audio into Romo's earpiece, and he appears to know all the calls beforehand.

This is factually incorrect; Romo's 'precognition' was based on his high-level study of tape and defensive alignments, which he has explained in numerous interviews.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Our next breaking news scoop is 100% guaranteed to be correct

The next piece of news that we break, 100% guarantee that it's correct. 100%. We are not going to take any more risks. We're going to get back in the winning streak.

Their track record remained hit-or-miss as intended for a comedy show.
Loss
HankHank

Lacrosse is the sport of the future and will surpass baseball

My cool throne is lacrosse... My other hot seat could have been baseball because lacrosse is coming for that America's Pastime, sport of the future. Premier Lacrosse League was announced. TV deal... This sounds like a real dud. No, this is going to be great.

The PLL has survived and grown, but lacrosse has not surpassed baseball as 'America's Pastime.'
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jason Witten and Booger McFarland are definitely going to fight

[Big Cat] Do you think Booger McFarland and Jason Witten are going to fight? [PFT Commenter] Yes. I do too. Absolutely. If you listen to the first quarter of that game, it was ridiculous. Like they were going into the next play of the game, still trying to get the last word over each other.

While the booth was notoriously dysfunctional and was eventually broken up, no physical fight between Witten and McFarland ever occurred.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jason Witten will be on the Booger Mobile by the end of the season

Bold prediction. Jason Witten's going to be on the Booger Mobile by the end of the season. They should put him both on the Booger Mobile.

Witten stayed in the booth for the duration of the season and did not join Booger on the sideline crane.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NASA is only calling Pluto 'not a planet' to stay in the news

That was such a fucking classic. Is Pluto a planet? That was a classic NASA, like, we don't have enough shit to do, so we're going to make Pluto not a planet, and then in a few months we're going to be like, actually, just kidding, it is a planet... NASA likes to keep their name in the press.

Hot TakeMediaHotSarcastic
This is a satirical theory about scientific classification; there is no evidence NASA manipulates planetary status for PR.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jimmy Pitaro will eventually go to Mike Golic with his hat in his hand for a Mike and Mike reunion

There's going to be a Mike and Mike reunion. It's going to happen. Jimmy [Pitaro] is going to go to Mike Golic with his hat in his hand and say, Mike, we screwed up.

A full Mike and Mike reunion on ESPN never occurred; the show remained defunct.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A Mike and Mike reboot would be worth signing a new contract with ESPN for

I will sign another contract with ESPN if it's to work on the reboot of Mike and Mike. There we go.

OpinionMediaMediumSarcastic
The reboot never happened and the hosts never returned to ESPN in this capacity.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Skip Bayless will blame LeBron James for destroying the American education system

Skip Bayless for saying that LeBron James is destroying the American educational system by making children stay up too late to watch West Coast games. Ruining America's future. He'll deputize himself to be the watchdog and guardian of America.

PredictionMediaFireSarcastic
While Skip Bayless consistently critiqued LeBron's move to LA, he never literally blamed him for the collapse of the US education system on air.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Stephen A. Smith is using the N-word on air to get ESPN to fire him so he can reunite with Skip Bayless

I also have a theory that Stephen A. Smith is just trying to get broken up with at ESPN because he misses Skip Bayless so much... God bless the broken road that will eventually lead Stephen A. Smith back to skip. And if he has to drop the in-bomb a couple times on the air, so be it.

Hot TakeMediaScorchingSarcastic
They eventually did reunite on First Take (Skip as guest) and social media, but not because Stephen A. was fired for this reason.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Journalists should be allowed to punch each other because of 'freedom of the press'

There's a little thing out there called freedom of the press, which means that journalists are allowed to do whatever they want... and say whatever they want, and you can't do anything about it. So they arrested this guy for just being a reporter.

OpinionMediaHotSarcastic
The First Amendment does not grant immunity for physical assault.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

ESPN should hire Curt Schilling and Keith Olbermann for a PTI-style debate show

Politics are big now. Trump is huge. Pick a side. ... hire a PTI-style debate show with Curt Schilling and Keith Olbermann. And just like the MJ-LeBron debate comes up every day, just do a Colin Kaepernick debate every single day. People want to hear that.

ESPN explicitly moved away from politics under Pitaro, doing the opposite of this satirical advice.
Loss
Joe BuckJoe Buck

I won't be the play-by-play announcer for Thursday Night Football on Fox

[Are you going to do Thursday Night Football this year?] No. ... I think they want their own identity. ... We would have to do 11. And then I've got the baseball playoffs at the beginning when that whole thing kicks in. So I think it would be tough to do.

Fox did eventually use Buck and Aikman for their TNF package starting in 2018, contradicting his initial 'No'.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The WatchESPN app allows the network to spy on you inside your house

Alex Jones thinks that Bill Walton was being 100% serious... It would also be great if Bill Walton accidentally exposed this, and ESPN was trying not to let this out, and he was just off on one of his weird trips, and he unwittingly uncovered the most giant conspiracy in the history of cable television.

Hot TakeMediaHotSarcastic
There is no evidence the WatchESPN app uses device cameras for unauthorized surveillance of users' homes.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Super Bowl National Anthem will go over two minutes

So I'm taking the over [on the national anthem] just because you don't want to root for the under in the national anthem. That's pretty much treason, right?

Pink's national anthem at Super Bowl LII lasted approximately 1 minute and 52 seconds, meaning the under hit.
Loss
HankHank

Bill Belichick will become the commissioner of Lacrosse to take down the NFL

Bill Belichick hates the NFL, hates Roger Goodell... He's going to become the commissioner of lacrosse. He knows. He sees the writing on the wall. The NFL is going to be dead soon. Concussions. Everyone's going to stop playing... then he's going to start recruiting the best football minds to lacrosse... he goes on top as the best coach of all time [by taking down the NFL].

Bill Belichick did not become the commissioner of Lacrosse and the NFL is still the dominant sport in America.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

The National Championship TV ratings are going to suck

The ratings are going to suck. There's no question the ratings are going to suck. Because outside of this quarter of the country, people just don't care.

The 2018 title game actually saw a significant ratings increase over the previous year, fueled by the drama of the overtime finish.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL Network should hire Jeff Fisher to bring them back to mediocrity

Jeff Fisher, he brings the mediocrity back. So you're going from low... To right in the middle. I think Jeff Fisher's the perfect hire.

Hot TakeMediaMediumSarcastic
Satirical recommendation; Fisher was never hired as a lead analyst there.
Loss
Anthony ScaramucciAnthony Scaramucci

The Scaramucci Post will eventually turn into a revolutionary site

the Scaramucci Post is going to turn into a revolutionary site over time. And I think it will be an intersection on a highway of extremism in our polarized society. And so, you know, give it a couple months. You'll see. There'll be great things on that.

The Scaramucci Post did not become a 'revolutionary site'; it mostly remained a Twitter account and eventually pivoted into a podcast and general media presence for Scaramucci without changing the media landscape.
Loss
Dan PatrickDan Patrick

I will likely retire from the radio show within the next five years

Three or four. Five, maybe. Maybe five. I don't know. Maybe six. No. No more than five more years.

Incorrect. Patrick did not retire within five years; as of 2024, he is still actively hosting The Dan Patrick Show and recently signed a multi-year extension.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Instant replay should be abolished in sports

I think we should actually get rid of instant replay. All together, just give it all the power back to the refs and the umps... I feel like I watch instant replays more than I watch sports now.

Replay has only expanded since 2017, making this take incorrect in terms of the direction of sports.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The 'Golden Age' of podcasts is over now that people are making wedding planning podcasts

The couple that met because one was a fan of his podcast and then they're getting married and they're creating a podcast together about going through the wedding planning. That right there is like if you could think of the most stereotypical podcast podcast. It is over, boys. It is all done.

The podcast industry continued to grow exponentially for years after this statement.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL ratings are down because players aren't sleeping with Kardashians anymore

Do you think that's why NBA ratings are up and NFL is down because none of the NFL players are sleeping with the Kardashians?

Hot TakeMediaMediumSarcastic
Ratings fluctuations are due to complex factors like streaming, cord-cutting, and political protests, not Kardashian dating habits.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Les Miles will replace Magic Johnson as the most obvious tweeter on the internet

Magic, you're on the hot seat. If Les [Miles] starts figuring out how to predict MVPs and stuff, Magic might be out of a job. ... [Les] is giving strict play-by-play of the game. It's like Norm MacDonald doing golf tournament updates.

Les Miles' Twitter activity never quite reached the iconic status of Magic Johnson's 'obvious' tweets, and Magic remains the gold standard for the bit.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nobody who writes a book actually reads it cover-to-cover

I have a working theory that nobody that's written a book has actually read their book. Do you listen to your podcast over and over? Yeah, sometimes.

Most authors read their books many times during the editing process, though PFT is focusing on reading the final published product.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Pardon My Take should own the rights to Electric Avenue through squatter's rights

At what point do you legally, like, squatters rights on a song where people know the song more because of us than because of Eddie Grant, so then we just become the owners of that song?

OpinionMediaMediumSarcastic
Intellectual property law does not recognize 'squatter's rights' for copyrighted music based on frequent usage.
Loss
Joe BuckJoe Buck

Tony Romo will struggle with the transition to sports broadcasting

I think he and the world is going to be surprised at what this job demands. Let's just say that you can't be nice all the time. Tony Romo is a nice guy... I think it's going to be a difficult transition. This is not the most forgiving society we live in these days.

Tony Romo was an immediate critical and fan success in his first year, widely praised for his ability to predict plays before they happened.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Chris Berman retired from ESPN because he knew the All-Star Game was in Miami and he'd sweat too much

Chris Berman retired from the All-Star game and ESPN last winter... I think maybe Chris Berman was like, oh, fuck. The home run derby is going to be in Miami. I think he was. They don't make a sweatshirt that's dark enough to cover up the stains that Berman would be sweating through.

Berman did retire/step back in 2017, but the sweating reason is a joke.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NBA Commissioner Adam Silver will appear in a blockbuster movie as himself within the year

The only thing Silver hasn't done yet, I don't think, I can't recall him appearing in a movie as himself, like a big blockbuster movie, but I guarantee within the next year he's going to do it.

Adam Silver did not appear in a blockbuster movie as himself in the 2017-2018 window. He finally had a cameo in the movie 'Hustle', but that wasn't until 2022.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Markelle Fultz failing to fill in the template on his Instagram ad was a genius marketing move

Everybody ought to ignore everything Big Cat just said because we actually gave Markelle Fultz the best PR advice of all time... We got millions more impressions on this thing than he would have got if he actually tweeted out the right thing... this is a genius marketing strategy by Tissot.

Hot TakeMediaHotSarcastic
While it did get more impressions, it was a legitimate mistake and not a planned strategy, making the literal claim incorrect.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Peyton Manning hosting the ESPYs will not be good

I feel like this is going to suck, but... what do I know? Unless they just have him on stage drilling those Boys and Girls Club in the face with the footballs. He should just do that for like two hours.

Manning's hosting was generally well-received by critics, though it leaned heavily into the 'safe' jokes PFT predicted.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jay Cutler would be a good broadcaster if he is self-deprecating

Jay Cutler's thinking about going in the booth. So I'm excited for it. I think if Jay is honest and self-deprecating... I actually think he'd be good.

Jay Cutler was hired by FOX in 2017 but left before the season started to play for the Dolphins. He never truly established a broadcasting career, making this prediction largely incorrect in its longevity.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

United Airlines should become the presenting sponsor for the UFC to embrace their 'dragging' reputation

I had one go the self-deprecation route and become a UFC sponsor, like the presenting sponsor for UFC. That'd be pretty funny.

Hot TakeMediaHotSarcastic
United did not become a UFC sponsor; they eventually settled with the passenger and overhauled their policies.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Tony Romo will not be a good broadcaster

Tony... he's not going to be – I don't think he's going to be very good in the broadcast booth. Hot take, Tony Romo is not – this is the classic media loving the guy who smiled a lot, who had his backwards hat... who answered questions, and was generally likable.

Romo was an immediate sensation at CBS, praised for his ability to predict plays and his enthusiasm, though some criticism emerged in later years.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rugby is the sport of the future

I was at the rugby tournament. That is the sport of the future. It solidified it. Shout out another semifinals for the U.S. national team.

Rugby remains a niche sport in the United States compared to the 'big four' and soccer.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

ESPN should hire Bill Belichick for one day specifically to fire all the employees they are cutting

I think they should bring in Bill Belichick, hire him one day contract, have him fire everyone, soften the blow. Because when Bill Belichick fires you, it means you could still be at the peak... He's doing it one year too early. And he's actually doing you a favor by letting you get on the market and test the waters.

OpinionMediaHotSarcastic
A joke proposal that obviously did not happen.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rugby is already huge in America

I'm going to take you one step further and say rugby is already huge in America. This was the, yeah, we're here. Get used to it.

OpinionMediaMediumSarcastic
Rugby remains a niche sport in America compared to the Big 4 leagues.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Marquette King is quitting the NFL to join Barstool Sports

Marquette King actually did a little bit of flirting with joining Barstool earlier today... he put up the peace sign on Twitter, meaning he was quitting to join Barstool Sports. Heard it here first.

PredictionMediaHotSarcastic
Marquette King did not quit the NFL for Barstool in 2017; he played for the Raiders and Broncos before eventually having a short-lived media partnership much later.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I will issue a cease and desist to anyone else who tries to do airport reviews

Oh, we're called the Flyboys. I can't wait until someone actually does the airport reviews and we're like, cease and desist. We've been squatting on that idea for five years. We're patent trolls for podcast ideas.

Hot TakeMediaMediumSarcastic
They never actually patent-trolled anyone over airport reviews, as it's a comedic bit.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Adam Schefter didn't go to Mexico because he's afraid of getting kidnapped because he fits perfectly in a trunk

Maybe because his body is so short and it fits so perfectly in a trunk, he doesn't want to go there and get kidnapped.

Hot TakeMediaHotSarcastic
Cruel comedic bit, not a factual claim.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

We have officially run JJ Watt off the internet

How long has it been since J.J. Watt tweeted? 20 days. 20 days since J.J. Watt has tweeted. We have officially run him off the internet.

Watt eventually returned to Twitter, and his silence was likely due to his season-ending injury/surgery recovery.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

ESPN First Take's ratings would improve if they made it an R-rated adult program

How can we solve First Take?... Or make it porn. People love porn. Just make it porn. Everybody's naked. First Take, porn... Replace them with Ron Jeremy, Peter North, and Madison Ivy.

Hot TakeMediaScorchingSarcastic
ESPN did not, in fact, turn First Take into a pornographic program.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Auburn girl getting hit in the face by a football was a staged video

I think it was planned. Obviously, she still got the ball off her face, but there's a second video of someone videotaping her behind her. That seems too convenient... I said in the text, I was like, I don't know how, but I know.

The girl, Ashley Ward, later explained she was simply trying to catch it and the second video was from a friend; there is no evidence it was staged.
Loss
Richard DeitschRichard Deitsch

Deadspin under Univision ownership will not change as much as people think

I do not think that Deadspin under Univision will change as much as people think. The question will be, will the guys who are running Deadspin now stick around for the long haul or will there be a sort of an editorial change? But I don't think Univision bought Deadspin not to have Deadspin.

This proved somewhat incorrect in the long term; though it didn't change immediately, by 2019, editorial interference from subsequent owners (G/O Media) led to the entire staff resigning.
Loss
HankHank

The 'Send Beer Money' Venmo kid on College GameDay is a fake viral ad

No, you don't do that. Seemed a little fishy... Nowhere to be found. No one can find Sam Crowder... It's a fake. It's a viral ad.

Sam Crowder was a real person (an Iowa State student) who actually raised over $1 million for a children's hospital after the sign went viral. It was not a corporate ad.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Twitter is officially out to get Curt Schilling

Twitter is out to get Curt Schilling. It has nothing to do with his awful opinions, his racist beliefs, the fact that he's addicted to memes and retweeting idiots... Nope.

OpinionMediaMediumSarcastic
The take is sarcastic; Big Cat literally believes Schilling's behavior is the cause, but the literal claim that Twitter is out to get him is incorrect.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers