Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

I have very little faith in Ohio State winning the rest of their games

Ohio State, I have very little faith in them to win the rest of their games. Because they give up so many big plays on defense... They have like one of those [Purdue losses] a year now.

Ohio State won all five remaining games, including the Big Ten Championship and the Rose Bowl.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am still buying Scott Frost as a good coach for Nebraska

Their quarterback got injured. I don't know. For whatever reason, I'm still buying Scott Frost.

Scott Frost never had a winning season at Nebraska and was fired in 2022 with a 16-31 record.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I have bought back into the Wisconsin Badgers as a College Football Playoff contender

I've bought back into the Wisconsin Badgers season. If they beat Michigan and Penn State on the road, there's a pass. And they just got to take care of Ohio State, Big Ten Championship game. A team with only one loss against a very, very good BYU team... how do you leave them out of the college football playoff?

Wisconsin finished the season 8-5 and was not considered for the CFP.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Arkansas was the better team despite losing 34-3 to Auburn

The 34-3 score was not indicative of how well the Razorbacks played. Special teams played dictated that score. So the better team didn't win... 34-3. Arkansas outplayed them. Except for the score.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
Losing by 31 points almost always indicates the other team was significantly better that day.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Saban is an underachiever because he only wins a title every other year

Nick Saban's an underachiever... with this in mind, five national titles really does not seem like enough in an 11-year period. If Saban were as good at being a head coach as he is at recruiting, Alabama would have won the national title on a yearly basis. But he isn't.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
Saban is widely considered the GOAT of college football. Suggesting that winning 'only' 5 titles in 11 years is underachieving is a comedic hot take.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Miami Hurricanes should officially retire the turnover chain after losing to LSU

If you were Miami, if you were a Mark Richt, if you were a Miami fan, you can't in good conscience keep the turnover chain alive. It's dead. At some point, you just have to have it be dead because it's hollow.

The Turnover Chain persisted for several more years before being officially retired by Mario Cristobal in 2022.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

FAU has the most talented roster ever seen at the Group of Five level

Lane Kiffin... this is as talented a team at that level [FAU] that you're ever going to see. Now, chemistry-wise, it'll be a miracle if he can get everybody to play together.

While talented, the 2018 FAU team underwhelmed, finishing 5-7. It's difficult to call them the most talented G5 roster ever given the lack of results compared to teams like 2017 UCF or Boise State eras.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

My 2018 College Football Playoff field is Washington, Wisconsin, Clemson, and Georgia

All right, Final Four. Wisconsin, Washington, Clemson, Georgia.

The actual 2018 CFP field was Alabama, Clemson, Notre Dame, and Oklahoma. Staples only got 1 of 4 correct.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Saban stays on top because he has a factory where he personally shits out new players

I think Nick Saban personally shits players out. Because he chews them out in practice, and then he digests them for a while, and he takes a crap, and boom, I got a linebacker. ... I'd be like, yes, Nick Saban has a factory where he shits players out.

OpinionCFBScorchingSarcastic
Biologically impossible, though Saban's ability to replace talent is legendary.
Loss
Ndamukong SuhNdamukong Suh

Hiring Scott Frost was a great decision that should have happened three years ago

Great decision. I wanted it to happen three years ago and actually voted for it... I suggested it, for lack of a better word... Scott Frost has the mechanisms and the – I would say he's cut from a good cloth to be able to do it.

Scott Frost went 16-31 at Nebraska and was fired mid-season in 2022, becoming arguably the biggest failure in program history.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Bill Snyder will retire and then un-retire during his five-year contract extension

The best part about that extension is he's going to retire and come back within those five years. Oh, absolutely. Yeah.

Bill Snyder retired for good after the 2018 season and did not return to coaching at Kansas State during that five-year window.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Urban Meyer will eventually coach at Notre Dame

I think he's going to resurface in a few years at Notre Dame. If there's any organization that has a history of overlooking some of their leaders' past discrepancies, it's the Catholic Church. So I could see him joining up with Touchdown Jesus.

PredictionCFBHotSarcastic
Urban Meyer never coached at Notre Dame; he eventually went to the Jacksonville Jaguars and then retired from coaching.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Dabo Swinney will be the first coach to win a game of Fortnite to impress recruits

I'm going to make a prediction. I'm going to try to call my shot. Dabo [Swinney] is going to be the first one to ever win a game of Fortnite. To battle royale number one. Because he's going to start playing and being like, check it out, guys. I play Fortnite like you do.

Dabo never publically won a Fortnite Battle Royale as a recruiting ploy, though Clemson did have a heavy Fortnite culture that year.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

We will travel to Baton Rouge for the LSU-Alabama game if a video of a bar singing 'Down in the Bayou' surfaces

If at some point during the fall... somebody sends us a video in Tigerland or at a bar in Baton Rouge of the whole bar singing Coach O down in the bayou to drink paint, we will come down there for that Saturday night game. I promise you.

The PMT crew did not attend the 2018 LSU-Alabama game in Baton Rouge.
Loss
Johnny ManzielJohnny Manziel

Jimbo Fisher is a massive upgrade for Texas A&M

[Jimbo Fisher] is a big deal for us. It had been in the works for what seemed like a year and a half... I think we were ready for a little bit of a change and a guy who doesn't happen a lot where you get a coach that leaves from a national championship contending team and goes to a team that wants that.

While initially promising, Fisher was eventually fired in 2023 with a massive buyout after failing to deliver the championships Manziel mentions.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I count the LSU bowl game against Notre Dame as a win because I hate Notre Dame

And I count your bowl game [Citrus Bowl] as a win. That was a weird game. I count that as a win. I hate Notre Dame, so I count that as a win. So just in my record book, you went 7-1.

Literally, LSU lost the game 21-17, so the 'record book' claim is factually incorrect despite the bias.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am nervous that Scott Frost is building a powerhouse at Nebraska

I'm very nervous about Nebraska... We're going to walk into Nebraska and Scott Frost is going to build an 11-win team. And I'm going to be very, very upset about it.

Scott Frost famously struggled at Nebraska, never winning more than 5 games in a season and finishing with a 16-31 record.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nebraska is back because Scott Frost is hospitalizing players with Rabdo

Nebraska is back. Nebraska is back in a very, very big way. Scott Frost just implemented his conditioning program at Nebraska. And he got two players were hospitalized... with Rabdo, which means they're building up some muscles out there. That's a culture change.

Hot TakeCFBFireSarcastic
Scott Frost's tenure at Nebraska was a failure; he never had a winning season and was eventually fired. The program did not 'come back' under him.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen stinks and doesn't pass my eyeball test

I personally think Josh Allen stinks. I've watched him play every time. He doesn't pass my eyeball test, which is, as most people know, probably the hardest test to pass.

While Allen became a superstar in the NFL, at the time of the draft, his college stats and 'eyeball test' were highly controversial, making this a common but ultimately incorrect evaluation of his potential.
Loss
Andy StaplesAndy Staples

Willie Taggart will be a recruiting monster at Florida State

I will go Willie Taggart because I don't think people understand how well Willie Taggart is going to be able to recruit in the state of Florida. That dude comes in with an FSU logo on his polo shirt. There are going to be guys jumping to sign with him.

Taggart was a disaster at FSU, finishing with a 9-12 record and failing to secure top-tier classes before being fired early in his second season.
Loss
Danny KanellDanny Kanell

The College Football Playoff should be an eight-team system with five conference champions and three wildcards.

I try to get the easiest, simplest solution... And it's five conference champs and three wild cards. And everything would matter that much more because the conference championships would matter... and the three wild cards make those valuable.

The playoff system was eventually overhauled to a 12-team format starting in 2024, bypassing the 8-team model Kanell suggested.
Loss
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

USC will cover the 7.5-point spread against Ohio State in the Cotton Bowl

I definitely like the Trojans to cover. It's a seven-and-a-half point spread right now, which between these two teams is just ridiculously large to me. I don't see how anybody looks at what Ohio State's done this year and what USC's done this year... and says that Ohio State's more than a touchdown better than the Trojans.

Ohio State won 24-7, covering the 7.5-point spread.
Loss
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Oklahoma and Baker Mayfield have the edge over Georgia in the Rose Bowl

The closer I look at it, the more I just really think that I can't go against Baker Mayfield in a game like this and against that Oklahoma offense, which has just been absolutely superb all year long... I just feel like when you get to a playoff, if you have a unit like Oklahoma's offense, which is just that much better than everybody else that's there, that gives it something of an edge.

Georgia won a classic in double overtime, 54-48.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Lane Kiffin will likely only last three weeks into his 10-year contract at FAU

Lane Kiffin, coach of FAU... just signed a 10-year contract to stay at FAU. What do you think? He's going to last maybe like three weeks?

Lane Kiffin stayed at FAU for three seasons (2017-2019) before leaving for Ole Miss, which is significantly longer than three weeks, making the literal prediction incorrect.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Herm Edwards could go 4-7 at Arizona State just like every other coach

I bet you $1 that Herm Edwards could get the exact same record as all of our other coaches and go 4-7.

In his first season (2018), Herm Edwards went 7-6. He never actually finished a season with exactly 4 wins at ASU (closest was 5-6 in the shortened 2020).
Loss
Devin HesterDevin Hester

The Miami Hurricanes are officially 'back' because of their recent recruiting success

When we start getting the players that used to go to the mind, the type of players that we used to recruit, when they start signing... I think we're back.

Miami finished 10-3 in 2017 but struggled in subsequent years under Richt and Diaz, showing they weren't truly 'back' to their dynasty era.
Loss
Jim RossJim Ross

Oklahoma is good enough to win the national championship this year

Do you think that this year the team is good enough to win a title? Yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely... I believe that they have it to do because if we can get an occasional three and out, a turnover... the sooner offense... they're something else.

Oklahoma lost to Georgia 54-48 in the Rose Bowl (Playoff Semifinal) on January 1, 2018.
Loss
Matt LeinartMatt Leinart

Oklahoma is the best team in college football right now

But I think Oklahoma is the best team right now. Baker Mayfield, they're a great man.

Oklahoma lost to Georgia in the Rose Bowl (Semifinal).
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Clemson is the best team in the country and will crush Alabama in the playoffs

I actually think Clemson's going to win it all. I think they're the best team. I think they're going to whoop the fuck out of Alabama, which is going to be hilarious because then you get the Ohio State fans being like, should have been us to get the whoop the fuck out of Clemson.

Incorrect. Alabama defeated Clemson 24-6 in the Sugar Bowl semifinal and went on to win the championship.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Oklahoma will lose the Big 12 Championship Game

I honestly think Oklahoma's going to lose. That's going to be the havoc that's going to be wreaked on Saturday.

Oklahoma defeated TCU 41-17 on December 2, 2017, to win the Big 12 title and secure a playoff spot.
Loss
Beau AllenBeau Allen

Wisconsin will beat Ohio State 27-17 in the Big Ten Championship

Obviously the Badgers are going to win... I think it's going to be 27-17.

Ohio State won the 2017 Big Ten Championship 27-21.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jeff Fisher is the perfect candidate for the UCLA coaching job

I am so excited for Jeff Fisher to possibly be in our life. Not only is it... It would be so perfect for him to be in the Pac-12 because we would get that 10:30 kickoff time. College football is perfect for Jeff Fisher because if you go 6-6, you go to a bowl game. He rolls out of bed bowl eligible. That would be amazing.

Jeff Fisher was rumored for the UCLA job but was never hired; Chip Kelly was eventually hired in late 2017.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin will beat Ohio State in the Big Ten Championship

I think Wisconsin could beat Ohio State. I really do. Halftime of the Michigan game, I was like, oh, fuck, but Wisconsin put it on them in the second half, and I was like, this defense can play with – hey, defense travels.

Ohio State defeated Wisconsin 27-21 on December 2, 2017.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Miami Hurricanes are officially back

As a team, Miami is officially, officially back. Now, Hank said it last week. The U. But they are now back.

Miami lost their final three games of the season (Pitt, Clemson, Wisconsin) and haven't returned to that level of national relevance consistently since, showing they weren't truly 'back'.
Loss
HankHank

The Miami Hurricanes are officially back

The U is back. They had the black jerseys, which was just unreal. Dominated Virginia Tech. And the fans... there was multiple incidents of fans fighting police, fans fighting each other. Police fighting fans. That's back. The U's got all their swagger back.

The Hurricanes lost their final three games of the 2017 season (Pitt, Clemson, Wisconsin) and returned to mediocrity shortly after.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

John Gruden to Tennessee is fate because his skin tone perfectly matches the school's orange

John Gruden looks like he should be coaching in Tennessee Orange. If you take on aggregate the different tones of John Gruden's skin and his hair and his lips and you put it all together into one blender and average it out, you get Tennessee Orange... His face is the perfect match for the Feng Shui of Knoxville.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
Gruden did not take the Tennessee job; Jeremy Pruitt was hired.
Loss
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Maryland football will become a contender in the Big Ten if DJ Durkin stays

I think if DJ Durkin stays, that there'll be a time not too far from now when not just the Minnesotas of the world that you beat, maybe you can step up. I'm telling you.

Durkin was fired less than a year later following the death of Jordan McNair and a scandal regarding a toxic program culture. Maryland never rose to contender status in the Big Ten during or after his tenure.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL teams should have a college game ready to play on 12 hours notice if a baseball playoff game gets rained out

So why doesn't the Sun Belt... [if] there's a rain out of an important baseball game, they should have a game ready to go on 12 hours notice.

This is a satirical scheduling suggestion that has never been implemented.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Coach Ed Orgeron was never on the hot seat at LSU

I'm staying resolute in my support of Coach O. I don't think he was ever on the hot seat. Don't think he's ever going to be on the hot seat.

Orgeron was famously on the hot seat multiple times and was eventually reached a mutual separation with LSU in 2021, despite winning a title.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Coach O is the greatest interim head coach of all time, but not a great permanent head coach

Coach O is the greatest interim head coach of all time. Of all time. You give him some guys that aren't getting the most out of themselves... Coach O will whip them into shape in two seconds. You give Coach O the team from day one... he's a great interim coach. He's not the greatest head coach.

Ed Orgeron went on to win the National Championship as the permanent head coach of LSU in 2019, proving he was more than just an interim specialist.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Alabama's second string could win the SEC

Alabama debates are back... could Alabama's second team win the SEC? Because they're deep. Real deep... the Hawaiian quarterback [Tua Tagovailoa], the second string, it would be unbelievable.

While Alabama's roster was historically deep, no second-string team could realistically win a major conference.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Baylor coach Matt Rhule will be fired by the end of the season and replaced by Lane Kiffin

At the end of the season, this guy [Matt Rhule] gets fired... It's Lane Kiffin's destiny to take over the Baylor program.

Matt Rhule was not fired; he stayed at Baylor for three seasons before going to the NFL. Lane Kiffin did not take over Baylor.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Confirmed: Mike Gundy has shaved his mullet

I've heard the same rumor as you [Hank]... Mike Gundy does not have a mullet anymore. But this is a major Samson and Delilah case here. If he loses his mullet, he loses power.

This was a false rumor. Mike Gundy kept his mullet throughout the 2017 season and for several years after.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Baylor should blow up the Robert Griffin III statue to move past their scandals

There's a statue of Robert Griffin outside the stadium. I think that thing needs to come down like that Saddam statue in Baghdad. Blow it up.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
The statue was never blown up; it remains a fixture at McLane Stadium.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Chip Kelly is house shopping in College Station to replace Kevin Sumlin

The fire of the hot seat got lit under Kevin Sumlin. So now Chip Kelly's driving his General Lee down to College Station. He's ready to go. He's house shopping. Rumor is his wife... no, no chance. Chip Kelly's married. His girlfriend's football. Chip Kelly's made up pretend girlfriend is now working with a realtor in College Station.

Kevin Sumlin was fired after the season, but Chip Kelly took the UCLA job instead of the Texas A&M job (which went to Jimbo Fisher).
Loss
Liam (Bubba)Liam (Bubba)

Nick Saban would score 100 points on Lane Kiffin if they played

He's [Saban] not playing against Lane Kiffin. So make that 10-1. Saban would probably go like, he'd put up a 100 burger.

OpinionCFBHotSarcastic
While they played several times, Saban never put up 100 points on Kiffin.
Loss
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Alabama would have lost by 40 points to Texas in 2010 if Colt McCoy didn't get hurt

I think we would have lost by at least 40. It's in large part, too, because if you guys have been to the Rose Bowl in January, it's that humidity. It's the humidity in the air that gets you, and I'm just not sure we were conditioned well enough to hang if Colt didn't get hurt.

Hot TakeCFBScorchingSarcastic
This is a hyperbolic hypothetical. Alabama won the game 37-21; a 40-point swing is clearly an intended joke.
Loss
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Georgia is a year away from being a serious contender

I think Georgia's like a year away. Because Georgia... they're still a little bit young in the trenches offensively. Defensively, they're really, really good. But I think their offense is about a year away up front.

Georgia was far from a year away; they went 13-2 and were one play away from winning the National Championship in the 2017 season.
Loss
Greg McElroyGreg McElroy

Stanford is a surprise playoff contender for 2017

Watch out for Stanford... Bryce Love is a kid who is really, really talented... Stanford is a team that nobody's really talking about right now... they could be sitting there at 10 wins, 11 wins near season's end and on the cusp of a potential playoff berth.

Stanford finished 9-5 and lost the Pac-12 Championship, missing the playoff.
Loss
Sean SalisburySean Salisbury

Sam Darnold will be the best quarterback USC has ever had

He'll be the best quarterback we've ever had there [USC]. I'm serious... I think he's going to be the best college and NFL quarterback USC's ever had.

Darnold did not win a Heisman or reach the heights of Carson Palmer or Caleb Williams at USC, and his NFL career has been disappointing.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers